r/DebateAVegan • • 1d ago

getting more and more depressed with veganism and life

8 Upvotes

Hello I have been vegan for a few months now but the more I learn about our foods and how they are harvested and produced I become more and more demotivated, I feel like a hypocrite. I feel like every single crop I eat, makes me have blood on my hands. I know that veganism isn't about avoiding every animal death, but I sure wish It was. I know that every vegan counts, but honestly I see the problem is much broader. the problem is the human. I feel like the best thing I could do I just end my life, or at least that is the solution I come to when thinking about these issues. I don't want to live a life that causes endless animal deaths and suffering.


r/DebateAVegan • • 2d ago

Ethics Ethically raising and slaughtering animals for meat

9 Upvotes

Recently responded to a comment in a post in the vegan sub where a person said they would buy meat if it didn't involve this much animal suffering i.e. if it was slightly more ethical than the meat we get today.

My response was "killing even ethically raised animals is still animal cruelty" and i got heavily downvoted for it.

Can anyone please share their opinion on ethical raising and slaughter?


r/DebateAVegan • • 2d ago

Why is eating non-vegetarian food considered morally wrong?

1 Upvotes

In nature, animals eat other animals as part of the food chain. Humans are omnivores too, so eating meat is also part of our natural dietary capabilities.

However, many argue that eating meat is morally wrong because animals experience pain and suffering. But we also consume plants, which are living organisms. Since plants don't express suffering in the same way animals do, we generally have little hesitation about eating them.

So, is the issue really about the suffering involved, or are we more emotionally connected to certain forms of life?

I'm not trying to justify animal suffering. I'm genuinely curious about where we draw the line between nature, survival, and morality.

What are your thoughts?


r/DebateAVegan • • 2d ago

Sometimes I feel like vegans put the suffering of animals above the suffering of humans and nature.

0 Upvotes

To an extent I understand why they may advocate for it more, but I’m talking more in personal actions.

Like the amount of vegans that I see who don’t bother getting their clothes second hand, when we have enough clothes for the next 6 generations, and the vast majority is made by exploiting humans and ends up polluting and therefore killing lots of animals.

Who buy electronics they don’t need when it’s made from exploiting children.

Who focus so much on avoiding non human exploitation that they end up exploiting humans and nature in the process.

I am certain that there are vegans out there who do minimize or avoid all these things, and perhaps my perception is skewed by videos I see of militant vegans online but I wonder what people think of those who become so entrenched by this identity that they end up developing a blind spot or worse supremacy mindset when it comes to other things.


r/DebateAVegan • • 2d ago

☕ Lifestyle Would vegans make exceptions for trying food from other cultures

0 Upvotes

How do vegans feel about not being able to try food from other cultures and more specifically how would a vegan manage food in a multicultural relationship where your partners culture has a big emphasis on meat dishes.

Ive aksed a few vegan freinds and they all say they would never for example, make an exception when travelling in Italy to try the pizza or they would never try Bejing roast duck when in China.

I honestly can't fully understand how vegans can give up those experiences because its really important to me.

I know just because the food is from another culture it doesn't magically become not the corpse of an animal that was killed for human benefit.

However, in my worldview the value of experiencing new things from other cultures and learning through a shared meal / experience that I can't get at home is equal to my love for animals.

(I study wildlife conservation and a language so its a strange mix of "save the animals" and "our food is great and important you should try it!" )

I ask this question because I stopped being vegetarian after 5 years because my bf is from a very different culture to me where food is a big part of celebrations, family bonding ect, if I didn’t meet him I would probably be vegan now.

His family are farmers and chefs (so food is especially important its how they make a living). After a few months of dating I understood that asking his family to not only accommodate a language barrier but also change their cuisine for me was a big request that I didn't want to make out of politeness/ respect.

Its been 3 years now and his family love me, so I feel I could return to my vegetarian ethics but I still feel like I couldn't say no to their food.

Food is their love language especially for me who is low intermediate at BEST in their language.

They will just bring me food and put the best dishes in my bowl at dinner. I know they appreciate me not being fussy about things most people of my culture wouldn't eat so if I suddenly turn my nose up at most things I know it will be difficult.

So overall regarding travel and relationships specifically how do you ethically and socially balance these factors, I genuinely want to do better for animals and the environment and I need like advice on how I can reshape my approach to food to make this all work.

