r/EDH • u/DisdainfulStacks • 13h ago
Question I was told I committed a “social faux pas” at Commander with friends last night—but I don’t know why?
Me and five friends were playing precons out of the box. I was playing Mardu Surge, with [[Zurgo Stormrender]], with one friend playing the [[Stella Lee, Wild Card]].
In my prior (6) commander games as a new player, I’ve mostly used decks I’ve made myself based around lore or themes, while my friends use “fairly solid” or “strong” out of the box or upgraded precons. I am often knocked out of the game in 3-5 turns, and this time, I was hopeful I’d be able to at least deal meaningful damage before anyone could cripple my board at a weak spot (1-2 creatures on the board, no commander or buffs). An example deck I’ve been running is here (ManaBox).
I played this deck in a 1v1 against a friend’s Bracket 3 Ghidorah deck, and almost got my token generation up before I was wiped and destroyed for 20 damage (with 2 health remaining). I’m used to not winning my games, but seeing a deck finally work well together and then get crushed was a little demotivating.
My friends encouraged me to borrow or buy more precons, as my themed decks, while being lore specific and unique, simply “aren’t strong enough for the rest of the pod”.
Over around four to five turns, I slowly build up my board, preparing to deal with Stella Lee. I’ve been told that anyone who can pilot a spellslinger deck accurately is a strong threat, so I decided to target my friend running Stella Lee and dealt minor (2 damage) attacks to the Stella Lee player using [[Grenzo, Havoc Raider]], also exiling the Lee player’s cards—these turned out to be islands and mountains, and I was sternly told that “messing with lands is a faux pas, we can heavily hurt you for that”
Eventually, I summoned Zurgo, and attached [[Infantry Shield]], creating four tapped and attacking 1/1 Warrior tokens, and swinging with Zurgo and then the Warriors for 7 damage. Much later, about 40 minutes (didn’t keep track) into the game, I drew [[Divine Visitation]], and turned the next summoned warrior tokens into 4/4 Angels, bringing my friend down to 16 health.
I was then told what I did was incorrect, and was then hit with creatures from my friends and counterspells from the Stella Lee player when trying to regain my (now wiped) board. I had to leave early for work, and scooped, and was told my friends would be discussing this with me tomorrow as to the etiquette of this, and they told me “commander is a social format. The goal is not to win. It’s to talk with friends.”
How can I improve as to not have something like this happen again?