r/AcademicBiblical • • 6d ago

Weekly Open Discussion Thread

10 Upvotes

Welcome to this week's open discussion thread!

This thread is meant to be a place for members of the r/AcademicBiblical community to freely discuss topics of interest which would normally not be allowed on the subreddit. All off-topic and meta-discussion will be redirected to this thread.

Rules 1-3 do not apply in open discussion threads, but rule 4 will still be strictly enforced. Please report violations of Rule 4 using Reddit's report feature to notify the moderation team. Furthermore, while theological discussions are allowed in this thread, this is still an ecumenical community which welcomes and appreciates people of any and all faith positions and traditions. Therefore this thread is not a place for proselytization. Feel free to discuss your perspectives or beliefs on religious or philosophical matters, but do not preach to anyone in this space. Preaching and proselytizing will be removed.

In order to best see new discussions over the course of the week, please consider sorting this thread by "new" rather than "best" or "top". This way when someone wants to start a discussion on a new topic you will see it! Enjoy the open discussion thread!


r/AcademicBiblical • • 5h ago

Question Date of Colossians

9 Upvotes

Holding to the scholarly position that Colossians is a pseudonymous epistle, when was it written?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 11h ago

Question The Vulgate Catholic Epistles

15 Upvotes

Did Jerome actually translate the Catholic epistles, or just the Gospels? And, did he write the prologue to the Latin translation of the Catholic epistles?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 8h ago

Ethiopian Bible Question

6 Upvotes

Are the Ethiopian Bibles like the Faith Made ones legitimate, or marketing nonsense?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 3h ago

Peter and Paul.

2 Upvotes

It seems the issue Paul really had in Antioch with Peter; was Peter left the non-Jewish believers when the Jew believers sent by James arrived, even though Peter had already had his Vision encounter in Acts 10:28.
Some people argued that Peter associated with the non-Jews believers in the first place with the idea and hope that he will convert them but majority said that was not the case: as this was explained by Paul as well.


r/AcademicBiblical • • 19h ago

Question Why does the Farrer hypothesis place Matthew as being earlier than Luke?

27 Upvotes

I’m currently attending the Biblical Studies Symposium and this question was asked, but neither Bart Ehrman nor John Kloppenborg could answer the question. Mark Goodacre is expected to arrive a little later and they’re betting he has an answer, but in the meantime I thought I would pose this question to you all to see if anyone has some deeper knowledge on the subject!


r/AcademicBiblical • • 18h ago

Question Greek grammar check on John 1:11 — Can hoi idioi mean "the men of the country" instead of "his own people"?

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone, if anyone here is Greek or educated in Koine Greek, could you help explain this?

In John 1:11 (Εἰς τὰ ἴδια ἦλθεν, καὶ οἱ ἴδιοι αὐτὸν οὐ παρέλαβον), I heard some fringe Christian pastors claim that because the separate word "his" (autou) isn't written in the Greek, hoi idioi actually means "the men of the country" rather than "his own people."

From a Greek grammar standpoint, has this verse always meant "his own people" rejected him, or is "the men of the country" an actual valid translation?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 1d ago

In Whose House was the Last Supper Held?

4 Upvotes

Are there any scholarly clues or suggestions on who the owner of the house was where the last Supper was held?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 1d ago

Discussion Help regarding understanding of the Parable of the Talents (Matthew 25:14-30) / Parable of the Minas (Luke 19:11-27)

10 Upvotes

I've been listening to various interpretations of these similar parables from Christian perspectives. There seems to be some quite differing ideas as to the meaning. The majority seem to hold that the Master represents Jesus, but a few more progressive preachers are putting forth a seemingly novel perspective which fits in nicely with a social gospel that the Master is meant to represent the rulers of this world who are often greedy and cruel to the poor.

But, I wish to turn now towards the more rigorous Academic side of Biblical studies. Is there anything approximating a consensus as to how the Gospel authors and the early Christians would have viewed this parable? Who would the Master have represented to them?

And is there any significance to the differences between Matttew and Luke's versions?

Thank you for any insight into this perplexing story.


r/AcademicBiblical • • 1d ago

Were the gospels written to be taken individually?

15 Upvotes

Do we know what the intent of a gospel was? Was, say Luke, supposed to stand on its own? Were there people in the Jesus movement who were Mark gospel followers, separate from, say Luke gospel followers?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 2d ago

Question “Heaven” in Luke 10:18

19 Upvotes

I would like to know how you interpret Luke 10:18, specifically regarding the heaven Jesus refers to when he says, “I saw Satan fall like lightning from heaven.”

I understand that this passage is not referring to Satan’s primordial fall, but I would like to understand which heaven Jesus is referring to in this context and what exactly this fall signifies.


r/AcademicBiblical • • 1d ago

Why does the author of Acts misrepresent Judas the Galilean in Acts 5:37?

