r/EdwardII • • 4h ago

Discussion In March 1315, Edward II tried to stop the Great Famine by capping food prices by royal decree—and accidentally starved the markets.

Post image
10 Upvotes

When torrential rains wiped out the European harvests in 1315, livestock prices across England skyrocketed overnight. Under pressure from Parliament, Edward II issued a royal ordinance in March 1315 fixing strict maximum prices on oxen, pigs, sheep, geese, and chickens across the kingdom.

The physical reality of supply and demand hit immediately. According to the contemporary Vita Edwardi Secundi and chronicler John of Trokelowe, farmers and merchants simply refused to bring livestock or grain to market at a guaranteed loss. Towns went completely dry, black-market prices surged past the old rates, and even the royal household struggled to buy provisions while traveling through the countryside. By early 1316, the Crown had to quietly repeal the entire ordinance because enforcing the price caps was starving the population faster than the weather.

It is one of the cleanest primary-source examples of medieval logistics colliding head-on with royal legislation.

Are there any other medieval economic decrees that backfired this fast in the chronicles?

 

 


r/EdwardII • • 1d ago

People The Four de Monthermer kids: grandchildren of Edward I, nieces & nephews of Edward II and half-siblings of the de Clares

Post image
11 Upvotes

Joan of Acre, the high-spirited older sister of Edward II, created a scandal when she eloped with her household squire, Ralph de Monthermer. She already had four children by her first husband, the famous de Clares, and she had four more with her dashing second husband.

Because they were not as wealthy as their older siblings, they don't appear in the record as often.

They were:

Mary de Monthermer (October 1297 - c. 1371) - Married the Earl of Fife and had a daughter

Joan de Monthermer (1299 - unknown) - Became a nun at Amesbury, where her Aunt Mary, also a nun, and half-niece Joan Gaveston lived.

Thomas de Monthermer, 2nd Baron Monthermer (4 October 1301 – 24 June 134) Inherited his father's title, and his daughter married into the Montagu family that was prominent during Edward III's reign.

Edward de Monthermer (1304–1340) - Spent his life in the service of his wealthy older sister Elizabeth and was buried beside his mother Joan.

Since their stepmother Isabel ran the households of Eleanor of Woodstock & Joan of the Tower, Edward II & Isabella's daughters, it is likely these children were raised alongside them. Since Isabel was Hugh Despenser the Younger's sister, there's a good chance that John of Eltham, Edward II and Isabella's younger son, as well as the many Despenser-de Clare kids, were in the mix. They all probably knew and socialized with each other.

Source: Kathryn Warner's Blog

Image: the de Monthermer arms, wiki commons


r/EdwardII • • 2d ago

On This Day On November 20th 1322, ten fisherman who had in the presence King Edward II and took a great pike, great eels, and a large number of other fish, got paid ten shillings.

Post image
10 Upvotes

According to Edward's surviving chamber account: "The 20th day of November, paid to 10 fishermen of the said Thorn [near Doncaster] who fished in the king's presence and took great pike, great eels, and a large number of other fish, by the hands of Sir Johan Lesturmy, 20 shillings."

So, I have questions. We don't know exactly when this royal fishing excursion happened and whether it was also on November 20th. It seems Sir Johan Lesturmy was sent to give payment, and thus it could be that the fishing took place earlier.

Also, are we to believe that Edward II just stood there and watched these men fish? Nobody suggested he give the angling a go himself? Because he seems like the kind of guy who would want to help reel in that great pike. And he also seems like the kind of guy who would king-splain to the fisherman about how they might better do their jobs. Earnestly and sincerely so, with the best of intentions.

Maybe the hapless clerk was just writing down what he heard and didn't want to make his king sound weird.

In any case, I hope Edward enjoyed the seafood feast that no doubt happened as a result of this fishing trip.

Source: Kathryn Warner's Blog.

Image: Early xivth century depiction of fishermen in a small boat, using a drift-net (British Library, Royal Mss. 2 B VII, folio 73).


r/EdwardII • • 2d ago

Battles When an idiot becomes Admiral (Battle of Sluys) Edward III related, so slightly later, but still great information about the general period.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/EdwardII • • 3d ago

Discussion The "Sea-Monster"— Hugh Despenser the Younger, Terror of the English Channel

Post image
10 Upvotes

In August 1321, armed barons surrounded London in matching green-and-yellow liveries and forced King Edward II to banish his favorite, Hugh Despenser the Younger, from England forever. Hugh's aging father boarded a ship and retired quietly to Bordeaux to wait out the political storm. Hugh the Younger had other ideas. Instead of slinking off into French exile, he stepped onto the deck of an armed warship in the Strait of Dover, teamed up with the toughest privateers on the English coast, and spent the autumn of 1321 terrorizing the English Channel; earning himself an unforgettable nickname from a contemporary chronicler who called him a "sea-monster."

