r/anime • u/pittman66 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Homura • May 02 '17
Annoucing Anime Survivor! - Planning/Entry Thread
Note for subreddits still wanting to join at the bottom.
u/pittman66 here, the mod of Zenbu, Whose Line is it Anime?, and Warm Talk Wednesday. And I’m here to announce coming to r/anime in Mid-July (After Best Girl Contest), the hit thread from r/nfl is making its way to r/anime in the form of Anime Survivor! As we haven’t had our “Best Anime Contest” in a while, and I think this will be an interesting shake up to the concept. (tl;dr at bottom)
What is this “Survivor” game?
The Survivor concept is based on the reality game show Survivor ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivor_(franchise) ) , where a group of people live on an island competing in challenges and surviving away from civilization. And at the end of each episode the group votes out a member and that person cannot win the final prize.
The Reddit version from /r/NFL includes the voting where users will pick the team they want it too be eliminated and those with the most are out of the contest.
So how does this work?
Mostly taking the same rules from /r/nfl’s Survivor Contest; 32 Anime will be chosen for this contest, and every day a thread will be posted where users are to vote on which anime they would like to see eliminated. As the next day comes, whichever Anime has the most votes is eliminated from the contest, simple as that and we do another vote. When it reaches the final 3 anime, a final vote will occur where users will vote for the Winner of the contest based on whatever qualities they believe in.
Wouldn’t the most popular anime just win this?
Not necessarily, the more popular the anime the more likely it’ll be known to vote for it, and lesser known anime may be ignored and backstab at the end. This should be bit more interesting than the regular contest with the most popular ending up as the winner.
How exactly would we strategize alliances and/or backstabs?
That’s coming up below
This sounds like a salty idea...How do I get my anime involved?
With so many anime out there and not wanting to extend this contest forever, I am limiting this contest to 32 anime, but the way of picking them should help with strategy and make it more interesting. If you want to have your anime involved with this contest, the Main Active Subreddit of it is to be involved with the following.
- It must be moderator approved of the main subreddit to participate. By main subreddit, this is referring to the subreddit most people go to when wanting to discuss the anime. For example, a moderator of /r/Naruto would need to approve the contest if they want Naruto to be in it, a mod of r/Naruto_Hentai cannot. To be in, have the mods send a Subreddit PM to me (if using New Mod Mail) or just state you're a mod of the subreddit and your subreddit would like to participate, I'll verify myself by a quick check.
- The Subreddit must have at least 100 Subscribers to keep very obscure anime out and spamming the contests.
- The last post in the subreddit must have been made 3 months earlier than this post to avoid shows not many care about at the moment.
- If more than 32 anime qualify with the previously mentioned, the 32 will be then decided from a randomizer. No advantages will be given over others.
So you may be wondering why involve anime subreddits? I feel this is one of the better ways to narrow down the anime that could be involved than just picking them myself, have an active fanbase that can have a voice for the contest, give spotlights to some smaller ones, and make alliances more interesting between subreddits similarly to what teams did in r/nfl’s.
What are some important dates to remember?
As mentioned, this will be starting after the Best Girl Contest, likely a week or after to calm the salt, so around mid to late July. Entries though begin today and the final deadline will be July 10th, so you’ve got about 2 ½ months until then, anime that will be participating will be announced later after than. So post in your anime’s subreddit to see if they would like to be involved!
As this is the first time doing it and the Best Girl Contest coming, I’d like to give plenty of time for entries and hyping it up.
I’m a moderator of one of these subreddits, and I’m concerned about brigading, will you be doing anything to punish those that do?
As a moderator of r/anime, I’m open to giving warnings or bans if there’s toxic behavior happening outside of here due to this contest. If you’re a mod of one of the subreddits that ends up participating and you’re having problems with users, please do tell me.
I believe that should be everything should be addressed, but as mentioned with the title, this is also a planning thread which means if there’s any changes you’d like me to make, then I’d be open to hearing them. I hope this will be interesting twist to to the usual contest, and hopefully this turns out to be fun.
I’ll post reminder in about a month and week before the deadline to enter is over.
tl;dr: We're having a Survivor Contest in July after the best girl Contest, where you vote for anime to be eliminated until the final 3 where you vote or the winner. Want your anime to be in? Read the qualification section.
