r/Hungergames • u/CapnKruncheroo • 3h ago
Sunrise on the Reaping Sunrise on the Reaping disrespects the original trilogy. Spoiler
DISCLAIMER: I am discussing Sunrise as well as the other Hunger Games stories based purely on the films - whether this is a valid qualifier I leave up for debate, but "well the book explains this" feels like making excuses for the movie writers.
Also, SPOILERS!
I just finished Sunrise on the Reaping in theaters, and I generally consider myself an optimistic moviegoer; most movies have something going for them, and tapping into that generally leads to a positive experience even if the movie is grade A slop.
Sunrise is not that. It is a movie that is naturally fan service galore (which let's be honest, can be really fun) but it also wants the audience to 100% buy into its contributions to the original trilogy's overall themes of power, revolution, and systemic violence.
First, some positives because despite everything I am about to say, I was glued to my goddamn seat the entire 2.5+ hour runtime. We all knew it was going to be trauma porn, and it may have been tongue in cheek with Haymitch committing to sobriety in the beginning, but my god by the end does that man deserve every drink he has for the next 26 years. 48 tributes step into the most visually stunning arena ever constructed, and despite being told repeatedly that it is a killing machine, I was so lost in the beauty of it that I was genuinely surprised when the water was poison and the butterflies were tasers.
The performances are also top notch. Sunrise had the unenviable task of revisiting beloved characters and making them feel new and untested but preserving the core of the versions that we see in the original trilogy. Jesse Plemons in particular delivers a young, reckless Plutarch whose cunning nature makes it impossibly easy to envision Philip Seymour Hoffman drawing from those experiences as he devises his own Games decades later. Kieran Culkin plays the perfect "season 1" late night host frantic to secure his stardom, and shows how Stanley Tucci's comfort with the crowd and unpredictable tributes is both a skill and talent. And props to the main star. Joseph Zada has the look and feel of a "rascal" that his character embodies to the Capital, but the raw emotion and softhearted empathy that we get makes him an easily lovable protagonist.
Ok, now the issues. Haymitch's revolutionary backstory is completely unnecessary. Haymitch in the original movies is a broken man, someone who was so thoroughly defeated by his Games that his district's tributes dying is a yearly routine that he drinks his way through. The Games being a free-for-all of literal children for the entertainment of the elite was already enough to justify his attitude. Learning that he was in the 2nd Quarter Quell with twice the bodies cemented how brutal the Capital really is. He didn't need to be a failed revolutionary who was singled out by Snow to suffer eternally. In fact, making it feel like he needs a "but this also happened!" arc cheapens how traumatic the Games inherently are. Haymitch just needed to be a living reminder of the toll the Games takes from the winner, and how they serve as a reminder that the Capital's power is absolute. Instead, we have to believe that Haymitch attempted to start the revolution but failed and is racked with guilt not because he had to murder people, possibly from his own district, but because he didn't save the world. Not every character in the series has to be a major figure in the revolution from the start, and the original character arc of Haymitch already is extremely effective. Katniss is so inspirational as a rebel that she makes a man who has given up on life see a future where his cycle of torment is finally broken.
This is frustrating because the movie already presents a far more interesting perspective on the long formation of revolution. "Implicit submission" is the idea that power is held through perception and subservience rather than might, and the writers take steps to set up that idea. The tributes have all the weapons in the training room, yet when 4 unarmed peacekeepers order them around, not a single person dares to question them. Haymitch could have been someone who hates the Games, resents the Capital, wants change but his perception that the Capital is invincible is so unshakeable that he does his duty as a tribute just to make it home. He could've talked big revolutionary ideas, and he could've been a thorn in Snow's side by being so vocal, but when the chips were down and he's confronted with whether to actually act, he submits to his opponent before ever making a move.
This arc would've displayed how fearsome the Quarter Quells really were to the people in the districts. In fact, this is probably the only Hunger Games movie ever where a straightforward battle royale would've been the more effective choice. A raw, bloody spectacle that displays violence on a sickening level that forces Haymitch to do unspeakable things to his fellow tributes because he simply did not have a choice not to. I guess that ending would've been too bleak for the studio, and they had to throw in a feel-good vow to change things and a disastrous epilogue scene at the end just so audiences don't walk out feeling depressed at the socioeconomic state of the world.
Instead, the Quarter Quell added nothing to the plot. This movie could've been the usual 24 tributes, and I don't think any part of it would change. We don't get to see the initial rush to the Cornucopia that would've been twice as hellish as Katniss', and a volcano wipes out more than half the tributes anyway. By the time the Games matter again, we're down to 5 tributes just like every other movie. The Quarter Quell is supposed to be a monumental event every 25 years that crushes every hope of rebellion, but here it's played like a standard TV special. There's no particularly special display in the Capital for the Quell, and Flickerman riles up a crowd that feels smaller than the first film.
All of this cheapens the original trilogy and how special Katniss really was to the revolution and to breaking the cycle of power that existed in Panem. Haymitch having multiple identical "young ally dies in their arms" moment to Katniss makes Rue's televised death being the flashpoint for rebellion feel almost arbitrary. Haymitch finding loopholes to sabotage the Games to force a no contest finish diminishes Katniss finally being the first tribute to find a way to break the Games by fundamentally betraying their intent of always having a victor. Even if Haymitch fails at the revolution and it all being swept under the rug by the Capital, just knowing that someone else figured it out before Katniss just ruins the achievement.
The lack of stakes from the Quarter Quell again downplay how good at their intended effect the Games really were. The Third Quarter Quell felt heavier than this just by having its tributes find creative ways to beg not to be forced back into the Arena during their pre-interviews.
In all, it's an entertaining movie. It's even got a unique angle on the revolution against the Capital. But Sunrise is too scared to really embrace its own ideas, and as a result leaves audiences with contradictory themes and a "well I guess we tried but surely one day" attitude.