r/AnCap101 • • 20h ago

What is government

0 Upvotes

This article builds on the article on the state. The meaning of “state” used here is the one I introduced in that article.

While it's common for the two terms to be used interchangeably. In my view, they mean different things.

I will begin by giving a technical definition of government, then later I will give one more compatible with everyday use.

A Government is a state that only acts in accordance with policy it has publicised to the general public.

Note that a government is a state, a specific type of state, being a state is a necessary condition to be a government.

So all that is true of a state is true of a government.

The other type of state, which is a negation of a government, is a dictatorship.

A dictatorship is a state that acts either contrary to, or without any basis in, policy it has publicised to the general public.

[For simplicity, I will refer to "policy publicised to the general public" as “existing policy” from this point forward.]

Because a government restricts its actions to existing policy, its actions are predictable.

(only referring to government as I've defined it here, not necessarily how the real world entities called governments always behave).

A dictatorship's actions are unpredictable. They are not limited to existing policy, but to the private momentary desires of some person. (The dictator)

Two types of state action:

So there's two kinds of actions a state may engage in, in relation to whether it is consistent with existing policy or not.

  1. State action that is consistent with existing policy, we shall call this governmental action.
  2. State action that is contrary to, or without any basis in existing policy, we shall call this dictatorial action.

The spectrum :

In reality, a state may not behave exclusively as a government or a dictatorship. A single state can engage in both types of action—sometimes acting in accordance with existing policy and sometimes not.

Because states can be mixed, they exist along a political spectrum:

Pure Government: A state that only engages in Governmental action.

Pure Dictatorship: A state that only engages in Dictatorial action.

Mixed States: The wide variety of states in between, with differing ratios of both actions.

The more a state engages in governmental action, the more of a Government it is ; the more it engages in dictatorial action, the more of a Dictatorship it is.

For common usage, it is best to classify a state based on which of the two types of action dominates its behaviour.

If governmental action dominates, we shall call it a government; if dictatorial action dominates, we shall call it a dictatorship.


r/AnCap101 • • 5h ago

I'm conducting a social experiment on Discord: Can a society function with complete freedom and equal rights?

0 Upvotes

I've been thinking about an interesting question: What would happen if we created an online society where everyone had equal rights, complete creative freedom, and no conventional moderation powers?

I decided to actually try it instead of just discussing it theoretically.

I have a Discord server that originally served as a testing ground for my bot. Now that development is finished, I'm turning it into a persistent sandbox experiment.

Here's how it works:

  • Everyone has the freedom to shape the server.
  • Members can change the server name and icon, create roles, add emojis, build channels, and establish their own communities.
  • Everyone has equal opportunities to participate and contribute.
  • Nobody can ban, kick, mute, or timeout other members.
  • Nobody can simply wipe the server and destroy what everyone has built.

I'm still the server owner, mainly to maintain the infrastructure and prevent the entire experiment from being destroyed. However, I don't want to control how the community develops.

I also have a plan for the future.

If the server eventually reaches around 300–500 members, I'd like to introduce democratic elections. Members could vote for a President who would receive administrative responsibilities and help organize the growing community.

The goal isn't necessarily to eliminate leadership forever, but to see whether a decentralized community can develop naturally and whether democratic leadership becomes necessary as it grows.

But there's a problem I'm particularly interested in exploring.

What happens when someone abuses their freedom?

Bullies and disruptive individuals will probably exist. Some people might leave because of conflicts, but what if neither side wants to leave? Without conventional moderation, how would the community resolve these situations?

Would people naturally develop social rules, informal leadership, cooperation, and methods of conflict resolution? Or would unrestricted freedom eventually create instability and undermine everyone else's freedom?

I'm genuinely curious about what will happen, including the possibility that the experiment fails.

I'd like to invite anyone interested in this idea to participate.

This isn't a finished community with an established culture or hierarchy. You're joining while it's still developing, and you'll have the opportunity to influence what it becomes.

Discord server: https://discord.gg/MMJSqcR6J

I'd also appreciate hearing your thoughts:

  1. Can a society function without conventional punishment or centralized authority?
  2. Can social pressure and cooperation replace traditional moderation?
  3. Does equal freedom necessarily lead to equal treatment?
  4. Would democratic leadership eventually become necessary?
  5. What do you think would be the biggest reason this experiment could fail?

I'm not trying to prove a political ideology or establish a perfect society. I simply want to see what happens when people are given genuine freedom and the responsibility to build something together.


r/AnCap101 • • 20h ago

What is the state part 2

0 Upvotes

There will always be a state

The concept doesn't depend on any particular entity existing; rather, it relies on the differences in capability to use force among various organisations.

Among different organisations, just like among individuals, there will always be differences in their capability to use force.

So there will always be an organisation more capable than all others, that's the state.

For as long as there are differences in the capability to use force, there is a state.

Just like in a race there will always be first place, it's not fixed in a particular runner. It's whoever crosses the finish line first.

The State can't be abolished but only shift from one organisation to another

We must ask, who or what will abolish it? Are they capable of doing it? With what power?

For one entity to abolish another it must have a greater capability to use force than the one it wants to abolish (must be more powerful).

But by definition the state is the entity most capable, meaning there's no entity within that territory that has a greater capability than it.

Therefore the state can't be abolished. Because no entity satisfies the necessary condition to do so.

If an entity within some defined territory can be abolished by another within the same territory, then it's not the state of that territory. If it is the state, then there's no entity within that territory capable of destroying it.

