r/AskUS • u/joebraga2 • 35m ago
Why have American automakers moved away from affordable small cars when so many consumers want better fuel economy?
I'm Brazilian, and I've been following discussions about American car culture after watching a video about problematic engines.
Something that surprised me is how many Americans say they don't actually want enormous SUVs or V8 pickups. Some prefer compact cars, hybrids or EVs but complain about limited affordable options.
Brazil is also a continental-sized country. We drive long distances, have major agricultural regions and sometimes face difficult roads. So I understand why someone might need a large pickup for towing, farming or commercial work.
But why has the American market become so concentrated on SUVs and trucks, even for ordinary urban transportation?
In Brazil, traditional manufacturers such as Chevrolet, Ford, Volkswagen and Fiat historically sold smaller vehicles, often based on European designs.
Our older naturally aspirated 1.0 engines were primarily economy choices. Modern 1.0 turbos replaced many 1.4 and 1.6 engines, while 1.3, 1.5 and 2.0 turbos replaced larger naturally aspirated engines, including some V6 applications.
Meanwhile, Chinese manufacturers such as BYD and GWM are increasing competition with full hybrids, PHEVs and EVs. Traditional brands such as Toyota and Jeep have responded with substantial promotional discounts.
We also have expensive cars and high taxes, so I'm not presenting Brazil as a perfect example.
But I question whether American manufacturers have prioritized higher-margin SUVs and pickups at the expense of affordable alternatives.
And urban planning probably reinforces that dependence when people need to drive several miles to reach schools, supermarkets or workplaces.
I'm not suggesting that everyone should abandon large engines or pickups.
I'm curious: do you think Americans genuinely prefer larger vehicles, or have manufacturer pricing, product availability, regulations and urban planning significantly shaped those preferences?
Would you consider buying a smaller full hybrid, PHEV or EV if it offered good reliability, adequate performance and an attractive price?