r/AcademicQuran • • 1d ago

Weekly Open Discussion Thread

2 Upvotes

This is the general discussion thread in which anyone can make posts and/or comments. This thread will, automatically, repeat every week.

This thread will be lightly moderated only for breaking our subs Rule 1: Be Respectful, and Reddit's Content Policy. Questions unrelated to the subreddit may be asked, but preaching and proselytizing will be removed.

r/AcademicQuran offers many helpful resources for those looking to ask and answer questions, including:


r/AcademicQuran • • 9h ago

The painting of Plato (Aflāṭūn) in the Islamic world, charming wild animals with the sounds of his wondrous musical instrument, thereby surpassing his rival Aristotle. It was produced by Madhu a Mughal court painter during the reign of Emperor Akbar.

Post image
36 Upvotes

r/AcademicQuran • • 2h ago

According to Nicolai Sinai, the Quran underwent a "substantial amount of scribal editing" at a "secondary stage" of its formulation during Muhammad's lifetime (credit: NeophyteOne)

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Originally posted here.


r/AcademicQuran • • 6h ago

Quran “Does the Qur’an present the story of Dhul-Qarnayn as an account of actual historical events, expecting its audience to understand him as a real historical figure, or is it retelling an existing legendary tradition without necessarily making a claim about the historical accuracy of the events?

3 Upvotes

I’d also be interested in understanding if the Qur'an's use of the word dhikr (ذِكْرًا) in 18:83 usually translated as story, narrative or parable tell us anything about whether it considers the account historical?

They ask you ˹O Prophet˺ about Ⱬul-Qarnain. Say, “I will relate to you something of his narrative.” Quran 18:83?

Thank you all for your comments in advance and for any Academic sources cited!


r/AcademicQuran • • 17h ago

Question References to Jacob of Serugh/other Syriac church fathers and saints in Islamic literature?

5 Upvotes

I know that somewhere along the way somebody showed me hadith or some kind of Islamic literature that referenced Jacob and I was wondering what those specific references are. Also, are there references to other Syriac church fathers or saints in extra-Quranic Islamic texts?


r/AcademicQuran • • 22h ago

Transformations of Hajj Throughout History: A Qualitative Analysis of Its Civilizational, Humanitarian, and Administrative Dimensions (2026) By Safran Safar Almakaty [FREE ACCESS]

Thumbnail
brill.com
5 Upvotes

r/AcademicQuran • • 1d ago

Sexual intercourse at age Nine : Sanhedrin 54b:20 and Bukhari

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

Perhaps the hadith's specific reference to the age of nine reflects the influence of earlier Rabbinic Jewish law


r/AcademicQuran • • 18h ago

Question From historical/academic perspective is the Athari aqeeda the original form of Islam?

0 Upvotes

It seems to me that Deobandis who follow the Maturidi school are closer to traditional Islam. Where did the idea that only Athari is the correct aqeeda come from? Was it purely Salafism that started this thought-process or something else?


r/AcademicQuran • • 1d ago

Jonathan Brown's criticisms of Wael Hallaq about the hadith critics and their epistemological versus operative certainty

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Source:


r/AcademicQuran • • 1d ago

Quran The Noble Quran, English Translation by Ahmed Bahgat.

Thumbnail
archive.org
4 Upvotes

This work is a deliberately literal English translation of the Arabic Quran. It keeps the wording raw and allows the verses to stand without commentary. The English follows Arabic grammar, vocabulary, and sentence structure. Passive constructions and the verse layout are preserved intact. This English is literal, not literary, on purpose.


r/AcademicQuran • • 1d ago

Book/Paper Mullā Ṣadrā argues that all Existence is one fundamental reality manifesting in different degrees of intensity. The essences by which we categorise things are mental labels. God the One is simple & pure Being, Existence itself & is the totality of Existence.

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

r/AcademicQuran • • 2d ago

Video/Podcast What Was Mecca Like Before Islam?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
17 Upvotes

r/AcademicQuran • • 2d ago

Andreas Gorke argues that some exegetical statements can be traced back to the Companions

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

r/AcademicQuran • • 2d ago

Why Didn't the Companions Identify Dhul Qarnayn as Alexander?

