r/AnCap101 • • 6d ago

Hoppe Is an Embarrassment to the Libertarian Movement

0 Upvotes

Hoppe gave a speech where he endorsed Holocaust Denial, seemed to imply the existence of some kind of international Jewish conspiracy, and peddled of bunch of bullshit history.

I think Hoppe is a deeply unserious thinker, but you don't have to agree with me about that to see how what he presents as "the libertarian version" is not only wrong on the facts but is not really libertarian at all. It's contrarian but it has nothing to do with libertarianism.

Just read what he said in a recent speech at his own think tank based in Turkey, and the fact that Hoppe lives in Turkey is relevant, as you will see. I highly recommend you read the whole transcript because man it is a lot of bullshit, and I'm having to pick just the worst of the bullshit.

So what about the second world war? Again the history that we learned in Germany was of course that the Germans started that damn thing too. In fact it was by no means the case.

Hitler was a great friend of Great Britain and the Anglo-Saxon world…He had no interest in conducting war against England or the United States. What he did want was to regain some of originally German territory that had been occupied by Poland, which was created after World War I…So Germany had some fights there with Poland. The Poles were very intransigent, encouraged by the British and the French, that if anything ever happened to the Poles that would be a reason for war of them against Germany.

When Germany invaded Poland in agreement with Russia—which invaded Poland a couple weeks later—Britain declared war on Germany…So there was no war declaration of Germany against any of the western powers. To the contrary, the western powers declared war against Germany…

Germany was forced to conduct a war in the west…Germany wanted peace—it sought to secure peace in the west—because its ambition, Hitler’s intention, was directed toward the east. He wanted to have nothing to do with the west. They were considered even friends.

Now how did this world war end? Again, the British managed to get the Americans entangled in this war too, just as they had done during the first war, and it was again of course the Americans who ultimately decided the outcome of the war.

If I submitted this as an essay answer for an AP History course in high school, I'd get flunked. It's a bunch of crap, but how can anyone take this seriously? Hoppe provides basically no evidence to back up his claims, scanty reasoning to back up his claims, and some of his claims are so vague, I don't even know if they are falsifiable. And this guy is supposed to be some deep thinker who is the greatest living libertarian intellectual?

Let's start with his claim that "Germany" did not start World War II. But wait a minute.

What is "Germany"? Let me remind you, Hoppe is not only an anarcho-capitalist, but he claims the mantle of Murray Rothbard and makes himself out to be (or is cracked up to be) the living heir apparent, the St. Peter to Murray Rothbard the Christ. So what did Rothbard say?

Rothbard wrote in The Anatomy of the State:

….one of the basic doctrines of the State was to identify itself with the territory it governed. Since most men tend to love their homeland, the identification of that land and its people with the State was a means of making natural patriotism work to the State’s advantage. If “Ruritania” was being attacked by “Waldavia” the first task of the State and its intellectuals was to convince the people of Ruritania that the attack was really upon them, and not simply upon the ruling caste. In this way, a war between rulers was converted into a war between peoples, with each people coming to the defence of its rulers in the erroneous belief that the rulers were defending them.

Hoppe is committing the very error Rothbard warned against!

So, like I said, the version of history being presented by Hoppe isn't libertarian. He's speaking about collectives as if they are real; he is conflating groups of people with the state that rules over them. So, when he says "Germany" you should read "the Nazi state."

But then, Hoppe seems to go out of his way to not mention the Nazis. He only mentions "the National Socialists" by name twice, basically to say "it's the fault of democracy that the National Socialists took power," with no mention of what "National Socialism" is or what Hitler believed or how "National Socialism" led to the both the war and the Holocaust. Because: the Nazis were socialists. And the zero-sum thinking of socialism logically leads to totalitarianism and genocide. A "revisionist" historian should be pointing out how Hitler was a socialist and yet Hoppe has almost nothing to say about Hitler or his socialism. So Hoppe is not only not doing libertarianism, he isn't doing "revisionist" history either! He is regurgitating a narrative that was set in stone in the 1960s by Neo-Nazis like David Leslie Hoggan.

And this narrative is crap.

Hoppe says that it's "by no means the case" that World War II was started by "the Germans."

Okay. So who did start WW2? Hoppe never says. Maybe nobody started World War II? After all, the "mainstream narrative" presented about World War 2 has "huge holes in the story" so, maybe World War 2 never happened at all? It's all one big hoax?

Hoppe doesn't make it clear, but I think that he believes it's "the case" that "Germany" (really: the Nazi state) is not responsible for WW2 because "Germany" did not declare war on Britain, but Britain's govt declared war on Germany, and thus "Germany" was "forced" to fight a war in the West.

That's the only way I can make sense of Hoppe bringing up this little factoid about the lack of a reciprocal war declaration from Hitler against Britain, as if somehow because Hitler didn't declare war therefore Hitler is absolved of starting the war.

But notice the double standard. Hoppe says "Germany" was "forced" to fight a war in the West because of the British declaration of war on Germany, but Hoppe does not say this about America.

Hitler declared war on America even though America had not declared war on Nazi Germany.

Congress declared war against Japan on December 8, 1941. They did not declare war on Germany. Three full days elapsed, and there was no American declaration of war against Germany, and then Hitler declared war against the United States on December 11.

