r/DefendingAIArt • Antis Final Boss • 15h ago

If antis are okay with fanart, they should be okay with AI art

Post image
4 Upvotes

78 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 15h ago

This is an automated reminder from the Mod team. If your post contains images which reveal the personal information of private figures, be sure to censor that information and repost. Private info includes names, recognizable profile pictures, social media usernames and URLs. Failure to do this will result in your post being removed by the Mod team and possible further action.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

3

u/curtainpoles 2h ago • Bravo

TFW you see the mod post another dumb opinion, and then they ban anyone who makes fun of them for said opinion 😂 power trip 

2

u/Witty-Designer7316 Antis Final Boss 2h ago

Rule 9.

14

u/Sea_Association_5277 13h ago • Bravo

Lol, to the naysayers I got a request: show me the emails you got from Marvel Comics and DC comics giving you or an artist you know permission to make R34 commissions of SMTAS Black Cat porking BTAS Catwoman. No email =no permission = theft.

5

u/CZ-TheFlyInTheSoup 11h ago

If you stop to think about it, even before AI, everyone was taking copyrighted artwork without permission to make fan art, whether NSFW or not, or memes.

2

u/PrettySplatty AI Sis 1h ago

Exactly. Drawing a copyrighted character from scratch without permission is still legally an 'unauthorized derivative work,' not automatic Fair Use, even if you don't trace anything. Companies just tolerate fan art and convention prints because suing fans is bad PR (plus it can get too expensive).

-3

u/UmbraVictus 10h ago

I am not against AI art, but your argument is a false equivalency.

Fair Use allows people to use DC characters to make NSFW art. So long as you are not copying directly the media it is taken from. This essentially means you can't make a copy of any Iron Man issue and just add nudity in it or something.

To use an example where fair use was not protective. When overwatch first came out Blizzard went hard against a number of NSFW content creators because they used actual overwatch assets and story elements to make their art which does not fall under Fair Use.

3

u/Revolutionary_Bag518 10h ago

Except there are TONNNNNS UPON TONS of artists who will produce art / material of copyrighted characters / properties and sell them at conventions which is breaking copyright because you are profiting off of IPs.

It's the exact same if you garner a following creating fan art and you have a Patreon / Ko Fi people can give you money.

Also, fair use doesn't cover everything because Nintendo was able to shut down custom Pokemon games made with completely fan made assets that was available for download for free.

2

u/Sea_Association_5277 10h ago

There are millions of art pieces of characters in not only their original appearance but even the same art style. Some are drawn for free/fun and some are paid commissions. All are copyright violations. Secondly copyright extends to the character concept not just the story. Essentially I can't make any art with Iron Man's likeness period. Thirdly, Fair use isn't actually a protection. It's just a bandaid because the big companies don't see art commissions as a financial threat worth pursuing. They are absolutely worthless to go after. They're politely giving artists the illusion of "freedom" while holding the leash.

1

u/PrettySplatty AI Sis 1h ago

Fair Use doesn't actually cover drawing and selling copyrighted characters just because you drew them from scratch. Under copyright law, making new art of someone else's character without permission is still an unauthorized derivative work, unless it's clear parody or commentary, companies can shut it down anytime (like Nintendo does with scratch-built fan games)

9

u/Glebasya 10h ago

The worst offender is the majority of JoJo fandom, where a lot of fans are rabidly anti-AI, but if an artist copies manga (i.e. Araki's) or anime artstyle 1:1, indistinguishable from official artwork, then it's perfectly fine.

3

u/SomeGuyOfTheWeb 9h ago • Bravo

Arakis artstyle is very detailed. If someone generates an image of it you lose the decision making process on each detailed element.

How much artistic and creative decision making is it okay to hand over to an ai before it no longer becomes your "art"

1

u/Klutzy-Culture-2184 3h ago

Dude if you can replicate araki's art then props to you man

4

u/Cedarstripe 7h ago

1

u/PrettySplatty AI Sis 1h ago

Exactly, this is what antis do, we shouldnt be saying this type of stuff.

5

u/EarthboundMisaki AI helped my worldbuilding 12h ago

I understand your message, but I disagree with the way you're trying to execute it

1

u/ConsciousIssue7111 AI Should Be Used As Tools, Not Replacements 11h ago

Fair, I guess

6

u/Halloween_Forever_ 15h ago

And ai uses it's data feed for parameters not reproduction, is it possible to reproduce? Yes, but ai is trained for parameters

1

u/RichnjCole 14h ago

If you consider AI content and fan art to be comparable, then AI content that is sold should also be considered copyright infringement.

