r/AnCap101 • u/Avi-Lin • 20h ago
What is government
This article builds on the article on the state. The meaning of “state” used here is the one I introduced in that article.
While it's common for the two terms to be used interchangeably. In my view, they mean different things.
I will begin by giving a technical definition of government, then later I will give one more compatible with everyday use.
A Government is a state that only acts in accordance with policy it has publicised to the general public.
Note that a government is a state, a specific type of state, being a state is a necessary condition to be a government.
So all that is true of a state is true of a government.
The other type of state, which is a negation of a government, is a dictatorship.
A dictatorship is a state that acts either contrary to, or without any basis in, policy it has publicised to the general public.
[For simplicity, I will refer to "policy publicised to the general public" as “existing policy” from this point forward.]
Because a government restricts its actions to existing policy, its actions are predictable.
(only referring to government as I've defined it here, not necessarily how the real world entities called governments always behave).
A dictatorship's actions are unpredictable. They are not limited to existing policy, but to the private momentary desires of some person. (The dictator)
Two types of state action:
So there's two kinds of actions a state may engage in, in relation to whether it is consistent with existing policy or not.
- State action that is consistent with existing policy, we shall call this governmental action.
- State action that is contrary to, or without any basis in existing policy, we shall call this dictatorial action.
The spectrum :
In reality, a state may not behave exclusively as a government or a dictatorship. A single state can engage in both types of action—sometimes acting in accordance with existing policy and sometimes not.
Because states can be mixed, they exist along a political spectrum:
Pure Government: A state that only engages in Governmental action.
Pure Dictatorship: A state that only engages in Dictatorial action.
Mixed States: The wide variety of states in between, with differing ratios of both actions.
The more a state engages in governmental action, the more of a Government it is ; the more it engages in dictatorial action, the more of a Dictatorship it is.
For common usage, it is best to classify a state based on which of the two types of action dominates its behaviour.
If governmental action dominates, we shall call it a government; if dictatorial action dominates, we shall call it a dictatorship.