Ello folks, I wanted to make a brief post outlining all of the current cases and previous court cases which have been dropped for images/books for plaintiffs attempting to claim copyright on their own works.
This contains a mix of a couple of reasons which will be added under the applicable links. I've added 6 so far but I'm sure I'll find more eventually which I'll amend as needed. If you need a place to show how a lot of copyright or direct stealing cases have been dropped, this is the spot.
HERE is a further list of all ongoing current lawsuits, too many to add here.
HERE is a big list of publishers suing AI platforms, as well as publishers that made deals with AI platforms. Again too many to add here.
12/25 - I'll be going through soon and seeing if any can be updated.
The lawsuit was initially started against LAION in Germany, as Robert believed his images were being used in the LAION dataset without his permission, however, due to the non-profit research nature of LAION, this ruling was dropped.
DIRECT QUOTE
The Hamburg District Court has ruled that LAION, a non-profit organisation, did not infringe copyright law bycreating a datasetfor training artificial intelligence (AI)models through web scraping publicly available images, as this activity constitutes a legitimate form of text and data mining (TDM) for scientific research purposes. The photographer Robert Kneschke (the ‘claimant’) brought a lawsuit before the Hamburg District Court against LAION, a non-profit organisation that created a dataset for training AI models (the ‘defendant’). According to the claimant’s allegations, LAION had infringed his copyright by reproducing one of his images without permission as part of the dataset creation process.
"The court sided with Anthropic on two fronts. Firstly, it held that the purpose and character of using books to train LLMs was spectacularly transformative, likening the process to human learning. The judge emphasized that the AI model did not reproduce or distribute the original works, but instead analysed patterns and relationships in the text to generate new, original content. Because the outputs did not substantially replicate the claimants’ works, the court found no direct infringement."
INITAL CLAIMS DISMISSED BUT PLANTIFF CAN AMEND THEIR AGUMENT, HOWEVER, THIS WOULD NEED THEM TO PROVE THAT GENERATED CONTENT DIRECTLY INFRINGED ON THIER COPYRIGHT.
FURTHER DETAILS
A case raised against Stability AI with plaintiffs arguing that the images generated violated copyright infringement.
DIRECT QUOTE
Judge Orrick agreed with all three companies that the images the systems actually created likely did not infringe the artists’ copyrights. He allowed the claims to be amended but said he was “not convinced” that allegations based on the systems’ output could survive without showing that the images were substantially similar to the artists’ work.
Getty images filed a lawsuit against Stability AI for two main reasons: Claiming Stability AI used millions of copyrighted images to train their model without permission and claiming many of the generated works created were too similar to the original images they were trained off. These claims were dropped as there wasn’t sufficient enough evidence to suggest either was true. Getty's copyright case was narrowed to secondary infringement, reflecting the difficulty it faced in proving direct copying by an AI model trained outside the UK.
DIRECT QUOTES
“The training claim has likely been dropped due to Getty failing to establish a sufficient connection between the infringing acts and the UK jurisdiction for copyright law to bite,” Ben Maling, a partner at law firm EIP, told TechCrunch in an email. “Meanwhile, the output claim has likely been dropped due toGetty failing to establish that what the models reproduced reflects a substantial part of what was created in the images (e.g. by a photographer).”In Getty’s closing arguments, the company’s lawyers saidthey dropped those claims due to weak evidence and a lack of knowledgeable witnesses from Stability AI. The company framed the move as strategic, allowing both it and the court to focus on what Getty believes are stronger and more winnable allegations.
META AI USE DEEMED TO BE FAIR USE, NO EVIDENCE TO SHOW MARKET BEING DILUTED
FURTHER DETAILS
Another case dismissed, however this time the verdict rested more on the plaintiff’s arguments not being correct, not providing enough evidence that the generated content would dilute the market of the trained works, not the verdict of the judge's ruling on the argued copyright infringement.
DIRECT QUOTE
The US district judge Vince Chhabria, in San Francisco, said in his decision on the Meta case that the authors had not presented enough evidence that the technology company’s AI would cause “market dilution” by flooding the market with work similar to theirs. As a consequence Meta’s use of their work was judged a “fair use” – a legal doctrine that allows use of copyright protected work without permission – and no copyright liability applied."
This one will be a bit harder I suspect, with the IP of Darth Vader being very recognisable character, I believe this court case compared to the others will sway more in the favour of Disney and Universal. But I could be wrong.
