r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 10h ago

NEW UPDATE [New 1.5-Year Update]: I’m about to ruin my best friend’s life, and I don’t feel remorse.

1.4k Upvotes

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/ThrowRA-dontdesrveit

Originally posted to r/TrueOffMyChest

Previous BoRUs: #1, #2, #3

[New 1.5-Year Update]: I’m about to ruin my best friend’s life, and I don’t feel remorse.

NEW UPDATE MARKED WITH ----

Thanks to u/lordemme for letting me know about the latest update!

Trigger Warnings: infidelity, emotional abuse and manipulation, abuse of authority

Mood Spoilers: depressing


RECAP

Original Post (rareddit): September 25, 2024

My soon to be ex best friend and I have been friends since middle school. We know everything about each other, our families are basically one big family now. You get the idea.

Like I said, we tell each other everything. Recently, she came to me telling me she’s been having an affair for about 4 months with her superior at her new job (she started about a year ago). She told me, not out of guilt, but to brag about the dream vacation she’s going on with her AP, disguised as a work trip. She asked me to cover for her if her husband asks if we’ve been in contact, because she’s planning on going black for that week so he would have no way of finding out.

Side note: we’ve both known her husband since high school. They are high school lovers, so they’ve been together for almost 15 years. Her husband is one of the most honest, hardworking genuine people I know. He of course took everything she’s said about working late and the business trip at face value because he trusts her more than he trusts himself.

I told her I would not be covering for her and to get out of my house, because I couldn’t even look at her right now. Later, I told my husband everything that happened, and he was just as shocked and disgusted. Her husband is basically his best friend now, so he of course has a lot of loyalty to him as well. My husband pointed out something I didn’t even think of… our security camera. It caught everything.

We plan on going to her husband tonight with the proof. It will be up to him to do what he wishes with it. But he deserves to know.

Secondly, we’re taking this to her job. As far as I know, “fraternization” of any kind is prohibited at her workplace. She was also promoted once by this same supervisor, so this could be seen as favoritism. Our guess is that they will both be fired.

Finally, I’m going to send a snippet of her admitting the affair to all of her family, including mine. As I said, are families are very intertwined, so I will easily be able to contact the majority of her family. I’m not going to give her a chance to spin this against me or her husband.

Some may think this is harsh, but I whole heartedly disagree with that she’s doing.

ETA: I decided to take the advice of some of the commenters and leave it up to her STBX to decide to go nuclear or not. As some of you pointed out, he may decide to stay with her, and going nuclear would ruin his life in turn.

The other reason is going nuclear and making her lose her job could affect the outcome of the divorce. We still plan to tell him, but we have decided against the other 2 options FOR NOW. I’m going to let STBX know if she tries to pin this on either of us or tells ANYONE a single lie, I will do a 180 and go nuclear.

I will not be seen as a villain for a situation I didn’t even ask to be in in the first place. SHE was the one who thought it would be smart to tell her monogamous friend with traditional values that she’s cheating on her spouse, she can lie in her bed.

SMALL UPDATE: Everyone involved: Alyssa=best friend, Noah=Bffs hub. I decided to take the advice of a few people and reach out to Alyssa before I went to her husband. I recorded the conversation, and let her know I was for my safety. She seemed still extremely nonchalant about the whole thing. I told her I was worried for her, and even for her, this was very out of character behavior.

Long story short, she’s felt very “weak” and “unbalanced” in her and Noah’s marriage. For context, Noah went to a trade school and makes very good money, while up until her promotion, Alyssa was making slightly more than minimum wage. She has recently been reading up on some “anti-traditional values”, and the women in those forums attacked her for making less than her husband. She then explained that she noticed her supervisor was trying to flirt with her, and her internet friends told her to run with it, and use him to get higher up. She of course did, but admitted she’d become emotionally attached to him as well.

All in all, she admitted she doesn’t really regret the affair, because it “helped with her career” and “she found love”. I told her she had the option to tell Noah the truth before me, but Hubby and I were coming over tonight with the video of her admitting the affair, so she wouldn’t be able to sway it in her favor. Again, she very nonchalantly said “mm. Okay” and hung up on me.

Idk what the heck is going on. I can’t tell if she’s having some sort of psychosis, or she’s literally just so detached from her marriage, that she doesn’t care what happens. Hubby and I still plan on going to Noah tonight, but I’m honestly intrigued to see that she says to him, if she says anything at all.

Relevant Comments

OOP on having the legal rights and consent to send the video evidence to Alyssa’s workplace

OOP: I’m pretty sure we’ll be fine legally, if we do ever end up sharing it (we’ve decided against it for now.)

She knew we had cameras in our house, we have a very obvious ring doorbell as well as outdoor cameras. The indoor ones are obvious as well.

Plus, where we live, you have the right to record on your property without consent. So there would be no ability to retaliate against us.

+

This is the whole reason I got so upset. She’s a new hire, with basically no experience in the field, and she got a promotion for the stereotypical “banging the boss”. She’s always been the person to look for loopholes or easier ways to do stuff, but this is a new low.

I hope at the very least, the supervisor gets fired. Someone like that shouldn’t be in a position of power, because they obviously can’t handle it.

I’ve thought about maybe making an anonymous tip to the company about HIM specifically, but I don’t want it to lead back to my ex friend (for now).

OOP on telling Alyssa’s husband about the video evidence and then going nuclear

OOP: The only reason I’m against it for now is because of some insightful comments. He’s a very good man, and he might forgive her and decide to reconcile. Even though I don’t agree with it, it’s his decision, and I don’t want to in turn ruin his life by letting everyone know he stayed with a cheater. Someone also said affecting her job could affect the outcome of a possible divorce, and I wouldn’t want anything to play against him.

+

I completely agree, and hubby and I decided against going nuclear, because at the end of the day, STBX will be the only one who gets hurt. It will be solely his decision, unless she tries to spread rumors or lies about me, my husband, or STBX. I plan to tell him if she decides to try and spin this, I will send a clip of the video to anyone she tells, and let it spread from there.

Commenter: Agree. Also OP, please be prepared for her husband to stay with his wife and cut you and your husband off. Marriages are complicated, and sometimes things don’t play out the way you imagine they will. You should tell him, 100%, but what he does with that information is up to him.

And please remember that this is not JUST blowing up your ex friend’s life- it’s blowing up her husband’s life too. It’s his call whether he wants to go nuclear or not.

OOP: I honestly wouldn’t be surprised if he decided to stay with her. He’s a very forgiving man and may be willing to give it a shot. As tough as it will be, we do see ourselves going NC with both of them unless a divorce were to take place. Because as much as we’d love to continue being friends and support husband, if ex friend is part of the deal, we can’t support that.

 

Update #1: September 27, 2024 (two days later)

Apologize for not having time last night, we were obviously busy.

People involved: Ex bestie= Alyssa, Besties hub=Noah

I took a lot of peoples advice, and decided not to go nuclear. As many people said, at the end of the day, it’s not my circus. The decision should be left up to the wronged party, and that is Noah. I also decided to reach out to Alyssa before telling Noah, and decided to give her a chance to confess to Noah herself.

After I talked to her, I was legit thinking about reaching out to her parents about medical help, because she was so unbothered and so non-remorseful about the affair, that I thought she was having some sort of mental break or psychosis. Yeah, Alyssa’s always been the kind to find loopholes or ways ahead, but cheating on your spouse of almost 2 decades for financial gain? It’s not normal.

