The Animals We Became by Finn Longman
Genres: Adult, Fantasy, Historical Fantasy
Representation: Asexual MC, autistic nonbinary MC, secondary trans character
PoV: First-person, past-tense; first-person, present-tense
Published on: 26th November 2026 (UK); 27th July 2027 (US)
Goodreads
★★★★★
You exist because of a crime, because of a curse, and because of a trick.
Blodeuedd never asked to be made.
Created from flowers of oak, broom, and meadowsweet to marry a man cursed never to have a human wife, Blodeuedd has no knowledge of the world, no family outside the marriage, and no power to choose. But a caged animal still has claws, and Blodeuedd will find a way to be free, whatever the cost.
Gwydion knows what it is to be unmade.
Haunted by the years he served in animal form as punishment for his brother's crimes, Gwydion has turned his tricks to his nephew's happiness - and the creation of Blodeuedd is the greatest trick of them all. But his creation asks questions he cannot answer and drags from the depths of the forest the past he has been trying so hard to forget. Now they both must face their unmaking.
From the author of The Wolf and His King comes a spellbinding new medieval fantasy standalone retelling the story of Blodeuedd from Welsh mythology in a profound exploration of cyclical trauma and transformation. As angry as it is hopeful, this visionary novel is unmissable for readers of Katherine Arden, Naomi Novik, and Samantha Shannon.
Highlights
~queering up the Welsh myths
~(newbie-to-Welsh-myths friendly!)
~constant galaxy-brain moments
~rich, gorgeous prose
~kinder than canon
The Animals We Became is very different from Longman’s debut, The Wolf and His King – but I think I might love it even more than I did Wolf.
This is a retelling of part of the Mabinogion, a foundational text of Welsh mythology. You absolutely don’t need to know the original myths to enjoy this book, Animals We Became doesn’t go in expecting/requiring the reader to have any prior knowledge at all! But speaking as someone who does know the myths – I cannot express how much I adore and appreciate this retelling. The changes Longman’s made, the aspects they’ve chosen to explore and dig into, the obvious respect and love they have for the source material and its culture… It all made me so incredibly happy!
(Especially as an asexual, nonbinary, autistic half-Welsh person. My gods, the representation!!!)
Gwydion is a magician, the nephew of King Math. He and his brother are the court’s darlings, often acting as their uncle’s representatives beyond the court. Their life is pretty golden! Right up until Gilfaethwy – the brother – decides he simply must have Goewin, a woman who is very much off-limits, and Gwydion arranges an opening. Goewin calls it rape, and the brothers are punished by being turned into animals for three years. Specifically, they’re turned into a male and female pair of animals – first deer, then boars, then wolves – each for a year, each time swapping which of them is male and which female. They have three children – a fawn, a piglet, and a wolf cub. Who become human when Gwydion and Gilfaethwy do, when their punishment is over.
(I feel the need to emphasise that this isn’t something Longman came up with. This is direct from Welsh mythology.)
All of this is summarised for us in the second chapter, along with how exactly Gwydion came to be raising his nephew Lleu, and why it is that Lleu can’t marry a human woman, or one transformed from an animal either. Basically, it’s all the immediate backstory we need to understand why Gwydion and Math would work together to make a woman out of flowers – whom they name Blodeuedd – for Lleu to marry. So again: you don’t need any familiarity with the myths at all; Longman makes sure we have all the information we need to understand what’s happening and how we got here.
This is a slow, beautiful book. It’s not plotless, but the plot doesn’t move quickly; it coalesces slowly, bit by bit, in time with our gradual understanding of how deeply screwed-up Blodeuedd’s situation is, and how deeply screwed-up Gwydion is as a person who is pretending, very hard, that he definitely doesn’t have trauma, nope, none at all, why would you think that?
(He has so much trauma.)
At first glance, The Animals We Became looks like a more straightforward, more accessible book than The Wolf and His King was – there is no second-person narration here (well, technically Gwydion’s parts are second-person, but they’re functionally first-person so don’t worry about it) and no PoVs in free verse. However, the second you take a closer peek at The Animals We Became, it is IMMEDIATELY obvious that this book, too, is the product of an incredible amount of writing craft, that the love of words and language that was so on display in Wolf and His King abounds here as well, that the same amount of surgical-, jeweller-precision has gone into the choice and placement of every single word in this book. The English AND the Welsh.