DIRECT QUOTE
"Midjourney backlashed at the claims quoting: "Midjourney also argued that the studios are trying to “have it both ways,” using AI tools themselves while seeking to punish a popular AI service."
In the complaint, Warner Bros. Discovery's legal team alleges that "Midjourney already possesses the technological means and measures that could prevent its distribution, public display, and public performance of infringing images and videos. But Midjourney has made a calculated and profit-driven decision to offer zero protection to copyright owners even though Midjourney knows about the breathtaking scope of its piracy and copyright infringement." Elsewhere, they argue, "Evidently, Midjourney will not stop stealing Warner Bros. Discovery’s intellectual property until a court orders it to stop. Midjourney’s large-scale infringement is systematic, ongoing, and willful, and Warner Bros. Discovery has been, and continues to be, substantially and irreparably harmed by it."
DIRECT QUOTE
“Midjourney is blatantly and purposefully infringing copyrighted works, and we filed this suit to protect our content, our partners, and our investments.”
AI WIN, LACK OF CONCRETE EVIDENCE TO BRING THE SUIT
FURTHER DETAILS
Another case dismissed, failing to prove the evidence which was brought against Open AI
DIRECT QUOTE
"A New York federal judge dismissed a copyright lawsuit brought by Raw Story Media Inc. and Alternet Media Inc. over training data for OpenAI Inc.‘s chatbot on Thursday because they lacked concrete injury to bring the suit."
District court dismisses authors’ claims for direct copyright infringement based on derivative work theory, vicarious copyright infringement and violation of Digital Millennium Copyright Act and other claims based on allegations that plaintiffs’ books were used in training of Meta’s artificial intelligence product, LLaMA.
First, the court dismissed plaintiffs’ claim against OpenAI for vicarious copyright infringement based on allegations that the outputs its users generate on ChatGPT are infringing.
DIRECT QUOTE
The court rejected the conclusory assertion that every output of ChatGPT is an infringing derivative work, finding that plaintiffs had failed to allege “what the outputs entail or allege that any particular output is substantially similar – or similar at all – to [plaintiffs’] books.” Absent facts plausibly establishing substantial similarity of protected expression between the works in suit and specific outputs, the complaint failed to allege any direct infringement by users for which OpenAI could be secondarily liable.
Japanese media group Nikkei, alongside daily newspaper The Asahi Shimbun, has filed a lawsuit claiming that San Francisco-based Perplexity used their articles without permission, including content behind paywalls, since at least June 2024. The media groups are seeking an injunction to stop Perplexity from reproducing their content and to force the deletion of any data already used. They are also seeking damages of 2.2 billion yen (£11.1 million) each.
DIRECT QUOTE
“This course of Perplexity’s actions amounts to large-scale, ongoing ‘free riding’ on article content that journalists from both companies have spent immense time and effort to research and write, while Perplexity pays no compensation,” they said. “If left unchecked, this situation could undermine the foundation of journalism, which is committed to conveying facts accurately, and ultimately threaten the core of democracy.”
A group of authors has filed a lawsuit against Microsoft, accusing the tech giant of using copyrighted works to train its large language model (LLM). The class action complaint filed by several authors and professors, including Pulitzer prize winner Kai Bird and Whiting award winner Victor LaVelle, claims that Microsoft ignored the law by downloading around 200,000 copyrighted works and feeding it to the company’s Megatron-Turing Natural Language Generation model. The end result, the plaintiffs claim, is an AI model able to generate expressions that mimic the authors’ manner of writing and the themes in their work.
DIRECT QUOTE
“Microsoft’s commercial gain has come at the expense of creators and rightsholders,” the lawsuit states. The complaint seeks to not just represent the plaintiffs, but other copyright holders under the US Copyright Act whose works were used by Microsoft for this training.
Sept 16 (Reuters) - Walt Disney (DIS.N), Comcast's (CMCSA.O), Universal and Warner Bros Discovery (WBD.O), have jointly filed a copyright lawsuit against China's MiniMax alleging that its image- and video-generating service Hailuo AI was built from intellectual property stolen from the three major Hollywood studios.The suit, filed in the district court in California on Tuesday, claims MiniMax "audaciously" used the studios' famous copyrighted characters to market Hailuo as a "Hollywood studio in your pocket" and advertise and promote its service.
DIRECT QUOTE
"A responsible approach to AI innovation is critical, and today's lawsuit against MiniMax again demonstrates our shared commitment to holding accountable those who violate copyright laws, wherever they may be based," the companies said in a statement.
