r/DnD • u/VictorRM • 19h ago
5.5 Edition People who Insist Leaving Cover Automatically Breaks Hiding Barely Hides in Their Games as a Player.
First of all, I'm happy to see and always support people to house-rule to best fit their games. But the main goal of this post will be about how the RAW really works. Since many tables tend to rule things base on RAW.
There're two voices about what happens after you Hide and succeed in the DC15 Stealth check, currently.
The ones who claim leaving Cover does not automatically break your Hiding. The argument's been "staying behind the cover" and "out of line of sight" are only required at the moment when you take your Hide action as the rules stated clearly "...when you take Hide action...".
These requirements are also not included in the part of what ends your Hiding. The argument also believes what breaks the Hiding is finely defined with a series of conditions in the last part of the rule.
Others believe "staying behind the cover" and "out of line of sight" are also necessary even after you succeed in your Hide action, though they're not in the last part of what breaks the Hiding.
Now, my point is, the ones who insist leaving out of cover automatically breaks Hiding barely hides as a player.
Then, hold on, I know this sound unfriendly, but this is not a rant or insult, but I'm being serious, cuz if you are a Player who often builds around Hiding, then you'll know there's a LOT of features in 5.5e are about Hiding. Ruling Hide in a way that automatically breaks will literally make all those features broken and not usable at all.
First example: the Rogue's Cunning Action. If you're a Rogue main, or a Ranger running Nature's Mantle, you should already know that if leaving cover automatically breaks your hiding, then you can never get an attack with advantage out of hiding. Like, ever.
Because even if you successfully hide behind some cover or obscurement, the moment you actually want to attack, whether melee or ranged, you have to step out of the cover to do it, and that exact moment you lost your advantage ASAP. And the 5.5e hiding rules don't have anything like that 5e line where "the DM can still give your attack advantage."
Second example: the Rogue's Supreme Sneak in the PHB, and the Spell Subterfuge feat from the last book, the Arcana Unleashed. The two features are like this:
Stealth Attack (Cost: 1d6). If you have the Hide action’s Invisible condition, this attack doesn’t end that condition on you if you end the turn behind Three-Quarters Cover or Total Cover.
Sneaky Casting. If you have the Hide action’s Invisible condition, casting a spell with a Verbal component or making a spell attack doesn’t end that condition on you if you end the turn behind Three-Quarters Cover or Total Cover.
Now, if leaving cover instantly breaks your hiding, what are these two features even for? And if you're not allowed to leave cover in the first place, then that whole "if you end the turn behind Three-Quarters Cover or Total Cover." line does nothing.
Third example: Species traits. Stuffs like the Halfling's Naturally Stealthy, or the Night Elf trait in WotC's latest WoW book. None of them will work either.
Naturally Stealthy. You can take the Hide action even when you are obscured only by a creature that is at least one size larger than you.
Night Elf lv1 feature: You have proficiency in the Stealth skill, and while you are in Dim Light or Darkness, you can take the Hide action as a Bonus Action.
(This feature is 100% identical to the Shadow's monster traits, so many people believe this gives players an extended way to Hide like the Haflings.)
Because if a successful Hide still means you have to stay out of line of sight and stay in Heavily Obscurement, Three-Quarters Cover or Total Cover, then even when you hide using the special trick these traits give you, you're exposed the second the Hide succeeds — since you're still inside the enemy's line of sight.
So my point is, if you're a player who regularly builds your characters around hiding and regularly beats enemies by hiding, or a DM that players often Hide, then you'll know that a "leave cover and you're instantly revealed" ruling just not works and flat out impossible. It makes the 5.5e game impossible to Hide. Roguish characters might not even be playable anymore.
Lastly, I don't think it's that unacceptable that a creature is not literally 360 degrees alert all the time, the 5.5e rules didn't say "you'll automatically exposed" like it was in 5e.
It's also not that unacceptable either for a heroic character to sneak around behind somebody's toes in a world of Magic and Spells.
Edit: Another thing to add as someone pointed it out in the comment. In the Playtest UA2, the Hidden condition listed "you aren’t Heavily Obscured or behind any Cover" as something that would immediately end the Hiding, but was deliberately deleted in the released version of the game.
The Hide action in the official released version has almost the same list of end triggers, except that one, which can be expected as intentional.