Edit: Thanks everyone for pointing out all the things I overlooked! It's given me a lot of hope and confidence to have the difficult conversations I was scared to have. I now know some actions I can immediately take to rebalance my morals that I don't think I would have thought of.


r/DebateAVegan • • 3d ago

Ethics Why should I treat veganism differently than other consumption choices and not just be "freegan"?

26 Upvotes

Long before going vegan, I was basically "freegan" for several months. I phased out animal products in my cooking, clothes, cosmetics, etc. Before even really doing any research about veganism as a philosophy. It just felt intuitive to me. Thanksgiving was the last animal product consumption I did and felt a bit guilty at the time as I had just started learning more about animal ag. Lately I've been feeling very isolated at social events and that guilt is worn off, though. I know more than ever about animal ag and am very firmly pro animal liberation. I've even convinced a few people to go vegetarian at least.

The problem is I can't really logically defend the idea of, say, refusing a slice of birthday cake to myself. I tell myself 'that's not vegan", but so what? Whether something is vegan or not doesn't dictate whether it's right or wrong to do it. I'm the only vegan i even know. I wouldn't ask the person who made the cake whether they used child labor chocolate, so why should I ask if they used eggs? The outright refusal of any product that contains anything animal related seems to be a feature unique to veganism compared to other consumption pattern choices. But maybe I'm wrong.


r/DebateAVegan • • 3d ago

Human/animal moral equivalency

5 Upvotes

I'm not a vegan, and I doubt I ever will be. But I'm still interested in challenging my beliefs that clash in an incompatible way with 'popular' worldviews. And pretty much every time I discuss veganism it boils down to one specific disagreement: The vegan belief that all sentient lifeforms demand equal moral consideration.

Which is a perfectly fine worldview to have, but most people I've discussed this with treat it as an objective fact, which I've never gotten any adequate justification for.

If anyone has any non-subjective arguments to support this, I'd love to hear them.


r/DebateAVegan • • 3d ago

⚠ Activism Do rad-vegans actually believe that animals are equal to humans?

0 Upvotes

Often radical vegans (think someone like That Vegan Teacher or PETA) will use an argument that goes something like this:

"Imagine if that were human meat" or "Imagine if those were humans in that farm" implying that they see animals as equal to humans

But most of their attempts to destroy animal agriculture to be limited to non-violent or non-lethal means, such as disruptive protests and abstinence

whereas if I were trying to stop industrial scale cannibalism I would attempt more extreme methods like terrorism


r/DebateAVegan • • 3d ago

Quail eggs are vegan

0 Upvotes

If I raise quail, and give them a large amount of space, water and food and let them enjoy their lives in a protected space most vegans agree it's moral

And if I use their manure for crops I'm not harming or exploiting them

And if I take their eggs, which quail don't get attached to because they don't have a brooding instinct then I'm just using up nutrients

This should make quail eggs vegan

(Btw I'm not vegan, please don't crucify me)

If you think this is exploitation by this logic I can't let my dog shit in my lawn because they that would exploit them


r/DebateAVegan • • 5d ago

Ethics Why is exploitation bad if it doesn't harm the animal?

18 Upvotes

Hi all! I've been looking into some of the reasons why vegans won't eat eggs, even if they're from chickens that they personally have cared for. As well as vegan positions on things like dogs, whether as working dogs or pet dogs.

I understand that chickens will eat their eggs to conserve nutrients, but, if you're already providing all of those nutrients, including the grit that they need, then why is that form of exploitation harmful? I understand that you are still gaining something from the chickens, and thus it is exploitation, but I don't really get why all exploitation of animals is bad? It's not like it causes any distress to them to take their eggs, especially if they have already abandoned them, which they quite frequently do.

Similarly, I have seen some vegans talk about how they don't like working dogs, in any capacity, and I've seen some go so far as to say that they think dog sports are unethical. While I won't argue that there are some people in these worlds which are not training in an ethical way, I don't understand the harm of using dogs for purposes when they enjoy those purposes.

I guess what I am trying to ask is, why, personally, do you feel that exploitation of animals is bad in all contexts, even in situations where there is no negative welfare consequence for the animal, and sometimes even increased welfare in the case of working dogs? Also, can you see that, even if you personally choose to abstain from all animal exploitation to a practicable degree, that others can have a point if they disagree, or is it something that you can't see at all?

