r/Hungergames • • 3h ago

Sunrise on the Reaping Sunrise on the Reaping disrespects the original trilogy. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

DISCLAIMER: I am discussing Sunrise as well as the other Hunger Games stories based purely on the films - whether this is a valid qualifier I leave up for debate, but "well the book explains this" feels like making excuses for the movie writers.

Also, SPOILERS!

I just finished Sunrise on the Reaping in theaters, and I generally consider myself an optimistic moviegoer; most movies have something going for them, and tapping into that generally leads to a positive experience even if the movie is grade A slop.

Sunrise is not that. It is a movie that is naturally fan service galore (which let's be honest, can be really fun) but it also wants the audience to 100% buy into its contributions to the original trilogy's overall themes of power, revolution, and systemic violence.

First, some positives because despite everything I am about to say, I was glued to my goddamn seat the entire 2.5+ hour runtime. We all knew it was going to be trauma porn, and it may have been tongue in cheek with Haymitch committing to sobriety in the beginning, but my god by the end does that man deserve every drink he has for the next 26 years. 48 tributes step into the most visually stunning arena ever constructed, and despite being told repeatedly that it is a killing machine, I was so lost in the beauty of it that I was genuinely surprised when the water was poison and the butterflies were tasers.

The performances are also top notch. Sunrise had the unenviable task of revisiting beloved characters and making them feel new and untested but preserving the core of the versions that we see in the original trilogy. Jesse Plemons in particular delivers a young, reckless Plutarch whose cunning nature makes it impossibly easy to envision Philip Seymour Hoffman drawing from those experiences as he devises his own Games decades later. Kieran Culkin plays the perfect "season 1" late night host frantic to secure his stardom, and shows how Stanley Tucci's comfort with the crowd and unpredictable tributes is both a skill and talent. And props to the main star. Joseph Zada has the look and feel of a "rascal" that his character embodies to the Capital, but the raw emotion and softhearted empathy that we get makes him an easily lovable protagonist.

Ok, now the issues. Haymitch's revolutionary backstory is completely unnecessary. Haymitch in the original movies is a broken man, someone who was so thoroughly defeated by his Games that his district's tributes dying is a yearly routine that he drinks his way through. The Games being a free-for-all of literal children for the entertainment of the elite was already enough to justify his attitude. Learning that he was in the 2nd Quarter Quell with twice the bodies cemented how brutal the Capital really is. He didn't need to be a failed revolutionary who was singled out by Snow to suffer eternally. In fact, making it feel like he needs a "but this also happened!" arc cheapens how traumatic the Games inherently are. Haymitch just needed to be a living reminder of the toll the Games takes from the winner, and how they serve as a reminder that the Capital's power is absolute. Instead, we have to believe that Haymitch attempted to start the revolution but failed and is racked with guilt not because he had to murder people, possibly from his own district, but because he didn't save the world. Not every character in the series has to be a major figure in the revolution from the start, and the original character arc of Haymitch already is extremely effective. Katniss is so inspirational as a rebel that she makes a man who has given up on life see a future where his cycle of torment is finally broken.

This is frustrating because the movie already presents a far more interesting perspective on the long formation of revolution. "Implicit submission" is the idea that power is held through perception and subservience rather than might, and the writers take steps to set up that idea. The tributes have all the weapons in the training room, yet when 4 unarmed peacekeepers order them around, not a single person dares to question them. Haymitch could have been someone who hates the Games, resents the Capital, wants change but his perception that the Capital is invincible is so unshakeable that he does his duty as a tribute just to make it home. He could've talked big revolutionary ideas, and he could've been a thorn in Snow's side by being so vocal, but when the chips were down and he's confronted with whether to actually act, he submits to his opponent before ever making a move.

This arc would've displayed how fearsome the Quarter Quells really were to the people in the districts. In fact, this is probably the only Hunger Games movie ever where a straightforward battle royale would've been the more effective choice. A raw, bloody spectacle that displays violence on a sickening level that forces Haymitch to do unspeakable things to his fellow tributes because he simply did not have a choice not to. I guess that ending would've been too bleak for the studio, and they had to throw in a feel-good vow to change things and a disastrous epilogue scene at the end just so audiences don't walk out feeling depressed at the socioeconomic state of the world.