Currently Participating:
- Attack on Titan (/r/ShingekiNoKyojin)
- The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya (/r/haruhi)
- Ergo Proxy (/r/ergoproxy)
- D. Gray Man (/r/dgrayman)
- Kara no Kyoukai (r/karanokyoukai)
- Symphogear (/r/symphogear)
- One Punch Man (/r/Onepunchman)
- Hidamari Sketch (/r/HidamariSketch)
- Fate/Stay Night (/r/fatestaynight)
- Boku no Hero Academia (/r/BokuNoHeroAcademia)
- YuYu Hakusho (/r/YuYuHakusho)
- Baccano! (/r/Baccano)
- Steins;Gate (/r/SteinsGate)
- Little Witch Academia (r/LittleWitchAcademia)
- OreGairu (/r/OreGairuSNAFU)
- Monster Musume (/r/MonsterMusume)
- Sakurasou No Pet Na Kanojo (/r/sakurasou)
- Amagi Brilliant Park (/r/Amaburi/)
- One Piece (/r/onepiece)
- Kemono Friends (/r/kemonofriends)
- Clannad (/r/Clannad)
- Re:Zero (/r/re_zero)
- Flip Flappers (/r/Flip_Flappers)
- Fairy Tail (/r/fairytail)
- Hellsing (/r/hellsing)
- Monogatari Series (/r/araragi)
- No Game No Life (/r/nogamenolife)
- Katekyo Hitman Reborn! (/r/khr)
- Gintama (/r/Gintama)
- Skip Beat! (/r/SkipBeat)
- Lucky Star (/r/Luckystar)
- Fullmetal Alchemist (/r/FullmetalAlchemist)
- Haikyuu!! (/r/haikyuu)
- Hunter x Hunter (/r/HunterxHunter)
- Legend of the Galactic Heroes (/r/logh)
- Grimgar: Ashes and Illusions (/r/HaitoGensounoGrimgar)
- Noragami (/r/Noragami)
- Miss Kobayashi's Dragon Maid (/r/DragonMaid)
- Spice and Wolf (/r/SpiceAndWolf)
- Working!! (/r/wagnaria)
- Show by Rock (/r/showbyrock)
Note for those still wanting to join in:
If it's not too many more, I will forgo the random selection and just include all those that have agreed. If it gets to let's say around 45 though, I'll do the random selection or maybe a "Qualification Vote" (Everyone votes who they want to be in the contest) as that's already a month 1/2 long for this. So do feel free to keep entering even though we've hit 32, but do know that if it hits a certain limit that the random selection draft/Qualification Vote will be done.
16
u/Yuri-Girl May 02 '17
So how exactly does a moderator submit their subreddit's anime for approval? You never mentioned that bit.
23
u/Sinrus :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/MetalRain May 02 '17
r/karanokyoukai qualifies. This could be Shiki's chance to get past the first round in a contest. What do you say, /u/syntheticvalkyrur?
15
u/DoctorWhoops https://anilist.co/user/DoctorWhoops May 02 '17
Ah, it's a shame subreddits are needed to participate. That leaves out so many potential greats like Shouwa Genroku Rakugo Shinjuu or Tatami Galaxy.
5
u/Snakescipio May 02 '17
If by no briganding do you mean no planning and ganging up on one particular anime? Cause that shit was fun in the r/nfl version (I may or may not have been part of the ELOE)
5
u/Revriley1 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Gallimaufry May 03 '17 edited May 03 '17
Hey, /u/pittman66, I'm a mod of /r/Baccano. Discussed this with another mod and we've decided to throw our hat into the ring! I think we meet the requirements, right?
Thanks to /u/AniMonologues for bringing this to my attention.
4
u/TheBeatlesPkmnFan42 May 31 '17
Eh why the fuck not. I'm a mod of r/ShowByRock.
18
u/_vogonpoetry_ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ThisWasATriumph May 02 '17
They got it from /r/baseball, actually. And the NFL one was kind of a trainwreck... But at least this time there probably wont be evil alliances. Probably.
4
u/WhiteVans_FreeCandy May 03 '17
so who's going to be part of anime's evil league of evil?
5
u/272b May 02 '17 edited May 03 '17
r/OnePunchMan and r/BokuNoHeroAcademia, go for it!
Edit: Paging u/joseph_stalin_
2
u/Thrasher439 https://anilist.co/user/Thrasher May 03 '17
/r/fatestaynight is up for it
2
u/2ez May 28 '17
Mod from /r/SpiceandWolf here, count us in /u/pittman66!
47
u/Enraric May 02 '17
Paging /u/legoman2334 for /r/SpiceandWolf and /u/jaxspider for /r/gurrenlagann
You guys were the mods for those subreddits with the most recent activity on reddit, sorry to bother you.
PLEASE ENTER
77
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian May 02 '17
Well if anything we'll get some good use out of the new
Excited for this, sounds like it could be fun and frustrating!
33
u/reddadz x3https://anilist.co/user/MysticEyes May 02 '17 edited May 02 '17
There's no way this can go horribly wrong, right?