So if we applied to the American government the same standards Hoppe applies to Nazi Germany, then "America was forced to fight a war in Europe" because Hitler declared war on America even though America had not declared war on Germany. But does Hoppe say? That the British "entangled" America in a war. But couldn't we just as well say Hitler entangled America in a war by declaring war on America.

The fact that Hoppe goes out of his way to point out how Hitler did not declare war on Britain, but never mentions how Hitler declared war on America, should tell us a lot.

So far then, let me remind you: Hoppe isn't living up to Murray Rothbard's principles, he's not making an evidence-based argument, and now he's deliberately ignoring historical facts so that he can apply a double standard. Go ahead and try to defend that, you Hoppe fanboys. I welcome the challenge.

But then if "the Germans" didn't start the war....who did? Hoppe never tells us. What even is his argument? He never backs up his claim with either reasoning or evidence to actually falsify the premise that the Germans started the war. What? Is he gonna argue, well, ackshually, the Germans didn't start the war because Hitler was Austrian or something?

This guy is an intellectual lightweight, or perhaps a midwit who was mentally one-shotted by anti-Semitic propaganda intended to fool illiterate Russian peasants.

Let's go back to this point that Hoppe lives in Turkey, a country which does not criminalize Holocaust denial (which, to be clear, is a good thing, but then the fact that the Turkish government criminalizes or censors speech pointing out how the Ottoman Empire committed a genocide against the Armenians would suggest that the Turkish government is hardly some champion of the principle of the right to free speech).

Here is I think the most damning thing Hoppe said:

...if you look at what Israel—with Americans assistance—is doing in the Gaza Strip, is doing in Lebanon and doing in Iran, of which we all have documentation—we can see it, there are videos of that, the cruelty that is unrivaled. Nothing like that happened in World War I. Nothing like that happened in World War II. Look at Gaza completely flattened. And that is all explained to us as self-defense. And of course the Europeans, dumb as they are, having been made even dumber by the dumb Americans, they believe in this sort of thing. They compare what happens to Gaza with the so-called Holocaust.

I bolded that section to call out how I think Hoppe is a bitter America-hating loser. Read his speech and it reeks of a German nationalist who is upset America came along and ruined the chances of a 20th Century dominated by a German-dominated Europe and/or world. What else Hoppe said:

As far as the Holocaust is concerned, if you deny the teeniest detail in the official narrative of the Holocaust in Germany, you will be jailed.

Again: Hoppe lives in Turkey, where denying the Holocaust isn't a crime. And, likewise, denying the Holocaust is not a crime in the US. So what's Hoppe's point? That the German government is evil? No, it's to make himself out as some kind of a persecuted victim because he dares question the Holocaust. No, Doktor Hoppe, you're not a victim of anything, you're just an idiot. As your own words attest to!

So what's the point Despite the fact that nobody, even among those people who are called Holocaust deniers, has ever denied that cruel, evil, ugly things happened during that period. [Let me interject: cruel things like what exactly????]

But if you study these things a little bit more closely—again I learned that all from Rothbard too—there are huge holes in the story. There are lots of lies mixed into certain things that are undoubtedly true. There were never forensic investigations done in these places. The so-called Nuremberg trial was—even by high ranking American politicians like Taft, who was a presidential candidate—considered to be kangaroo courts. If you compare the evidence that had large holes with the evidence that we have about the cruelty that is done in Gaza, you must say: how can anybody not blame people who support this sort of thing.

Hoppe is not only denying the Holocaust, he is saying he got his Holocaust Denialism from Rothbard. I'm fucking done with this guy, he's a fucking loser.


r/AnCap101 • • 8h ago

I'm conducting a social experiment on Discord: Can a society function with complete freedom and equal rights?

0 Upvotes

I've been thinking about an interesting question: What would happen if we created an online society where everyone had equal rights, complete creative freedom, and no conventional moderation powers?

I decided to actually try it instead of just discussing it theoretically.

I have a Discord server that originally served as a testing ground for my bot. Now that development is finished, I'm turning it into a persistent sandbox experiment.

Here's how it works:

  • Everyone has the freedom to shape the server.
  • Members can change the server name and icon, create roles, add emojis, build channels, and establish their own communities.
  • Everyone has equal opportunities to participate and contribute.
  • Nobody can ban, kick, mute, or timeout other members.
  • Nobody can simply wipe the server and destroy what everyone has built.

I'm still the server owner, mainly to maintain the infrastructure and prevent the entire experiment from being destroyed. However, I don't want to control how the community develops.

I also have a plan for the future.

If the server eventually reaches around 300–500 members, I'd like to introduce democratic elections. Members could vote for a President who would receive administrative responsibilities and help organize the growing community.

The goal isn't necessarily to eliminate leadership forever, but to see whether a decentralized community can develop naturally and whether democratic leadership becomes necessary as it grows.

But there's a problem I'm particularly interested in exploring.

What happens when someone abuses their freedom?

Bullies and disruptive individuals will probably exist. Some people might leave because of conflicts, but what if neither side wants to leave? Without conventional moderation, how would the community resolve these situations?

Would people naturally develop social rules, informal leadership, cooperation, and methods of conflict resolution? Or would unrestricted freedom eventually create instability and undermine everyone else's freedom?

I'm genuinely curious about what will happen, including the possibility that the experiment fails.

I'd like to invite anyone interested in this idea to participate.

This isn't a finished community with an established culture or hierarchy. You're joining while it's still developing, and you'll have the opportunity to influence what it becomes.

