r/Outlander • u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • Dec 20 '21
7 An Echo In The Bone Book Club: An Echo in the Bone, Chapters 85-103
October 1980, Lallybroch - Buck MacKenzie is staying with Roger, Bree, and the children whom have taken a liking to him. Buck wants to go back to his time and they want to help him do so. Rob Cameron comes to take Jem for a sleepover, but Mandy wakes in the middle of the night screaming that Jemmy is gone. She says Rob took him to the stones and the rocks ate him.
When Brianna calls about Jem she finds that there was no sleepover planned and Rob’s truck is gone. Roger and Buck race to Craigh na Dun in search of Jem, but do not find him. They find out Rob read the letters from Jamie and Claire along with Roger’s notebook on time travel. They don’t know what he wants with Jem.
December 1777, Philadelphia - William rides to Valley Forge in search of Denny Hunter. Denny and Rachel return with William to Philadelphia where Denny operates on Henry. He is only able to remove one of the musket balls though. Dottie shows up at Denny and Rachel’s room wearing a sack dress and says she is willing to become a Quaker so she can marry Denny. They met in London and her ruse with William was to get her to America and Denny.
April 1778, Philadelphia - Claire and Ian return to America, Claire enters the city and Ian stays on the outskirts of town in order to find Rachel. In preparation for Henri-Christian’s surgery Claire finds that Lord John bought the vitriol and goes to visit him. Lord John tells her about Henry and a deal is struck, LJG will buy all of her medical supplies if she will agree to operate on Henry as well. Claire agrees to this, and successfully operates on Henri-Christian and Henry. Claire returns from Henry’s surgery to find two letters from Jamie. His letter from France details his exploits there and tells her he and Jenny will be sailing on the Euterpe.
October 1980, Lallybroch - Roger and Buck prepare to leave for the stones, they are going to look for Jem. Brianna takes them to Craigh na Dun and they go through the stones. That night after she has put Mandy to bed she hears footsteps in the hallway. Rob Cameron has shown up and wants to know where the gold is, otherwise he’ll harm Jem.
April 1778, Brest - Jamie and Jenny prepare to set sail but find that the Euterpe has already left port. They are forced to scramble and find another ship to sail on.
April 1778, Philadelphia - Lord John receives word the the Euterpe has sunk and all hands were lost. Captain Richardson finds LJG and informs him that he is about to arrest Claire for passing on seditionist materials. In an effort to save Claire and Fergus’s family LJG insists that Claire marry him so they can be kept safe. Claire reluctantly agrees. She has little memory of the ceremony, and days later contemplates suicide.
Lord John finds Claire awake and drinking one night. He himself has been drinking as well, he insists he will not mourn Jamie alone that night. Cut to the next morning and we find that Claire and Lord John had sex. LJG says it’s the first time in 15 years that he has slept with a woman. LJG tells Claire about a white deer at his plantation - “Do you see? I do not own this creature—would not, if I could. Its coming is a gift, which I accept with gratitude, but when it’s gone, there is no sense of abandonment or deprivation. I’m only glad to have had it for so long as it chose to remain.”
October 1980, Hydroelectric Dam - Jem finds himself locked in the same tunnel Brianna was locked in. He finds the little train in there and starts driving.
May 1778, Philadelphia - Rachel is out shopping with Rollo when he runs off, chasing a scent. Thinking Rollo has found Ian Rachel pursued him only to be caught by Arch Bug who tries to take her. We find that Ian is back in Philadelphia after learning that is where Rachel is. Fergus is hiding out when he gets told a large Scottish man is looking for him. Back with Arch and Rachel, William appears and tries to tackle Arch but is hit in the head with Arch’s axe. Arch gets away and William has a concussion. Claire and Lord John attend a gala in honor of General Howe.
Lord John goes to Claire’s bedroom one night and offers to “comfort” her. She declines, but pleasures John instead.
Arch Bug has been located and William goes off in pursuit of him. Arch shows up at the print shop where Rachel is and waits for Ian to come. When Ian comes rushing in a fight ensues and Ian is injured. William comes in just in time and shoots Arch.
Lord John and Claire are getting ready for tea when Jamie appears in their house. He is being pursued by British soldiers after being seen passing a package to Fergus. As the soldiers are trying to get inside William appears and sees Jamie, in a huge shock to him William realizes Jamie is his father. In order to avoid arrest Jamie takes Lord John hostage and they flee the city. Once they reach safety LJG tells Jamie he has had “carnal knowledge” of Claire.