If you didn’t see my small update, the whole reason Alyssa started the affair WAS to get the promotion at work, it evolved into an emotional fair eventually though. She admitted that her new “friends” from some “feminism” forums and Facebook groups told her she wasn’t as valuable if she was making significantly less than her spouse (something I learned she’s been more insecure about than she’s been telling people). They also told her that using a man isn’t cheating as long as there’s no emotional attachment, she’s just being a “girl-boss”.

She admitted she couldn’t separate her feelings from the intimate aspect, and started going on regular dates and vacations, and eventually they started calling each other boyfriend and girlfriend. The AP knows she’s married, but was told they were “on the verge of separation”.

My hubby and I arrived at Noah and Alyssa’s with some booze and some dinner, and by the time we were there, Noah had already gone through a bottle of wine. Surprisingly, Alyssa DID confess to Noah about the affair. He told us it was extremely non-apologetic, though. She sat him down, and told him that she wasn’t going on a business trip this week, she was going on a vacation with her boyfriend.

Noah, being the clueless and loyal person he is, thought he meant to say “husband”, and was so excited. He asked if they’re going to Italy like that planned for, and Alyssa just stared at him. She repeated “with my boyfriend”. It took a few minutes, but it finally sunk in. He told us it wasn’t pretty after that, and said he embarrassingly got on his knees and begged her to fix everything.

She yelled for a bit but then just stonewalled him again. She was already packed to leave, and just left him there sobbing. She turned off her location (which both Noah and I were a part of her family on the app), and we have no idea where she went. We assume she went to her APs house, because if she had gone home with 2 suitcases, her mother would’ve reached out to Noah immediately, she sees him as a son.

We sat down with Noah, and said we had video and audio proof of Alyssa exposing and explaining the affair, and we will send them to him in case he needs them. I explained to him, that in a moment of blind rage, I was planning on going scorched earth and telling EVERYONE, but once I calmed down and looked at this rationally, I realized that wasn’t the right thing to do.

The only person going full nuclear would hurt was him, because Alyssa obviously doesn’t care anymore. As I suspected, the idea of reconciliation is still on his mind, but he doesn’t see it happening. In order to reconcile, both parties must admit fault and WANT to reconcile, Alyssa clearly doesn’t. We’ve gotten him in contact with a friend of my hubby, who’s agrees to help him Pro-Bono until the divorce shows results. I can tell he’s still hesitant about going forward with divorce, but he knows he also can’t force Alyssa to stay.

As comments have suggested, this is where we bow out. We’re obviously going to continue to support Noah, but it’s not our situation to handle. It’s his. If there’s any future updates, I’ll ofc ask Noah first, but you’ll be the second to know. Thanks for being so supportive and helpful, it made me realize that how Noah handles his life and his marriage is HIS responsibility, not mine.

ETA: wanted to clear up some questions from the last post that I didn’t really answer in the update-

-What did Alyssa ever do to you that made you want to go so nuclear? Honestly, nothing in particular. Like I said, for the past few years our friendship has been for convenience at its best. We’ve basically been friends because we know each other so well, and we have at least 1 friend.

Alyssa has always had qualities I don’t agree with, but who doesn’t? I think it was just the whole situation that made my blood boil, especially since Alyssa has always been disgusted by cheaters. She was the kind of person to cut dozens of people out of her life if it meant not supporting someone’s infidelity.

So for her to make a complete 180 and not even have guilt for it, it just grinds my gears. That’s part of the reason I think she’s having some sort of mental breakdown. Not only is it hypocritical, it’s extremely out of character, even for her.

-Are you in love with Noah? of course not. Singing someone’s praises and trying to portray that they’re a genuine and good person doesn’t automatically mean you want to sleep with them. Our relationship has been nothing more than platonic for the entire time I’ve known him, because he loved Alyssa, and I loved their happiness. I love my husband and literally only ever saw Noah like a brother. Logic, people.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: I hope he (the husband) has some self-respect and dignity and goes through with the divorce. If he decides to inform their employer tell him to do it after the divorce.

OOP: As much as I love the guy, he basically worships the ground Alyssa walks on. If she came through the door right now, and said “sorry”, even with no remorse behind it, I’m 99% sure he’d pretend like the last 4 months were a fever dream.

Commenter 2: You handled this incredibly well, and even though it’s a painful situation for all involved, your thoughtful approach will likely help Noah through this difficult time. If there are future updates, I’m sure everyone following the story will be eager to hear how things unfold. Wishing the best for Noah—and for you and your husband as you continue to support him.....

OOP: Thank you, like I said, I made this post and the decision to go nuclear in a fit on blind rage, but I soon realized I was being irrational. It’s not my place to serve Alyssa vigilante justice. In all honesty, if she’s not careful, she may out herself at work. And it’s their decision what to do with the two of them.

OOP on notifying Alyssa’s workplace

OOP: I’m not going to. If Noah decides to reconcile, she’ll be out of a job, which just adds to the problem that caused the affair in the first place. If she gets fired during the divorce, it could be grounds for alimony she doesn’t deserve.

OOP on what forum Alyssa got the advice from

OOP: It wasn’t a national or creditable group, it was called like “Independent women of insert state” and it’s a bunch of women who give advice and other stuff tailored to laws and jobs in our state. The advice she got was from a group of women she met in that group who had their own personal group chat. She called them her “friends”, but I guarantee none of them are going to help her pick up her life now that it’s ruined 🤣

 

Update #2: October 5, 2024 (eight days later)

Well, I didn’t expect to be back so soon, but the last week has been basically a speed run of terrible events. This will probably be my last update, so feel free to consider this the conclusion of the events.

Everything bad that could have happened, happened. The past two days specifically have been absolutely horrible. Sorry if this is all over the place, I’m still all over the place.

So, idk if it was the day she left, or the day after, but Alyssa and AP went on their vacation. The only reason I know of because she posted pictures all over social media of her and AP, she had absolutely no shame. It was very clear that even if she wasn’t divorced, this was her new boyfriend. Which of course notified her family of the issues.

Noah’s phone was blowing up with apologies, accusations, everything you could think of. Noah, being the people pleaser he is, decided to tell her family they were on a “mutual break” instead of telling everybody she cheated and that was the AP. Alyssa’s mom, fortunately, didn’t believe him, and came to me. I didn’t hold back, I told her that she’s been cheating on Noah for months, and that she recently bragged to me about her sugar daddy AP, and that’s the only reason she’s come clean to Noah.

Alyssa’s mom then dropped a bomb on me that even I didn’t know, Alyssa is a serial cheater. Her mom said in high school, Alyssa would bring boys home under the guise of school projects or sports related things, but she caught Alyssa kissing 2 different boys. Keep in mind, she was dating Noah all this time. She said she didn’t think much of it, and just chalked it up to being a crazy hormonal teenager. She also said she never expected her to marry her high school boyfriend, and by the time they were married, she figured Alyssa had stopped doing all this stuff. Neither her nor I have no idea if she’s done anything like that since high school through to the present, but I’m not interested in digging further into it.