Thank you so much for reading and your time, I would love to hear what you have to say, because it's not something that I've been able to find the answer to elsewhere. I understand that vegans are not a monolithe, so I'd love to see a range of opinions. I have vegan friends in real life that I could ask, but tbh, I don't want to other them for being vegan any more than is avoidable, so I'm grateful for spaces like this.


r/DebateAVegan • • 5d ago

Ethics Undercover slaughterhouse footage elicits my support for animal welfare, not animal rights

0 Upvotes

I think vegetarians and vegans are laudable for their positive environmental and ethical impact, and as an omni I sometimes watch slaughterhouse videos to acknowledge the ethical choice I make otherwise by consuming meat. But those videos have never made me think about going vegan. The reason the videos cause discomfort is not because an animal dies, but because it suffers in excess of what is needed to kill and prepare it. This might sound horrifying to those who ascribe human-like natural rights to animals, but like most people, I don't. Seeing a cow panic as it is being led to slaughter makes me feel bad for the cow and wonder if there is a way to keep it calmer in its final moments. Seeing Temple Grandin instantly kill an unsuspecting cow with a bolt gun to the head makes me feel like it was a job well done. As such, while I find vegans laudable in their absolute minimization of animal suffering, I don't see being one personally as imperative for myself or others.

The most important objection to this would be our elevation of cats and dogs to a special status, but even then, WE are the ones who choose to elevate them. As much as I absolutely adore my cat and treat it like my own child, that love comes from my personal bond with my cat and cats in general. Not a universal conviction that all beings with the cognition level of a cat or higher deserve equal consideration as a person.


r/DebateAVegan • • 6d ago

Where is the line?

2 Upvotes

Hi, I'm thinking about veganism and I was always kinda curious. Where is the line of what's banned as "animal" products? Cause there's a large "trend" of insect snacks and products, are those "banned" as well? Like beeswax or cosmetics/beverages (Campari) using carmine from insects? Or even true silk? And also, what about corals which are frequently used in toothpaste, calcium supplements or skincare products?


r/DebateAVegan • • 6d ago

Ethics Is eating meat really immoral?

0 Upvotes

Have you ever considered the argument that because animals cannot consent to being eaten and that humans gain pleasure/benefit from eating them so therefor could that be considered a justification and therefor not immoral? Just a thought I had, and I'd be interested to hear how vegans approach this from an ethical perspective.


r/DebateAVegan • • 6d ago

Ethics I think y’all are right, but I don’t care

0 Upvotes

I think being vegan is probably right or at least better than being a meat eater. I’m also probably not gonna change. I mean bacon taste too goddamn good for me to give up and I don’t feel like giving up an entire part of my diet over some fucking animals that I don’t care about. If you have some reasons that could change my opinion on not giving up animal products and reasons I should genuinely care throw them at me


r/DebateAVegan • • 7d ago

Ethics Would you eat meat that was chemically produced/grown in a factory?

10 Upvotes

In an ideal world where this "meat" is made and grown in a factory, it is carbon neutral, made to be pretty healthy, and the slab of meat is not sentient, will vegans eat it?

Some may say that at least 1 animal had to be harmed in order to produce this meat. But using the internet on your smart device also harms animals across the globe. So where is the line drawn?


r/DebateAVegan • • 6d ago

How veganism handles science?

0 Upvotes

If anyone has a tiny bit insight to how science and research work, its clear that animals of all kinds (from monkeys, through mice and fish to flies) are used and unalived daily for the purpose of research. Its all done in super strict ethic codes restricting the welfare, amounts act.

Yet its still hundreds of animals being born to die for a better or worst scientific study. Like worms are being fed only polystyrene, studied whether they actually can (and they do!) be a part of recycling. Were banning animal cosmetics testing, yet we induce cancer, chromosomal aberrations act. in animals to study possible pharmaceutics or just how it works.

Is there any solution to this? Is it moral to be a vegan but a scientist?


r/DebateAVegan • • 6d ago

Why can’t you eat eggs

0 Upvotes

As a vegan who eats eggs, why don’t others eat eggs? I have my own chickens and eat their eggs. So why don’t more vegans do this? Just get your own chickens so you can be sure they’re properly taken care of.


r/DebateAVegan • • 8d ago

Ethics Is Veganism needed to ethically care for nature?