Discord server: https://discord.gg/MMJSqcR6J

I'd also appreciate hearing your thoughts:

  1. Can a society function without conventional punishment or centralized authority?
  2. Can social pressure and cooperation replace traditional moderation?
  3. Does equal freedom necessarily lead to equal treatment?
  4. Would democratic leadership eventually become necessary?
  5. What do you think would be the biggest reason this experiment could fail?

I'm not trying to prove a political ideology or establish a perfect society. I simply want to see what happens when people are given genuine freedom and the responsibility to build something together.


r/AnCap101 • • 23h ago

What is government

0 Upvotes

This article builds on the article on the state. The meaning of “state” used here is the one I introduced in that article.

While it's common for the two terms to be used interchangeably. In my view, they mean different things.

I will begin by giving a technical definition of government, then later I will give one more compatible with everyday use.

A Government is a state that only acts in accordance with policy it has publicised to the general public.

Note that a government is a state, a specific type of state, being a state is a necessary condition to be a government.

So all that is true of a state is true of a government.

The other type of state, which is a negation of a government, is a dictatorship.

A dictatorship is a state that acts either contrary to, or without any basis in, policy it has publicised to the general public.

[For simplicity, I will refer to "policy publicised to the general public" as “existing policy” from this point forward.]

Because a government restricts its actions to existing policy, its actions are predictable.

(only referring to government as I've defined it here, not necessarily how the real world entities called governments always behave).

A dictatorship's actions are unpredictable. They are not limited to existing policy, but to the private momentary desires of some person. (The dictator)

Two types of state action:

So there's two kinds of actions a state may engage in, in relation to whether it is consistent with existing policy or not.

  1. State action that is consistent with existing policy, we shall call this governmental action.
  2. State action that is contrary to, or without any basis in existing policy, we shall call this dictatorial action.

The spectrum :

In reality, a state may not behave exclusively as a government or a dictatorship. A single state can engage in both types of action—sometimes acting in accordance with existing policy and sometimes not.

Because states can be mixed, they exist along a political spectrum:

Pure Government: A state that only engages in Governmental action.

Pure Dictatorship: A state that only engages in Dictatorial action.

Mixed States: The wide variety of states in between, with differing ratios of both actions.

The more a state engages in governmental action, the more of a Government it is ; the more it engages in dictatorial action, the more of a Dictatorship it is.

For common usage, it is best to classify a state based on which of the two types of action dominates its behaviour.

If governmental action dominates, we shall call it a government; if dictatorial action dominates, we shall call it a dictatorship.


r/AnCap101 • • 23h ago

What is the state part 2

0 Upvotes

There will always be a state

The concept doesn't depend on any particular entity existing; rather, it relies on the differences in capability to use force among various organisations.

Among different organisations, just like among individuals, there will always be differences in their capability to use force.

So there will always be an organisation more capable than all others, that's the state.

For as long as there are differences in the capability to use force, there is a state.

Just like in a race there will always be first place, it's not fixed in a particular runner. It's whoever crosses the finish line first.

The State can't be abolished but only shift from one organisation to another

We must ask, who or what will abolish it? Are they capable of doing it? With what power?

For one entity to abolish another it must have a greater capability to use force than the one it wants to abolish (must be more powerful).

But by definition the state is the entity most capable, meaning there's no entity within that territory that has a greater capability than it.

Therefore the state can't be abolished. Because no entity satisfies the necessary condition to do so.

If an entity within some defined territory can be abolished by another within the same territory, then it's not the state of that territory. If it is the state, then there's no entity within that territory capable of destroying it.

In simpler terms.

If it can be abolished, then it's not a state. If it is a state, then it can't be abolished.

The state can change

What is possible though is for the state to change.

Any organisation that is a state is an incumbent state, not the definition of state itself.

An organisation can gain or lose being a state, it can become a state or cease being one. Who the state is…may change, but the existence of one is inherent to any society.

Just like over the course of a race, who is first place may change, but first place will always exist, it can't be abolished.

How the state can change :

If some other entity were to develop a capability for force which exceeds that of an incumbent state i.e sufficient to destroy it , the incumbent would cease to be the state and the now more powerful entity would become the new state.

The state has not been abolished, it has changed. What has happened is substitution not abolishment. Whoever supersedes number one becomes the new number one.

Abolishing former state :

And if the now superior entity were to abolish the now inferior one, it wouldn't be abolishing a state, but a former state.(thus it still remains true that a state can't be abolished).

So an organisation that is an incumbent state can be abolished, but not while it is a state.

It would no longer be a state when that occurs.

It would have ceased to be one the moment another organisation satisfied the necessary condition to destroy it, i.e when another entity exceeded this incumbent’s capability for force, before even being abolished.

Related point, “abolition of hierarchies”.

There's another related aspect of anarchism, the broader and core of it. Which is the so-called “abolition of hierarchies”.

To abolish something requires overpowering it, which is a hierarchical act in itself.

Even if they somehow managed to abolish existing hierarchies, how would they prevent new ones from forming?

They can't prevent new ones from forming without going against their own ideals.

To stop hierarchies from forming, they must be more powerful than those who may want to form them. This would itself be a hierarchy , with the anarchists on top.

You can only stop your inferiors not your equals.

Therefore it's contradictory to say one is able to “prevent hierarchies from forming”.

Having the power to prevent them means you are already standing at the top of one.

The state is anti-egalitarian

Anarchism is simply communism, which is about equality.