In simpler terms.

If it can be abolished, then it's not a state. If it is a state, then it can't be abolished.

The state can change

What is possible though is for the state to change.

Any organisation that is a state is an incumbent state, not the definition of state itself.

An organisation can gain or lose being a state, it can become a state or cease being one. Who the state is…may change, but the existence of one is inherent to any society.

Just like over the course of a race, who is first place may change, but first place will always exist, it can't be abolished.

How the state can change :

If some other entity were to develop a capability for force which exceeds that of an incumbent state i.e sufficient to destroy it , the incumbent would cease to be the state and the now more powerful entity would become the new state.

The state has not been abolished, it has changed. What has happened is substitution not abolishment. Whoever supersedes number one becomes the new number one.

Abolishing former state :

And if the now superior entity were to abolish the now inferior one, it wouldn't be abolishing a state, but a former state.(thus it still remains true that a state can't be abolished).

So an organisation that is an incumbent state can be abolished, but not while it is a state.

It would no longer be a state when that occurs.

It would have ceased to be one the moment another organisation satisfied the necessary condition to destroy it, i.e when another entity exceeded this incumbent’s capability for force, before even being abolished.

Related point, “abolition of hierarchies”.

There's another related aspect of anarchism, the broader and core of it. Which is the so-called “abolition of hierarchies”.

To abolish something requires overpowering it, which is a hierarchical act in itself.

Even if they somehow managed to abolish existing hierarchies, how would they prevent new ones from forming?

They can't prevent new ones from forming without going against their own ideals.

To stop hierarchies from forming, they must be more powerful than those who may want to form them. This would itself be a hierarchy , with the anarchists on top.

You can only stop your inferiors not your equals.

Therefore it's contradictory to say one is able to “prevent hierarchies from forming”.

Having the power to prevent them means you are already standing at the top of one.

The state is anti-egalitarian

Anarchism is simply communism, which is about equality.

It's consistent with anarchism to want to abolish the state as part of the goal of abolishing differences (inequities) / hierarchies.

Because, as I've stated in this and the previous article. The basis of the state are the inevitable differences (inequities) in the capability to use force.

But the capability to use force is not and will never be equal (egalitarian), not among individuals and not among organisations.


r/AnCap101 • • 20h ago

What is the state

0 Upvotes

A state is the organisation that is the most capable at using force within some defined territory.

  • Territory

1)A state only exists in relation to some territory.

A state is a state of some specific territory.

Eg The state of territory A or of territory B etc.

2)The state of some territory exists within it.

Eg The state of territory A, exists within territory A.

Organisations outside of A, whatever their capabilities are, can't be the state of this territory.

  • Superiority not monopoly

There's a definition of the state which says that, a state is the organisation that holds a monopoly on the use of force.

It's impossible for any entity to have a monopoly on the use of force, no matter how powerful it is, it can only penalise individuals after they've already used force.

An organisation declaring the use of force by others prohibited, does not make it impossible for them to use it. They still can, and some will in fact use it.

All it can do is react after force has been used.

To have a monopoly it would have to be able to know in advance which Individual (of the possibly millions) will use force and at what time, then act before the Individual uses it. But no entity can ever be able to do that, especially for large numbers of people.

What a state has is not a monopoly on the use of force; but superiority over every person and organisation in the capability to use it. (Persons and organisations within the territory it is a state of)

  • Legitimacy

A slightly different definition says, the state is the organisation that holds a monopoly on the legitimate use of force.

This translates to “the only organisation whose use of force is legitimate”,

but legitimate to whom?

Whose appraisal of an organisation's use of force as legitimate is necessary for it to be a state?

Different people can point to different organisations and say “this is the only organisation whose use of force is legitimate, therefore they have a monopoly on the legitimate use of force”

Any organisation may say that their use of force is legitimate and the use of force by others isn't. That would mean it has a monopoly, according to its view of legitimacy (whatever it is).

They may say “the majority” decides legitimacy, but that would be an alteration, this definition only says “legitimate”. It doesn't say to the majority or to whom.

Legitimacy also varies by the ideology being used to judge an instance of a use of force.

Some use of force may be legitimate in one political ideology while also being illegitimate in another. Which one is used to judge legitimacy to qualify as a state?

However the proponents of this definition answer these questions what remains is this ;

It doesn't matter who or how many believe an organisation's use of force is legitimate if within the same territory, there exists some other organisation(s) with a greater capability to use force.

This organisation would be unable to enforce any policy on the more powerful organisations despite belief in its legitimacy.

  • Rank not policy

The term itself doesn't say when and how an organisation uses force.

It's only about its position in the hierarchy of capability to use force within some defined territory, not how that force is used.

That an organisation is a state, is not a statement about how it acts or its policies.

It's only about its relative capability to use force.

These two must be kept separate,

[1] The policies and/or behaviour of an organisation, this includes how it uses force.

And [2] Its rank amongst other organisations in the capability to use force.

Don't fuse policy with rank in capability.

Thus there could be differences among states in their policies. But what makes them states is that within their territories, they are the most capable at using force.

  • Only one state at a time :

There can only be one state in some specific territory at a time, by definition.

Multiple organisations can have the capability to use force, but only one qualifies as the "most capable".

A state is not necessarily the only one with the capability to use force; it is the one most capable to use it.

It's only in this sense that a state can be said to have a monopoly, only one can be the most capable of all.