This just explains why Alyssa was just so nonchalant about cheating, because apparently she has just always done it. I’m guessing her “girlboss” friends awoke something inside her, and she remembered how easily and nonchalantly she would cheat, and it inspired to just to it again? I don’t know…

I’ll be honest, I kind of yelled at her mother, something I’m not proud of. Like I’ve said in previous posts, Alyssa’s mom is basically my mom, so formalities and everything aren’t something I think about when I talk to her. So I freaked out and told her she set Noah up for this kind of life, when he could’ve found somebody ten times better. She took it like a champ, and just let me vent until I was calm again. I apologized for yelling, but calmly said you and I both know Noah deserved better. You should’ve said something before he got married to her. She agreed, but said it’s too late now to focus on that, and that the real issue at this time was supporting Noah. I told her if she wanted to support Noah, she could’ve told him his fiancé was a cheater 10 years ago, and hung up on her. I’ve since talked to her, we’re fine, but I was just to mad at her in the moment.

Next thing that happened was that the photos got back to a colleague, and both of them were out a job before their vacation was even over. As I assumed, their workplace was extremely upset, and did consider Alyssa getting the promotion favoritism, and they were both let go. Noah told me there was AT LEAST 3 HR complaints about them, so it’s was a no brainer. Of course, the beautiful relationship Alyssa and her AP had turned sour as soon as he learned he was let go from his 6 figure job because of her. He was so pissed, he even cancelled Alyssa’s plane ticket home out of spite, and planned to leave her stranded there.

This is where all of you will be disappointed, and so am I, but Noah immediately forgave her, bought her a ticket, and moved her back in. She told him it was just a huge mistake, and seeing how her AP treated her made her realize what she could’ve lost. It’s obviously all BS to me and hubby, but you already know Noah ate that shit up. He’s told us that he’s urging her to go to couples counseling, but ofc it’s not an ultimatum, so basically she just got to have her cake and eat it with no consequences.

We told Noah previously, and reminded him, that if he decided to take Alyssa back, we’d be going at the very least low contact. We kept to our word, and have completely blocked Alyssa, and have Noah unblocked, but don’t plan to engage in small talk to invitations to stuff. We refuse to be like him and just act like this never happened, because that’s not normal. He understood, but told us he has to stand by the vows he made to his wife, which we both understand to an extent, and wished him well.

So yep, Alyssa got to sleep with another man, go on a nice vacation, lose her job, and still gets a bed and a husband to come home to. All’s well that ends well? Idek how to feel about this. Like if they wanna live their fucked up broken marriage life, that’s their choice. I’m not even mad anymore, just drained. I’m almost glad it’s over now, because I don’t know if I could deal with this for months on end. I knew this was going to happen eventually, it’s just who Noah is, but it feels just as idiotic as it sounds. Idk I’m just rambling at this point.

I’m glad we decided to step back, because honestly, both of them have very clear psychological issues that needs to be addressed with a professional, but neither of them will ever do that. I’d rather be rid of people like this. Sorry if I’m being blunt or mean, but at the end of the day, both of them have issues I didn’t sign up to deal with. I don’t need this kind of stress while hubby and I are trying for kids. So yeah I guess this is it. Yep.

Top Comments

Commenter 1: I feel for Noah. He'll always be a sucker for her, and she'll always get away with anything. No consequences for anything, MC is not an ultimatum...sigh... unbelievable

Maybe one day he'll catch her with a guy in their own bed, and he'll snap out of it.

You did the right thing the way you handled it and distanced yourself rn. Don't turn your back on Noah though. He's going to need people.

Commenter 2: I feel no sympathy for Noah. He needs to find his balls from wherever she hid them bc she will cheat on him again and again and he will always stupidly take her back. You’re completely justified staying away from that mess.

 

Update #3: November 2, 2024 (almost one month later)

It’s been about a month since I last posted. I wasn’t planning on updating, but the most hilarious thing happened with Alyssa and Noah, I needed to tell something. Bear with me, this is all through the grapevine, bc hub and I are still NC with them.

So first off, Noah has rewarded Alyssa’s cheating with another vacation. They’re planning on going to Italy for their vow renewal. Their plan is to basically start over their marriage, even though they’ve been together for 15+ years. Ngl, I burst out laughing when I was told this. I just think it’s so hilarious that they’re both gonna sweep this under the rug and try to act like their life didn’t implode. But hey, if it makes them happy, who am I to stop them.

The second thing is they’ve decided to try for a baby. One thing Alyssa and I always bonded over was being conservatives who wanted to be child free. Neither of us just felt like we would be good mothers. Of course, since we live in a largely conservative community with conservative families, we were always basically bullied into changing our mind. But we had each other, that’s the important part.

Once I met my husband, I had kind of changed my mind about kids (which we are also currently trying for), but Alyssa never swayed. The last conversation we had about her family pressuring her into kids was about two months ago, a week or two before the cheating incident. Not only do I think this is a terrible idea because the baby is going to grow up in a dysfunctional family, I guarantee Alyssa won’t love this child. I honestly just feel pity for everyone involved now.

Noah for thinking his life has to be staying with a cheater, Alyssa for basically forcing herself to live a life she doesn’t want to live, and their future child for being born into this cluster fuck.

But yeah, consider this the official end. Maybe I’ll be back in a year or two when it turns out Noah has been raising another man’s baby 🤣

 

Hey, I’m back: April 19, 2025 (five months later from the prior update)

I doubt anyone will even see this, but at the time, I found it cathartic to write this all down. And I’m here to bring some much needed good news to my story.

My husband and I are doing wonderful. I am now pregnant! I’m approx 12 weeks along, and everything looks fine. We’ve starting throwing around nursery ideas and we are so happy and excited to be parents. I can’t wait!

Now onto what anyone would actually care about: Noah and Alyssa. I’ll be honest, not much news. Early on, they kinda went through every phase with us. They reached out begging to reconcile, then got angry with us that we wouldn’t talk to them, then eventually just gave up. We never replied to anything they sent, just saved anything in case it were to ever escalate. I think it finally set in for them, and they just stopped trying to contact us after about 2 months. The rest of this is second hand information, so bear with me, and don’t take it at face value:

-Alyssa and Noah tried for a baby with no luck. If I had to guess, I assume it’s because she probably didn’t actually get her birth control removed. We both got IUDs together only a few months before D day, and since they last for years, I assume she just still has it. ETA: Yes, I only had my iud for about 4-5 months total. My husband and I felt we weren’t ready yet, but we ended up coming into some money that changed our minds. It was a mutual decision, and I got it removed. Just adding this before I get flooded with questions about how I got pregnant when I just got an iud.

-they’re still together, obviously, and most of their family has agreed to brush this under the rug. Apparently it’s easier for everyone involved to just pretend the whole thing never happened. I assume her family all agreeing to ignore those months of infidelity are why both her and Noah were so confident in trying to have us forget this too.

-haven’t heard anything about AP or the whole job mess other than Alyssa MAY have taken legal action against her place of work? I assume she’s trying to play the victim card.

Welp, I think that’s pretty much it. Sorry Alyssa didn’t get pregnant by AP and now Noah is their third wheel or whatever Reddit likes nowdays. Just some rumors through the grapevine, and my life continues just fine. Sending love 🩷.  


----NEW UPDATE----

Life Update: November 15, 2026 (19 months later from the previous update)

Logged into this on accident lol (just recently redownloaded Reddit, and it’s under my spam email)

This is gonna be a super weird turn of events, and idek if anyone will see this.