It's consistent with anarchism to want to abolish the state as part of the goal of abolishing differences (inequities) / hierarchies.

Because, as I've stated in this and the previous article. The basis of the state are the inevitable differences (inequities) in the capability to use force.

But the capability to use force is not and will never be equal (egalitarian), not among individuals and not among organisations.


r/AnCap101 • • 23h ago

What is the state

0 Upvotes

A state is the organisation that is the most capable at using force within some defined territory.

  • Territory

1)A state only exists in relation to some territory.

A state is a state of some specific territory.

Eg The state of territory A or of territory B etc.

2)The state of some territory exists within it.

Eg The state of territory A, exists within territory A.

Organisations outside of A, whatever their capabilities are, can't be the state of this territory.

  • Superiority not monopoly

There's a definition of the state which says that, a state is the organisation that holds a monopoly on the use of force.

It's impossible for any entity to have a monopoly on the use of force, no matter how powerful it is, it can only penalise individuals after they've already used force.

An organisation declaring the use of force by others prohibited, does not make it impossible for them to use it. They still can, and some will in fact use it.

All it can do is react after force has been used.

To have a monopoly it would have to be able to know in advance which Individual (of the possibly millions) will use force and at what time, then act before the Individual uses it. But no entity can ever be able to do that, especially for large numbers of people.

What a state has is not a monopoly on the use of force; but superiority over every person and organisation in the capability to use it. (Persons and organisations within the territory it is a state of)

  • Legitimacy

A slightly different definition says, the state is the organisation that holds a monopoly on the legitimate use of force.

This translates to “the only organisation whose use of force is legitimate”,

but legitimate to whom?

Whose appraisal of an organisation's use of force as legitimate is necessary for it to be a state?

Different people can point to different organisations and say “this is the only organisation whose use of force is legitimate, therefore they have a monopoly on the legitimate use of force”

Any organisation may say that their use of force is legitimate and the use of force by others isn't. That would mean it has a monopoly, according to its view of legitimacy (whatever it is).

They may say “the majority” decides legitimacy, but that would be an alteration, this definition only says “legitimate”. It doesn't say to the majority or to whom.

Legitimacy also varies by the ideology being used to judge an instance of a use of force.

Some use of force may be legitimate in one political ideology while also being illegitimate in another. Which one is used to judge legitimacy to qualify as a state?

However the proponents of this definition answer these questions what remains is this ;

It doesn't matter who or how many believe an organisation's use of force is legitimate if within the same territory, there exists some other organisation(s) with a greater capability to use force.

This organisation would be unable to enforce any policy on the more powerful organisations despite belief in its legitimacy.

  • Rank not policy

The term itself doesn't say when and how an organisation uses force.

It's only about its position in the hierarchy of capability to use force within some defined territory, not how that force is used.

That an organisation is a state, is not a statement about how it acts or its policies.

It's only about its relative capability to use force.

These two must be kept separate,

[1] The policies and/or behaviour of an organisation, this includes how it uses force.

And [2] Its rank amongst other organisations in the capability to use force.

Don't fuse policy with rank in capability.

Thus there could be differences among states in their policies. But what makes them states is that within their territories, they are the most capable at using force.

  • Only one state at a time :

There can only be one state in some specific territory at a time, by definition.

Multiple organisations can have the capability to use force, but only one qualifies as the "most capable".

A state is not necessarily the only one with the capability to use force; it is the one most capable to use it.

It's only in this sense that a state can be said to have a monopoly, only one can be the most capable of all.


r/AnCap101 • • 4d ago

Can Capitalism Really Be Anarchist?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
8 Upvotes

r/AnCap101 • • 9d ago

Human rights and self governence.

0 Upvotes

I'm wondering two things:

1: do you guys consider rights contradictory to ancap ideas. To "protect" the individual is like a cage in the zoo protects the lion. They just keep the individual safe from other individuals. With a set of written rules - witch is an autoritarian idea by itself (rules created by few control all). But they don't allow contradicting with others peoples freedom so you're not compleatly free. They shield person from fabricated coincidences the sistem created itself.

Let me give you an example. Burgluar and you. Hypoteticaly this doesn't happen in America. In todays society the only thing that stops burgluar from braking in is the law (and other persons rights). Preventivly you might lock him in your bathroom (witch is based on a tru story) to prevent him from taking your stuff. But now you are a "kidnapper" because you took his rights of free movement. And now you are in the wrong, and even if your property is damaged you are obligated to pay compensations. You cant even protect yourself because of his rights.

In Ancap society the thing stoping the burgluar is thought that you might blow his head off because you can be as armed as you please. That is an serious thread and even if he allredy did broke into your home you can still tske revenge because there is noone stoping you.

2: What do you thing about governing yourself in a community around you that you did not accept, but you're not obligated to move? Can community still enforce it's rules? Or you're simply not obligated to obey those rulles? But who is stoping them to be predatory and force you to accept the community you dont support.

how would communitys work and govern themselfs in ancap.


r/AnCap101 • • 12d ago

Larken Rose is overrated

0 Upvotes

I’ve seen this dude’s name popping up since 2015. Apparently he spent time in prison for not filing income taxes? Finally got around to reading him. Not sure what I expected. He didn’t say anything Rothbard or Hoppe haven’t already said. But he did appeal to the psychological side of things. So as a former ancap, here’s why I think he’s overrated.