A settlement has been made between UMG and Udio in a lawsuit by UMG that sees the two companies working together.
DIRECT QUOTE
"Universal Music Group and AI song generation platform Udio have reached a settlement in a copyright infringement lawsuitand have agreed to collaborate on new music creation, the two companies said in a joint statement. Universal and Udio say they have reached “a compensatory legal settlement” as well as new licence deals for recorded music and publishing that “will provide further revenue opportunities for UMG artists and songwriters.” Financial terms of the settlement haven't been disclosed."
Reddit opened up a lawsuit against Perplexity AI (and others) about the scraping of their website to train AI models.
DIRECT QUOTE
"The case is one of many filed by content owners against tech companies over the alleged misuse of their copyrighted material to train AI systems. Reddit filed a similar lawsuit against AI start-up Anthropic in June that is still ongoing. "Our approach remains principled and responsible as we provide factual answers with accurate AI, and we will not tolerate threats against openness and the public interest," Perplexity said in a statement. "AI companies are locked in an arms race for quality human content - and that pressure has fueled an industrial-scale 'data laundering' economy," Reddit chief legal officer Ben Lee said in a statement."
Stability AI has mostly prevailed against Getty Images in a British court battle over intellectual property
DIRECT QUOTE
"Justice Joanna Smith said in her ruling that Getty's trademark claims “succeed (in part)” but that her findings are "both historic and extremely limited in scope." Stability argued that the case doesn’t belong in the United Kingdom because the AI model's training technically happened elsewhere, on computers run by U.S. tech giant Amazon. It also argued that “only a tiny proportion” of the random outputs of its AI image-generator “look at all similar” to Getty’s works. Getty withdrew a key part of its case against Stability AI during the trial as it admitted there was no evidence the training and development of AI text-to-image product Stable Diffusion took place in the UK.
DIRECT QUOTE TWO
In addition a claim of secondary infringement of copyright was dismissed, The judge (Mrs Justice Joanna Smith) ruled: “An AI model such as Stable Diffusion which does not store or reproduce any copyright works (and has never done so) is not an ‘infringing copy’.” She declined to rule on the passing off claim and ruled in favour of some of Getty’s claims about trademark infringement related to watermarks.
So far the precent seems to be that most cases of claims from plaintiffs is that direct copyright is dismissed, due to outputted works not bearing any resemblance to the original works. Or being able to prove their works were in the datasets in the first place.
However it has been noted that some of these cases have been dismissed due to wrongly structured arguments on the plaintiffs part.
The issue is, because some of these models are taught on such large amounts of data, some artist/photographer/author attempting to prove that their works were used in training has an almost impossible task. Hell even 5 images added would only make up 0.0000001% of the dataset of 5 billion (LAION).
I could be wrong but I think Sarah Andersen will have a hard time directly proving that any generated output directly infringes on their work, unless they specifically went out of their way to generate a piece similar to theirs, which could be used as evidence against them, in a sense of. "Well yeah, you went out of your way to make a prompt that specifically used your style"
In either case, trying to create a lawsuit against an AI company for directly fringing on specifically plaintiff's work won't work, since their work is a drop ink in the ocean of analysed works. The likelihood of creating anything substantially similar is near impossible ~0.00001% (Unless someone prompts for that specific style).
Warner Bros will no doubt have an easy time proving their images have been infringed (page 26), in the linked page they show side by side comparisons which can't be denied. However other factors such as market dilution and fair use may come into effect. Or they may make a settlement to work together or pay out like other companies have.
—————————————————————————————————————————————————
To Recap: We know AI doesn't steal on a technical level, it is a tool that utilizes the datasets that a 3rd party has to link or add to the AI models for them to use. Sort of like saying that a car that had syphoned fuel to it, stole the fuel in the first place.. it doesn't make sense. Although not the same, it reminds me of the "Guns don't kill people, people kill people" arguments a while ago. In this case, it's not the AI that uses the datasets but a person physically adding them for it to train off.
The term "AI Steals art" misattributes the agency of the model. The model doesn't decide what data it's trained on or what it's utilized for, or whatever its trained on is ethically sound. And the fact that most models don't memorize the individual artworks, they learn statistical patterns from up to billions of images, which is more abstraction, not theft.
I somewhat dislike the generalization that people have of saying "AI steals art" or "Fuck AI", AI encompasses a lot more than generative AI, it's sort of like someone using a car to run over people and everyone repeatedly saying "Fuck engines" as a result of it.
Tell me, how does AI apparently steal again?