8 Upvotes

​In Acts 5:37, the author portrays Judas the Galilean’s movement as having collapsed immediately after his death. Yet according to the Jewish-Roman historian Flavius Josephus (Jewish War 2.117–118, 2.433–434, 2.447, 7.253; Jewish Antiquities 18.4–10, 18.23, 20.102), Judas’s resistance did not simply vanish; rather, it continued through a family lineage that remained active for decades. His sons James and Simon were later crucified for insurrection under the Roman procurator Tiberius Julius Alexander (Ant. 20.102), and subsequent descendants played leading roles in the First Jewish–Roman War (66–70 CE, culminating in the fall of Masada in 73/74 CE), most notably Menahem (War 2.433–448) and Eleazar ben Jair (War 2.447; 7.253).

​In Josephus’s account, Judas and his ideological movement, the so-called "fourth philosophy", were so consequential that Josephus directly blamed them for sowing the seeds of the revolt that ultimately resulted in the destruction of Jerusalem and the Second Temple (Ant. 18.4–10; War 2.118).

​*"After him Judas the Galilean rose up in the days of the census and drew away some of the people after him. He too perished, and all who followed him were scattered."*

— Acts 5:37 (New Revised Standard Version)

​*"Under his administration it was that a certain Galilean, whose name was Judas, prevailed with his countrymen to revolt, and said they were cowards if they would endure to pay a tax to the Romans and would after God submit to mortal men as their lords."*

— Flavius Josephus, Jewish War 2.118 (trans. William Whiston)

​*"So men of this stamp were the beginning of that great calamity which came upon us."*

— Flavius Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 18.8 (trans. Louis H. Feldman, Loeb Classical Library)

​Thus, when read alongside Josephus, the claim in Acts 5:37 that all of Judas’s followers were scattered after his death appears historically inaccurate. How one explains this discrepancy depends heavily on when and with what sources the author of Luke–Acts wrote, a subject of ongoing scholarly debate:

​Possible dependence on Josephus: Several scholars—including Steve Mason, Richard I. Pervo, and Dennis R. MacDonald have argued that the author of Luke–Acts was familiar with Josephus’s writings (Jewish War and/or Jewish Antiquities), even if this remains contested among mainstream commentators. If the author knew Josephus’s work, the depiction in Acts 5:37 cannot be dismissed as mere ignorance; instead, it would represent a deliberate rhetorical distortion designed to serve Gamaliel’s theological argument (Acts 5:38–39) and to distance early Christianity from violent Judean revolutionaries.

​Dating and historical memory: While most scholars date Luke–Acts to the late first century CE (c. 80–95 CE), others such as Matthias Klinghardt and Markus Vinzent, within debates over the relationship between canonical Luke and Marcion’s Gospel propose a mid-second-century date. Yet even under the more conventional late-first-century dating, written in the aftermath of the Temple’s destruction, Judas the Galilean would still have been a recognizable symbol of anti-Roman resistance. In either scenario, the author subordinates historical precision to apologetic and literary aims


r/AcademicBiblical • • 1d ago

Same or different "god" and "father" in John 20:17?

3 Upvotes

A peculiar thought occurred to me the other day when rereading John 20:17 ESV:

Jesus said to her, “Do not cling to me, for I have not yet ascended to the Father; but go to my brothers and say to them, ‘I am ascending to my Father and your Father, to my God and your God.’ ”

Something about Jesus' phrasing seems a little odd.

The apostle Paul often opened his epistles with the phrase "God our Father", using the plural "our" (Gr. ἐγώ). For example, 1 Corinthians 1:3 ESV

Grace to you and peace from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ.

Likewise, Jesus invoked the "our Father" (Gr. ἐγώ) phrase when teaching the Lord's Prayer in Matthew 6:9 ESV

Pray then like this: “Our Father in heaven, hallowed be your name.

I do see ἐγώ is missing in Luke's version of the Lord's Prayer, however, in Luke 11:2 ESV.

And he said to them, “When you pray, say: “Father, hallowed be your name. Your kingdom come.

But bringing my question back to John's gospel:

I have always assumed - citing a theological answer here - that Jesus' phrasing in John 20:17 is simply him extending sonship to the disciples and signifying that God is indeed their father, but do any scholars have the opinion that Jesus is drawing some sort of distinction here given the laborious phrasing?

For example, could he be saying something like, "I am ascending to where both my god/father are and your god/father are"? Or perhaps scholars think this is just John's way of invoking the same idea found in Matthew? I just find it odd that I don't see ἐγώ in the text, why not just say ἐγώ?

===

Sidenote: I do find it a little odd that in John 20:17, the "my Father" has the Greek definite article ("my [the] Father]") while "my God" does not have the Greek definite article. Elsewhere, I know scholars have the opinion that "the God" is distinct given the Greek definite article, such as in John 1:1b ("[the] God").


r/AcademicBiblical • • 2d ago

Question when discussing apocryphal/non cannon texts, what terms should be used when classifying them?

9 Upvotes

hello! I've been meaning to make a doc to include apocryphal/non canonical texts but when I began my research I noticed different terms used such as deuterocanonical and pseudepigrapha

from a scholarly perspective what terms should both be used and are appropriate? I plan on intending to include everything not canon to the bible itself


r/AcademicBiblical • • 2d ago

What did 'Abraham,' 'Isaac,' 'Jacob,' and 'Joseph' represent for Jews before the Torah was composed?