Rose argues that political authority is a shared delusion, and thar’s a great critique but not very original and besides, ancapism relies on the hallucination that “aggression” is an objective fact, like a physical law like gravity. But it’s not. Aggression is a subjective interpretation based on deeply contested definitions of property. Even with basic definitions like punching or trespassing one’s house, there’s always complex nuances, especially in a capital intensive economy with millions of people.

With or without a final legal arbiter, nothing stops powerful networks from expanding the definition of “defensive force” or “property rights “ or “democracy” or “human rights.” You see what I’m saying? If a neighboring socialist commune is considered a risk to property values or a group of individuals considers another group of individuals a threat, whoever is stronger can violently get what they want, regardless of whether the other group really was a threat. And they’ll tell themselves it’s all for democracy or for the rule of law or the NAP or whatever. Pick your poison.

Larken Rose says competition will rationally and peacefully negotiate, but why? Because it affects their bottom line? Fuck, look at Putin in Ukraine. War is shit for the economy and all of Russia’s young men are dying for no reason. This is Putin’s (and the Russian establishment’s ) bottom line. Clearly, throughout history and in the current day, when groups of individuals with mutually exclusive, non-negotiable frameworks can’t agree, arbitration turns to violence. Whether over land, ethics, WMDs, or even abortion, or theoretically environmental ethics (e.g., spewing greenhouse gases is an act of aggression). Point is, neither side compromises their fundamental principles, leading directly to armed conflict or the creation of isolated, militarized enclaves. Basically, states.

As far as I can tell, and Larken Rose never addresses this, the only mechanism that separates ancapism from statism is a population with an unshakable, vigilant cultural commitment to libertarian norms. But if a society already possesses libertarian virtues, they could easily maintain a constitutional, limited minarchy without the systemic risks involved with ancapism. If anything, ancapism becomes the logical conclusion of minarchy, so there’s no need to advocate specifically for ancapism, what we need (across the spectrum) is a recognition of personal responsibility. No system is gonna save us.


r/AnCap101 • • 13d ago

Don't take a NAP - Why the "Non-Aggression Pact" of Ancaps makes no sense

0 Upvotes

The "anarcho"-capitalist "philosophy" is based on the specious assumption of a universal "Non-Aggression Pact" between humans. This does not even work if we don't assume it as ahistorical and pre-social, even if such a thing is impossible. For example, "breaking the NAP" (which is mostly based on property, not humanity) such as trespassing or taking from "another's property" is subject to arbitrary, effectively unlimited retaliation, up to and including (but not limited to) death. In fact, the alleged ability and legitimacy to kill "trespassers" at will is what leads many people to "anarcho"-capitalism. We will see in this essay how the assumption of a NAP is entirely unfounded, and, indeed, hamful.

NO SOCIAL REALITY

However, despite not requiring agreement of the other parties in order to be universally assumed, the "NAP" does not have a real counterpart in human anthropology. In fact, competition for scarce resources, up to and including "taking of resources", "trespassing into another's territory", or even outright aggression against the members of the competing groups, are common and widely attested. This does not mean something like "war of all against all is the natural state of mankind" as Hobbes says: To begin with, as mentioned, the primary unit that wages agonistic competition is the human group (or "tribe"). Inside the groups, competitions are bound by strong social laws that regulate acceptable (often minimal) levels of aggression. Cooperation within the group is, by necessity, much more vital and widespread than competition. However, the social customs regulating what is acceptable and unacceptable inside the groups also vary with regards to history, social context, level of material development, and other factors. That is to say, they are explicit or at the very least culturally regulated rules, which are known by the participants and are often laid out by their institutions and myths governing social life. In other words, they are NOT a pre-social, universal "NAP". Most especially, they do not presuppose that individuals of a group or society have an unlimited "right" to "individual private property", something that has never been true in any society in history (including modern capitalist society).

NO NATURAL REALITY

Yet the NAP would actually need to be retrotracted to the pre-cultural in order to be a valid argument applicable to any human being regardless of original culture, history, religion, or ethnic. However, we can't find any example of any animal, plant, fungi, bacteria or being that is ruled by "The NAP". In nature, animals and other forms of life attack each other all the time, and most especially they transgress into other's "Property". See how the stag has to protect "His" harem against upstarts and would-be usurpers. The "proprietor" of anything is usually the one that has enough force and strength to keep it. There is no "property registry" that others have to respect. Only dissuasion is respected, at most, and only while it stays self-evident. That being said, animals in nature are usually much less violent than "anarcho"-capitalist, for they will mostly use ritualized displays of dominance against those of the same species, rather than outright killing "trespassers" or would-be "thieves" just because they can.

A PARADOX OF DEATH

The "Breaking of the NAP" is said to result in a forfeiture of the right to life. This is enshrined by famous "crypto-anarchist" (AKA ancap with fancy glasses) manifestos and systems, in which assassination markets are an accepted way to deal with "breakers of the NAP". However, there isn't a way to ascertain consensus, or even an open debate, as to whom actually "broke the NAP" or not. In practice, open and anonymous assassination markets work on anyone and everyone. So that in reality, they are more likely to "Break the NAP" themselves. And these are done rather stealthily because of the heavy stigma on for-hire assassination. If an "ancap" society was even possible, it would then be ruled by the greatest merchants in death; the ones more apt to kill, muffle and disorganize all the opposition. Aggression is a preferred tool to achieve this. We can see this unfold in the real world in drug cartels, gang wars, warlords, intelligence agencies, and other lawless organizations.


r/AnCap101 • • 14d ago

The most important question is: why sacrifice yourself for the sake of libertarianism?

