r/Fantasy • • 21d ago

Book Club r/Fantasy November Megathread and Book Club hub. Get your links here!

25 Upvotes

This is the Monthly Megathread for October 2026. It's where the mod team links important things. It will always be stickied at the top of the subreddit. Please regularly check here for things like official movie and TV discussions, book club news, important subreddit announcements, etc.

Last month's book club hub can be found here.

Important Links

New Here? Have a look at:

You might also be interested in our yearly BOOK BINGO reading challenge.

Special Threads & Megathreads:

Recurring Threads:

Book Club Hub - Book Clubs and Read-alongs

Goodreads Book of the Month: A Wall is Also a Road by Annalee Newitz

Run by u/PlantLady32, u/RAAAImmaSunGod

  • Announcement
  • Midway Discussion - November 16th
  • Final Discussion - November 30th

Feminism in Fantasy: Spear by Nicola Griffith

Run by u/Moonlitgrey,  u/xenizondich23, u/Nineteen_Adze, u/evil_moooojojojo, u/Merle8888,  u/doctorbonkers,  u/Lenahe_nl, u/sarahlynngrey, u/ohmage_resistance

  • Announcement
  • Midway Discussion - November 11th
  • Final Discussion - November 25th

New Voices: The Heresy of Thieves by Mia V. Moss

Run by u/HeLiBeB, u/cubansombrero, u/ullsi u/undeadgoblin

  • Announcement
  • Midway Discussion - November 9th
  • Final Discussion - November 23rd

HEA: Hammajang Luck by Makana Yamamoto

Run by u/tiniestspoon, u/xenizondich23 , u/orangewombat, u/OutOfEffs

  • Announcement
  • Midway Discussion - November 12th
  • Final Discussion - November 25th

Beyond Binaries: Returns in December with A Slice of Mars by Guerric Hache

Run by u/xenizondich23, u/ohmage_resistance, u/recchai, u/C0smicOcurrence, u/Lenahe_nl, and u/sarahlynngrey 

Short Fiction Book Club: 

Run by u/tarvolon, u/Nineteen_Adze, u/Jos_V

Readalong of Earthsea:


r/Fantasy • • Sep 30 '26 Bravo

Announcement Upcoming Changes to r/Fantasy's Recurring Threads

185 Upvotes

Currently on r/fantasy, we have a selection of recurring threads - Monthly Book Discussion, Daily Recommendations and Simple Questions, Tuesday Review, Friday Social, the Sunday Self-Promo, Monday Show and Tell and Writing Wednesday.

The majority of these see a lot of use, however the last two -- the Monday Show and Tell and Writing Wednesday threads -- see little to no use on a weekly basis. We have also received a lot of feedback from you to this effect from our recent State of the Subreddit post, and from general comments on the subreddit. Therefore, we have come to the decision to discontinue these threads going forward.

However, this post is not all about things we will be removing: we will be debuting a new weekly discussion thread on the subreddit tomorrow! The Tuesday Review thread is currently a place to share reviews for all modes of speculative fiction, however it is largely dominated by discussion of books. To encourage discussion of not-a-book media, the new Thursday Not-A-Book thread will be an equivalent to the Tuesday review thread but focused on all types of speculative media that are not books - this could be films, TV, comics, audio dramas, games, or the like. This thread is not intended to stymie discussion elsewhere of non-book content - standalone posts on this topic are still welcome and encouraged.

This new recurring thread will debut tomorrow - we hope to see you there talking about all the things you have enjoyed recently outside of the realm of books!


r/Fantasy • • 2h ago

A work of fantasy doesn't need to be deep/meaningful or have flowery prose to be great. It just needs to be fun.

54 Upvotes

I feel like this is an unpopular opinion for this sub because I often see posts where people review popular works of fantasy and mention that they're basically the fast food equivalent of reading because there are no deep themes or beautiful prose. I'm personally not a fan of that idea. Something can be truly amazing and life changing even if it isn't very deep or beautifully written. The message can be nothing more than "evil is bad" or "love is more powerful than hate," and that's totally fine. As long as a work of fantasy transports you, the reader, to an amazing world you'd love to explore, and with fun characters that you love, that's all that matters. Something can be so full of mystery, suspense, and adventure without trying to change the world with its message. Right now my favorite series is Land of Stories by Chris Colfer, which is just about two kids traveling around a world where fairy tale characters are real. There's really no deeper meaning beyond just good triumphing over evil, but I would die for those characters and that world is so much fun to visit. I feel like people need to loosen up in here.


r/Fantasy • • 2h ago

Books with a good/ kind MC changing a Grimdark world

6 Upvotes

Just seems like an interesting idea wondering if there are any books like that out there.

i don’t think they need to change the whole world or anything but just being a strange beacon of light in a very dark world.

Im not looking for a story where that beacon get snuffed out either. Unless its like at the very end and thats used to change the world or some shit… but that would be spoilers so don’t mention that


r/Fantasy • • 10h ago

Review Spoiler free review for Tuyo trilogy by Rachel Neumeier

19 Upvotes

As I've had the series recommend here, I figured I'll write a review. This is a spoiler free review for the main Tuyo trilogy (Tuyo, Tarashana, and Tasmakat), I haven't read any other book in the world.

In short, I find it a beautifully optimistic series about the interaction of different cultures with their many differences, without one swallowing the other lead by a wonderful, flawed, emotionally intelligent main character.

The trilogy showcases our main characters, Ryo and Ares, both from drastically different people, solving many politically charged issues. The books are really about their relationship and the relationship between these two people.

I've loved many things within the books. First and foremost, I loved how the author presents drastically different and ruthless cultures not having to war or merge in order to survive with one another. This is quite a breath of fresh air in today's grimdark climate. Additionally, the main character Ryo is an absolute treat.

Ryo is a good-hearted man from the tribal culture. While his upbringing within the culture did leave him some scars such as tempere, he shows an incredible emotional intelligence. I find him the perfect "show and don't tell" your audience a character is intelligent.

Another thing I love is the "unreliable narrator" type of pov. We're getting a POV from the thoughts of Ryu, but in a world where sorcerers that continously read everyone's mind walk freely, Ryo has perfected hiding his thoughts and ponders from prying minds (and us). For example, the narrative would sometimes change abruptly to the scenery when it strays into thoughts Ryo doesn't want known. This gives the audience some mysteries regarding Ryo even though we're literally in his own brain.

The two things I disliked would be the prose and romance. Obviously, it's a metter of taste, but I felt the prose was a little too digestible and direct. This makes sense from Ryo's mind, but it still bothered me a little. The romance I wouldn't explain as it's spoilery, but it's not about the idea of the specifics, just the execution.

I hope more people will give this series a shot, and thanks for the recommendation!