Hugh was an inland Welsh Marcher lord who didn't know a bowline from a rudder, so he partnered with a man who did: Robert Batail of Winchelsea, a seasoned Baron of the Cinque Ports and one of the sharpest naval commanders in England. Together with a pack of veteran Kent and Sussex shipmasters, Hugh and Batail turned the Narrow Seas between Dover and Calais into a private hunting ground.

Their biggest prize came off the sands of Sandwich. Out of the Channel mist loomed two massive Genoese merchant carracks, towering Mediterranean "dromonds" built like floating castles and packed to the gunwales with luxury Italian cloth, rare Eastern spices, and chests of silver bullion. Hugh's low-slung cogs swarmed the heavy merchantmen, grappled their hulls, and swarmed over the rails with swords and crossbows. After a brutal deck fight that left Genoese sailors dead in the scuppers, Hugh's men stripped the holds clean and hauled a king's ransom in contraband back toward their coastal anchorages.

Emboldened by the Sandwich haul, Hugh and Batail grew even bolder. At the end of September 1321, while technically an outlaw under sentence of death if he set foot on English soil, Hugh sailed his flotilla straight into Southampton Water. Over September 30 and October 1, his crews raided the port of Southampton itself, seizing cargo and shaking down coastal shipping right under the noses of local authorities who had no fleet strong enough to stop him.

Even wilder was what happened after dark. Hugh wasn't just raiding ships; he was running a shadow war room from the sea. While royal heralds officially proclaimed him banished, King Edward II repeatedly rode down to the Kentish coast at Queenborough and the Isle of Thanet, and later near Portchester. Under cover of night, small boats slipped out of the surf onto the shingle beaches, bringing Hugh ashore to meet the King in person, plan the winter military campaign against the barons, and row back out to his fleet before dawn.

When Edward II's army finally crushed the Marcher rebellion in early 1322 and cancelled Hugh's exile, Hugh stepped off his flagship and marched straight back into Westminster as the most powerful man in England. With a few strokes of the royal pen, he handed out blanket pardons to Robert Batail and his Cinque Ports captains, turning a gang of Channel pirates into honored naval officers overnight.

The only people who never forgot the autumn of 1321 were the merchants of Genoa. Furious over the butchered crews and stolen carracks off Sandwich, Genoa slapped trade embargoes on English wool and hounded the English Crown for compensation for fifteen years; creating the exact diplomatic pipeline that later brought papal notary Manuele Fieschi (author of the famous letter claiming Edward II survived Berkeley Castle) directly into the English royal court.

Primary Sources: Vita Edwardi Secundi; Calendar of Patent Rolls (1321–1324); Calendar of Close Rolls (1321–1322); The National Archives SC 8/17/833 (Southampton Raid Petition); Rotuli Parliamentorum (1321 & 1326); Anglo-Genoese Diplomatic & Compensation Rolls (Edward II–Edward III).

 

 


r/EdwardII • • 3d ago

People The Women Who Mothered Edward II

Thumbnail
themedievalbeekeeper.com
17 Upvotes

Oh Edward, you really did like to be mothered!


r/EdwardII • • 3d ago

Tiresome myths The Middle Ages according to historians VS the middle ages according to "Hollywood"

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

This is a good, simple non-AI video lasting only 1:33 mins. which nicely points out what's wrong with the way Hollywood insists on portraying medieval towns. Make it make sense. It's so dumb.


r/EdwardII • • 4d ago

Discussion When Parliament exiled Hugh Despenser the Younger in August 1321, he didn't go to France—he became a state-backed pirate in the English Channel.

Post image
17 Upvotes

 

Most people remember Hugh Despenser the Younger for grabbing Welsh marches or meeting his brutal end at Hereford in November 1326, but his "exile" in the late summer of 1321 is one of the wildest logistical scams of Edward II's reign.

When the barons forced Parliament to banish both Despensers in August 1321, Hugh the Elder actually crossed over to Bordeaux. Hugh the Younger never left English waters. Instead, Edward II quietly placed his favorite under the protection of the Cinque Ports mariners, including Winchelsea admiral Robert Batail, and let him operate out of the Channel with a fleet of armed ships.