2 Upvotes

I have a simple question for libertarians—regardless of your specific stripe. Libertarianism implies that the state provides no assistance to anyone; once it’s established, those who worked to bring it about will find themselves on equal footing with those who did absolutely nothing. So, here’s the question: what incentive does an average businessperson or government official have to sacrifice their own time—time they could otherwise spend on themselves? Look at it this way: the best strategy for a libertarian might actually be to become a corrupt official. Why? Because if libertarianism never comes to pass, you end up with a fortune—and, as an official, you can even crush your competitors. If libertarianism *does* come to pass, you’re already wealthy, while those who sacrificed their lives on the barricades are gone, and their children end up working for your own affluent offspring. Furthermore, consider your own experience online—even here on Reddit, most communities are incredibly toxic. Why sacrifice your health and time for people who despise you? What is the point of self-sacrifice when you could use that same time for your own gain and come out much further ahead?


r/AnCap101 • • 17d ago

Socialists did it again

Post image
19 Upvotes

I got banned of democeracy of reddit because I was AnCap, saying that because i was AnCap i wanted to lower age of consent?? This is the image posted (notice that nothinf woukd point to such)


r/AnCap101 • • 20d ago

My mom (government agent) is trying to force me into the shower

0 Upvotes

It is clear that my mom is now a socialist deranged lunatic that wants me to conform to this f***ed up society that we live in, I am really scared because I have been cultivating my aroma in order to throw agents of the totalitariat off of my shady dealings (AI generating dank memes for epic weebs and posting them on ifunny).

Are there any ways that I can throw her off of the scent and keep my aura intact?


r/AnCap101 • • 20d ago

Mandatory Carry

3 Upvotes

Had the Founders foreseen the future, they would have written a very different Second Amendment: ❝A well protected public, being necessary to the security of a free State, the Duty of the People to keep and bear arms shall be Enforced.❞

The First Purpose of the Second Amendment was to enable the people to meet unlawful force with like force.


r/AnCap101 • • 21d ago

Would you tolerate a murder? (Conditions apply)

Post image
13 Upvotes

Conditions:

You live in Ancapistan. You and all others supposedly follow NAP. But since NAP isn’t a positive type of law, and rather a principle, it is open to subjective interpretation of each individual, meaning that what is Just can be subjective from one individual’s perspective. Plus, since you’re in Ancapistan, there’s no authority that has a legitimate power to rule out the final decision.

The event:

One Sunday you find out that a some “asshole” has been found dead. It’s clear that he was murdered and it’s clear it was premeditated. Pick any imaginable scenario from finding gas canisters by his burned house to a note stapled to his forehead saying “you shouldn’t have been such a piece of shit”. In other words - you see a textbook violation of NAP.

The Asshole:

Literally anyone you personally consider to be one. They never did anything wrong to you personally, but say you’ve heard, read, or even witnessed yourself them crossing the line you’d never allow yourself to cross. But they never did anything to you, nor they ever did something that would justify them being murdered.

Questions to You my fellow Ancap:

a) Would you tolerate that murder? By tolerate I mean you would not bother trying to find or helping to find the murderer, even though you recognize a clear violation of NAP on the territory where everyone supposedly subscribes to it.

b) Or would you personally seek Justice for that person if they didn’t have anyone that would seek Justice on their behalf?

I appreciate if you drop your answer and your reasoning behind whichever decision you’re choosing here.

Please abstain from adding more hypotheticals like: “there will be voluntary organizations that would investigate such matters, but I’d personally do nothing”. Instead, be more precise: “I will be funding orgs that will investigate these cases, and I will demand them to investigate, find, and bring the murderer of that asshole to Justice”.

\*\*\*

The purpose of this experiment is to determine:

\- whether NAP holds as a strong enough principle that will regulate anarcho-capitalist society within any territory on a voluntary basis creating sort of collectivist ideology with effective system of self governance that is intolerant of all NAP violations.

\- Ancapism is ultimately an Anarchic society first, and NAP is not a broad obligation in a legal sense, but more of foundation for legitimate framework of conflict resolution between private individuals, rather than a governing force for the entire collective aka society.

\*\*\*

Why I’m personally so curious about this: it seems like a lot of self proclaimed Ancaps have a very rosy idea of what Ancalism is going to look like in practice. Many idealize it to the point where they are literally recreating agencies with state like authority level that will be policing the society. Their reasoning stands on imagined obligations that everyone should be held to, and that somehow there will be uniformity in thought about what constitutes Aggression, Retaliation, Justice, and Proportionality as if those were black and white laws, but there will be no higher imposed authority.

I personally find this view completely absurd, childish, and incompatible with any Anarchic society. To be frank, I’d rather find out that I am simply more cynical and more self interested than others, and I can’t help but to think that many of self proclaimed Ancaps live in some lala land where they imagine security agencies and other institutions built to support functioning NAP based society to do a perfect, literally perfect job that never creates conflicts by accident or by malicious intent, or that such agencies will be focused on “justice” where acting like insurance company would make more sense (e.g.: your car is damaged in hit and run accident. Company gives you a check for repairs and doesn’t bother trying to find who hit your car).

