r/zen • • 5h ago

UNPLEASANT SCENES

2 Upvotes

When facing the end, generally beautiful scenes appear according to your mental inclinations, the most impressive or experienced first. If you do not do bad things right now, then there will be no unpleasant scenes when you face death. Even if there are some unpleasant scenes, they too will change into pleasant scenes. If you fear that you will go mad with terror at the moment of death and will fail to attain freedom, then you should first be free right now. Then you'll be all right right now. In respect to each and everything do not have any obsession at all. Do not remain fixated on intellectual interpretation. Then you will be free. -- Pai-chang

What do yall think?

P-chang seems to be saying something about what death experience is like. How the hell would be know? Has PC died and come back to tell the tale? Is PC telling tales outta school?

What about this stuff that says if we do bad we'll have to see "UNPLEASANT SCENES"? But even if we do do (doo-doo!) bad the "UNPLEASANT SCENES" don't last forever so what's the big deal? Yall think Pol-Pot would have ever turned around because of some unpleasant visions?

Reminds me of Bishop Sheen. Yall know about Bishop Fulton J Sheen? FJS was beautified this year, but caught flack back in the day because he said there was a hell, but there wasn't anyone in it because the grace of God is sufficient for all. A lot of fire and brimstone preachers that liked to scare their congregations didn't like FJS taking away their pet lash.

But we're here to talk zen and Huangbo teaches inherently complete, no attainment, and even good deeds are inconsequential to enlightenment. Huangbo says one must have a valiant heart but the gold chains of philanthropy and toil of privation are just more karma energy that when exhausted still amount to nothing.

I say all that to say this: I need to shut up.


r/zen • • 3h ago

Zen in academia: Increasingly w/o meditation

0 Upvotes
SourcePosition concerning meditation
Bielefeldt, 1988 (substitute for unverified Dumoulin)Explicitly identifies Zen as the Meditation School, while recognizing historical complexities.
Mohr, 2005Meditation is not exclusive to the Zen lineage and cannot establish its separate identity.
Hershock, 2024 archiveMeditative techniques are explicitly rejected as what distinguished Zen within Chinese Buddhism.

I was comparing these sources, and how much academia had changed it's view on Zen over time:

Mohr, M. (2005). Buddhism—Schools: Chan and Zen. In D. M. Borchert (Ed.), Encyclopedia of philosophy (2nd ed., Vol. 1, pp. 726–730). Macmillan Reference USA.

Hershock, P. (2019). Chan Buddhism. In E. N. Zalta & U. Nodelman (Eds.), The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy (Summer 2024 ed.). Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University. https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2024/entries/buddhism-chan/

Dumoulin, H. (1987). Ch'an. In M. Eliade (Ed.), The encyclopedia of religion (Vol. 3). Macmillan.