Here the trees grew like fierce spears, straight and sharp and unknowably tall, or else like stories, twisting and ancient.
If you love stories with unreliable narrators, then you are going to adore this book, because you can’t trust a single gods damn word Gwydion says. I highlighted so many of the things he said, trying to work out which were true, how many could be depended on, which ones contradicted others. And to be fair, one of the very first things he tells the reader is that he’s twisty of tongue, all but warning us not to believe a word, or at least not without verifying it elsewhere first! His narration really is a work of art, how slowly but perfectly pieces of the truth start to dawn on us, how certain lines or images echo throughout his chapters (when I came to the line the title is taken from I ACTUALLY SHRIEKED), how careful he/Longman is to make sure we (against all common sense) like him before we learn the whole story. This is so crucial, and so powerful, and I spent ages lying on my back starting at the ceiling while I went through all the ways this book would have been radically different if we’d known everything right away. Which has so many ramifications not just on the story, but also on our ideas of truth and justice and the way we apply or understand those things with strangers versus people we like, and hi, Longman, YOU ACTUALLY DIDN’T NEED TO COME FOR ME LIKE THIS.
the crashing waves stole my words and milled my uneasy thoughts like rocks into sand.
And Blodeuedd. Oh my gods, Blodeuedd. I have read so many versions of her story, okay? The classic one, and countless retellings, short stories and novels and even poems. But I have never read any take on her character and story that made me ache and sob and keen like The Animals We Became has made me. I’ve never read one that made me feel so seen, that went for my throat, that fucking flensed me like this did. And even if it didn’t reach right into my chest and spill my heart all over the pages – even if this interpretation was not immediately personal to me, it’s so CLEVER. It’s GENIUS. Reading Blodeuedd’s chapters is like a galaxy-brain moment in slow-motion as you put it together, because OH MY GODS, OF COURSE.
Of course Blodeuedd is deeply, is completely trans. Of course she is. Of course that makes sense. It’s so OBVIOUS now someone else has said it! How COULD her body possibly fit, when it’s not really hers, when it was meant to be FLOWERS? When it was literally crafted for someone else’s benefit? How could she make any sense of womanhood, of femininity, when she doesn’t have a lifetime of growing into it but is just DROPPED into it, as a supposed adult, the second she comes to life?
It’s genius. It is hands down the smartest and most powerful interpretation of Blodeuedd I have ever come across, and I’ll be stunned if any future one manages to outshine it.
I am not certain how similar we are, really, or whether I would be any happier if Gwydion had made for me a man’s body, for that would have been no more a choice than this. What I crave is something messier, something I do not have words for. I desire ugliness and imperfection and difference, for my body has always been perfect, and has never been mine.
I am swooning and crying and hugging the book to my chest so hard it hurts.
I would love The Animals We Became for this alone, for making Blodeuedd nonbinary, and specifically nonbinary in the way that it does. But Longman’s Blodeuedd is also autistic! The word is never used (how could it be, in this setting?) but it’s very obvious to anyone familiar with autistic people; the way she struggles with tone and facial expressions, how she reaches for specific textures when she’s stressed, how she’s soothed by repetitive work like spinning thread. Etc. I loved this so much, and again, it felt so correct, made so much sense to me. She was made of FLOWERS; how could she be neurotypical???
But there are so many other reasons to adore this book. There’s Gwydion’s queerness – he’s definitely asexual and almost certainly aromantic. There’s the WEALTH of different meanings, or interpretations, of the title, which is the kind of thing that always delights me. There’s the incisive examination of what beauty and womanhood mean in a patriarchy, and (not unrelated) what freedom can be for someone people think of as a woman. There’s the way that absolutely EVERY character in this book is wonderfully multi-faceted; no one is a simple villain, or a simple hero, either. Longman casts everything in shades of grey, lets their story and characters be genuinely complicated in all sorts of different ways – if you’re tired of books that spoon-feed you every point the author wants to make, of stories more interested in virtue-signalling than storytelling, then you’ll find The Animals We Became every bit as refreshing as I did!
It is not all that you are, says the god. It is all that they made you.