With that said, here’s my honest answer to my own question:

\- I would not give a flying fuck about that asshole. While I might be supporting voluntary orgs dealing with such cases IF I have spare resources, but I’d not even bother to call/send them an email asking to investigate a murder of some known piece of shit. My reasoning - 1) it’s none of my business, 2) i lack incentives, 3) I don’t have any personal risk for staying out from this because I am not engaging in behavior that would trigger those vigilantes to go after me personally.


r/AnCap101 • • 22d ago

NAP Rights and Those Who Can Not Afford to Defend them

5 Upvotes

I should start, at first, with acknowledging that I do for the most part accept the hypothetical NAP system proposed by anarcho-capitalism. I have even defended it against critiques (as you will see looking through my comments) on the basis that the question is not how do we defend every bodies rights, but how do we distribute the defense of all rights as efficiently as possible - and the any to any question about distribution is and always be the market. On these purely rhetorical, rationalistic grounds the anarcho-capitalist can reject any specific hypothetical case where this appears on true, since as compelling as they may be, our logic shows us that it must be misleading. As I have done.

Yet there is one particular case (which I think we can arrive at in the abstract, rhetorically) which I think is worth considering. To understand it, I will narrate how I arrived at this conclusion.

I was in a conversation about abortion. Like most AnCap's, I generally oppose state restrictions on abortion as grotesque and totalitarian. Like most people, I believe that the line of personhood lies not at the exact moment of conception, but somewhere between then and birth This exact point may be difficult to precisely pin down (if not impossible), and I would argue somewhat useless and regardless close to impossible for the layman to identify, yet the important point is that it exists. Before this point we don't afford the fetus personhood (or NAP rights) and after (say 9 months) we do.

During this conversation, the person representing the anti-abortion said something that stuck out to me - 'the fetus can advocate for it's right to exist.' This got me thinking- if we say that a baby/fetus whatever term you'd like to use does deserve NAP rights, how can that person possibly ever defend them?

Let's say that you do not think that an unborn child of any age deserves NAP protections. Okay. Let's say a two-year old, three-year old child. There is no possibility of it generating it's own income- no way for it to afford to participate in the system of courts, judges, mercenaries, insurance and so on so forth that we usually assume for fully-fledged persons.

If this child's parents decide too sexually assault and then murder it, who is there to persecute them?

The answer I anticipate at this point is one which begins with something like 'the community'. This is a terrible answer, because this is the exact same mechanism upon which the State already functions. A majority of people in a particular area agree that some things are wrong, and then conspire to control the lives of others. Sure, in this particular case we happen to agree with them, but all the Soviet communists agreed with the gulag. My issue is not even that my relying on this, we re-establish a pseudo-statelike mechanism that could eventually violate the NAP - it's that groups acting to control the behavior of others because they see as wrong is in ontological violation with an AnCap society.

The other suggestions is charities- this to me is a better idea. One can imagine, say a neighbor taking the parents to court out of the goodness of his heart- and the depth of his own pockets0, and after due process it is ruled that there was a NAP violation and appropriate measures are taken. Wonderful.

Yet both of these measures become dependent on the good-will of strangers. Not to say that this will not exist in AnCap, we can not rely on it. Indeed, the very appeal of AnCap philosophy is that it is the ultimate system of checks and balances- there is no longer any need to rely on a source of omnibenevolence and omniscience to steer civilization towards righteousness. If we accept that premise, then we are no better than the statists.

Well. Thoughts? Is there an answer to this that I'm missing? Is there an established AnCap answer to this problem - I can't imagine I'm the first person to ever think of this.

P.S I am not really interested in discussing the exact morality of abortion. It is just useful to demonstrate the problem I am describing here.


r/AnCap101 • • 24d ago

Objection Against Argumentation Ethics (AE) I Saw Recently

3 Upvotes

Hey, I recently ran across someone using what he called a "rebutting defeater" to AE. I don't know how many of you find AE plausible, but I do. Regardless, I thought up a few problems with it but am interested in other possible responses as well.

His original hypothetical included the names of Wittgenstein and Popper in a debate over meta-ethics. Wittgenstein's name has been changed to John, and Popper's to Steve. Keep in mind this is all from memory and is very likely not the exact hypothetical he deployed, though I tried to recall all that I could.

The objector to AE says: "Imagine John and Steve are discussing metaethics. John is an anti realist and does not think moral facts exist. In pursuance of the discourse he picks up a fire poker and threatens Steve that if he does not provide an example of a moral fact he will poke him. Steve does so, so John does not. The discussion is still rational despite the threat of violence as an intelligible and rational answer (within the dialectic) emerged as a result, or alongside, the threat of violence. This means AE is false."

What are the possible responses, problems with the objection, etc.?

Thanks.


r/AnCap101 • • 26d ago

State abolishment process

12 Upvotes

So if hypothetically one day everyone in one country woke up as ancap (assuming we don’t reach ancap in Hoppe’s way) but couldn’t agree what to do with the government institutions, what is the morally correct course of action? Are all taxpayers entitled to shares in abolished government’s institutions proportionally to their tax contributions?(Shares in the post company, army…etc) Or institutions should be sold as whole in the market?(Privatising every company as whole- full water company, full electricity company…, full army) Or simply abolished and sold into pieces?(Abolishing post office, selling the buildings, selling the desks…) Or simply employees fired and buildings abandoned?(Without selling state property) Or some hybrid version? Could this be morally decided democratically or some person have a right to step up and ignore everyone? Why?


r/AnCap101 • • 26d ago

How will privatised time work?