Paging /u/Thrasher439 for /r/fatestaynight & F/Z
Paging /u/H-K_47 for /r/ShingekiNoKyojin
13
u/ValiantSerpant :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Quinn_Crystal May 02 '17
Just in time for /r/Symphogear 's 4th season
10
u/Triggers_people May 02 '17 edited May 02 '17
Why do some random sub moderators have the power to deny an anime entry? Seems pretty stupid to me, it's not like they created the show.
10
u/someedmlover21 https://anilist.co/user/dilate May 03 '17
I hope my anime gets in
14
u/Sprite_isnt_lemonade :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sprite_isnt_Holo May 02 '17
What's the reasoning behind the 32?
I'd personally like it to be like the league of legends one was, a higher starting number (100+) but multiple out each week, until the number got smaller, and then became a 1 out per week.
Just preferences, I'll enjoy it nonetheless, and all the salt that comes with it (voting out steins;gate asap, the r/anime favourite is going DOWN).
12
u/SmurfRockRune https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smurf May 02 '17
I don't like this idea. The /r/NFL one turned into a horrible circlejerk really quickly and was just toxic the entire way through. I see this going exactly the same.
6
u/CaneloAlvarez25 May 02 '17
r/hajimenoippo
r/toloveru
6
u/kahzel https://myanimelist.net/profile/kahzel May 03 '17
i wonder if the mods at r/Gintama would approve the participation
6
u/smhmines https://anilist.co/user/mines May 05 '17
Better late than never right?
Paging /u/frogfu79, /u/vikinghedgehog, /u/dollyl from /r/haikyuu
Please?
4
u/drizztgeass :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/drizztgeass May 03 '17
/r/CodeGeass/ should get in on this
4
u/AniMonologues :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/AniMonologues May 03 '17
/u/senpike you and your /r/OuranAcademy is needed here in r/anime!
Let's get Ouran in the contest!!
4
u/Joll19 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Joll May 03 '17
u/ZeHaffen Let's do this shit!
Oh wait in addition to r/MadokaMagica you are also mod of r/swordartonline and r/anohana.
I mean if you want you can enter SAO, but it will be a short run...
1
u/[deleted] May 03 '17
A lot of the most popular girls are probably going to get eliminated early on actually under this. Eventually maybe people will solidify around one of the popular girls instead of someone who's just there because they're a no name who nobody hates?
1
u/Housedodo :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/housedodo May 04 '17
Sounds awesome!
Sign r/Sakurasou up for it! :)
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '17
/u/pittman66
As a mod of /r/luckystar we would like Lucky Star to officially enter this race
1
u/NovaBlue142 https://anilist.co/user/NovaBlue May 21 '17
Hey /u/pittman66!
I'm a mod representing /r/HaitoGensounoGrimgar, /r/DragonMaid, and /r/Noragami. All three of these subreddits would like to participate in the game! Thanks :D
we're ready for the saltfest
3
u/[deleted] May 02 '17
i would nominate lotgh, as it fills every requierement, but knowing this sub, people would eliminate it inmediately, so i guess i'll nominate kissxsis, for the lols
3
u/manaworkin May 03 '17
Given your tag I can assume /r/symphogear is already in? Because the world needs more determination to fist.
3
u/CT_BINO https://myanimelist.net/profile/CT_BINO May 03 '17
This will make a lor of people mad if for example one of the biggest shows can´t go in
Honest I still think steins gate or FMAB will win this but we will see how this goes
3
u/brothertaddeus :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/brothertaddeus May 03 '17
Any interest in getting /r/steinsgate in on this? /u/boylanator_94 /u/blue-psyduck /u/bobthelawyer
3
u/BranchofSin :K:https://kitsu.io/users/BranchofSin May 03 '17
/r/YuYuHakusho has joined the battle.
5
u/Lord_Xp https://anilist.co/user/LordXp May 03 '17 edited May 03 '17
/r/araragi mods to help enter the Monogatari Series! /u/nottherealmorty you know any of the active ones over there?
This contest is going to be
1
u/TomatoFork :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TomatoFork May 07 '17
Paging u/cdromantic from /r/Lain and u/GeneralissimoFranco from /r/logh
1
u/tayoku0 May 07 '17
/u/Reuku /u/NewSpecies /u/MountainZaki would you be down for having /r/Gintama participate in this?
4
u/TheManiacalGamer :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheManiacalGamer May 03 '17
Paging /u/phatboisteez, /u/FatiguedWalri, /u/ActualKrillin for /r/StardustCrusaders
You guys interested in getting in on this?