Back at the house Claire tells William the story of his birth and how that came to be. William becomes enraged and destroys part of the house on his way out. As he leaves Jenny comes in the door and comments “Like father, like son, I see.”
The book ends with Ian and Rachel watching the British army leave Philadelphia, and Rachel declaring her love for Ian.
We will have a two week break before we start MOBY. During those two weeks I will be posting free for all threads where you guys can discuss anything you want from the previous books! Week one will be books 1-3 and week two will be 4-7.
- Should DG have revealed that Jamie was alive so soon in the book?
- Reflecting on Jamie’s perceived death Lord John thinks - “He’d lost people before. Some of them dearly loved, more than life itself. But now he’d lost himself.” How do you feel about Lord John’s thoughts there?
- What do you think of Lord John and Claire sleeping together?
- What did Lord John mean when he told Claire to think of the white deer?
- Did you think Rob Cameron took Jem through the stones when you first read he had been taken?
- Claire thinks of the diamonds Lord John gave her and when she is going to leave. Do you think she meant leave Lord John, or go back to the 20th century?
- What did you think of the book overall?
- What do you think is meant by the title of the book “An Echo in the Bone”?
- Any additional thoughts or comments?
•
u/AutoModerator Dec 20 '21
Please do not reveal events from future books, or from later chapters of the current book the club hasn’t covered yet. Show talk is okay up to the current book. The number of pages listed are based on the Kindle edition of the books, which matches up with the hardback versions of them.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Dec 20 '21
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Dec 20 '21
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Dec 20 '21
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Dec 20 '21
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Dec 20 '21
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Dec 20 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Dec 20 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Dec 20 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Dec 20 '21
2
u/Nasi-Lemak2399 Jan 26 '25
After i watched the show for 7 season, i decided to buy the book for reading pleasure or to re immerse myself into Jamie n Claire's epic loving story whenever i need.
However, i started to regret myself or more preciously, getting suspicious on the storyline's sensibility and credibility. These feeling of being a dump fool all started from watching season 7 episode 11, when Claire sleep with LjG.
I was like jaw dropping and my heart was crunching and screaming, hysterically specifically on 2 scenes, which caught me in nightmare and cold sweating for a few weeks. Those 2 scenes had really make me stopped reading the story book instantly. I don't even want to know where it's either. I think i got the phobia of it, not to exaggerate.
Scene 1 How, on earth, my dearest Claire will have sex with the bloody Englishman LJG who's her beloved husband's best friend in just a unreasonably short time,!!!!! It was like the whole storyline becomes soap opera instantly, cheap and tasteless. The whole character of Claire for the past 10 yrs has been collapsed, horribly twisted as needed, especially at such tragical moment. Where is the integrity and faith that Jamie treasure the most?? What's puzzled me is that a moment before, Claire was still aware enough to yell at LJG that Jamie was her, nobody can steal him from her, immediately after, both were shoving into a so called violent, awkward love making night like they had decided not to mourn Jamie alone!!! My eyes were popping out and totally speechless and giggled in disgraced.
Scene 2 The next morning's intimacy conversation btw Claire and LJG. The whole thing really make me feel cheated and disgraceful if i choose to believe that, they were just making love out of over grief or so called mourning Jamie's death.A part from Claire has curiosity about LJG's sexual history and LJG's skittish apology, the deer story appeared the most hilarious comfort that LJG wishes Claire to believe and get enlighten from it. (Actually, my eyes was in tears and red, my emotions was outraged and anguished with disappointment. I felt completely spend and despaired. What a waste!!! What a fxxking waste!!! (Not to mention in the story book, Claire and LJG admire each other naked body, and Claire even praised LJG warrior's body; and Claire gave LJG a good hand jxb when LJG proudly presented his body to her in month later)
What turned out amused to me the most was many viewers blamed Jamie for being too violent on LJG after being told when he returned. I started questioning myself whether am i too naive to acknowledge what the true love is ???Being righteous upon ppl telling you they have carnal knowledge about your wife??? Being thankful for ur best friend for saving ur wife by making love to her??? Or being forgiven for what Claire said, LJG has more courage and gave something for her to hit(my god!! really Claire) or else she will remain too numb, and LJG was just timely to perform a heavenly triage she desperately needed???
Honestly, im more sympathy for Jamie, for these unnecessary mess he has to dealt for the rest of his life.
For me, i just quit. Enough is enough.