0 Upvotes

How will timezones be privatised? How will there be orderly communication?
“Privatised time” sounds so cool.


r/AnCap101 • • 28d ago

Former ancap has 3 questions

13 Upvotes

So I’m a former ancap, just so you know where I’m coming from. Not some ignorant reddit leftist that licks the boot of states and corporations and calls it the resistance. I’m just looking to see what kind of answers this post generates, since these are my problems with ancapism now.

First, I wanna discuss competing Dispute Resolution Organizations (DROs) that are supposed to peacefully negotiate legal standards through market arbitration. What happens when DROs representing populations with mutually exclusive, non-negotiable moral frameworks can’t agree? Things like abortion, environmental ethics, child rights, religious codes, spreading misinformation (like promoting socialism) etc.

Arbitration fails because neither compromises without abandoning its fundamental principles. To prevent friction and violence, DROs geographically isolate their clients, leading to a type of Balkanized private governments. Or Hoppe’s covenant communities.

Second, Austrian economics says that all value is subjective. Why would law and justice be an exception? Without a ultimate legal arbiter to define property boundaries, every party operates on subjective definitions of aggression. One man's exercise of property rights is another man's initiation of force. “Aggression” is not a raw physical fact, it is a normative interpretation of human action based on underlying property definitions.

Third, I still see the value in Austrian economics even if I don’t regard it as a priori true. But suppose it is. It’s a value-free science. Mises’ framework works just as well for a major bank in ancapistan holding mortgages across a region. They have an incentive to fund and collude with a dominant DRO to enforce contract interpretations that favor the creditor over the debtor. In fact, it’s entirely rational for every financial institution to acquire equity in DROs or create exclusive contracts with them.

Financial institutions and DROs can form cartels to control access to basic market infrastructure (payments, health services, land registry, communication networks). And if that’s what the majority customers want, dissenters can fuck right off.

Why wouldn’t banks/DROs have incentives to invest in propaganda to expand their own power and control of resources? All in the name of enforcing the NAP.

But let me guess: consumers will simply cancel their subscriptions with predatory agencies and switch to better ones. I’ve made this point before on this and other ancap subreddits: if you’re already assuming libertarian norms that actively resist corporate overreach, why not just have a minarchy?

If a population possesses a high level of civic virtue and has a vigilant commitment to liberty, enough to prevent private security from becoming tyrannical, that same population could easily maintain a constitutional, limited minarchist state.


r/AnCap101 • • Oct 21 '26

Is it possible to have a Theoceatic AnCap Society

8 Upvotes

How a normal AnCap society would work, Association charges rent on homes they build, and pays for private security, law firms etc.

But have the NAP directly interpreted by the local church, or a council of churches if it is a largely popilated area.


r/AnCap101 • • Oct 20 '26

Thoughts on this video?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

This video is about how socialism is better than capitalism


r/AnCap101 • • Oct 20 '26

Is there a point in being AnCap if you aren't already rich?

0 Upvotes

serious question. a lot of AnCap has to do with preserving wealth, also in an AnCap society you would probably get mogged by wealthier sociopathic people unless you were rich too and aligned with them.

I am AnCap leaning in theory since being sovereign is best as individual, and most of the elite do AnCap type wealth preservation anyways (panama papers, etc.) but as a pleb, is there a point in being AnCap without already being wealthy?


r/AnCap101 • • Oct 18 '26

So what's the consensus here on Software 'Piracy'?

15 Upvotes

If you're at all interested in software or gaming you've probably heard the news surrounding Sony recently. For the uninitiated Sony announced moving away from physical discs for their gaming consoles, ever since the community has been on the attack. They've managed to jailbreak the PS5 to unlock features like full backwards compatibility, the ability to install unsupported software and even bring about a full store front that offers most of the PSN store for free. They've also leveraged AI to recompile games as native to platforms they were previously locked out of, and are working on a full emulation for the PS5 on PC. In other news someone has managed to rebuild the entirety of Adobe's creative suite making it Free and open source, they've also started work on Microsoft Office.

Now I personally love this, however at the same time I recognise that there is the potential that it could discourage the creation of good games and software going forward. My question to this community who do not believe that IP should be protected, how would you avoid the highly likely possibility that creators would be unable to make a profit from their work because it gets 'pirated'?


r/AnCap101 • • Oct 17 '26

“Taxation is theft and should be abolished but we should still pay taxes”

Post image
42 Upvotes

r/AnCap101 • • Oct 16 '26

Were states an inevitable pry of our history?

7 Upvotes

States as we know them arose roughly 6000 years ago, coinciding with the rise of grain agricultural and sedentary civilizations situated along river banks. It’s popularly thought that grain agriculture allowed for states to form because it allowed thieves to easily count and track wealth and know who to extract it from.

I don’t think there’s any reason to believe that statism was ever necessary, or that civilization couldn’t have started without it, but I think it was a likely thing to happen, and we just didn’t get lucky. I’m not 100% sure, but I think the ideas of liberty could only have come about after we amassed enough wealth to support such a worldview. Between our nature as hierarchical, collectivist, authority-loving apes and the fact that violence and imposition of will was the norm for all of our history, it’s really no surprise to me that we got states. Creation of wealth through food surplus probably meant someone was going to parasitize it; pair that with an appeal to the religious nature of our species justifying state rule as divine and boom we have government.