2
u/Patrui :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Patrui May 02 '17 edited May 03 '17
/r/BokuDakegaInaiMachi
Paging:/u/SShirodkarMD
/r/RokkaNoYuusha
Paging: /u/soiguessthisisit
/r/HaiToGensouNoGrimgar
Paging: /u/NovaBlue142
2
u/OneLonelyMexican :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/FAILMymy May 03 '17
I've been following the LoL survivor threads for a while now, so I expect the Ashe of anime to pull through.
Question is, who is it going to be?
Actually excited on what will happen.
2
u/frostwolfeh :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/WolfehLol May 03 '17
/r/DogDays is dead and doesn't have the subscriber count. Can't even try to get my favorite show in.
2
u/GimmeDatGrimoire :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/GimmeDatGrimoire May 03 '17
/r/fairytail :D
2
u/AmiiboPuff https://myanimelist.net/profile/ButzPuff May 04 '17
u/AmiiboPuff and u/Siedrah for r/MonsterMusume
Edit: PM Sent!
1
u/AniMonologues :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/AniMonologues May 03 '17
/u/zinx10, I am paging you hoping to get Haruhi into this contest, if the other mods are active, do you know if you'd be able to talk them into this?
1
u/Eromanga_Sugoi May 03 '17
Kagami from MAL would be a great choice for this. Guy is the host of MAL Survivor.
1
u/[deleted] May 03 '17
So when is Best Girl starting?
1
u/kriogenia https://anilist.co/user/kriogenia May 03 '17
Oh shit, this looks really promising. It's the most pure from of Circlejerks vs Anticirclejerks and I love it. I will enjoy voting against some shows which I'm tired of (and yes, I'm motherfucking referencing JoJo's here).
But, if Evangelion enters and looking how much varied are the opinions about it (love or hate mostly) it's a good candidate to left the first.
1
u/[deleted] May 03 '17
I know people get salty whenever Gintama takes over the MAL Top 10 and takes ratings way too serious on that site. Quite ironic that most sequels from any other anime are higher than the 1st season and no one bats an eye.
I think r/Gintama is a good competitor to participate in Anime Survivor. (Forgive me padre and fellow fans for I have sinned by causing the purge)
1
u/JealotGaming https://anilist.co/user/Jealot May 03 '17
Determination to fist incoming
1
u/SoccerForEveryone May 03 '17
Where you at? r/ShokugekiNoSoma ???
1
u/diexu May 03 '17
/u/Siedrah or /r/MonsterMusume
1
u/jouzea May 04 '17
ayy Oregairu represent! Why is One Piece not here
1
u/BaronBones :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/alexander165 May 04 '17 edited May 04 '17
/u/yonkouproductions, /u/newspecies, /u/sakata_kintoki Please approve for /r/OnePiece
1
u/FireZura https://myanimelist.net/profile/Soleni May 04 '17
A bit late, but i summon /u/psalt for /r/Berserk/ and /u/ticklemehellmo for /r/Gintama/
1
u/ccpog737 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Capture737 May 06 '17
RemindMe! 11 Jul 2017 "Anime contest!"
1
u/neobowman :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/neobowman May 07 '17
So are there going to be tribes to split up the subreddits and contests between the tribes to see which team has to vote members off of their team? Cuz that sounds dank.
Plus, boons (Iunno what boons) for the winning team.
1
u/Shayne0423 May 07 '17
Let's Go r/hunterxhunter
1
u/hitrho5 https://myanimelist.net/profile/hitrho5 May 07 '17
Paging /u/mariololftw for /r/TokyoGhoul.
1
u/ShaKing807 x3myanimelist.net/profile/Shaking807 May 08 '17
/u/gearfire thoughts on entering HxH into the ring for this?
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '17
GIIINNTAAAMAAA
1
u/camocam0 May 13 '17 edited May 13 '17
So, I'm gonna call out some of my most viewed subs I would be excited to see.
Yo! /u/marshall_banana_ is this something /r/cowboybebop or /r/SpaceDandy is interested in getting involved in?
And i think /u/jaxspider, how about /r/gurrenlagann?
um.. /u/bigslothonmyface or /u/Dragon_Claw, is /r/pokemon eligible do you think? or is /r/pokemon too much about the games and not enough about the anime? I'm sorry I'm not aware of any sub as large/popular where the anime is discussed.
And I know its smaller in comparison to the others I've mentioned but I really liked /r/Keijo. /u/CronosDage or /u/redundan want in?
Edit: adding more of what I love,
/u/N3DSdude over at /r/DragonMaid
/u/GreatRequiem or someone, in /r/Kangoku_Gakuen
/u/MattWatchesChalk, I think /r/KillLaKill has a good shot
1
u/illtima :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/illuminatima May 02 '17
I'm sorry, but I really cannot see how it's different from any other popularity contest...
0
u/[deleted] May 02 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 02 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 02 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment