(Using a new account to avoid antis stalking my main, as apparently that's a thing. Also, this post is about the radical side of anti ai groups.)
I wasn't even aware that there was some kind of anti AI "movement" until I started seeing it onsocial media. I attended several CS seminars this year, and AI was among the many topics discussed. The professor even actively encouraged its use, even though pretty much everyone there was already using it.
Anyway, after reading through quite a few posts from anti AI individuals, one thing has become VERY clear: most of them have absolutely no idea what they're talking about.
The sheer amount of hypocrisy, hysteria, insecurity, and logically inconsistent arguments is genuinely impressive. they don't know how machine learning works, its environmental impact in comparison to other forms of infrastructure, how to use it, or evne what it's capable of. If they actually used their brain and did some research, it would look completely different. But no, they'd rather listen to bots and influencers spreading propaganda to make themselves feel better.
I'm struggling to understand why AI assisted art should be treated differently from other forms of artistic creation. I'm not religious, so the whole argument about AI lacking a "soul" is beyond me. More importantly, claiming AI is stealing doesn't make sense, unless you stand by the fact that humans are also stealing by looking at others' work. It doesn't save any images, it doesn't mash anything together. But of course antis don't know this, as they refuse to educate themselves. Technology and new innovations replace old ways of doing things. So, unless they give up every single invention and its products that have replaced somebody in the past, I don't see why they should be an exception. You can't sue someone just because they're better than you.
Some of my favorites:
- They claim AI is stealing from artists. They also demand that AI be banned due to it giving creeps an opportunity to create illegal images. If we go by their logic, AI would first need to steal the disgusting imagery from "real" artists in order to replicate them. Therefore, we should ban everything from pencils to the entire internet, as those are used by weirdos to produce and spread that kind of vile material.
- When somebody brings up how golf courses and other unnecessary infrastructure use way more water, they usually reply with: "We can hate both!!" Why, then, are they causing a massive fit under AI posts, and little to none under posts about golf courses or almond production?
- Comparing AI to NFTs. I have yet to see the technical similarities between these two. NFTs ran on proof of work blockchains. It doesn't give you the artwork. Only the token itself. It's expensive and useless. This goes back to my previous point: they don't know how AI works nor what it does. So if their cult tells them it's the same, then to them it's the same.
No, AI isn't going to disappear just because they dislike it. And no amount of whining, foaming at the mouth, or complaining about it on social media (that run on data centers, which they, ironically, also seem to hate and even threaten to BOMB) is going to stop it. If anything, AI is going to become increasingly more and more integrated into our everyday lives, workplaces, and infrastructure. That's simply the direction technology is heading. Deal with it.
I don't even make AI art, I'm just here to defend it. Because anti AI people must be one of the most ignorant, insufferable and idiotic groups active right now. I encourage you all AI artists to continue with your work. Keep on posting your art and don't stress over these lunatics. They don't listen to reason or logic. The world is already adapting at a fast pace. ~3 billion people use gen AI per MONTH. It won't be long before rabid antis are remembered only as the regressive morons that they are.
Moral of the story: Criticize AI all you want. There are perfectly valid reasons to do so. But if your entire arguemnt relies on misinformation, emotional outbursts, harassment, and a fundamental misunderstanding of the technology you're criticizing, perhaps it's time to do a little research before lecturing everyone else.
Otherwise, you might as well take a seat next to the flat earthers, 5G conspiracy theorists, and anti vaxxers. LOL.