Surprisingly, Alyssa and I are friends again. Her and Noah did end up having a baby. This happened during a time where the second hand information stopped, so I guess I was wrong about her keeping her IUD lol. Alyssa has been going to INTENSIVE therapy for a while now, which even included an inpatient stay. I’m going to keep it vague for her privacy, but she was diagnosed with two mental illnesses, as well as being diagnosed narcissistic. Through this time, she learned a lot about herself and her relationship with Noah.

She ended up breaking it off with Noah while she was pregnant, more for Noah than herself. He is so used to her taking charge, and well, sometimes being an absolute doormat, that she knew he’d never leave her. They luckily have been coparenting well for the past month and a half, but Alyssa does have majority custody right now because of his job, but neither mind. Noah gets to see the baby whenever he wants, and he gives her some money, so she only has to work part time when she does go back to work.

Obviously I was hesitant to welcome her back into my life, but she has really changed, and tbh, I missed Alyssa. It’s been great honestly, we both love having play dates, and I’m honestly really impressed with how much effort she’s put into changing for the better.

She doesn’t want to date “until my baby is 18” lol, but I’m hopeful someday she’ll find someone who will understand that we all have a past.

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 6m ago

CONCLUDED AITAH for “breaking my sobriety” on Halloween?

14 Upvotes

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/Otherwise-Ant1548

Originally posted to r/AITAH

AITAH for “breaking my sobriety” on Halloween?

Editor’s note: changed letters to names for ease of readability


Original Post: November 2, 2026

Last night I went out to some bars with friends and my partner to celebrate Halloween. About a week ago my friends asked if I would be ok with going out to bars since I don’t drink, I said I would be fine with that and might have a few drinks since its Halloween.

I had a few drinks, enough where I was a bit tipsy and I was probably the least drunk in our group. In the past I’ve had a few nights out that got a bit out of hand but so have all of my friends, nothing like that happened last night tho. Some of my friends ended up leaving early because they drank a bit too much and just wanted to go home but there was nothing crazy and I just spent most of the night with my partner.

This morning over text one of my friends told me I made everyone uncomfortable last night by breaking my sobriety and said that they felt like they were responsible for me and that they couldn’t have a good time because they were too worried about me drinking.

The thing is that I never quit drinking. I did significantly cut back on how much I was drinking about a year ago and stopped drinking hard liquor, but I would still have the occasional wine or beer, and I did this for health reasons, I was not an alcoholic. My friends knew this so I'm confused why they thought I was sober and why they wouldn’t bring it up before we went out if it was going to make them uncomfortable since I did not keep it a secret that I was going to be drinking.

It seems like my friends want an apology because I apparently ruined their Halloween, but I can’t see how I did anything wrong. I hardly even saw them all night because I was with my partner most of the time and nothing notable happened that I think could upset them. My partner said I didn’t do anything wrong and they had a fun night out with me.

Do I need to apologize for this? I have never claimed to be sober and have had many conversations with my friends about drinking since I stopped drinking regularly and it seems to me that they just made a very weird assumption about me and this could have been cleared up if they just asked me about it before hand.

AITAH has no consensus bot, OOP received the majority of NTAs

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Did they expect to use you as a designated driver and not tell you? That’s the only reason I could see anyone being annoyed that someone else drank. NTA

OOP: I don’t drive

Commenter 2: I wouldn’t necessarily apologize, but would politely remind them you’re not in recovery and still drink the occasional low abv drink. Your friends should accept that without needing an apology.

NTA. If they can’t accept that they’re not your parents, they aren’t responsible for your decisions, and you didn’t make any decisions against your own interests they’re the asshole.

NTA being said, be prepared to decide between giving an apology and ending friendships.

OOP: They've asked multiple times why I stopped drinking and every time I’ve told them that I only stopped drinking hard liquor and that I still have the occasional drink, I’ve even had wine with them since. I really don’t understand where they got the idea that I was sober. Seems like I need to explain myself every time I do or don’t drink.

Downvoted Commenter: You’ve gotten “out of hand” with your drinking, your friends don’t like being around you when you drink, you drink “for health reasons” 😂 I can’t tell you whether you’re an alcoholic or not, but this a lot of double talk and defensiveness. I’m not signing on. YTA.

OOP: The most out of hand it’s gotten is getting overly emotional after a breakup on a night in and once a hard fall while walking home. I think we’ve all been there tho lol and as long as the bad nights are few and far between I’ve never held it against my friends when they do that.

What did OOP mean by a few bad nights?

OOP: I make sure I correct them every time they say I don’t drink because I don’t want them to think I’m sober. I have never said I don’t drink. I have told them it is because of the hangovers I get and partially for money reasons. The two bad nights I’ve had with them was one very emotional night after a breakup when we were drinking at my apartment. And one night out where I tripped and fell hard on the way home.

Commenter 3: No need to apologize. Some people don’t like their friends changing their habits. In this case you weren’t necessarily “the responsible one” and that’s why it ruined their night. You couldn’t be counted on to be “the person that was sober." NTA

OOP: This is the first time we’ve gone out since I apparently went sober. There have been several nights in at one of our places with drinking but we all live very close together so I’ve never really been “the responsible one” while they were drinking.

Commenter 4: INFO do your friends think you are an alcoholic or have reason to believe it?

Sounds like they think that’s the reason you stopped.

Either way, that wouldn't mean you owe them an apology.

OOP: I told them when I decided I would no longer be drinking liquor that it was because of the bad hangovers I was having and the effect on my health. Even before I stopped I drank about once or twice a month, so I don’t think so. We’ve had conversations about why I don’t get drunk with them several times and they have seen me hungover before. The only thing I could think of that would make them believe I’m an alcoholic is that a couple members of my family are I guess that’s kinda genetic?

Downvoted Commenter 2: Is it possible your drinking has been more of a problem in the past than you're willing to admit? That maybe your friends breathed a sigh of relief when you stopped turning up wasted? That could explain a lot. I'm going to go with NAH.

OOP: When I stopped drinking hard liquor they continued inviting me out to drink and would offer to pick up booze for me, so I don’t think so. I’ve also hosted a wine tasting party since that they all attended with no issues being brought up.

OOP on the timeline of how much they actually drink

OOP: Pregame started at 6pm, I had two drinks. Went to the bar around 9pm and left at 2am, I had three drinks at the bar that I shared with my partner. So about drinks over 8 hours, enough to keep a buzz.

Commenter 5: NTA...but, drop some ages. What you described as your changing relationship with alcohol is the exact actions of ALL my middle aged friends. Maybe you noticed the need early? But it seems like your friends are having an internal struggle. You're fine.

OOP: Mid-twenties  

Update: November 15, 2026 (almost two weeks later)

This updates a bit late, but I thought someone might be curious what happened.

I’m gonna call the friend who texted saying I made everyone uncomfortable by my drinking Alex and the friend that took an uber back with them early Beth.

Basically I asked Alex for specifics on what I did that made them uncomfortable and if it was really everyone that was uncomfortable or just them and they wouldn’t really give me a clear answer just kept saying how I don’t normally drink and people were worried I would do something crazy which stopped them from having fun. I pointed out that I barely saw anyone from our group all night because they were on the dance floor while my partner and I were on the other side of the bar. Alex said that just proves their point if I didn’t notice everyone being concerned about me I must have been pretty out of it. I called bullshit and called Beth.

I asked Beth if she had heard anything from Alex about Halloween and she said Alex had a really rough night. I knew Alex and Beth left early because they drank a bit too much but apparently that was an understatement.