This feels like the first mythological retelling I’ve read in quite some time that really explores its source material, that interrogates and considers and dissects it – and doing all of that with so much respect and love for the ‘canon’. It has been some time since I visited Wales, and Longman made me so homesick for it, despite being careful not to anchor the story with too much geographic or historic reality (the Note on the Setting at the beginning of the book is just wonderful) – because despite that, and despite various fantastical details that are all Longman’s creation, this story feels like Wales, feels Welsh, in some vital way I can’t articulate, but that I mean as an immense compliment.
Part of that is the gorgeous nature imagery, which saturates every aspect of the story. If you’ve read The Wolf and His King, then you already know that Longman’s prose is gorgeous, but so much more of the writing here embraces the natural world in a way that Wolf didn’t (probably because poor Bisclavret was doing his best to choose humanity over nature, not that those things have to be opposing, but for him they are). A large part of this reflects the connection the people in this setting have with the land. Gwydion’s magic literally comes from his ties to his home earth, but Longman has also created a pantheon of deities, one for each locale, and almost everyone worships the god of their home. This is an enormous part of most people’s identity, and extremely plot-relevant. So it only makes sense that Blodeuedd and Gwydion often think in terms of trees, animals, running water. Their synonyms and metaphors are full of it.
you’d walked in the sun, and it had scattered freckles like seeds across your cheeks.
And of course – Blodeuedd was made from flowers. Gwydion spent three years as different animals. They both have a very clear connection to the not-human nature.
Is that what you are?” I asked. “My enemy?”
You said, “I am your creation,” which didn’t, when I thought about it later, answer my question.
Which is another thing I’ve never seen a retelling of this story do before – make clear, and explore, the similarities in Gwydion and Blodeuedd’s situations. It’s another thing that strikes me as genius, that is so obvious now someone has pointed it out to me. The two characters are very different, and so are their situations – but those situations are also powerfully similar in some ways. Gwydion’s trauma, and his feelings about his trauma, affect…absolutely everything about Blodeuedd’s creation, everything in how she’s ‘raised’ (a process that lasts only a week!) That Gwydion doesn’t recognise this…is part of his being an unreliable narrator: it’s not only us, the reader, who can’t rely on him. He’s lying to himself, too. Desperately.
I had given you to Lleu, bound you to him, treated you as an object to be traded. As a bouquet of flowers: beautiful, and a sign of my love for him, but nothing that could grow.
There’s so much going on in this book – so many, not conversations, exactly – because I never felt like Longman had one conclusion that they were trying to lead me towards – but explorations. Of womanhood, and womanhood within a patriarchal culture. Of outcasts, especially willing outcasts, people who don’t want to be a part of the ‘normal’ world. Of trauma. Of community. Of kyriarchy. Of justice and punishment, and where justice stops being justice and becomes only punishment. Of autonomy, in many different senses of the word. I don’t think I have the language to talk about the awfulness of Blodeuedd’s sex life with her husband Lleu, but I think it’s important, especially because Lleu is never aware that he’s hurting her, has no intent to do so but does do so. There’s something there about how irrelevant intent is to damage done – about how terrible it is, that we can be good people but still do harm.
I am not less imprisoned because the gaoler speaks softly to me.
And yet – for those who know the original myth, and are worried – The Animals We Became is not a tragedy. The traditional, canonical ‘ending’ of Blodeuedd’s story is powerfully reframed, into a joy, a triumph. Everyone else’s endings also manage to be hopeful, despite the canon Longman was working with! That’s probably one of the things I’m most grateful for in this retelling; that the ending is gentler, kinder, than the one I’m used to.
Like The Wolf and His King, this is a book that rewards taking your time and thinking about what you read. There are so many layers to what Longman is doing at any one point, and I doubt any of us can spot and understand all of them at once every time. But it was so much fun to try! And I don’t think there’s any reason you couldn’t read this without going over every line with a magnifying glass – any reason you couldn’t read this ‘just’ as a beautiful story of a woman made from flowers who wants her freedom. As a story about magicians and princes and gods, a languid kind of adventure-intrigue story. One that takes the rough gem of the canon and cuts it, polishes it, until it absolutely shines.
This is easily one of the best books of the year – of any year. If you had any doubt at all that Longman was a master bard, well – you won’t after this!
Applicable bingo squares: Trans Protagonist (HM); Small Press (HM); Published in 2026; arguably Explorers and Rangers; arguably Non-Human Protagonist
You can find more of my reviews, rec lists, and weekly publishing roundups at Every Book a Doorway!