Edit: I'm not sure why reddit decided to put a "Deals" flair and not review, and I can't edit it on mobile.


r/Fantasy • • 11h ago

Bingo review Bingo 2026 Mini Reviews - 60% done!

18 Upvotes

I've ticked off another five books for this year's Bingo, meaning I only have ten more squares to go! For whatever reason I've found this year's board trickier to fill than the 2025 board, but I think a lot of that is down to me reaching for a fair amount of historical fiction this year in amongst my usual diet of fantasy, horror and sci-fi.

Published in 2026 - The Unhaunting by Micaiah Johnson - 3.5 Stars - I adore Johnson's sci-fi so was very excited to dive into her horror debut. I still love her writing and elements of this story were incredibly chilling, but it never went as creepy or as cruel as I wanted it to.

Middle Grade - Amari and the Night Brothers by B.B. Alston - 2.5 Stars - I love dipping into MG from time to time so was very excited to see it on this year's board, and this MG novel in particular has been on my radar since it was released. While completely appreciating that I am not the target audience for this novel, I found it a bit of a mess with a great idea at its core. There were a few too many quirky things added in to make it appear whacky and/or whimsical that ultimately didn't add anything substantial to the world-building. (HM)

First Contact - The Lesson by Cadwell Turnbull - 4 Stars - I love Earth-set sci-fi where the science fictional elements are just a sprinkle on top, so I was enthralled by this novel following various people of the U.S. Virgin Islands living in the wake of an alien invasion. While an advanced race in terms of their medicine and technology, the Ynaa respond to the slightest thing they perceive as a threat with disproportional violence, making the entire novel a brilliant examination of conquest and colonialism.

Published in the 70s - Kindred by Octavia E. Butler - 3.5 Stars - I'm ashamed to say I hadn't read anything by Butler before this, but she's definitely an author I'll be returning to. It's difficult to say I enjoyed this novel, but I certainly respect it and Butler's skill at writing grey morality in all its forms. Alice was the heart of the story for me and I'll be sad about her forever. (HM)

Author of Colour - The Midnight Timetable by Bora Chung; translated by Anton Hur - 5 Stars - I previously read and enjoyed Cursed Bunny, but was still so pleasantly surprised by how much I loved this collection of interconnected stories focused on the cursed objects in a research facility known as The Institute. If you're a fan of The Magnus Archives, this is a book for you. (HM)


r/Fantasy • • 1h ago

Vote for our December Goodreads Book of the Month - Holidays

2 Upvotes

Hello! It's time to vote for the December 2026 Book of the Month. The poll is open until December 26, 2026 11:59PM PST. If you are not a member of our r/Fantasy Goodreads Group, you will need to join. You can connect with more r/Fantasy members and check out what they are reading!

This month's theme is Holidays, so let's get ready to celebrate!

Our choices are:

Saturnalia by Stephanie Feldman

The Saturnalia carnival marks three years since Nina walked away from Philadelphia’s elite Saturn Club—with its genteel debauchery, arcane pecking order, and winking interest in alchemy and the occult. In doing so, she abandoned her closest friends and her chance to climb the social ladder. Since then, she’s eked out a living by telling fortunes with her Saturn Club tarot deck, a solemn initiation gift that Nina always considered a gag but has turned out to be more useful than she could have ever imagined.

For most, the Saturnalia carnival marks a brief winter reprieve for the beleaguered people of the historic city, which is being eroded by extreme weather, a collapsing economy, and feverish summers—whose disease carrying mosquitos are perhaps the only thing one can count on. Like Thanksgiving or Halloween, Saturnalia has become a purely American holiday despite its pagan roots; and nearly everyone, rich or poor, forgets their troubles for a moment.

For Nina, Saturnalia is simply a cruel reminder of the night that changed everything for her. But when she gets a chance call from Max, one of the Saturn Club’s best-connected members and her last remaining friend, the favor he asks will plunge her back into the Club’s wild solstice masquerade, on a mysterious errand she cannot say no to.

Tonight, Nina will put on a dress of blackest black, and attend the biggest party of the year. Before it’s over, she will discover secret societies battling for power in an increasingly precarious world and become custodian of a horrifying secret—and the target of a mysterious hunter. As Nina runs across an alternate Philadelphia balanced on a knife’s edge between celebration and catastrophe, through parades, worship houses, museums, hidden mansions, and the place she once called home, she’s forced to confront her past in order to take charge of her own—and perhaps everyone’s—future.

Krampus: The Yule Lord by Brom

Santa Claus, my dear old friend, you are a thief, a traitor, a slanderer, a murderer, a liar, but worst of all you are a mockery of everything for which I stood. You have sung your last ho, ho, ho, for I am coming for your head. . . . I am coming to take back what is mine, to take back Yuletide . . .
—from Krampus

The author and artist of The Child Thief returns with a modern fabulist tale of Krampus, the Lord of Yule and the dark enemy of Santa Claus

One Christmas Eve in a small hollow in Boone County, West Virginia, struggling songwriter Jesse Walker witnesses a strange spectacle: seven devilish figures chasing a man in a red suit toward a sleigh and eight reindeer. When the reindeer leap skyward, taking the sleigh, devil men, and Santa into the clouds, screams follow. Moments later, a large sack plummets back to earth, a magical sack that thrusts the down-on-his-luck singer into the clutches of the terrifying Yule Lord, Krampus. But the lines between good and evil become blurred as Jesse's new master reveals many dark secrets about the cherry-cheeked Santa Claus, including how half a millennium ago the jolly old saint imprisoned Krampus and usurped his magic.

Santa's time is running short, for the Yule Lord is determined to have his retribution and reclaim Yuletide. If Jesse can survive this ancient feud, he might have the chance to redeem himself in his family's eyes, to save his own broken dreams, . . . and to help bring the magic of Yule to the impoverished folk of Boone County.

Arrows of the Queen by Mercedes Lackey

Chosen by the Companion Rolan, a mystical horse-like being with powers beyond imagining, Talia, once a runaway, has now become a trainee Herald, destined to become one of the Queen's own elite guard. For Talia has certain awakening talents of the mind that only a Companion like Rolan can truly sense.

But as Talia struggles to master her unique abilities, time is running out. For conspiracy is brewing in Valdemar, a deadly treason that could destroy Queen and kingdom. Opposed by unknown enemies capable of both diabolical magic and treacherous assassination, the Queen must turn to Talia and the Heralds for aid in protecting the realm and ensuring the future of the Queen's heir, a child already in danger of becoming bespelled by the Queen's own foes.

Harbour of Hungry Ghosts by Eliza Chan

"My name is not Kim, it's Kiamling. It means Sword Spirit. I was forged to cut down the undead. Demons and monsters aren't just in your storybooks, they walk among us."

The Au family serve the people of Hong Kong: blessing shrines, honouring the dead and dealing with dangerous monster incursions. The expectations on eldest daughter Kiamling are high, which is not something her strict grandmother will let her forget.

