r/EdwardII • u/Charles318Hill • 4h ago
Discussion In March 1315, Edward II tried to stop the Great Famine by capping food prices by royal decree—and accidentally starved the markets.
When torrential rains wiped out the European harvests in 1315, livestock prices across England skyrocketed overnight. Under pressure from Parliament, Edward II issued a royal ordinance in March 1315 fixing strict maximum prices on oxen, pigs, sheep, geese, and chickens across the kingdom.
The physical reality of supply and demand hit immediately. According to the contemporary Vita Edwardi Secundi and chronicler John of Trokelowe, farmers and merchants simply refused to bring livestock or grain to market at a guaranteed loss. Towns went completely dry, black-market prices surged past the old rates, and even the royal household struggled to buy provisions while traveling through the countryside. By early 1316, the Crown had to quietly repeal the entire ordinance because enforcing the price caps was starving the population faster than the weather.
It is one of the cleanest primary-source examples of medieval logistics colliding head-on with royal legislation.
Are there any other medieval economic decrees that backfired this fast in the chronicles?