Alex drank way too much and had been puking in the bathroom when Beth decided to take them home. Alex was pretty pissed that they had to go home early and was upset that Beth made them leave since I was probably just as trashed because they assumed my tolerance would have changed over the last year. Beth said Alex was probably just spreading rumours about me to take the attention off themselves.

I’ve talked to most of my other friends who went out with us since and they said that they had heard from Alex that things got out of hand with me but didn’t see anything and decided it was none of their business. Some people who are closer friends with Alex said this kinda thing was typical with them and no one took it too seriously.

As of now we’re all still friends but I am pretty upset with Alex and don’t think I’ll be going out with them anytime soon, but I don’t think this is worth blowing the friend group up over. Might be dumb for this but we’ll see how things go.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: If I were you I’d distance yourself as quickly as possible before Alex decides to target you and attempts to turn everyone against you.

OOP: I mean they already have targeted me and it didn’t work. The way I see it I can end the friendship now and have a lot less friends or wait and see how it goes and it might be fine. I’m hoping Alex grows the fuck up.

Commenter 2: Alex is not your friend. I’d avoid her when at all possible.

OOP: I already didn’t hang out with them much one on one just in a group setting. If I’m hosting anything I won’t invite them for the time being, but I don’t see the need to avoid them otherwise. I won’t be going to bars with them that’s for sure lol.

Commenter 3: In your original thread it says you’re not even an alcoholic and you didn’t quit drinking, you just cut back.

So there is no “breaking sobriety” because you were never sober.

So… what?

OOP: Yeah Alex just told me they were uncomfortable I broke my sobriety even though there was no sobriety to break. Seems they just came up with some dumb reason to put the blame on me so people wouldn’t focus on them.

Commenter 4: How did you “break your sobriety” if you never stopped drinking? This entire story is nonsense.

OOP: I didn’t break sobriety because I wasn’t sober, that’s just what my friend was saying happened.

Commenter 5: Tell Alex, "Why would you spread bullshit about me, when it was you that got out of hand when you got wasted and got kicked out,"

OOP: I heard that Beth gave them quite the earful. I haven’t really talked to Alex since, I don’t plan on seeing then unless it’s in a group setting, and then if they try to bring it up other people will be there to hopefully shut it down.

Commenter 6: You may be part of the same friend group, but you can create your own distance. She's not your friend, be civil & polite, don't ask people to pick sides and don't let them ask you to pick sides either. Keep conversations with her to a minimum & be discrete & noncommittal about what you say to her. NTA

OOP: Yeah that’s what I’m planning on doing

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 10h ago

ONGOING My aunt (36f) wants me (24f) to be her surrogate + 3-Year Update

674 Upvotes

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/ThrowRA588324

Originally posted to r/relationship_advice

My aunt (36f) wants me (24f) to be her surrogate + 3-Year Update

**Trigger Warnings: ** medical issues, mentions mental health issues, coercion


Original Post: November 2, 2023

Backstory: My aunt (36f, my mom's sister) and her husband/my uncle have been married for about 9 years and have been trying to have a child without any luck. About a year and a half ago, my aunt experienced a medical issue, and she sees a heart specialist and a lung specialist who have both told her it is extremely unsafe for her to be pregnant due to her condition and strongly advise for her own life and any child she carries' life that she does not become pregnant. This has caused my aunt and uncle to consider surrogacy.

About a year ago, my aunt casually asked me in front of my mom and grandma in a jokey tone if I would be her surrogate. In a non-confrontational way, I said no because I wasn't interested in being pregnant at all, even for my own children. My mom (53f) told my aunt she would be her surrogate if she could, and my grandma (mid-70f) chimed in and said she would have too. I didn't take that as a jab at me, but more like trying to be supportive of my aunt. I thought that conversation was over.

Fast forward to about a month ago, my aunt asked me again in private during a family gathering, with my fiancé (23m) present, if I would be her surrogate again. My aunt said it could be in a few years, so my fiancé and I would be married for a few years by that time. She wants to know the surrogate personally, so she trusts them and can go over to their house and "love on the belly whenever she wanted." She has had a few co-workers volunteer to be her surrogate, but she and her husband are not comfortable with them. When my aunt asked again, I said again that I wasn't interested.

The part that I feel kind of weird about and I think will cause drama is that when she first asked me a year ago, I was adamant I never wanted to be pregnant at all, but at the time I was really struggling with GAD *(editor's note: generalized anxiety disorder - a mental health condition characterized by six months or more of chronic, exaggerated worry and tension that is unfounded or severe than normal anxiety people experience). Now I have my anxiety under control, and I am more open to having biological children/being pregnant. I still haven't fully decided if I want biological children/to be pregnant, but I don't feel it's completely off the table anymore. I feel that if I do choose to be pregnant with my own child in the future, I don't want my aunt to get her hopes up that I will do it for her too, since my original reasoning was that I didn't want to be pregnant. It is recommended (at least in my state) that the surrogate has had a pregnancy before becoming a surrogate for someone else, which I feel I can explain to my aunt, but in all honesty I just don't think I want to go through with a pregnancy for anyone else.

I know I don't owe anyone my body and don't have to be pregnant to carry someone else's child, but I just feel there will be so much discomfort, awkwardness, and potentially resentment if in the future I'm at family gatherings with my maternal family with my biological children and I didn't help my aunt when I could have. I've even considered going through my first pregnancy with my child, then the second pregnancy with my child and my aunt's child at the same time so they would be wombmates, but not siblings, just cousins. Does this sound like a good idea? Does anyone have any insight or experience with this? I'm not sure if my insurance would cover any expenses regarding this. I'm concerned telling any of my family any of this will get everyone's hopes up, so I have only talked to my fiancé and a couple friends about this.

Extra info: I'm in Indiana if that helps. My fiancé and I live in the same town as my parents, my grandparents, and my aunt and uncle. We all see each other often. My mom and aunt are the only two siblings and there are no cousins around my aunt's age to ask because they're all around my mom's age or older. My fiancé said he would support me in any decision I make since it is my body.

TL;DR: My aunt wants me to be her surrogate, I'm not sure I want to do that, so I am considering being pregnant with both my child and hers at the same time as wombmate cousins.

EDIT: Thank you all so much for so many comments! I have decided I'm completely uninterested in being my aunt's surrogate, I just felt some guilt about not helping her if I were to choose to be pregnant with my own baby someday. I really don't believe I could be pregnant for someone else, and I don't want to be pregnant and not have a baby to raise at the end. I will practice standing firm with my "no." I'm worried about other people's feelings, but I need to do what's best to protect myself. I really appreciated all of the comments.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Crazy how they're "not comfortable" with their volunteers, but they're totally fine for you to be incredibly uncomfortable for 9 months!

I have 3 children, and there's no way in any universe I'd go through that for someone else, the only thing that made the pregnancies bearable was knowing I'd have my babies at the end of it. I cannot emphasize enough how massive the whole pregnancy thing is, it is torture for your body and mind, and they need to stop acting like it's just a big belly.