When the British disrupt the Hungry Ghosts festival and her grandmother is seized by a strange new monster, Kiamling must step up and lead the search. She is aided by unexpected allies: Archie, an earnest civil servant, Hoi gor, childhood sweetheart turned merchant-pirate and Jingling, her younger sister keeping secrets of her own. Kiamling must figure out who is behind the incursion and more importantly, how to defeat them.

With British fables mingling with local Chinese monsters, can Kiamling prove herself, when the old rules no longer seem to apply?

Babel meets Buffy the Vampire Slayer - a family of demon hunters find their hands full when unfamiliar monsters start stalking the streets of Opium War-era Hong Kong, in this fantasy adventure from No. 1 Sunday Times bestseller Eliza Chan.

The Christmas Mystery by Jostein Gaarder

One day Elisabet, while Christmas shopping with her mother, vanishes into thin air. Accompanied by angels, shepherds, kings and even a Roman governor, she is rushing back through time and space to Bethlehem, to be present at the birth of Christ. Fifty years later a boy called Joachim pieces together her story from a magic advent calendar and brings it to a conclusion.

After the poll is complete, I will lead the discussion for the chosen book next month. Head on over to Goodreads to vote in the poll.


r/Fantasy • • 17h ago

Fantasy book with the rogue-mage-fighter party

20 Upvotes

I’m looking for books with an rpg feel to them, where there’s a rogue-fighter-mage sorta party composition. I’d prefer more recent fantasy, for some reason I can’t get into older sword and sorcery style books, but I welcome the recs regardless. Bonus if they get along with each others/are friends.


r/Fantasy • • 22h ago

r/Fantasy r/Fantasy Daily Recommendations and Simple Questions Thread - November 21, 2026

47 Upvotes

Welcome to the daily recommendation requests and simple questions thread, now 1025.83% more adorable than ever before!

Stickied/highlight slots are limited, so please remember to like and subscribe upvote this thread for visibility on the subreddit <3

——

This thread is to be used for recommendation requests or simple questions that are small/general enough that they won’t spark a full thread of discussion.

Check out r/Fantasy's 2026 Book Bingo Card here!

As usual, first have a look at the sidebar in case what you're after is there. The r/Fantasy wiki contains links to many community resources, including "best of" lists, flowcharts, the LGTBQ+ database, and more. If you need some help figuring out what you want, think about including some of the information below:

  • Books you’ve liked or disliked
  • Traits like prose, characters, or settings you most enjoy
  • Series vs. standalone preference
  • Tone preference (lighthearted, grimdark, etc)
  • Complexity/depth level

Be sure to check out responses to other users' requests in the thread, as you may find plenty of ideas there as well. Happy reading, and may your TBR grow ever higher!

——

tiny image link to make the preview show up correctly

art credit: special thanks to our artist, Himmis commissions, who we commissioned to create this gorgeous piece of art for us with practically no direction other than "cozy, magical, bookish, and maybe a gryphon???" We absolutely love it, and we hope you do too.


r/Fantasy • • 1d ago

Review Book review: The Animals We Became by Finn Longman

32 Upvotes

The Animals We Became by Finn Longman
Genres: Adult, Fantasy, Historical Fantasy
Representation: Asexual MC, autistic nonbinary MC, secondary trans character
PoV: First-person, past-tense; first-person, present-tense
Published on: 26th November 2026 (UK); 27th July 2027 (US)
Goodreads
★★★★★

You exist because of a crime, because of a curse, and because of a trick.

Blodeuedd never asked to be made.

Created from flowers of oak, broom, and meadowsweet to marry a man cursed never to have a human wife, Blodeuedd has no knowledge of the world, no family outside the marriage, and no power to choose. But a caged animal still has claws, and Blodeuedd will find a way to be free, whatever the cost.

Gwydion knows what it is to be unmade.

Haunted by the years he served in animal form as punishment for his brother's crimes, Gwydion has turned his tricks to his nephew's happiness - and the creation of Blodeuedd is the greatest trick of them all. But his creation asks questions he cannot answer and drags from the depths of the forest the past he has been trying so hard to forget. Now they both must face their unmaking.

From the author of The Wolf and His King comes a spellbinding new medieval fantasy standalone retelling the story of Blodeuedd from Welsh mythology in a profound exploration of cyclical trauma and transformation. As angry as it is hopeful, this visionary novel is unmissable for readers of Katherine Arden, Naomi Novik, and Samantha Shannon.

Highlights

~queering up the Welsh myths
~(newbie-to-Welsh-myths friendly!)
~constant galaxy-brain moments
~rich, gorgeous prose
~kinder than canon

The Animals We Became is very different from Longman’s debut, The Wolf and His King – but I think I might love it even more than I did Wolf.

This is a retelling of part of the Mabinogion, a foundational text of Welsh mythology. You absolutely don’t need to know the original myths to enjoy this book, Animals We Became doesn’t go in expecting/requiring the reader to have any prior knowledge at all! But speaking as someone who does know the myths – I cannot express how much I adore and appreciate this retelling. The changes Longman’s made, the aspects they’ve chosen to explore and dig into, the obvious respect and love they have for the source material and its culture… It all made me so incredibly happy!

(Especially as an asexual, nonbinary, autistic half-Welsh person. My gods, the representation!!!)

Gwydion is a magician, the nephew of King Math. He and his brother are the court’s darlings, often acting as their uncle’s representatives beyond the court. Their life is pretty golden! Right up until Gilfaethwy – the brother – decides he simply must have Goewin, a woman who is very much off-limits, and Gwydion arranges an opening. Goewin calls it rape, and the brothers are punished by being turned into animals for three years. Specifically, they’re turned into a male and female pair of animals – first deer, then boars, then wolves – each for a year, each time swapping which of them is male and which female. They have three children – a fawn, a piglet, and a wolf cub. Who become human when Gwydion and Gilfaethwy do, when their punishment is over.

(I feel the need to emphasise that this isn’t something Longman came up with. This is direct from Welsh mythology.)

All of this is summarised for us in the second chapter, along with how exactly Gwydion came to be raising his nephew Lleu, and why it is that Lleu can’t marry a human woman, or one transformed from an animal either. Basically, it’s all the immediate backstory we need to understand why Gwydion and Math would work together to make a woman out of flowers – whom they name Blodeuedd – for Lleu to marry. So again: you don’t need any familiarity with the myths at all; Longman makes sure we have all the information we need to understand what’s happening and how we got here.

This is a slow, beautiful book. It’s not plotless, but the plot doesn’t move quickly; it coalesces slowly, bit by bit, in time with our gradual understanding of how deeply screwed-up Blodeuedd’s situation is, and how deeply screwed-up Gwydion is as a person who is pretending, very hard, that he definitely doesn’t have trauma, nope, none at all, why would you think that?

(He has so much trauma.)

At first glance, The Animals We Became looks like a more straightforward, more accessible book than The Wolf and His King was – there is no second-person narration here (well, technically Gwydion’s parts are second-person, but they’re functionally first-person so don’t worry about it) and no PoVs in free verse. However, the second you take a closer peek at The Animals We Became, it is IMMEDIATELY obvious that this book, too, is the product of an incredible amount of writing craft, that the love of words and language that was so on display in Wolf and His King abounds here as well, that the same amount of surgical-, jeweller-precision has gone into the choice and placement of every single word in this book. The English AND the Welsh.

Here the trees grew like fierce spears, straight and sharp and unknowably tall, or else like stories, twisting and ancient.

If you love stories with unreliable narrators, then you are going to adore this book, because you can’t trust a single gods damn word Gwydion says. I highlighted so many of the things he said, trying to work out which were true, how many could be depended on, which ones contradicted others. And to be fair, one of the very first things he tells the reader is that he’s twisty of tongue, all but warning us not to believe a word, or at least not without verifying it elsewhere first! His narration really is a work of art, how slowly but perfectly pieces of the truth start to dawn on us, how certain lines or images echo throughout his chapters (when I came to the line the title is taken from I ACTUALLY SHRIEKED), how careful he/Longman is to make sure we (against all common sense) like him before we learn the whole story. This is so crucial, and so powerful, and I spent ages lying on my back starting at the ceiling while I went through all the ways this book would have been radically different if we’d known everything right away. Which has so many ramifications not just on the story, but also on our ideas of truth and justice and the way we apply or understand those things with strangers versus people we like, and hi, Longman, YOU ACTUALLY DIDN’T NEED TO COME FOR ME LIKE THIS.

the crashing waves stole my words and milled my uneasy thoughts like rocks into sand.

And Blodeuedd. Oh my gods, Blodeuedd. I have read so many versions of her story, okay? The classic one, and countless retellings, short stories and novels and even poems. But I have never read any take on her character and story that made me ache and sob and keen like The Animals We Became has made me. I’ve never read one that made me feel so seen, that went for my throat, that fucking flensed me like this did. And even if it didn’t reach right into my chest and spill my heart all over the pages – even if this interpretation was not immediately personal to me, it’s so CLEVER. It’s GENIUS. Reading Blodeuedd’s chapters is like a galaxy-brain moment in slow-motion as you put it together, because OH MY GODS, OF COURSE.

Of course Blodeuedd is deeply, is completely trans. Of course she is. Of course that makes sense. It’s so OBVIOUS now someone else has said it! How COULD her body possibly fit, when it’s not really hers, when it was meant to be FLOWERS? When it was literally crafted for someone else’s benefit? How could she make any sense of womanhood, of femininity, when she doesn’t have a lifetime of growing into it but is just DROPPED into it, as a supposed adult, the second she comes to life?

It’s genius. It is hands down the smartest and most powerful interpretation of Blodeuedd I have ever come across, and I’ll be stunned if any future one manages to outshine it.

I am not certain how similar we are, really, or whether I would be any happier if Gwydion had made for me a man’s body, for that would have been no more a choice than this. What I crave is something messier, something I do not have words for. I desire ugliness and imperfection and difference, for my body has always been perfect, and has never been mine.

I am swooning and crying and hugging the book to my chest so hard it hurts.

I would love The Animals We Became for this alone, for making Blodeuedd nonbinary, and specifically nonbinary in the way that it does. But Longman’s Blodeuedd is also autistic! The word is never used (how could it be, in this setting?) but it’s very obvious to anyone familiar with autistic people; the way she struggles with tone and facial expressions, how she reaches for specific textures when she’s stressed, how she’s soothed by repetitive work like spinning thread. Etc. I loved this so much, and again, it felt so correct, made so much sense to me. She was made of FLOWERS; how could she be neurotypical???

But there are so many other reasons to adore this book. There’s Gwydion’s queerness – he’s definitely asexual and almost certainly aromantic. There’s the WEALTH of different meanings, or interpretations, of the title, which is the kind of thing that always delights me. There’s the incisive examination of what beauty and womanhood mean in a patriarchy, and (not unrelated) what freedom can be for someone people think of as a woman. There’s the way that absolutely EVERY character in this book is wonderfully multi-faceted; no one is a simple villain, or a simple hero, either. Longman casts everything in shades of grey, lets their story and characters be genuinely complicated in all sorts of different ways – if you’re tired of books that spoon-feed you every point the author wants to make, of stories more interested in virtue-signalling than storytelling, then you’ll find The Animals We Became every bit as refreshing as I did!

It is not all that you are, says the god. It is all that they made you.

This feels like the first mythological retelling I’ve read in quite some time that really explores its source material, that interrogates and considers and dissects it – and doing all of that with so much respect and love for the ‘canon’. It has been some time since I visited Wales, and Longman made me so homesick for it, despite being careful not to anchor the story with too much geographic or historic reality (the Note on the Setting at the beginning of the book is just wonderful) – because despite that, and despite various fantastical details that are all Longman’s creation, this story feels like Wales, feels Welsh, in some vital way I can’t articulate, but that I mean as an immense compliment.

Part of that is the gorgeous nature imagery, which saturates every aspect of the story. If you’ve read The Wolf and His King, then you already know that Longman’s prose is gorgeous, but so much more of the writing here embraces the natural world in a way that Wolf didn’t (probably because poor Bisclavret was doing his best to choose humanity over nature, not that those things have to be opposing, but for him they are). A large part of this reflects the connection the people in this setting have with the land. Gwydion’s magic literally comes from his ties to his home earth, but Longman has also created a pantheon of deities, one for each locale, and almost everyone worships the god of their home. This is an enormous part of most people’s identity, and extremely plot-relevant. So it only makes sense that Blodeuedd and Gwydion often think in terms of trees, animals, running water. Their synonyms and metaphors are full of it.

you’d walked in the sun, and it had scattered freckles like seeds across your cheeks.

And of course – Blodeuedd was made from flowers. Gwydion spent three years as different animals. They both have a very clear connection to the not-human nature.

Is that what you are?” I asked. “My enemy?”

You said, “I am your creation,” which didn’t, when I thought about it later, answer my question.

Which is another thing I’ve never seen a retelling of this story do before – make clear, and explore, the similarities in Gwydion and Blodeuedd’s situations. It’s another thing that strikes me as genius, that is so obvious now someone has pointed it out to me. The two characters are very different, and so are their situations – but those situations are also powerfully similar in some ways. Gwydion’s trauma, and his feelings about his trauma, affect…absolutely everything about Blodeuedd’s creation, everything in how she’s ‘raised’ (a process that lasts only a week!) That Gwydion doesn’t recognise this…is part of his being an unreliable narrator: it’s not only us, the reader, who can’t rely on him. He’s lying to himself, too. Desperately.