Instead, the Quarter Quell added nothing to the plot. This movie could've been the usual 24 tributes, and I don't think any part of it would change. We don't get to see the initial rush to the Cornucopia that would've been twice as hellish as Katniss', and a volcano wipes out more than half the tributes anyway. By the time the Games matter again, we're down to 5 tributes just like every other movie. The Quarter Quell is supposed to be a monumental event every 25 years that crushes every hope of rebellion, but here it's played like a standard TV special. There's no particularly special display in the Capital for the Quell, and Flickerman riles up a crowd that feels smaller than the first film.

All of this cheapens the original trilogy and how special Katniss really was to the revolution and to breaking the cycle of power that existed in Panem. Haymitch having multiple identical "young ally dies in their arms" moment to Katniss makes Rue's televised death being the flashpoint for rebellion feel almost arbitrary. Haymitch finding loopholes to sabotage the Games to force a no contest finish diminishes Katniss finally being the first tribute to find a way to break the Games by fundamentally betraying their intent of always having a victor. Even if Haymitch fails at the revolution and it all being swept under the rug by the Capital, just knowing that someone else figured it out before Katniss just ruins the achievement.

The lack of stakes from the Quarter Quell again downplay how good at their intended effect the Games really were. The Third Quarter Quell felt heavier than this just by having its tributes find creative ways to beg not to be forced back into the Arena during their pre-interviews.

In all, it's an entertaining movie. It's even got a unique angle on the revolution against the Capital. But Sunrise is too scared to really embrace its own ideas, and as a result leaves audiences with contradictory themes and a "well I guess we tried but surely one day" attitude.


r/Hungergames • • 9h ago

Sunrise on the Reaping as someone who never read the book, sunrise on the reaping is easily the best film in the entire franchise and the negativity makes zero sense Spoiler

4 Upvotes

I just got back from the theater and honestly think r/movies and half the critics have completely lost the plot on this one. Going in completely blind without ever reading the book was the best decision I could have made, because it feels like 90% of the complaints in here are just book purists mad that Francis Lawrence didn't waste forty minutes on bloated side quests or explicitly show every single drop of gore. In actual cinema, less is more. People complaining that the tributes die too fast or that Ampert and Maysilee don't look mangled enough after the animal swarms are totally missing the point of the visual contrast inside a deceptively pretty arena. We don't need twenty minutes of backstory on every minor newcomer to feel the weight of what Haymitch goes through, and watching him jump down to blow up the underground water tank felt snappy and urgent rather than dragging out the third act for no reason.

Honestly, this topped Catching Fire for me as the peak of the entire series. Joseph Zada and Jesse Plemons carried more thematic weight in two hours than the original trilogy did in four movies, and you actually benefit from not having a checklist of novel chapters in your head while watching their dynamic play out. Even the epilogue at the end that everyone is nitpicking down to the wigs hit way harder if you just treat it as a cinematic bookend instead of freeze-framing it to look for flaws. Sometimes an adaptation improves on the source material by trimming the fat and trusting the audience to fill in the blanks, and once the knee-jerk book comparisons die down, people are going to realize this is the smartest movie in the whole franchise.


r/Hungergames • • 10h ago

Sunrise on the Reaping What’s Up with Caesar? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I liked the movie overall, but something that bothered me was the way Kieran Culkin played Caesar Flickerman.

He’s just acts like a total asshole the whole time. He actively belittles the tributes, is mean even towards the rest of the crew, and is overall just totally different than how he is portrayed in the books and by Stanley Tucci.

I mean of course he’s just making a production, but prior to this film he was never disrespectful to the tributes, even to the ones that had no chance like Rue. And Katniss even notes that his reaction to Peeta’s bombshell seems genuine. Even if he was just acting, he still put on a likable persona. Was this character change deliberate? Or did Culkin just misplay him?


r/Hungergames • • 13h ago

Sunrise on the Reaping Maybe controversial: I thought that sunrise on the reaping was bad Spoiler

11 Upvotes

Hunger games: Sunrise on the reaping took what is so great about the hunger games franchise; story telling about morality and fascism through the lens of characters and turned it on its head in the worst way possible. (Some spoilers incoming)

Every plot line and meaning is screamed at the viewer “THIS IS PROPAGANDA AND PROPAGANDA IS BAD” but the film ultimately fails to say anything meaningful about propaganda at all other than “hey this is what it is”

The original series proposes just war theory to the viewer and allows the reader/viewer to reach their own conclusion, this film just tells you what to think.