OOP: This is a reason I'm so hesitant to be her surrogate. Pregnancy is a pretty scary thought for me. My mom says how amazing pregnancy is and how I should experience it (we were talking about me adopting instead when we had this conversation). I feel like pregnancy could be worth it if I have my baby at the end of it. I don't really want to go through a pregnancy knowing I'm not keeping/raising the baby after it, which is why I'd consider being pregnant with my own with hers at the same time if that were a possibility. These comments are helping me lean towards "no" though

Commenter 2: No responsible doctor or surrogate agency is going to agree to a procedure involving multiple embryos from two different sets of parents simultaneously for the same reason they wouldn’t agree to make you a surrogate now: there are too many risks and unknowns beyond the already significant risks even the easiest pregnancy carries.

Fortunately, your aunt is not entitled to your womb. If she wants kids, she needs to accept that it’s a “no” from you and look elsewhere. As for the rest of your family, just because they’d do it for her if they could doesn’t mean they’re entitled to make your reproductive choices for you, either. Practice saying “this isn’t up for discussion,” and really think about how many of these family gatherings you and your future kids need to attend if that’s not enough to make people drop the subject.

OOP: I appreciate your comment. I used to see a therapist for my anxiety and setting boundaries and being firm was something I need to work on

OOP responds to a long thread about her aunt trying to control the surrogacy process and taking advantages of her if OOP goes ahead

OOP: I do feel my aunt would try to be controlling over my diet and things I can/cannot do, which is partially why I thought if I were also pregnant with mine at the same time, I could more easily set boundaries. Now I know that's a dumb idea anyway and I'll just say no and stand by it

Commenter 3: Don't do it. If you aren't 100% in then you ARE 100% out. Pregnancy changes your body forever.

OOP: "Not 100% in means 100% out" is a great perspective, thank you

Has OOP's aunt offered money for surrogacy as it can be a financial issue for the aunt and uncle

OOP: She didn't give a price or specific number, she just said she would pay for it

Commenter 4: Instead of giving her hope, just say no. You don't want to do it, and anyone who tries to change your mind isn't worth being around. Did anyone even consider the fact that you struggled with GAD?

OOP: My family doesn't know I see a psychiatrist and used to see a therapist. Mental health isn't something we talk about, and I decided to get help by myself when I was 22 and I'm doing a lot better now

Commenter 5: Is the reason she’s comfortable with you doing it and not her co-workers possibly because she feels she’ll be able to cross your boundaries, and make you feel guilty so she can do whatever she wants?

Because “being able to love on the belly anytime” feels like a massive boundary cross. I hated being touched without my consent while pregnant. And “anytime” sounds to me like you’d be expected to be at her beck and call.

You gotta say something along the lines of “hard no on that, I don’t want to be pregnant but if I was, it wouldn’t be for someone else”, and then deal with the discomfort that brings. You’ll feel better after you’ve been firm - even if she thinks you’ve been an asshole about it. Trust me. This nebulous area you’re in is the worst.

Family may feel they can ask anything, but it also means that you get to say anything, including no.

OOP: I believe it probably has something to do with the dynamic of being co-workers vs being aunt and niece. She probably feels she can be a little pushier with me than her co-worker  

Update: November 15, 2026 (three years later)

[Update] My aunt (36f) wants me (24f) to be her surrogate

I made the original post 3 years ago, and I remembered it because my aunt (39f) casually brought up me (27f) being her surrogate again at a small family gathering. My aunt was talking to my mom and me about how if she were to have a baby, she would likely need a surrogate, "like if maybe OP would want to for us someday" and she moved past that comment and was talking about her favorite baby names. Since she didn't directly ask me this time, I just didn't comment on it.

Looking back on the original post, I see how naive and anxious I was. A lot of things have changed since I made the original post. I feel a lot more sure of myself and in my capability to say no, my husband and I are married, I know I want to have a baby, and we've been struggling with infertility for over 2 years. We have "unexplained infertility" on my part, all we know is that my follicles don't mature and I have an ovulation problem. I have done 4 rounds of medication to try to stimulate follicle maturation with no luck, and one round of shots in March of this year to stimulate follicle maturation. The round of shots did allow me to have 3 mature follicles, but that did not result in a pregnancy. We're open to trying shots again in the future, but we have put trying to conceive on pause for now. Our journey to parenthood looks a little different than I had expected it to, and I've spent some time grieving that, but I know everything will be okay. I was always sympathetic towards my aunt's fertility struggles, but I had no idea what it was like to WANT to have a baby like I did when my husband and I started to try to conceive, and that makes me really sad that she has been dealing with this for so long.

I still know I don't want to be a surrogate for anyone, even if/when I am able to have/carry my own baby. I do wonder if it's worth trying to have a conversation with my aunt saying I am not interested in being a surrogate, or just ignore the comments like I have been doing. My aunt did pull me to the side a few years ago asking about it and I said no, but clearly she's still thinking about it. Would it be worth it for me to bring it up and say, "please stop mentioning me possibly someday being your surrogate because I don't want to be a surrogate for anyone," or just leave it alone since there hasn't been a formal discussion about it? I imagine there hasn't been a formal discussion about it because I haven't had my own baby, so do I just wait until then or bring it up now/next time she mentions it in passing? I don't know if it would be even worth bringing it up if there isn't a formal discussion about it.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: I think you need to be clear and tell her you will not a be a surrogate. You don't have to be one if you don't want to. But I think you should tell her this firmly, so she understands it's not happening. Perhaps she will find someone else. I think right now she's holding onto hope that you'll change your mind, so you really need to be firm.

OOP: This is a good point. I was wondering if bringing it up would do much since I've told her no before, but I think I need to be more firm about it and not just a "no I'm not interested"

Commenter 2: Have you told her about your infertility struggles? I'd frame it like this: "Aunt, I know you want me to be your surrogate, but I am not going to do that. I understand how tough it is to want a baby and not be able to have one. Husband and I have been spending years sorting out infertility issues ourselves. My priority is on having my own child, and after that it will be on caring for them. I truly hope you find a solution that allows you to have a baby, but I won't be able to help."

OOP: I haven't told my aunt, but I've told my grandma everything, and I know my grandma has mentioned to her that we're trying at least. My aunt told me she would be both jealous but also happy for me if I were to have a baby. I don't know the extent that my aunt knows about my infertility or treatments since I haven't told her

Commenter 3: You wouldn't qualify. You haven't been pregnant and given birth, and you've got infertility issues. There are certain qualifications that your aunt is apparently unaware of.

It's also a huge ask. Some surrogates get attached to their babies. You mentioned in the original thread that she wants to come "love the belly" whenever she wants, so you wouldn't have any privacy. It sounds exhausting. That plus nausea, weight gain, swelling, pain etc.

I think you should tell your aunt that it won't happen. It's frankly odd of her to single you out and expect something this major, before even asking if it's something you want. I would tell her about the infertility too, since she seems to think you will be convinced eventually if she keeps bringing it up. You can tell her all this in front of other people, if she also asks in front of people. Your family can't resent you for not qualifying for a major medical procedure.

OOP: "Love on the belly" lives rent free in my head and makes me really uncomfortable

OOP responds to a comment about her infertility struggles and to relax

OOP: "Just relax" is an upsetting response to my infertility struggles to me because it's not like I'm not getting pregnant because I'm not relaxed enough. My MIL doesn't get this at all. Many months of taking ovulation tests and planning days when to try, and going to a fertility clinic and taking meds feels necessary when it's not happening naturally. Thank you for validating my feelings ❤️.