I had given you to Lleu, bound you to him, treated you as an object to be traded. As a bouquet of flowers: beautiful, and a sign of my love for him, but nothing that could grow.

There’s so much going on in this book – so many, not conversations, exactly – because I never felt like Longman had one conclusion that they were trying to lead me towards – but explorations. Of womanhood, and womanhood within a patriarchal culture. Of outcasts, especially willing outcasts, people who don’t want to be a part of the ‘normal’ world. Of trauma. Of community. Of kyriarchy. Of justice and punishment, and where justice stops being justice and becomes only punishment. Of autonomy, in many different senses of the word. I don’t think I have the language to talk about the awfulness of Blodeuedd’s sex life with her husband Lleu, but I think it’s important, especially because Lleu is never aware that he’s hurting her, has no intent to do so but does do so. There’s something there about how irrelevant intent is to damage done – about how terrible it is, that we can be good people but still do harm.

I am not less imprisoned because the gaoler speaks softly to me.

And yet – for those who know the original myth, and are worried – The Animals We Became is not a tragedy. The traditional, canonical ‘ending’ of Blodeuedd’s story is powerfully reframed, into a joy, a triumph. Everyone else’s endings also manage to be hopeful, despite the canon Longman was working with! That’s probably one of the things I’m most grateful for in this retelling; that the ending is gentler, kinder, than the one I’m used to.

Like The Wolf and His King, this is a book that rewards taking your time and thinking about what you read. There are so many layers to what Longman is doing at any one point, and I doubt any of us can spot and understand all of them at once every time. But it was so much fun to try! And I don’t think there’s any reason you couldn’t read this without going over every line with a magnifying glass – any reason you couldn’t read this ‘just’ as a beautiful story of a woman made from flowers who wants her freedom. As a story about magicians and princes and gods, a languid kind of adventure-intrigue story. One that takes the rough gem of the canon and cuts it, polishes it, until it absolutely shines.

This is easily one of the best books of the year – of any year. If you had any doubt at all that Longman was a master bard, well – you won’t after this!

Applicable bingo squares: Trans Protagonist (HM); Small Press (HM); Published in 2026; arguably Explorers and Rangers; arguably Non-Human Protagonist

You can find more of my reviews, rec lists, and weekly publishing roundups at Every Book a Doorway!


r/Fantasy • • 17h ago

I just finished reading the Artefacts of Power books by Maggie Furey

6 Upvotes

I came to reading this series because I'm on a "quest" to read all the translated fantasy books in the public library (not romantazy - I like much grander fantasy like Magician, Wheel of Time, and such), and through that I got to read a lot of older fantasy books (70s-90s), and I'd say I'm near the end of what it has to offer me.

Anyway, this series ending is horrible - it feels as if there's a book missing about how she deals with the elves and Sarah, and brings balance to the world. Also, there was much more death than what I expected beforehand.

Just some thoughts I wish to share with others.


r/Fantasy • • 12h ago

"When It Falls (The Valens Legacy #5)" by Jan Stryvant

1 Upvotes

Book number five of an eighteen book paranormal urban fantasy series. I read the well printed and well bound POD (print on demand) trade paperback self published by the author in 2017 that I bought from Amazon in 2026. I have bought books #6, #7, and #8 in the series and will read them soon. BTW, the author's real name is John Van Stry.

Sean was a college student at University of Nevada in Reno, Nevada. He was a junior working on his computer science degree when he was brutally attacked and kidnapped by an unknown group of people just before his 21st birthday. He was rescued by his mother's neighbor and lifelong friend, Sampson, who turns out to be a were-lion. Sampson had promised Sean's long dead father to watch over his family, Sampson did so and died for his efforts. But, before dying, Sampson bites Sean and changes him into a were-lion to cure Sean of his injuries.

Sean finds out that his father was an alchemist and was working on a alchemy to free the Lycan slaves from the Magic Users. Which is why the Magic Users had Sean's father murdered. And now the Magic Users are trying to murder Sean and his friends since they think that Sean will continue his father's work. And, Sean has found his father's magic notes and is making a lot of progress. And Sean and his new friends are now attacking the Magic Users covens and freeing their Lycan slaves.

"WARNING: “When It Falls” contains explicit sexuality, nudity, violence, bad language, attempted murder, actual murder, military style raids, mass combat, self-defense, pro-active self-defense, destruction of private property, vandalism, breaking and entering, robbery, assault & battery, tantric magic, polyamory, mayhem, people who aim to misbehave, gratuitous sex and violence, an opportunistic goblin, and an old man who gets broken out of an old folks home in order to cheat at roulette."

This series is real pulp like old science fiction with lots of action and dialogue. I love it ! Just like the Robert Heinlein books that I love.

Warning: this series might be damaging to your savings account since there are so many books.

The author has a website:
http://www.vanstry.net/stryvant/

My rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars
Amazon rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars (2,521 reviews)
https://www.amazon.com/dp/1983848069

Lynn


r/Fantasy • • 1d ago

Book Club FIF Bookclub: Our January read is The Wall by Marlen Haushofer

38 Upvotes

The votes are in! Our FIF bookclub read for the January theme of Women in Translation is: The Wall by Marlen Haushofer, translated from German by Shaun Whiteside

The Wall by Marlen Haushofer, translated from German by Shaun Whiteside

First published to acclaim in Germany, The Wall chronicles the life of the last surviving human on earth, an ordinary middle-aged woman who awakens one morning to find that everyone else has vanished. Assuming her isolation to be the result of a military experiment gone awry, she begins the terrifying work of survival and self-renewal. This novel is at once a simple and moving tale and a disturbing meditation on humanity.

The midway discussion will be Wednesday, January 13. If anyone has read the book before and has a good pausing point by chapter or page number, let us know (but generally it will be around the midway point of the book)! The final discussion will be Wednesday, January 27.

As a reminder, this month, we're reading Spear by Nicola Griffith. Join us for the discussion on November 25.

For anyone curious, here's the results of the poll:


r/Fantasy • • 1d ago

Review Finished burning blade silver eye trilogy today, have some thoughts

8 Upvotes

Although i quite liked this trilogy, i feel like gyre takes it way too easy on his sister in the final book.

She massively betrays him in the second book. She uses her familiar bonds to have him do the literal opposite of what he is working for, and it quite literally dooms the world.

So i feel like its absurd for him to immediately accept everything maya has done, just because she "believed she was doing the right thing"

Like sure, i dont need him to kick her down when she realises she was wrong. But it does feel weird hes immediatly completely okay with what happened


r/Fantasy • • 1d ago

Authors Who's Characters 'Jump off the Page' ?

35 Upvotes

This isn't necessarily another recommendation thread, we have enough threads like these.

I'm curious to see what other fantasy readers' opinions are on authors who can really make their characters come alive. I've read a few books recently where the characters seemed so dull with no characterisation.

A few of the greats at this in my opinion are GRRM, Tolkien, Abercrombie. Others I think are great are Tad Williams, Scott Lynch, and Robin Hobb. Maybe that's too cliche but I'm looking for other opinions here, and what makes a character come alive for you?


r/Fantasy • • 1d ago

r/Fantasy r/Fantasy Daily Recommendations and Simple Questions Thread - November 20, 2026

50 Upvotes

Welcome to the daily recommendation requests and simple questions thread, now 1025.83% more adorable than ever before!

Stickied/highlight slots are limited, so please remember to like and subscribe upvote this thread for visibility on the subreddit <3

——

This thread is to be used for recommendation requests or simple questions that are small/general enough that they won’t spark a full thread of discussion.

Check out r/Fantasy's 2026 Book Bingo Card here!

As usual, first have a look at the sidebar in case what you're after is there. The r/Fantasy wiki contains links to many community resources, including "best of" lists, flowcharts, the LGTBQ+ database, and more. If you need some help figuring out what you want, think about including some of the information below:

  • Books you’ve liked or disliked
  • Traits like prose, characters, or settings you most enjoy
  • Series vs. standalone preference
  • Tone preference (lighthearted, grimdark, etc)
  • Complexity/depth level

Be sure to check out responses to other users' requests in the thread, as you may find plenty of ideas there as well. Happy reading, and may your TBR grow ever higher!

——

tiny image link to make the preview show up correctly

art credit: special thanks to our artist, Himmis commissions, who we commissioned to create this gorgeous piece of art for us with practically no direction other than "cozy, magical, bookish, and maybe a gryphon???" We absolutely love it, and we hope you do too.


r/Fantasy • • 1d ago

Books like the anime/manga Frieren?

29 Upvotes

Frieren is my comfort read. I have read all but one of the manga volumes and have watched the anime several times. The beautiful soundtrack is an everyday listen for me too. It makes excellent reading music!

I’m wondering if there are any recommendations you might have for books like Frieren (aside from the obvious LOTR).

In particular, I’m looking for reads which may share these characteristics with Frieren: slice of life storylines, elf characters (or long-lived characters), unexpected found family, magical trials or competitions, and travelling in a party.

Thank you in advance for any help!


r/Fantasy • • 1d ago

/r/Fantasy r/Fantasy Friday Social Thread - November 20, 2026

18 Upvotes

Come tell the community what you're reading, how you're feeling, what your life is like.


r/Fantasy • • 10h ago

Are traditional publishers dropping white authors in favor of authors from marginalized groups?

0 Upvotes

Yeah I know how the title sounds, but here's why I'm asking.

Benedict Jacka, author of the Alex Verus and Inheritance of Magic series, posted this a day ago.

https://benedictjacka.co.uk/inheritance-of-magic/self-publishing-announcement/

He claims that his publisher dropped him due to declining sales, and so he'll be self publishing Inheritance of Magic going forward. Except he then goes on to say that the real reason wasn't declining sales but rather a systematic trend in the U.S. publishing industry to move away from white authors in favor of authors from marginalized groups (people of colour, people with disabilities etc.)

So I wanted to ask if this is a trend that anyone here has noticed, in the US or elsewhere, over the last 5-6 years (Benedict's timeline from his post). Some of the evidence Benedict presents is, at face value, compelling. But I don't have any way of verifying what he's saying (I can't see his sales numbers), and I'd also hate to think that an author whose works I've previously enjoyed is blaming wokeness, as the far right would define it, as a reason for being dropped by his publisher. I'm not in the industry and I don't have the contacts, so I don't have the information needed to form an opinion here.

Benedict says that "This particular prejudice is widespread, normal, and accepted in the publishing industry", and that the general advice given is to just put up with it.

I was hoping someone here could comment on this, specifically with regard to the allegations Benedict has made in his post. Any authors with a "big" publishers, or who had been with one previously, or anyone who works in the industry - can you say anything here?


r/Fantasy • • 2d ago

AMA I'm John Gwynne, author of various epic fantasy series set in the worlds of the Banished Lands and the Bloodsworn. My most recent book The Wolves of War has just been published. Ask Me Anything.

Thumbnail hachettebookgroup.com
1.1k Upvotes

My latest novel, The Wolves of War, has just been published. It is the beginning of The Wolfheart Chronicles, a duology inspired by Slavic mythology and 10th century Eastern Europe.


r/Fantasy • • 1d ago

Looking for a spicific type of novel

0 Upvotes

I have searched high and low for a novel like it ive found things like it but never quite it

Firstly a fantasy world magic nobility(dukedoms kingdoms medivle all that and any magics fine weather it be tied to the nobility or if everyone can create it)

I want a fmc

She has to be reletivly young around 8 - 18 (mostly to avoid smut i really dont want smut)

She has to be traumitised from something(a horrid past life/ a regression after a life where nobody cared and she was abused)

She has to have proper trauma responses (flinching cutting purging hiding away freezing) id avoid the ones who are purly manipulitive as they hide there emotions id rather one whos broken and cant fully hide it

Her family(found family works too) this time genuinly cares for her but she doesnt understand it she doesnt heal just because they are there she still is hurt and scared and is waiting for one of them to stop acting nice and just hurt her in some way

She does slowly heal it doesnt happen in the first half of the book it takes a while and isnt a smooth progress there are set back(something triggers her and she gets worse) but she gets better over time but isnt fixed just better

And it cant have romance be the solution it can have romance and it can help but it cant fix her (no "he is the only one i feel safe around")

[Optional]i also like yuri

[Optional]The story has more then just her healing(her going to school or something)

I dont want it to be a cozy shes traumatized but hides it super well no issues and gets better i want her to have trouble getting better doing so slowly and unevenly while having problems(cutting purging freezing flinching hiding) im good with her hiding it but i want it to be something that even when found out doesnt stop it takes work to get better it takes time and when she gets triggered(something bad happening or something related to her trauma) i want her to slip back get worse go back thoes bad habits

[Very optional]Also a suicide attempt is fine but she doesnt automaticaly get better after she can realsise she doesnt want to die but shes still hurt she still has to work to get better

Let me know if you find something like that as i just can

Remember has to have magic and or nobility but cant be only nobility as thats basicaly just a historicle not a fantasy

Finaly i want the bad self distructive tendacys like cutting starving not sleeping or pushing herself till she literaly passes freezing when scared or running and hiding somewhere when scared and flinching


r/Fantasy • • 1d ago

"Never Surrender (The Kurtherian Gambit #16)" by Michael Anderle

2 Upvotes

Book number sixteen of a twenty-one book science fiction and paranormal fantasy series. There is also an eleven book follow on series and many other books related to the The Kurtherian Gambit Universe, over 200 books in total. I read the well printed and well bound POD (print on demand) trade paperback self published by the author in 2017 that I bought new on Amazon in 2026. I have the next two books in the series and will read them soon. The related series are listed at:
https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/pe.cgi?46598

The series is a cross between science fiction and paranormal fantasy. A thousand plus years ago, an alien space ship crash landed in the Baltics. A man, Michael, found the space ship, went inside, and was forever changed into the first vampire using alien nanocytes. However, there were werewolves and werebears already existing on Earth and they still exist but they are very rare.