2

u/dawnfire05 Anti-Capitalist, Pro-Inovation 12h ago • Heartwarming

Or you can go in the other direction. That's only a capitalistic conclusion. Theft of creative ideas only exists under capitalism. AI content and fan works can be comparable, but because I think none of it is theft and none of this should legally be treated as theft. I don't believe anything creative should be put under a copyright.

-5

u/TheDemonEyeX 11h ago

Gonna go out on a limb and guess that you've never had an semi-original idea for a character in your life.

4

u/dawnfire05 Anti-Capitalist, Pro-Inovation 8h ago

Nah I just don't have a fragile ego. I'm confident in what I make and don't feel a need to protect its "sacred specialness" with fantasy value that only makes artists starve. I actually care about the creative. But whatever gets you through the night, you do you random stranger, convince yourself of whatever you must to protect your fragile artist ego. Keep defending the system that allows artists to starve and go homeless. I actually care about people creating art. I care about creative freedom. I care about art being a form of expression and not a system of rules. The "art" you defend is the Capitalist's wallet.

-1

u/[deleted] 8h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/dawnfire05 Anti-Capitalist, Pro-Inovation 8h ago

Oh, so because you aren't starving means there's no problems, got it. Any art out in the world has no particular owner. It is given up to the collective once it is shown. To think otherwise is the mindset of the peasant protecting their shovel over sharing the land. Just because your brainlet is incapable of understanding something doesn't make it wrong. If you think capitalism is independent of corporation, then you have an infantile disorder. But no intelligent life found here, so I'm not responding anymore.

-2

u/TheDemonEyeX 7h ago

Me not starving is not an indictment of a lack of problem you tawdry trog. It was a statement on you comment on ego. At least try to be consistent.

Ah yes communist approach to art. Another does the work to make it and the indolent claims it for themselves. No dear, art belongs to the artist, unless sold, then it belongs to the winning bid.

As for capitalism, yes it is indeed independent of corporatism(the word I actually used). Corporations utilize capitalism but capitalism is any exchange of service or product(as the case may be) for payment. When you go buy at that independent business instead of the big corporations? That's still capitalism.

A mark of intelligence is being able to take in new information and adjusting your view to it. Which you are unfortunately found lacking in, my crummy communist commentator. Though if you mean what you said about not responding, I thank you for sparing me your stillborn thoughts.

3

u/dawnfire05 Anti-Capitalist, Pro-Inovation 6h ago

No intelligent life found here. Stay mad.

1

u/DefendingAIArt-ModTeam 7h ago

This sub is not for inciting debate. Please move your comment to aiwars for that.

-5

u/Substantial_Pie_8619 14h ago

I do think there’s a difference between someone making ai stuff online and posting it or selling it

3

u/SnooRabbits6411 12h ago

No, Not any that matters to me. Legal to use = legal to sell as far as I am concerned.

1

u/Wonderful_Gap4867 9h ago

Segregation was legal until the late 1960s

Slavery was legal until 1985 in America. Slavery is still legal in many countries.

Child Mairrage is still legal in 32 states.

Schoolgirl's underpants are legal to sell in Japan.

Legallity should never be an argument for what is and isn't okay.

1

u/SnooRabbits6411 6h ago

:egality is Not an argument for what is ok. But in this case it happens tp be legal, and it is ok.

Did you just compare AI use to slavery and segregation??? Ok. You made the claim. You need to evidence that Ai use is like Segregation.

This should be good.

See this is when you Lose the audience. Making off the wall comparisons because you feel things.

1

u/Wonderful_Gap4867 5h ago

I wasn't comparing. I was saying legallity is not an excuse and listed examples as of such.

1

u/SnooRabbits6411 4h ago edited 3h ago

Fair enough on the structure — counterexamples to "legal means okay," not a comparison. I'll take that.

Two of them are wrong, though. Slavery wasn't legal in America until 1985; the 13th Amendment abolished it in 1865. You might be thinking of Mississippi, which rejected the amendment that year, voted symbolically to ratify in 1995, and didn't file the paperwork until 2013 — none of which changed anyone's legal status. And slavery isn't legal anywhere today. It persists illegally, which is worse and a different claim.