OOP explains more about her family background / history with infertility

OOP: I'm guessing there is something genetic about this too. My grandma struggled with fertility too, she tried for 3 years to have my mom born in 1970, then again for years later to have another, then accepted they wouldn't have another until my grandma unexpectedly got pregnant and had my aunt 17 years after she had my mom. My aunt has never conceived to my knowledge. My mom never had any issues getting pregnant, and she would talk about how easy it was for her before she knew I was struggling.

I don't exactly know why my aunt never conceived, but I know my follicles don't mature so there is nothing to fertilize each cycle. I took fertility shots that worked, but those were about $2000 per cycle and my doctor estimated with my overall information they have from my blood tests and ultrasounds that each follicle that shots can help me produce has about a 10-15% chance of becoming fertilized. It's possible I have endometriosis, but the only way to confirm that is through surgery.

OOP expands more details about the costs of getting pregnant

OOP: Yes I'm in the US and everything healthcare is so insanely expensive. My fertility doctor wants me to get an HSG before we do another round of fertility shots, but I am not ready to pay for that. I had a lot of menstrual pain as a teenager, but I took birth control for 7 years and didn't experience horrible pain on the meds or in the 2 years I've been off of them. I did genetic testing to see if I carry cystic fibrosis, spinal muscular atrophy, or fragile x syndrome since my sister has fragile x syndrome, but I tested negative for carrying all of those things. None of my general practitioner, gynecologist, or fertility doctors are concerned about me being pregnant, just getting there is a struggle. What kind of genetic testing are you suggesting I get?

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP


r/BestofRedditorUpdates • • 10h ago Popcorn

ONGOING AITA for correcting my girlfriend’s family every time they mispronounce my turtle’s name?

2.4k Upvotes

I am not the OOP, OOP is u/IntrusiveGas

AITA for correcting my girlfriend’s family every time they mispronounce my turtle’s name? - posted 2026-09-23 to r/AmItheAsshole

I have a turtle named Geoff. Yes I know Geoff is normally pronounced Jeff. His isnt. My girlfriend’s family knows this and still calls him Jeff basically every time his name comes up.

His name starts with /ɖ͡ʐ/ instead of the normal American English J sound /d͡ʒ/. So regular Geoff/Jeff is roughly /d͡ʒɛf/ and his is /ɖ͡ʐɛf/. They are similar but they are NOT the same consonant. /d͡ʒ/ is a voiced postalveolar affricate and /ɖ͡ʐ/ is a voiced retroflex affricate. Basically you make the beginning of “Jeff” with the tongue farther back/retracted, which gives it a harder, deeper “dzh” sound.

I’m really into etymology and historical linguistics so the spelling was intentional too. Geoff is already a weird spelling from a modern English perspective because gives you basically no reason to predict /d͡ʒɛf/ unless you already know the name. Obviously I am NOT claiming medieval Geoffrey was pronounced /ɖ͡ʐɛf/. I just liked the spelling and wanted the initial consonant pronounced differently. I’m Black and I’ve also kept turtles most of my life.

My girlfriend learned it almost immediately. I dont expect some perfect textbook retroflex consonant every time. I just want it to sound noticeably different from Jeff.

Her family does not try. This comes up MAYBE once or twice a month because he is a turtle, so I dont understand why remembering it is apparently such a huge burden.

My girlfriend’s mom told me I need to stop correcting people because “the turtle doesnt know the difference.” I dont understand why that matters. Geoff also doesnt know how his name is spelled. That doesnt mean his name can just become Craig.

I even showed her 9-year-old nephew how to make the sound once because everyone acted like I invented an impossible consonant. I told him to make a J sound and pull his tongue farther back. He got pretty close almost immediately. Apparently mentioning this later came across like I was saying a 9 year old could do something the adults couldnt, but he literally could.

The argument actually started when her brother said “Jeff” again, I corrected him, and he admitted he KNOWS how I want it pronounced and says Jeff on purpose because he thinks the whole thing is stupid.

That changed it for me. Before that I assumed they forgot. If you know how a name is pronounced and deliberately say it differently because you think the pronunciation is stupid, then youre just intentionally saying it wrong.

And yes I know hes a turtle. Everybody keeps bringing this up like I somehow forgot.

My girlfriend thinks I should accept Jeff because the difference is small enough that most people cant hear it anyway. I think once they know there is a difference, especially after one of them admits hes doing it wrong on purpose, its weird for me to pretend there isnt.

I dont expect perfect /ɖ͡ʐ/. Literally any attempt to make it sound different from an American J is fine. They just dont try.

AITA?

-

000oooOOO000ooo: YTA for trying to force this level of control on others, it sounds insufferable. It's just a turtle and you can't make people do your bidding, I'm sorry.

JackfruitLess2816: Tragedeigh the turtle.

slimedewnautica: YTA. Must be a pretty good view, because that's one hell of a weird hill to die on

I tried to understand why my girlfriend was leaving me and apparently made it worse. - posted 2026-09-30 (a week later) to r/BreakUps

My girlfriend of almost 4 years left me yesterday and I think I somehow made the breakup worse by trying to understand why it was happening.

We’ve been having problems for a while and I knew she was frustrated with me, but I didnt think we were actually at the point of breaking up. Then her brother found a Reddit post I made a while ago about an argument involving the pronunciation of my turtle Geoff’s name. He immediately knew it was me and showed her my account.

She was furious that I had been talking about arguments involving her family online. I told her I deliberately avoided identifying details and was genuinely trying to get outside opinions, but apparently that made it worse because she said I always have a justification for everything. I’m black and we’ve been together long enough that I thought she understood how my brain works by now.

Eventually she said “you care more about being right than you care about me.”

That genuinely hurt me and I asked how she could establish that. We’ve been together for almost 4 years. Thats a pretty massive conclusion to make about how much somebody cares about you.

She started listing examples. She said I dont know when to drop arguments, I correct things that dont matter, and when shes upset I focus on whether what she said was actually accurate instead of why she said it.

So I asked what I would have to do differently for her to conclude that I care about her more.

She said sometimes I could just let something go even when I think I’m right. I asked how that would establish anything though. If I deliberately stop correcting something because she told me to, that proves I can stop doing it. It doesnt establish how much I care about either thing.

She said “THIS. What you’re doing right now is exactly what I mean.”

I told her that seemed circular. She was using me asking how she reached her conclusion as additional evidence for the conclusion. She started crying and told me she couldnt do this anymore.

I realize now that was probably not the appropriate time to keep asking questions. I genuinely wasnt trying to win the breakup. I was trying to understand what I had apparently been doing wrong for years without realizing it.

Before she left she told me not to contact her until she contacts me first. I’ve respected that completely. I did write out what I want to say when she does contact me so I dont forget anything important, but its currently 11 pages and I’m starting to think giving her the whole thing would probably make this worse.

I feel horrible. I love her and I dont want this relationship to be over. But I still dont understand how she established that being right matters more to me than she does. Every time I tried to understand her reasoning, it apparently became more evidence that she was right.

AITA for using Reddit as a neutral third party and then getting blamed when her brother found it? - posted 2026-09-30 (the same day) to r/AITA_Relationships

My girlfriend is currently staying with her parents and one of the major reasons is that she found out I’ve posted about arguments involving her and her family on Reddit.

Her brother found my account because he recognized a post about the pronunciation of my turtle Geoff’s name. He then went through my profile, figured out which other posts involved their family and showed everyone.

My girlfriend says I was airing out private family business online. I have three problems with that.