—————————————————————————————————————————————————
Googles (Official) response to the UK government about their copyright rules/plans, where they state that the purpose of image generation is to create new images and the fact it sometimes makes copies is a bug: HERE (Page 11)
Open AI's response to UK Government copyright plans: HERE
High Court Judge Joanna Smith on Stability AI's Model (Link above), to quote:
This response refers to the model itself, not the input datasets, not the outputted images, but the way in which the Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models operate.
TLDR: As noted in a hight court in England, by a high court judge. While being influenced by it for the weights during training, the model doesn't store any of the copyrighted works, the weights are not an infringing copy and do not store an infringing copy.
The subreddit rules are posted below. This thread is primarily for anyone struggling to see them on the sidebar, due to factors like mobile formatting, for example. Please heed them.
If you have any feedback on these rules, please consider opening a modmail and politely speaking with us directly.
Thank you, and have a good day.
1. All posts must be AI related.
2. This Sub is a space for Pro-AI activism. For debate, go to r/aiwars.
3. Follow Reddit's Content Policy.
4. No spam.
5. NSFW allowed with spoiler.
6. Posts triggering political or other debates will be locked and moved to r/aiwars.
This is a pro-AI activist Sub, so it focuses on promoting pro-AI and not on political or other controversial debates. Such posts will be locked and cross posted to r/aiwars.
7. No suggestions of violence.
8. No brigading. Censor names of private individuals and other Subs before posting.
9. Speak Pro-AI thoughts freely. You will be protected from attacks here.
10. This sub focuses on AI activism. Please post AI art to AI Art subs listed in the sidebar.
11. Account must be more than 7 days old to comment or post.
In order to cut down on spam and harassment, we have a new AutoMod rule that an account must be at least 7 days old to post or comment here.
12. No crossposting. Take a screenshot, censor sub and user info and then post.
In order to cut down on potential brigading, cross posts will be removed. Please repost by taking a screenshot of the post and censoring the sub name as well as the username and private info of any users.
Apparently, AI users go around bullying artists and destroying their work. 😂
According to the original caption, the only "unrealistic" part is the destruction — apparently, AI users would steal the artwork for model training instead.
There's a difference between criticizing AI training practices and portraying AI users as cartoon villains.
Edit: I reposted this with a corrected image to protect people's privacy. I've removed identifying usernames and subreddit information, including those associated with opposing or anti-AI communities. Regardless of our disagreements, everyone's privacy deserves respect.
“I’m not a Luddite, so I don’t fear the unknown,” Fincher told the Los Angeles Times.
“Is everyone satisfied that we have figured this art form out enough that what we really need to do is go back to celluloid?” he continued. “How long have people painted? 40,000 years? We’re talking about a thing that’s a hundred years old and everyone’s going, ‘Stop. Pencils down. No more iterating. It’s not necessary to have at your fingertips the ability to change the color of that person’s eyes.'”
People comment asking how you did it, what model you used, and how much quota it cost. Many fellow AI users discuss the production process and some of the author's unique manual design choices that distinguish it from other AI-generated videos. Some also discuss the actual plot content. There are even dedicated AI creative competitions where only videos made with AI are eligible to enter. People do criticize boring, assembly-line products, but that's because they're boring, not because AI was used. If you have a genuinely brilliant AI work, people will praise you, and no one will criticize you. AI-generated videos are naturally labeled as AI-generated, and human handcrafted videos are likewise labeled as handmade. For AI-generated videos, people discuss the core ideas, are amazed that you handled everything flawlessly, and recognize that the technology democratizes creation. For handcrafted videos, there is more admiration for patience and perseverance, and for strong foundational skills. Both are truly worthy of praise. Bilibili is truly great—everyone should give it a try.
I won't name this particular subreddit as that is against Reddit's rule and may encourage brigading, but is a subreddit to discuss movies in.
I got insta banned for posting an AI image. No warning, no history of bans, just insta banned. Yes it's against their rules, but I don't know how frequently I'm expected to read a subreddits rules for any changes, I've been posting there for years (on an older account).
I asked why as I was genuinely confused and was told there was a "strict" anti AI policy. Confused, I asked if that applies to movies with AI in it too? Does their strict anti AI stance extend to banning movie trailers/posterz (and the accounts that post them) from using AI? Will Fincher be banned if he tries to host an AMA after using AI in his new movie?
Or does their zero tolerance policy only apply when they feel like it? A non zero zero tolerance policy?