Michael has sired vampires and they have sired vampires. But only one of the vampire "children" is a daywalker like Michael. And Michael enforces strict rules among the vampires and the weres, no blood drinking, no letting humans know of them, etc. Violators of Michael's rules face swift termination.

But it has been thousand years since Michael was changed and he now sleeps for years at a time. Michael's helpers found a young woman named Bethany Anne working for the USA government who is dying of a rare blood disease. Michael took her to the alien space ship to become the second first generation vampire on Earth.

Bethany Anne and her war fleet of space ships with the hollowed out asteroid as the central battleship have gone through the Stargate to the Kingdom of Yoll. The war fleet decimated Yoll's defensive and offensive forces quite handily. But there were losses. And Bethany Anne defeated the King of Yoll in single combat who turned out to be a Kutherian in disguise. Now the other space aliens are coming through the other stargates to see who the humans are.

This series is real pulp like old science fiction with lots of action and dialogue. I love it !

Warning: this series might be damaging to your savings account since there are so many books.

The author has a website at:
https://lmbpn.com/

My rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
Amazon rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars (3,655 reviews)
https://www.amazon.com/Surrender-Kurtherian-Gambit-Michael-Anderle/dp/1642020583

Lynn


r/Fantasy • • 2d ago

There's No Such Thing as a School for Witches by Laramie Dean

9 Upvotes

There's No Such Thing as a School for Witches by Laramie Dean
Genres: Adult, Fantasy, Contemporary Fantasy, Horror
Representation: gay MC, trans MC, M/M
PoV: 1st/2nd-person, past-tense; third-person, present-tense; first-person, past-tense
Published on: 24th November 2026
Goodreads
★★★★★

Tom and Maggie were best friends, the only queer outcasts in their tiny town of Burke on the windy plains of Eastern Montana. But now, ten years since Tom’s disappearance one dark October night, he has summoned Maggie back to Burke. Maggie has finally claimed her trans identity and wants nothing more to do with the homophobic population of the hometown she denies . . . but curiosity draws her back. Tom has a story to tell. The story of how he became a witch and the terrible things he did to accomplish this feat. At the story’s end, he warns her, he’s going to call in a favor . . . one that will impact all the people of Burke. But the horror he threatens to unleash may destroy him and Maggie both, body and soul.

Laramie Dean grew up on the Montana prairie, which helped him fashion his writing style, what he refers to as “Montana Gothic.” After earning his Doctorate in Speech Communication and Playwriting from Southern Illinois University Carbondale, Laramie accepted the position of Director of Theatre at Hellgate High School in Missoula, Montana, where he lives with his husband. He is also the author of Black Forest and Haunt Me, Then.

I received this book for free from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

Highlights

~unreliable narrator/s GALORE
~witchcraft as evil, witchcraft as wonder
~more people should wear cloaks
~don’t make deals you don’t understand
~sometimes you want to burn the whole world down, and should

I LOVED THIS SO MUCH!

This book is a razor, sharp and gleaming, small enough to be innocuous right up until it slides across your throat, opens you up, leaves you spilling your heart’s raw red secrets all over the floor. It is feral and vicious and true, deeply messy, deeply fucked-up. It is not palatable or safe or simple. It burns going down. I wanted to reread it the moment I finished it, and I’m going to be thinking about it for a long, long time.

TNSTaaSFW opens with someone telling a story. It’s sort of first-person and sort of second-person, though the speaker – Tom – isn’t talking to us, but to someone called Maggie, a friend he hasn’t seen for a while. He’s explaining why he vanished ten years ago. This necessitates telling her – us – about what his life was like as a teenager, both before Maggie moved to the same town and became his best friend, and during that friendship, when there were things he deliberately hid from her.

It’s not pretty. It’s the sort of real-life horror you’d expect, when the premise is ‘obviously gay boy in rural Montana’. But what makes it different is two things: the way it’s told, and Tom’s determination to become a witch.

The prose is electric, visceral, articulating – so many emotions and experiences that English doesn’t have good words for.

I breathed in the darkness and looked up. No stars, no moon. Not a glint of light. Just the wind. Howling some. Howling lonesome; you know how it sounds. Like your soul. Like your sadness. Like if you coughed up all your despair and your pain and your rage and spit it out of you and it caught in the air and blew back in your face but a thousandfold, ten thousandfold: icy and stinking. Your fear and your loneliness and your rage.

It would be so easy for the writing to tip over into pretentiousness, to become the deeply purple prose of a hurting teenager. But it never does. It’s too – pared-down, distilled down, for that; everything decorative and unnecessary stripped away, so that all that’s left is pure emotion, bleeding all over the page, crackling with intensity. Dean has done what so few storytellers can and managed to capture the searing violence of puberty, the sense of being a living nuclear bomb, about to explode at any moment. I think a lot of storytellers forget that feeling, and that’s why they can’t recreate it when they’re writing as adults, but Dean has nailed it.

But he hurt me. Don’t you get that, Maggie? The motherfucker had it coming! Because of him I felt pain–in my face, my mouth, my gut, my balls, my heart and my lungs and in the darkness inside me nobody is supposed to see or feel or touch except he did and he soothed it, somebody finally FINALLY fucking soothed it AND THEN HE MADE IT HURT ALL OVER AGAIN!

Laramie Dean, I salute you so fucking hard.

The witchcraft builds slowly. Tom doesn’t even know for sure that magic is real, except it has to be, he needs it to be. He’s making it up as he goes along, from bits of movies and tv shows, Dorothy’s magical red shoes and pentagrams and birthday candles. And sometimes it seems to work. Or almost work. Or work almost like he wanted.

This isn’t Fantasy, and it’s not escapist. This is Horror, full-on, a sucking whirlpool of human evil poisoning someone until he wants his whole town to burn, and let’s be real, long before he wanted that I wanted it. I was cheering Tom on and at no point was I sorry for that. The absolutely batshit levels of hate directed at him and Maggie! The things their peers did, the things the adults let them get away with – or did themselves! I don’t know how anyone escapes from these kinds of situations without becoming a mass murderer, and I respect the hells out of all those who do manage it, but I’d be interested to know how many readers are actually horrified by Tom and what he wants. I was not this kind of queer kid, I never suffered like Tom did, that’s not what made his story so immersive for me – that I put down wholly to Dean’s incredible storytelling, the craft that’s gone into this book. I’d like to know if any readers can resist both Dean’s craft and Tom’s story enough to insist that mass murder is always wrong actually.