First, I deliberately avoided identifying details. Before her brother found the account, thousands of people could have read everything I posted and none of them would know who my girlfriend or her family were. Her brother is the person who connected anonymous stories to specific real people and then started showing those people the posts. I dont understand how I’m solely responsible for exposing them when he is literally the person who identified them.

Second, these arguments happened to ME too. I understand that I dont have the right to post somebody else’s private information just because I know it, but if somebody says something to me and we have an argument about it, that is also an event in my own life. I dont understand how my girlfriend can basically claim ownership over the entire interaction and say I’m not allowed to talk about my side of something I personally experienced.

Third, and this is what really annoys me, multiple people in her family have told me some variation of “ask anyone” when I disagreed with them. My girlfriend has done it too.

So I actually asked people who had no connection to either of us.

Now apparently that was wrong because “ask anyone” was not supposed to mean Reddit. But asking our friends seems LESS neutral because they already know us. Reddit was basically the only place I could ask where nobody had any reason to take either person’s side.

I brought all three points up during our argument and she said the fact that I had constructed “three separate defenses” instead of just apologizing was exactly the problem.

I dont really know what I’m supposed to do with that. If there are three reasons I think something is being characterized unfairly, obviously I’m going to explain all three. Having multiple reasons doesnt somehow make each reason less valid.

She has asked me not to contact her right now and I’m respecting that completely.

I realize there is an obvious irony in making another Reddit post about being in trouble for making Reddit posts. But I’m not asking Reddit to judge another argument with her family. I’m asking whether I was wrong to talk about arguments that also happened to me in the first place.

AITA?

Can I sue my ex for telling people I'm manipulative when I have evidence that I'm generally polite? - posted 2026-10-27 (a month later) to r/legaladvice

Location: Monterey, California. My ex girlfriend (26F) and I (28M) broke up a few weeks ago after almost four years together. Apparently she’s been telling mutual friends that I’m manipulative and emotionally controlling. I think this is defamation because I have literally thousands of text messages proving that I was polite to her.

I was always very careful about how I spoke to her, especially during disagreements. I rarely raised my voice and almost always said please and thank you. She, on the other hand, has called me an asshole probably hundreds of times. I have screenshots of this.

One of her complaints was that I made her feel guilty whenever she wanted to do something without me. This is ridiculous because I always explicitly told her she was allowed to do whatever she wanted. For example, if she wanted to go out with her friends instead of spending time with me, I’d say something like “Of course you can go, I just wish I hadn’t canceled my own plans to spend time with you, but that’s my problem, not yours.” I genuinely don’t understand how that could be considered controlling when I’m specifically telling her she has a choice.

She also claimed I kept score in our relationship. I did maintain a spreadsheet of things I’d done for her, but that was primarily for my own reference. I never showed it to her unless she said something demonstrably false, like that I never helped her with anything. Even then I would usually only show her the relevant rows. I also kept track of things she did for me, so it’s not like the spreadsheet was biased.

There was an incident last year where she wanted to break up with me after an argument. I told her I respected her decision but asked her to wait until the following morning because she’d already agreed to accompany me to a family dinner that evening. I explained that if she broke up with me beforehand I’d have to tell everyone why she wasn’t there, whereas if she waited until afterward we could handle it privately. She agreed to come and we ended up staying together another year. She’s now using this as an example of manipulation, which makes no sense because it was her decision to stay.

Another thing she brings up is that I would sometimes cry during arguments. I’m not sure how crying is manipulative when it’s an involuntary bodily function. I did occasionally tell her that if she continued arguing with me while I was crying she’d be knowingly causing me additional distress, but I don’t think that’s an unreasonable thing to point out.

Since the breakup I’ve been putting together evidence of my character. I have screenshots of me thanking her for dinner, complimenting her appearance, asking about her day, and even apologizing on occasions when I hadn’t actually done anything wrong. I also found a message from 2023 where she literally described me as “the sweetest person I’ve ever met.” I don’t see how she can legally call me manipulative now when she previously admitted the opposite in writing.

I’ve contacted two mutual friends to ask exactly what she’s been saying. One of them refused to tell me, so I asked whether he was comfortable potentially becoming a witness in a defamation case without knowing what information he was withholding. He told me to leave him alone, which I did.

I don’t want to ruin her life or anything. I just want her to issue a written correction to everyone she’s spoken to. I would also like her to acknowledge that the breakup was her choice and not something I forced her into, because she’s been making it sound like she had no choice but to leave.

Would a lawyer be interested in a case like this? I have 1,800 screenshots, the spreadsheet, and a recording of her telling me I’m a good person while we were still together. I also have a birthday card where she wrote that she couldn’t imagine her life without me, which I think could be particularly important evidence.

-

Decent-Proposal-8475: The non-legal advice is you need to move on with your life. I felt embarrassed for you reading this, how did you not feel embarrassed typing it up?

The legal advice: In order to prove defamation, you have to prove harm. Actual harm. Like if she got you fired from your job. You also have to show that the statement is provably false. A judge isn't gonna care about a birthday card.

I have 1,800 screenshots, the spreadsheet, and a recording of her telling me I’m a good person while we were still together.

This probably proves your ex was right. This is unhealthy behavior.

No lawyer is gonna take on your case because there's no money in it. This is just you being obsessive

AITA for telling my ex-girlfriend she can’t use things I said during our relationship as evidence against me now that it’s over? - posted 2026-11-15 (2 weeks later) to r/AITARelationship

My ex-girlfriend and I broke up after almost four years together. She’s been telling people I was manipulative and controlling, and her main evidence is screenshots of private conversations we had while dating.

I think this is extremely unfair because those messages were written with the understanding that we were in a committed relationship. I consented to having those conversations with my girlfriend, not with some future ex-girlfriend who would distribute them to people who already dislike me.

For example, she’s showing people a message where I told her she was free to go out with her friends, but that I’d probably spend the evening wondering why she preferred spending time with them when she knew I was upset. She stayed home voluntarily. I specifically gave her a choice, so I don’t understand how that constitutes controlling behavior.

She’s also showing people messages where I said I couldn’t live without her. Apparently that’s emotional manipulation now, despite the fact that she told me she loved me literally hundreds of times. I have screenshots of those too, but unlike her I haven’t been circulating them.

I told her that even if she thinks I was a bad boyfriend, she doesn’t get to retroactively change the meaning of things I said when we were together. She said the meaning hasn’t changed, she’s just finally recognizing what I was doing. I pointed out that she called me the best boyfriend she’d ever had in 2024, so either she was lying then or she’s lying now. She refused to answer.

I’ve offered to sit down with her and review the messages individually so we can establish which ones were actually manipulative and which ones she’s simply interpreting negatively because she no longer likes me. She declined and eventually blocked me.

I think there’s also a basic fairness issue here. She was involved in every one of these conversations, yet somehow I’m the only person being held accountable for them. If she felt manipulated, she could have said something at the time instead of waiting until we broke up to start collecting evidence.

I don’t think it’s reasonable to judge a relationship using information that was never intended to be used outside that relationship. Otherwise literally anything you say to someone you love could be held against you years later.

AITA(Relationship)?

-

0hip: You are manipulative

Your first example was extremely manipulative

It was textbook emotional manipulation

smilesbig: YTA for also not recognizing YTA and then complaining about being called out as an AH.

Labeling as "Ongoing" because he will probably crop up in yet another subreddit soon, trying to get validation from a different audience.

Reminder: I am not OOP.