r/CompetitiveEDH • • 5h ago

General Discussion / Question Thoracle Ban Affecting Glarbsday?

0 Upvotes

Hello, I’m fairly new to cEDH (4 Months 🥳) and the deck I immediately fell in love with was Glarb Doomsday. It’s not the strongest deck in the format, but it’s one that I have fun piloting.
However, it has come to my attention that with the upcoming Commander update, two cards are potentially in danger of getting hit with the ban hammer, Rhystic Study & Thoracle.
Now while I run both in my list, I don’t really care about losing out on Rhystic Study, as I’ve still got plenty of draw engines/tutors I can rely on. I care significantly more about Thoracle as it’s the primary way to win off my doomsday piles. Yes, technically I can win off of [[Jace, Wielder of Mysteries]] as well, but he’s more expensive, and honestly harder to win with than Thoracle.
My question therefore lies in this; Can Glarb Doomsday survive if Thoracle gets banned? Would losing out on Thoracle make the deck that much worse? Obviously I know that it isn’t confirmed or anything that the card will be banned but I’m just concerned about my favorite deck.


r/CompetitiveEDH • • 5h ago

Deck Fine Tuning Big Elves Deck, tuning help to bracket 5

0 Upvotes
  • Decklist link: https://moxfield.com/decks/S-GdRb3PK0OTuhpByjzLqA
  • Color: Mono-green
  • Commander: Marwyn, the Nurturer
  • Budget: depends on the prices of the upgrades.
  • What is your deck supposed to do?: Swarming the opponents with a lot of big elves by stockpiling +1/+1 counters on elves. These are supplemented by cards, that gives additional bonuses to power and toughness or some other specials.
  • Win Conditions: Opponents overrunned with big elves. There is an infinity combo with Marwyn, the Nurturer in combination of the Staff of Dominion included too.
  • Meta? What's that? Deck is currently bracket 4 and stands not so well in bracket 5 games even if I still won some games.
  • What are you NOT willing to change about your deck? I'm quite flexible, as long the general theme is not getting a huge change.
  • Have you already played this deck, and if so, which issues did you encounter and what would you like to improve?: Deck has been played many times, and it is fast but sometime still too slow. Or creature removal is a big hurt as well. There are currently too less creature protection available. And even there are some removals implemented, it can be not enough.
  • In the deck list there is a part named Considered. Most of the cards there are already owned by me and can easily be swapped in. But I'm still interested in other cards fitting well here.
  • Card exchange: If a card should be added, please also tell, which card has to be removed.

r/CompetitiveEDH • • 13h ago

Help, I am new to cEDH! Trying to understand how this deck wins, help a newb?

11 Upvotes

EDIT: Solved! Thank you!!

List in question: https://edhtop16.com/tournament/imperial-siege-nurberg/decklist/hiUsBl9NwbZVBldg74b67Vmdi4C3

I came across this list that did pretty well at a recent tournament of 54 people (4-1-2), and I can't quite figure out how it converts.

I am admittedly new to cEDH, so maybe I'm just missing something obvious.

As far as I can figure out, on a Protean Hulk cheat like Entomb + Necromancy, you get a Hulk pile of Ruthless Technomancer + Carrion Feeder +Phyrexian Dreadnought, which nets you 3 treasures and another Hulk pile. From there, I can see Shang-chi + Apprentice Necromancer to get you another Hulk pile, with 2 more CMC of creatures to tutor for in the second pile that starts to seem much less definitive. It's around here I feel like I begin to lose the plot.

I would go for Badgermole Cub in that 2nd pile, and for the 3rd pile, get Enduring Vitality + Eternal Witness, allowing me to Apprentice Necromancer again for a 4th Pile, grabbing Goblin Engineer (fetching Wishclaw Talisman [and maybe formidable speaker for 2 tutors? (Final fortune + Underworld Breach for another turn to untap and breach for a win... Somehow?)

I don't get what the win looks like other than maybe your opponents concede in the face of your big acrural of value and board. Does it rely on breaching into grinding station, and Praetor's grasping a Thoracle or brain freeze from a Ral/RogSi in your pod?

I like playing weird decks, and I really want to unpack this one, and would love any insight.

Thanks 🙏