Tom is so unbelievably fucked-up, not just once he reaches the point of being willing to burn it all down, but long before that. He falls for one of his lead abusers – falls hard, and Dean truly makes it believable, understandable, the horrible knotty mess that is being a teenage boy whose bully is exactly your type. They have something like a romance, even, hidden away behind closed doors, and you’re screaming at Tom to know better even as you completely get it. (I can’t overstate how much this impressed me, because no storyteller has made me get it before, the idea of falling for your bully.) It’s awful and despairing and as the reader you’re waiting for it all to detonate any second – which of course it does.

From one perspective, it’s a victim striking back not just at a bully, but at an unforgivable betrayal. And yet, from another angle… It feels more complicated, less clean, than that. Because years and years and YEARS of this have warped Tom. We’ve seen it happen. We understand it perfectly; we get it, viscerally. It’s heartbreaking and terrifying, and simultaneously an ugly part of me was cheering, was screaming for Tom to do what he does. If not worse.

I don’t know if I’d call TNSTaaSFW cathartic, but it’s something like cathartic. Something on the same family tree as wish fulfilment.

It’s witchcraft Tom uses to strike back – and then he disappears. With another witch/warlock/sorcerer, one using the name Caliban. Later, we learn a lot more about ‘Caliban’, and the kind of thing he teaches Tom to do. This is not fluffy Wiccan witchcraft; it’s bloody and terrible, and we mostly see it used for terrible things. Tom never quite spells out all the specifics of how magic works, but bit by bit we can piece clues together: there are enormous, primal forces, and beings that might as well be demons, and you can only access magic at all if you’re responsible for the death of a family member. Every witch we see is bound up in chains of obligations and debt to higher powers who aren’t nice at all.

But at the same time – how much of what Tom’s said is true? When the book switches gears to Maggie’s POV, we learn that at least some of the things Tom has claimed Maggie knows for a fact are lies. Unreliable narrators galore in this one, folx; good luck trying to figure out how trustworthy Tom is, because I never could.

Tom stared at her, unblinking. Then, slowly, slowly, a snake of a smile coiled across the lower half of his long, complicated face. It twisted, that smile; it writhed.

TNSTaaSFW is not, however, one of those books playing coy about whether or not we’re dealing with actual magic or lies and hallucinations. Almost the moment we start to wonder, we’re given iron-clad proof. Since I absolutely despise stories that are ambiguous about the existence of magic, this pleased me greatly. But what really interested me is that – the magic we can be sure is real? Isn’t as ugly and twisted as the magic Tom talks about. Not at all.

“You can,” said the witch-woman whose face was composed of galaxies, stars like hard diamond chips, and the empty blackness between that was the most terrifying, the most gratifying, the most beautiful thing Maggie had ever seen–

And so the unreliability continues – magic is real, okay, but is it as terrible as Tom tells us it is? Or did he go down a particular path, and there are other ways to do magic, ones less messed-up? Gods only know, honestly.

grinning at Tom with the smoke wreathed around them and their mouths opening wide to catch the world and grind it between their teeth and swallow it so it vanishes forever and ever–

What matters to me is that the magic feels magical, feels wild and gorgeous and wondrous. The same vibrating-with-tension potency with which Dean writes emotions is on full blast whenever we approach magic, and even when we are dealing with the kind of magic Tom does – even when it’s dark, it’s still beautiful too, strange and alien in a way that’s intoxicating. This is not the first time I’ve thought this, but there’s something very correct, or very true, about collating witchcraft and queerness; it feels like a natural pairing, and in a book like this even more so, because this is very much a book about the queer person as Other, being Othered by the rest of the world. Witchcraft takes that Othering even further, and in Tom’s case specifically, the one leads to the other; being Othered because of his queerness is what drives him to witchcraft, but also, he chooses witchcraft, in the climax of Part One, in part as a rejection of the normal world that has treated him so badly.

Which is where Maggie stands as a kind of contrast, because Maggie hasn’t rejected the normal world. In the ten years since Tom disappeared, she’s built a life for herself, transitioned socially and surgically. She’s not a fainting flower innocent or anything, she doesn’t clutch any pearls when she realises what Tom wants to do to their hometown, but she’s also not on board with it. In a way, her life kind of proves that Tom could have chosen differently, could still choose differently and come back and have a regular human life. (Tom’s narration insists that’s not true, that any witch trying to give up their witchcraft only ends in disaster, but how much can we trust him on that, really?)

More interesting to me personally is that Maggie’s magic feeds into the concern of Who Is Telling The Truth Actually? Tom claims he was taught that witches have to kill a family member to gain their power, but Tom also tells us about instances when teen!Maggie did magic without having done that. So how much of that claim is bull?

Woven in with all the horror and magic is an unexpected vein of humour. Maggie and Tom are really funny. Some of it is the Millennial terminology or phrasings, some of it is a particular kind of humour you find among flamboyant queers, but a lot of it is that flat, wait-is-that-sarcasm-or-not humour that a) I really love and b) meshes so well with this particular story.

Oh my good gay god, Maggie thought,

It this book has a flaw, I’d say that it’s the way in which it’s assumed that we think killing all the bullies etc would be wrong. It’s taken for granted that we feel that way; no effort is really put into convincing us that Killing Is Bad. Which meant I didn’t really get Maggie’s opposition to Tom’s plans, and that made the last couple of pages feel a little pat to me. And the whole ‘if all of us leave these tiny towns when we can, these places will never change’ felt shoehorned in at the last second.

None of that was enough to impact my rating. On writing skill alone, this deserves at least 4.5 stars, and I can’t give less than 5 to a book I enjoyed reading THIS FREAKING MUCH.

TNSTaaSFW is fundamentally a book about queerness, specifically the flavours of queer that are white gay man and white trans woman. Some of this means digging into real ugliness, real evil, homophobia and transphobia and things that are neither but still part of the reality of living your true self. This is a story about assault and trauma and cycles of abuse and how different people choose to respond to those things. It’s about small American towns. It’s about witchcraft, magic, what it is and what it can do and how even terrible things can be wondrous. And gods, this is a book about RAGE, about hurt, about different kinds of love, about FEELING so much that you can’t possibly contain it.

There’s nothing like the rage of a queer witchboy

I adored it. It horrified me and delighted me and I couldn’t put it down. Expect it on my Best of Year list next month.

Laramie Dean is going directly to my auto-buy author list, and he should VERY MUCH be on yours as well!

Applicable bingo squares: Trans Protagonist, Small Press (HM), Published in 2026

You can find more of my reviews, rec lists, and weekly publishing roundups at Every Book a Doorway!