Contemporary chroniclers didn't mince words about what happened next. The Vita Edwardi Secundi and Flores Historiarum describe Hugh turning the Strait of Dover into a personal protection racket, calling him a "sea monster" lying in wait for merchantmen until "no ship got through unharmed." Off Sandwich, his fleet intercepted and looted two massive merchant ships carrying luxury cargo, while the King's own Chancery records show Edward secretly meeting and coordinating with his "exiled" favorite along the Kent coast and at Portchester, all before officially recalling him after Boroughbridge in March 1322.

Most royals use exile to lay low and write letters begging for a pardon. Hugh used his to run a maritime syndicate with the King's tacit backing.

For anyone who has dug into the 1321–1322 Chancery rolls: how much of the loot from those Channel raids do you think went straight into funding Edward's spring campaign against the barons?

 


r/EdwardII • • 4d ago

Question Who was really in charge - Edward or Hugh?

Post image
10 Upvotes

Edward II didn't really seem to know what was going on, while Hugh liked to keep himself updated on all things. Your thoughts on this?


r/EdwardII • • 5d ago

Question The Monks cried because he disgraced the Crown by "muddying his hands in the ditches with commoners." His nobles despised him—the commoners loved him.

Post image
33 Upvotes

 

 

Edward II was known for his affirmation of common work. Edward was known to be skilled with shoeing horses, and most famously, muddying his hands in the ditches at Clarendon Palace in Wiltshire alongside, (and I am quite sure) a very shocked and nervous wheelwright Elis “Eliot” Peck and a laborer named Gibbe.

Would you prefer a king who rules from his throne, rarely seen by commoners, or a king who “muddies his hands” in the ditches beside you?


r/EdwardII • • 5d ago

Chronicles Execution of Edmund Fitzalan, Earl of Arundel

Thumbnail
reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/EdwardII • • 6d ago

On This Day 700 Years Ago Today, Karma came calling for Edward II and Hugh the Younger at a place that the Annales Paulini calls "The Vale of Treachery," a name that really should have stuck. The men were captured, and Edward was placed under house arrest while Hugh was taken to his doom.

Post image
20 Upvotes

The men were captured near Llantrisant, in South Wales. One can only guess the shock these two powerful men must have felt seeing their power and status evaporate. They had it coming, and they had plenty of chances to course correct.

I do love the name the "Vale of Treachery" though the name did not, alas, stick.

Pictured: Llantrisant today. Looks like a lovely spot from which to be taken to your doom.

More about their capture here, and the image is public domain.


r/EdwardII • • 6d ago

Discussion Isabella and Roger Mortimer capture Edward II, 16th November 1326. Theirnarmy and invasion was backed by the French

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/EdwardII • • 8d ago

Just for laughs Why would Edward II's personality type be if he took a Meyers-Briggs test?

Post image
2 Upvotes

I've heard the Meyers-Briggs personality test described as corporate astrology, but it also strikes me as something Edward II would take and take seriously. Astrology was taken very seriously in his time, and he was a double Taurus, which tracks.

So, I took the test and used my deep well of E2 knowledge to answer as he might. He came up ENFP-T:

As an ENFP (Campaigner), you are a vibrant force of enthusiasm, creativity, and idealism. Your mind is a constant whirlwind of ideas and possibilities, each more exciting than the last. You approach life with an infectious energy that draws others to you, your charisma and genuine interest in people making you a natural connector and inspirational force.

Your curiosity knows no bounds, and you have an insatiable appetite for new experiences and perspectives. This openness, combined with your vivid imagination, allows you to see potential and opportunity where others might not. You’re not just a dreamer, though – you’re a dreamer with a mission, driven by a deep-seated desire to make the world a better place.

While your enthusiasm and creativity are your superpowers, they can also present challenges. Your mind moves at lightning speed, jumping from one exciting idea to another, which can make it difficult to focus on mundane tasks or stick to routines. You may find yourself starting numerous projects with gusto, only to leave them unfinished when a new, more exciting prospect catches your eye.

At your core, you are driven by your values and your quest for authenticity. You have a strong sense of right and wrong, and you’re not afraid to stand up for what you believe in. This idealism, coupled with your natural empathy, makes you a powerful advocate for causes you care about. However, it can also lead to disappointment when the world doesn’t live up to your high standards.

Edited to add: I'm a INFP-A, so two key letters away.


r/EdwardII • • 9d ago

Question What is the consensus on when and how Edward II of England died?

Thumbnail reddit.com
7 Upvotes

r/EdwardII • • 9d ago

On This Day Happy 714th Birthday to Edward III, who learned from his father and mother's mistakes.

Post image
18 Upvotes

On this day in 1312, Isabella of France gave birth to a healthy son who would go on to be one of England's greatest monarchs. Known at birth as Edward of Windsor after the castle where he was born, he would be crowned king as a young teen while his deposed father was still alive. He was 100% for sure Edward II's son (come on people, let's put that nonsense to rest) and was adored by both his parents. Edward II and Isabella would go on to have four more children, John of Eltham, Eleanor of Woodstock and Joan of the Tower.

Like any kid caught up in his parents'breakup however, he had some issues, but that's another story.

He did clearly, however, study his father's mistakes and went out of his way not to make them, at least not until he became elderly.

Image: Young Edward III sucks it up and pays homage to France. That wouldn't last, though.


r/EdwardII • • 10d ago

Art and Artifacts Medieval Dragons

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/EdwardII • • 10d ago

Life at court Generosity and equal pay at the court of Edward II

Post image
20 Upvotes

A lot of attention is typically focused on the shortcomings of Edward II, but his chamber accounts reveal a far more sympathetic picture of this misunderstood king.

The accounts from late May 1325 until 31 October 1326 contain some captivating stories about daily life in the company of Edward II. Below are two of them.

A heartfelt conversation?

One of the squires of Edward II's chamber was Oliver of Bordeaux. An entry dated 7 February 1326 records an extremely large payment of twenty marks to Oliver 'when the king sat beside his bed a little before midnight'.

The next day Edward issued a proclamation that Isabella was 'adopting the counsel' of Roger Mortimer at the French court. Had he just heard this news on the night of 7 February, and that's why he sat beside Oliver's bed, late at night, perhaps anguished?

I think it's interesting to note that Edward went to Oliver, instead of commanding him to come over. It implies friendship and some level of closeness. Edward needed to talk to him about this unhappy situation he found himself in. Maybe he needed someone to confide in, maybe he wanted Oliver's opinion. Maybe they drank to ease Edward's pain, which led to a philosophical discussion which dragged on for hours, as can happen under the influence. Maybe Edward just didn't want to be alone. Roger had once been a trusted friend, and Isabella his beloved wife. It's easy to see why he would have found it difficult to fall asleep.

Or maybe Edward simply paid Oliver to do his bidding, and the exact nature of the agreed mission remains unknown. That Oliver was paid in cash as opposed to any valuable items, which would feel more appropriate as a gift, seems to imply this possibility. Perhaps the payment was meant to cover his intended expenses.

The two explanations needn’t be mutually exclusive. Whatever happened, Edward was clearly grateful to the compassionate Oliver and trusted him.

Gender equality: equal pay for equal work

In 1325/26, Edward II had between 28 and 33 valets attending him in his chamber at any given time. Two of the valets were women, which contrasts with the norm in royal and noble households of the Middle Ages. Kings and noblemen were expected to employ only men as their valets; it was their wives who would employ ladies-in-waiting and female companions.

The female valets' names were Joan Traghs, who was the wife of another chamber valet Robert Traghs, and Agnes de May, wife of the chamber valet Roger de May. The women were hired in early May 1326 and at the end of 1325 respectively, and received the same wages as the men.

The story of how Joan came to be hired is quite lovely. Joan had given birth to a daughter some time before 11 August 1325, as that's when Edward gave her husband Robert a bonus of 5s upon hearing the happy news. However, the labour appears to have been difficult, and Joan suffered from poor health for a long time afterwards. In September Robert left the royal court to visit his exhausted wife and newborn daughter, equipped with a further 5s as a royal gift. While still recovering, Joan was hired by Edward as a valet on 8 March 1326, even though she was ill and couldn’t work or even join the court.

It wasn’t until 10 May that she finally arrived at court, then located at Gloucester, and remarkably she was paid 16s in lost wages for the previous sixty-four days.

Yes you read that right - Joan was given sick pay in 1326 for more than two months, even before she’d worked a single day in the royal household.

Joan and Agnes, with their husbands Robert and Roger, were among the 24 chamber valets still with the king in South Wales on 31 October 1326, over a month after the queen's invasion and the last day the account was kept. Evidently, they were very fond of Edward and didn't want to leave him even when it was clear that all was lost. Edward said his goodbyes to them and left the safety of Caerphilly Castle, accompanied by only Hugh and a handful of others on a doomed final attempt at evading capture.

What's important to keep in mind when reading such accounts is that this information is as real as it gets. Chroniclers frequently present events according to their own agenda and report rumours and hearsay, while the royal chamber accounts are as factual as it gets, recording payments, roles, and presence, and not at all as boring as one might presume.