2 Upvotes

Do people need to be vegan to care for animal wellbeing holistically? What are the opinions towards conservationists, veterinarians and biologists not being vegan for the most part but leading the charge of caring for animals?

It seems most people working in the animal ethics fields: policy formation & legislation are omnivores (in terms of diet). What are the ethical opinions of this? Low, moderate or high?


r/DebateAVegan • • 9d ago

Ethics Veganism is only morally right when you ignore reality

10 Upvotes

People go vegan because they anti suffering and think its the morally right thing to do, but when you go vegan you give land back to the wild where animals are eaten alive and suffer extremely bad conditions.. resulting in worse torture to animals than humane farming

If you really cared about the suffering of animals you'd want to sterilize the wild
People romanticize nature too much but its just a violation machine where animals go thru unimaginable horrors


r/DebateAVegan • • 10d ago

Ethics Do you agree with me that taxidermy is never "respectful" or "out of respect"?

23 Upvotes

I say this because it's using the corpse of a being that could never consent to it as a decoration and personally I think that's incredibly disrespectful and I thought here was the place I'm least likely to get harrased in the comments.


r/DebateAVegan • • 10d ago

Ethics What are the ethical perspectives/opinions vegans have of non vegans?

8 Upvotes

I'm tryna understand how vegans view other people from an ethics viewpoint. Is it feelings of disappointment? Wanting them to do better?

What do y'all think of most of the world not being vegan and why that is? What are the ethics regarding that? Do you think one needs to be vegan to have a justification for caring about nature?


r/DebateAVegan • • 10d ago

Opinion on leather wear

3 Upvotes

Hi I have been living vegan for a few months now.
I have a bunch of jeans tho with a leather patch on the back and also a pair of leather slippers that have been gifted to me a few years ago. For the jeans I removed the patch but I don’t really want to get rid of the slippers, I feel like me only wearing them inside and barely anyone visiting me, doesn’t advocate leather wear. I was thinking to myself that it would be disrespectful throwing them out when they are still functional.
Also what do you think of buying second hand jeans with a leather patch on the back and removing it?
I know there are a bunch of vegan brands that are worth supporting. But I haven’t quite found any with nice fitting.


r/DebateAVegan • • 10d ago Heartwarming

Ethics is vore vegan?

0 Upvotes

One of the main ethical foundations of veganism is that animals cannot be killed and eaten as it is morally wrong to kill a living being. But if the being was a human who truly consented to being consumed (not to any direct harm of them either like in voluntary cannibalism) would there still be that moral issue? Obviously vore is still eating an animal, but would be go against the principles of veganism if both parties were alright with it? Asking for a friend


r/DebateAVegan • • 10d ago

Would you eat eggs from my rescue chickens?

0 Upvotes

Starting in covid, a local 4H program shut down, my friend knew we had an unused chicken coop, since then we scan Craigslist looking for people who are getting rid of their chickens, someimes they lose all but 1 and dont want them to be lonely, we also work with local farms who have layers that are past their prime and for whatever reason they dont want to eat them, we take them and they live in our fruit orchard, laying or not, we call it the chicken retirement home. Im not trying to argue about factory farm egg production, I know its awful, I know this is a very rare circumstance. Just curious what the ethical reason would be to not eat these.


r/DebateAVegan • • 12d ago

Questions about poor people and veganism

0 Upvotes

I’m not really here to debate I just have a genuine question be happy to debate each other in the comments.

So I have seen a lot of vegan posts for some reason and a common occurrence I’m seeing is that people ate very extreme with they beliefs, obviously all of yall aren’t and there are normal people who are vegans but a lot of vegans that I have seen personally seem very extreme. I keep seeing vegans say they don’t understand how someone can love animals and eat them, comparing eating animals to slavery, saying there is no excuse that makes eating animals acceptable, and many more things. And as someone who grew up in the hood in a food desert I’m genuinely wondering do the people who think this also think people who barely have a choice on what to eat are also morally corrupt? Where I live it’s less money to buy meats and eat that with rice and get full from that rather than trying to eat vegan, and you don’t have a huge choice in what to eat because the goal is to just have something that’s good while also being able to make you full. And some people might think this is a dumb question but I’m seeing people call people that eat meat nazis, abusers, even seen somebody say they don’t consider people who eat meat as human.

So basically my question is do the people who have these extreme beliefs also believe that people who are too poor to have a choice also are nazis, barely human, and whatever other name in the book?