They dodged the question and muted me.
They're going to have a sub with a strict, instant ban anti AI policy to discuss a medium that will be full to the brim with AI products at all layers of production very soon.
I don't mind if they want to strictly ban AI, but they should at least be consistent about it. They can be the anti-AI movie sub and discuss the small scattering of films that don't use AI that are released each year and another sub can become the default movies sub.
Ok, realistically they'll just keep banning people from using AI while watching movies with AI in it and the mods and users won't confront the hypocrisy
Most subreddits outright ban AI. When you find one with no bans, the discussion of any post with AI art is so dominated by anti AI sentiment that it poisons the entire discussion. I’ve seen this multiple times in different groups: baking groups, groups about jigsaw puzzles, groups about promoting literacy in upper elementary school, groups for teachers. In none of these places has there been any discussion of the images beyond the generic namecalling.
I was thinking about whether I should post this here or on aiwars. I decided that since this post is defending AI, it fits perfectly there.
I have many reasons for joining the pro-AI side. One of them is actually the artists' (not all I mean those who witch hunts and bully others) fault. Their behavior is uncivilized and fascist. I know some artists have always been like this, but sending death threats and dehumanizing someone for their decision to use a tool is insane. As both a traditional artist and an AI artist, I support all kinds of creation, and that’s why this AI-free art supporting AI artists was made. Witty played a huge role in my journey. She is actually pretty sweet and cool to talk to.
I love the way she manages to troll so everyone else can create and get less attention from antis. I think we should all let Witty rest and either coexist or ignore each other. I am pro-AI, and I am an artist—AI has never made me lazy. Love y’all, no matter what you scream at me.
I've been compiling all the ways below. What should we be calling them? MAGAnties?
Populist 'Us vs. Them' Framing: Both movements cast a small, unaccountable elite, Silicon Valley 'tech bros' for anti-AI critics and 'globalists' or the 'deep state' for MAGA - as actively subverting the livelihoods and values of ordinary people.
Fear of Economic and Cultural Replacement: Just as MAGA centres on the displacement of working-class jobs and national identity, anti-AI discourse focuses intensely on the replacement of human labour and the dilution of human culture by synthetic media.
Nostalgia for an Idealised Past: Both rely on a strong current of restorationism, with anti-AI sentiment idealising a pre-2022 internet of unchallenged human authenticity much like MAGA seeks to return to a perceived golden era of American manufacturing and social order.
Hostility Toward Institutional Gatekeepers: Hardline anti-AI factions mirror MAGA's deep distrust of legacy media, universities, and federal agencies by viewing academic AI researchers, tech journalists, and regulators as captured by corporate interests.
Moral Absolutism and Purity Testing: Online anti-AI communities treat any engagement with generative tools as a moral failing, echoing the rigid ideological boundaries and 'RINO' purity tests common within MAGA spaces.
Catastrophic and Apocalyptic Stakes: Both frame their opposition not as a policy debate, but as an existential battle for survival - whether warning of the end of human agency and the planet or the literal end of the nation.
Cross-Ideological Horseshoe Overlap: In practice, both camps converge on populist policy fronts.
Amateur Forensics and 'AI-vestigating': Anti-AI sleuths scrutinise shading, hands, and phrasing under a guilty-until-proven-innocent standard that mirrors 'transvestigating,' where online actors obsessively analyse physical features to 'expose' hidden targets.
Purity Spiral and Apostasy Policing: Like MAGA's immediate branding of dissenting conservatives as 'traitors,' anti-AI spaces rapidly turn on creators - labelling them 'scabs' or 'thieves' - for even minor, assistive use of generative tools.
Swarm Harassment, Review Bombing, and Cancellation: Both weaponise decentralised online mobs to brigade comment sections, mass-downvote projects, and pressure institutions into dropping targeted individuals or brands.
Doxing and Asymmetrical Targeting: Rather than solely confronting powerful executives or politicians, both movements frequently punch downward by leaking the personal details of everyday individuals, such as small-time hobbyists or local poll workers.
Dehumanising Rhetoric and Escalation to Threats: Framing opponents as existential predators destroying one's way of life allows both ecosystems to rationalise violent memes and death threats as righteous 'self-defence.'
This one was made in the pre-AI era, but it still remains one of the greatest masterpieces. The style itself (stick figures) is arguably so easy that even a complete art illiterate could learn to draw such figures in 10 minutes. By the "no effort medium" logic, this should be slop.
Yet, it was one of the greatest masterpieces ever.