Based on Kathryn Warner's blog (shortened, edited and amended).


r/EdwardII • • 11d ago

Historic Places Koblenz, in what is now Germany, is one of the oldest cities in the region and was visited by Edward III in 1338 where he met with a mysterious man named Will the Welshman, who was rumored to be his not dead father.

Post image
20 Upvotes

The city is now a UNESCO Heritage site, and it is still a lovely place to visit. Per Visit Germany:

French joie de vivre and German tradition have produced a truly unique cultural fusion in Koblenz, characterised by cosy wine taverns, narrow alleyways, romantic spots and a genuinely welcoming atmosphere. The Four Towers, as the oriels of four Baroque houses on each corner of the main street crossing are known, are the perfect place to begin a stroll through the Old Town. Other top attractions include the Guard House, which dates back to 1689, and the Schängel fountain, which stands in the courtyard of the Town Hall and is one of the city's main landmarks. A ferry that passes the Electoral Palace will take you to Stolzenfels Castle, one of the most impressive examples of early Prussian art and cultural history.

Obviously, it's changed since 1338 when Edward III may have visited with his not-dead father.


r/EdwardII • • 13d ago

Historic Places Lichfield Cathedral (near Birmingham), UK. The only surviving 3 spire medieval Cathedral in England finished around 1330 (OP)

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/EdwardII • • 13d ago

On This Day Treaty of Aberconwy, 9th November 1277. Edward I forces Llewellyn to give up large amounts of Wales and to pay homage to him. This completed the First stage of the conquest of Wales

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/EdwardII • • 14d ago

Cartoon Marrying age in Edward’s time

Post image
295 Upvotes

I stumbled upon this neat little cartoon and it’s obviously relating to Edward and Isabella, who married for political reasons when she was around 12.

Good to see these notions addressed. Myths, myths everywhere 😛


r/EdwardII • • 16d ago

Art and Artifacts me raiding the doughnut stash at 3am

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/EdwardII • • 16d ago

Article Thatching in the Later Middle Ages (Yes, this long post about the history of thatching in the later Middle Ages mentions our boy, Edward II.)

Thumbnail thatchinginfo.com
4 Upvotes

r/EdwardII • • 17d ago

Speculation / What if... History says Isabella of France and Edward II never met post-invasion. But one Flemish source claims they did in November 1326, wherein she begged for forgiveness and he angrily turned away. Could this be possible?

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

No English source claims Isabella and Edward met after her departure for France in March of 1325. Most historians agree they never saw each other again. However, one Flemish source describes a meeting occurring shortly after the execution of Hugh Despenser the Younger.

Kathryn Warner has a lengthy blog post on this subject, describing the known movements of Edward II after his capture. She writes about the Flemish account:

Last year, I read a chronicle from Flanders*, written in French, which gives an intriguingly different take on events in England in 1326 after the queen's invasion. The chronicle states that Isabella went to see Edward in his chamber after his capture, and fell to her knees in front of him. She begged him to "cool his anger" with her, but, obviously in an unforgiving and furious mood, Edward refused to talk or even to look at her. The chronology in the chronicle is not clear, and it is not stated where or when this alleged meeting took place. Presumably, it was before Hugh Despenser the Younger's execution on 24 November 1326; Isabella was hardly likely - in my opinion - to ask her husband to "cool his anger" with her after she had had his beloved chamberlain, companion and perhaps lover torn apart in public. The chronicle gives an otherwise correct and quite full account of what happened in England in the autumn of 1326.

We know chroniclers frequently embellished events and made up quotes. It's entirely possible that the chronicler simply added this bit of drama because it seemed like something that should have happened. But Warner goes on to write that the story can't be ruled out completely.

It's a pretty logical assumption that Edward would be angry with his wife, and there's evidence that she did want his forgiveness and even considered a reconciliation. She sent him gifts and luxuries while he was in captivity and offered to visit him but was refused permission by the counsel. Another time however, she refused to visit him, citing a knife he was known to carry in his hose.

Assuming the Fieschi Letter is genuine, and not everyone assumes that, it backs up the idea that Edward was not the least bit forgiving of Isabella, even years later. If The Lament of Edward II is genuine, and not everyone agrees that it is, it also backs up the idea that Edward was furious and unforgiving.

Ultimately Warner and most other historians land on the Flemish chronicle being incorrect, but it's still interesting to ponder whether or not it happened and why the English chronicles would suppress it if it did.

Additional information:

Warner, Kathryn. Edward II: The Unconventional King. Amberley, 2017. 

Images: public domain