11 Upvotes

If DQ is Alexander and the same story already existed before the revelation of Surah al-Kahf, why don't we find reports attributed to the Companions explicitly identifying DQ as Alexander? Instead, we find different and sometimes conflicting interpretations. For example, a report attributed to Umar appears to identify Dhul Qarnayn as an angel while reports attributed to Ali describe him as a righteous man and interpret his two horns non-literally. Some later Quranic exegetes identify Dhul Qarnayn with Alexander. But why don't we find a clear identification with Alexander in the traditions attributed to the Companions?


r/AcademicQuran • • 2d ago

Interpretation of Quran in a more grounded historical-critical approach: Given that the Quranic text itself does not show static laws and ways of practices being forever static from one generation to another generation, there is room for progressive, modernist Quran-informed law practices.

4 Upvotes

Is the premise for this accurate based on the academic, historical-critical understanding of Quran? I see that at the end of the day, there has to be a shift in how we interpret the Quran first. So maybe the historical-critical findings of the Quran will help shift the interpretation, just how the interpretation of the Bible were shifted. I see the power of this sub-reddit in helping to shift the interpretation and raising an informed, historical view.


r/AcademicQuran • • 2d ago

Question Could a Dead Sea Scrolls-Style Discovery Be Found for the Quran?

9 Upvotes

The Dead Sea Scrolls revolutionized Hebrew&Christian Bible and biblical studies by supplying manuscripts over a millennium older than previously known texts, confirming the overall stability of the tradition while revealing important variants and the rich diversity of Second Temple Judaism. Might a similar historical discovery one day emerge for the Quran and early Islam, reshaping our understanding of its textual history and origins?


r/AcademicQuran • • 2d ago

Pre-Islamic Arabia How Relevant is This Passage?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

What appears interesting to me is that this seems to follow the orthodox narrative quite well. I'm not sure if this passage presents a valid perspective (Arabia originally being monotheistic and then venturing into henotheism and later polytheism).

Not sure what to make of this from an academic perspective. Insight would be helpful.


r/AcademicQuran • • 2d ago

Quran Parallels to Q 26:63's imagery of the Red Sea's waves standing like massive mountains in Aphrahat and a pre-Islamic poem

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

(Sources: Aphrahat, Demonstrations 1.15 (Translation by Adam Lehto, p. 80); Nevin Reda, "The Quranic Talut (Saul) and the Rise of the Ancient Israelite Monarchy: An Intertextual Reading", p. 44)


r/AcademicQuran • • 2d ago

Is Ali Shariati’s reading of kāfir a political reinterpretation inserted into the text?

3 Upvotes

Hi all! I have a question pertaining to the semantics of kufr. I'm no academic and my interests lay primarily in Islamic Liberation Theology but I rely on historical-critical scholarship for many of my polemical arguments. In Religion vs Religion by Ali Shariati, he claims that the Qur’anic kāfir is defined by a “refusal to act”, that the term was not meant to apply to those who reject metaphysical beliefs such as the existence of God, or the soul, resurrection, etc. Which, I suppose makes sense, given that the Qur’an’s opponents are not atheists. Also that the root of kufr seems to frequently operate as an antonym of shukr. IIRC Juan Cole once explained (plz correct me if I'm wrong) that “ingratitude” is often a better translation than “disbelief”. But the claim that the term is never doctrinal seems difficult to defend against Q 64:7 and 34:3, where alladhīna kafarū are identified by their denial of the resurrection, or against Q 5:72–73, where kufr is predicated of a Christological position.

Sort of rambling here but my question(s) are: how would you characterize the relation between the ethical and the doxastic senses of kufr in the Qur’an itself, and do you think Shariati should be read as inserting a philological claim into the text, or a constructive theological one?


r/AcademicQuran • • 3d ago

The Caucasus: Mountains Full of Languages

Thumbnail
youtube.com
7 Upvotes

Quran 18:93 says that Dhul Qarnayn found a people "who could barely understand speech" in the territory where he built the gate between the two mountains to fend off Gog and Magog.

This detail, which sounds cryptic when mentioned by itself, is immediately made sense of when one reads the parallel story about Alexander the Great (whose legends many historians believe underlie the story of Dhul Qarnayn in the Quran) in the Syriac Alexander Legend (the Neshana). The Legend has critical geographic information about this story that helps us understand why the Quran describes these people the way it does: namely, that the region where Alexander constructed this gate was in the Caucasus territory.

For all of history, and especially in ancient times, the Caucasus was famous for its linguistic differentiation from the surrounding regions, and its linguistic diversity and the many languages spoken throughout it. Indeed, the Caucasus was home to the Kartvelian languages, a family of languages which are unrelated any other language in the world. This ethnographic information was important to know for anyone living in this area, as well as the many people who made contact with them through trade or through diplomacy.