On the substance: I agree legality doesn't settle what's right. I've argued that about training data in this sub for weeks — taking people's work without consent or compensation is a problem whatever courts decide about fair use.

But that obligation belongs to the companies building these tools. It's on them to make sure what they're selling doesn't infringe. Even if the company did wrong in building it, I don't inherit that wrong by leasing their product. I'm using a legal tool, legally, and I can charge for what I make with it. Your battle is with the AI company, not with me. (Obvious exception: if someone deliberately prompts for a copy of a specific artist's work and sells it, that's on them. That isn't what we're discussing.)

So no, this isn't "legal therefore moral." It's a claim about where responsibility sits in the chain.

1

u/IWILLSTEALYOURWAFFLE neutral traditional artist ♡´・ᴗ・`♡ 10h ago

MIKUUUU

1

u/Emergency_Ad6805 9h ago

I agree 100%

1

u/SimonSonian 2h ago

What’s the correlation?

-2

u/-JonyMcDony- 14h ago • Bravo

why can't you just be respectful? if someone doesn't want their art to be fed into ai then don't feed it into ai. jerk.

8

u/Sea_Association_5277 13h ago

Don't post it online. That simple.

-4

u/Natural-Return1230 13h ago • Bravo

It's called having fucking respect and NOT throwing other people's artwork into a machine

Also what if people just want to show off some art they made?

4

u/SnooRabbits6411 12h ago

Choices have consequences.

0

u/SimonSonian 2h ago

So you agree that ai “art” is a negative thing?

2

u/SnooRabbits6411 2h ago

No, what have I said that gave you that Idea?

5

u/Sea_Association_5277 13h ago

Sweetiepoo, respect rarely if eever existed on the internet. Do you even know the first rule kids were taught before using the internet? NEVER POST THINGS YOU DON'T WAT OTHES TO KNOW OR MESS WITH. If an artist wants to show off then they do so knowing they lost all control of their art. If they want total control then they share it in person. You can't have both widespread sharing and total control.

0

u/Zirchon 3h ago

You could at least try not be a condescending prick, like wtf is "sweetiepoo".

0

u/[deleted] 13h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Sea_Association_5277 13h ago

Just like it's the artist's fault for flunking internet safety class in elementary school.

1

u/[deleted] 12h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/hyperluminate AI Sis 12h ago

This sub is not for inciting debate. Please move your comment to aiwars for that.

2

u/hyperluminate AI Sis 13h ago

This sub is not for inciting debate. Please move your comment to aiwars for that.

1

u/PrettySplatty AI Sis 1h ago

whats up with the antis always commenting on Witty's posts?

-1

u/Due_Employment_3334 15h ago

Why? can you elaborate?

0

u/lordcola 11h ago

Y'all really equating small time artists making some cash on the side with letting literally anyone steal anyone's art style? Any artist who's "made it" isn't doing fan art of mario or iron man and selling it

-5

u/IDontJoeMan 13h ago

False equivalence

7

u/EtherKitty Only Limit Is Your Imagination 13h ago

Why? Calling a fallacy und not disproving it is also a fallacy, the fallacy fallacy.

2

u/orangekirby 10h ago

Nah it’s a pretty good equivalence

0

u/Thomas_Something 12h ago

😂😂😂😂

-7

u/QuitCharacter2345 14h ago

They're not the same tho

-7

u/guy_person98 14h ago

No correlation in your point

-10

u/Chemical_Wafer_7947 14h ago

fanart is a direct copy, ai art is a reinterpretation. the source is still there, but the output isn't the same. that's the difference.

8

u/TheSinhound 14h ago

What? Fanart is always the fans interpretation of the work.

7

u/MediumWin8277 15h ago

If you feel jealousy over a tool, you are a tool.

0

u/[deleted] 14h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/Versitax 13h ago

no but they are able to downvote anyone who asks

1

u/[deleted] 8h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Witty-Designer7316 Antis Final Boss 8h ago

This is a place for speaking Pro-AI thoughts freely and without judgement. Attacks against AI will result in a removal and possibly a ban. For debate purposes, please go to r/aiwars.

0

u/[deleted] 10h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/Witty-Designer7316 Antis Final Boss 10h ago

This is a place for speaking Pro-AI thoughts freely and without judgement. Attacks against AI will result in a removal and possibly a ban. For debate purposes, please go to r/aiwars.