13 Upvotes

In the writings of Amos, First Isaiah, and Micah, you’ll often come across the term '(house of) Jacob' as a reference to Israel. There are also instances where Amos mentions Israel as '(the house of) Joseph' and '(the house of) Isaac.' Interestingly, in the final verse of Micah, there's a reference to 'Abraham,' which appears to serve as yet another designation for Israel.

From what I gather, these texts were written before Deuteronomy, which explicitly names Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob as the Jewish patriarchs. Moreover, the majority of Deuteronomy was likely established before the various sections of Genesis were compiled.

So, before the Torah's creation, did people view these names in the same way they are presented in Genesis, as the mythical forefathers of the Jewish people, with Abraham as the father of Isaac, Isaac as the father of Jacob, and Jacob as the father of Joseph? Did these names start off as identifiers for places or groups that later evolved into individual names in the Torah, similar to how we see the names of Noah’s grandsons or Lot's descendants? Or is there a completely different backstory to their origins?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 2d ago

Question Who did Jesus get heaven and hell from?

12 Upvotes

So obviously second temple judaism was diverse and you can't just say "Modern judaism has X belief so all the Jews believed X too back then", but that makes me curious about specifics. Did heaven and hell come from a specific sect? Was it from another religion entirely?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 2d ago

Books about Ethiopia

11 Upvotes

Does anybody have any recommendations for books about the history of Christianity in Ethiopia.


r/AcademicBiblical • • 3d ago

How should we conceive of rewards/treasures being stored in "heaven" in the context of Matthew 5-6?

21 Upvotes

I'm wondering how ancient Jews would have understood this use of the concept of heaven:

Matthew 5:12 - "your reward is great in heaven"

Matthew 6:20 - "store up for yourselves treasures in heaven"

Most Bible readers may think that Jesus is saying you will be rewarded when you go to heaven. But if Matthew teaches the resurrection of the body, how should we think of disciples acquiring these heavenly objects?

Does heaven literally mean the sky, or another spacial descriptions within their cosmology? Or perhaps it simply means what is unseen, the "secret" place where the Father is? Perhaps the joy of rejoicing in the face of suffering is precisely the reward disciples are to expect?

Is it purely a temporal description, promising a delayed reward when the kingdom comes, i.e. heaven coming to earth at the resurrection, in contrast to the instant gratification of worldly rewards?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 2d ago

In Hebrews what did the author mean by a 'Great Cloud of Witnesses'

12 Upvotes

I'm curious if this was an early example of a belief in loved ones in heaven engaging with those on earth, or if this was mean to be taken as an example of a "historical record of faith heroes." Thank you


r/AcademicBiblical • • 3d ago

Question Why did the Israelites conflate El and Yahweh together into a singular God? How and why did Monotheism come about in Israel in general?

66 Upvotes

r/AcademicBiblical • • 3d ago

Pauline letters to Antioch and Alexandria

21 Upvotes

Why don’t we have Paul addressing congregations in Antioch and Alexandria. We know that he founded an Antiochian community. Isn’t it reasonable to expect him writing back to his first community telling them that he misses them, thanking them for their donations to the poor in Jerusalem? And how about Alexandria. It is interesting to me that he got mistaken for an Egyptian in Acts. I would imagine that at some point in his life, during his sojourn in Arabia*, he learned Egyptian esoteric ideas with some elements of Hinduism and Buddhism from Berenice thrown in.

Edit: and who is this Egyptian that caused Paul to get introuble? Paul had some temper but he doesn’t strike me a person with a rebellious personality. He’s an educated professional preacher, financially stable, and told people to obey the ruling class. He preached a Roman Empire version of the divine right of kings.

Thanks for your attention.

* Arabia could mean any desert region in Syria or the northwestern corner of the Arabian peninsula bordering Palestine and the Sinai peninsula.


r/AcademicBiblical • • 3d ago

Jesus biological father

0 Upvotes

Hi people. Are there any theories about who might be Jesus real father?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 3d ago

Question Epistle of James

4 Upvotes

Any good primers for the Epistle of James? I’d prefer an article. I don’t have time to read a book right now. Totally get it if that’s not possible. Thanks!


r/AcademicBiblical • • 4d ago

Have Jesus Ever Wanted to Spread His Words to the Gentiles?

25 Upvotes

What do we know about Jesus' view toward Gentiles? Were Gentiles a potential believers for Jesus? Who was the first disciple think that they should convert Gentiles?


r/AcademicBiblical • • 4d ago

Is there any extrabiblical evidence of the Jewish Revolt leaders other than Josephus who had interactions with Jesus followers? Such as Simon bar Giroa, John of Gischala, Menahem, Eleazar ben Yair or Simon bar Kokhba?

25 Upvotes

I'm asking this question as I'm trying to reconcile these major Jewish movements in relation to the passive nature of what is quoted as Jesus sayings and Paul's otherwise passive nature toward a ruling power. It just seems like a non-Jewish attitude to have enlighten of Jewish occupation history.