The video I shared has an entertaining introduction to this phenomena of the many languages spoken in the Caucasus, and hopefully will help people understand the historical background behind this Quranic referent!


r/AcademicQuran • • 3d ago

Islam and Naturalism served with a side of Hadith

4 Upvotes

How possible is it to naturalistically explain Islam. Is it harder to explain than other religions. In addition what percent of Hadith in Sahih Bukhari and Muslim are trustworthy?


r/AcademicQuran • • 4d ago

Quran What does the Quran say about homosexuality and other part of the LGBTQ+ community?

13 Upvotes

I'm thinking of exploring Islam a bit but am worried about doing so because of my experience with Christianity. I feel like there's no real place for me within religion because of my sexual orientation, and I don't know where to find sources of the Quran and read it as critically as I would like too. Can you all help me with this?


r/AcademicQuran • • 3d ago

Book/Paper Al-Shafi'i didn't single-handedly invent the usul al-fiqh. He was an important catalyst in the Islamic world shift toward hadith-centric legal theory, eventually leading to the creation of actual usul al-fiqh textbooks by Ibn Surayj & others a century later.

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

r/AcademicQuran • • 4d ago

Allah and Religious Syncretism

9 Upvotes

Source: Hamoud, H. (2025). 6 Allāh und die Voraussetzung der Synkretisierung/Monotheisierung am Beispiel des Raḥmān. In Die Genese Allāhs in der Spätantike: Zwischen Kultus und Synkretisierungsprozessen (pp. 333-379). Berlin, Boston: De Gruyter.

*English translation below (pp. 333-335). Footnotes appear at the end, followed by the works cited

6 Allah and the Prerequisite of Syncretism/Monotheization, Using Raḥmān as an Example

In the previous chapter, the emergence of the Muhammadan Allāh and his development as an individualizing proper name were examined through the first prerequisite of the cult. In the following two chapters, the focus will be placed on the second fundamental prerequisite that significantly advanced the emergence of Allāh: the process of syncretization. As we shall see, syncretization in the paleo-Islamic context assumed a specific character despite its common structural features. This entailed not only the integration of polytheistic divine names, epithets, and intermediary beings into Allāh, but also the adaptation, subjugation, and reconfiguration of the polytheistic world of gods.

An Old Testament scholar and Semitist (Frank M. Cross, died 2012) rightly pointed out that “[i]f you want syncretism in the Hebrew Bible, there is plenty of material to be found without manufacturing it.”[1] If this applies to the Hebrew Bible, the question arises as to how matters stand with regard to the Qurʾān. Unfortunately, despite numerous studies in religious studies on the subject of syncretism in Late Antiquity, there is to date no specialized work that subjects the divine names of Allāh, or al-Asmāʾ al-Ḥusnā (The Beautiful Names), in the Qurʾān [for example, Q. 7.180] to a comprehensive examination, particularly in view of the syncretistic tendencies of the period in which the Qurʾān emerged. In this region, there was a tendency, as already demonstrated, for certain gods not only to incorporate other pagan divine attributes into themselves, but also to merge with other gods, as in the case of Raḥmān and other polytheistic names, which will be explained in greater detail below. Such a syncretistic process was the outstanding characteristic of a constantly changing and simultaneously ambiguous conception of divinity in Late Antiquity. This process was often accompanied by a drastic reduction in divine names and played a decisive role in the question of monotheism. The syncretization of divine names can also be regarded as an indicator of the monotheization or unification of these names and the cultic practices associated with them.

Of all the polytheistic divine names that merged with Allāh through syncretization and convey to us decisive dimensions of the emergence of Allāh as a monotheistic God, the polytheistic name ar-Raḥmān is the most significant and will therefore serve here as a historical case study. Of particular importance is that this name is declared to belong to the few names that are explicitly designated in the Qurʾān as the al-Asmāʾ al-Ḥusnā of Allāh [Q. 17.110; 59.24], which is not customary for other divine epithets and names of gods in the Qurʾān. Of primary importance for what follows is how his existential polytheistic position in Late Antiquity was reshaped on the Qurʾānic stage and syncretized with Allāh, and how the polytheistic structures of Raḥmān were transformed in the Qurʾān. The following investigation, of course, makes no claim to completeness, but rather seeks to stimulate new discussions. It is an attempt to illuminate the Qurʾānic divine name ar-Raḥmān in the context of the syncretism taking place in Antiquity and Late Antiquity.

Ar-Raḥmān, which originally means ‘gracious’ or ‘merciful,’ becomes semantically complex when it is understood as a divine epithet, and is accordingly considered one of the most controversial among the divine names that contributed to the polytheistic-syncretistic process of the emergence of Allāh in the context of Late Antiquity. An attempt is made to specify more precisely the historical contribution of this particular name to the formation of the God Allāh. However, this syncretistic process has thus far received less attention in Islamic studies and religious studies research dealing with ar-Raḥmān. In the first chapter, we have already addressed some foundations of the triumphalist monotheistic narrative, to which numerous studies have also contributed by claiming that this name is necessarily and organically connected with monotheism (as we previously saw in the case of the designation Allāh). The claim that ar-Raḥmān is necessarily associated with monotheism (as remains to be demonstrated) and that this alone constitutes the preliminary stage of the rise of Islam is also consistent with the classical representation of the triumph of monotheism (something that formed a pillar of Islamic tradition), whereby a ‘praeparatio islamica’[2] is reconstructed (following Eusebius of Caesarea and his praeparatio evangelica), which establishes a connection to an ‘Abrahamic’ heritage or a vague ‘Abrahamic moment.’

It is noteworthy, however, that despite the strong emphasis on a ‘monotheistic’ origin of ar-Raḥmān, there is disagreement about what kind of monotheism underlay it. The Austrian Orientalist Aloys Sprenger (died 1893) regarded ar-Raḥmān as a ‘Nomen proprium,’[3] but nevertheless claimed a ‘Christian’ origin, assuming that ar-Raḥmān had been a name for Christ, the Son of God.[4] Later, this view was rejected, and some sought a Jewish origin for ar-Raḥmān, among them the Orientalist Hartwig Hirschfeld (died 1934), who described Sprenger’s assumptions as ‘incorrect’ and instead advocated a Jewish-Aramaic origin.[5] Although Arthur Jeffery (died 1959) was later unable to decide entirely definitively whether the term was Christian or Jewish, he nevertheless preferred a “Christian rather than a Jewish origin.”[6] Both sides ignore in this regard, whether intentionally or unintentionally, not only the polytheistic cultic components of ar-Raḥmān,[7] before he became ‘monotheistic,’ but also the syncretization that contributed to the transfer of this name to other monotheistic tendencies, a process that, as emphasized, was inscribed in the concept of polytheism and constituted one of the fundamental prerequisites in Late Antiquity. This will be discussed in detail in what follows....

Footnotes:

[1] Cited according to Smith 2002, p. xxxii, n. 111.

[2] For this expression, see Stroumsa 2016, pp. 108 and 120.

[3] Sprenger 1869, p. 198.

[4] Namely: “[...] that the word was applied by a Christian sect to the Son of God with reference to biblical passages, such as Heb. 2:17, but that Muhammad regarded it as a designation for the God of the Christians.” Sprenger 1869, pp. 201–202. One searches in vain for historically substantiated evidence of this alleged ‘sect’ in Muhammad’s surroundings.

[5] Hirschfeld 1886, p. 38.

[6] Jeffery 1938, p. 141.

Works Cited:

Smith, M. S. (2002): The Early History of God: Yahweh and the Other Deities in Ancient Israel, 2nd ed. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Eerdmans Publishing Company.

Stroumsa, Guy (2016): “Athen, Jerusalem und Mekka: der patristische Schmelztiegel der abrahamitischen Religionen”, in Nora K. Schmid and Angelika Neuwirth (eds.), Denkraum Spätantike: Reflexionen von Antiken im Umfeld des Koran. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz. pp. 107–124.

Sprenger, Aloys (1869): Das Leben und die Lehre des Mohammad: nach bisher größtenteils unbenutzten Quellen. Berlin, Halle (Saale): Nicolai’sche Verlagsbuchhandlung.

Hirschfeld, Hartwig (1886): Beiträge zur Erklärung des Ḳorân. Leipzig: Otto Schulze.

Jeffery, Arthur (1938): The foreign vocabulary of the Quran. Baroda: Oriental Institute.


r/AcademicQuran • • 4d ago

Question What kind of money was Dirham as this specific verse mentioned it?

Post image
8 Upvotes