The story telling is also objectively flawed, characters are introduced and then the next scene we see them and they’re dead, it’s clear these characters are introduced to die, rather than showing them as full people with their own lives which the original series did so successfully of course especially with rue.

Book plots which are essential to the propaganda angle, like silica crying under the tree or maysile killing the game maker are dropped which weakens the message of the film even more, despite its great source material.

Apologies for the negativity, I get that most people enjoyed the film but I ultimately feel like this movie was a disservice to the franchise and Suzanne Colin’s writing.


r/Hungergames • • 8h ago

Sunrise on the Reaping Extremely disappointed in SOTR movie Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I have been a huge fan of the Hunger Games books and movies. I actually got a tad bored of TBOSAS book but thought the movie was good.

I enjoyed the SOTR book a lot. It was interesting to see familiar characters in their younger years, the book really explained relationships well and the slow burn of Maysilee and Haymitch teaming up, etc.

SOTR movie was rushed. I can stomach Haymitch calling Burdie “Everdeen” to make it abundantly clear to the viewer, but they rushed the opening D12 scenes. We get introduced to Lenore for 1 minute and then are supposed to be attached to her?

One of my biggest issues was not allowing the D12 tribute relationships to play out longer. Maysilee and Haymitch did not like nor trust each other. We see that evolve into them calling each other family in the arena, which sadly was not the case for the movie.

Louella’s death was bad. The act of defiance being him clapping was….missing the key part where he brought her directly to Snow in another chariot. The movie version was so corny.

The lack of gore was terrible. Perhaps there’s some issue with PG-13 but if so…idk maybe make it R? Ampert barely having scratches when he should in fact be BONES was crazy

MAYSILEE NOT ATTACKING THE GAMEMAKERS??? The birds legit were so random I almost laughed. Haymitch consciously having Silka hit the force field????? Why why why???

Finally the epilogue was so quick and once again, BAD. It was so quick, it was corny as fuck. “Thank you guys” like it hasn’t been weeks and weeks since the revolution succeeded. UGH

They should’ve made it into two movies or extended it because they really lost the opportunity to make this meet the emotions from the book


r/Hungergames • • 23h ago

Sunrise on the Reaping Sunrise on the reaping: people’s reactions are shocking me Spoiler

31 Upvotes

After watching SOTR I spent an hour staring into space thinking about how Haymitch never gets a happy ending. His life is a tragedy. If you want to write him a happy story Haymitch is in his 30s when the revolution succeeds, so there’s time, but how could he possibly heal?

I then began questioning the purpose of having such a bone chilling tale exist in our collective consciousness. I thought about the arms industry as it exists today, and the profit being made from sending people to kill and die. I thought about the Pluto-cracy, and the economic disparity of today.

I went Reddit to explore these two things: Haymitch’s age and social commentary.

Instead I found conversation after conversation of people acting like movie critics. Isn’t it human nature to identify with the protagonist (to a fault). I didn’t find horror online, or any humanistic sentiments, just snobbery.

Like people weren’t sufficiently entertained.


r/Hungergames • • 14h ago Thanks

Sunrise on the Reaping Fantastic Adaptation, the Haters are Whiners Spoiler

75 Upvotes

Francis Lawrence put his whole foot in this one, I don’t think I’ve ever cried as much and as often in a movie as I did in SOTR. I’ve been reading and rereading these books since they came out and I think this is the best adaptation of the whole series.

Joseph Zada, McKenna Grace, Whitney Peake, and Jesse Plemmons are the standouts and deserve all the flowers. I was worried Zada’s Haymitch was gonna be a caricature of Woody Harrelson’s but my lord I swear I was watching Haymitch Abernathy himself on the screen. Oscar-worthy if you ask me. McKenna Grace as Maysilee AND Merrilee had me in tears, she brought such depth I didn’t expect from a former child star and I would bet money she’s going to be one of the biggest talents of her generation. Whitney Peake took a small role and became the heart of the entire movie. Her Lenore Dove was Covey through and through, truly the proper heir of Lucy Gray. And Jesse Plemmons. Jesse fucking Plemmons. I want that man in a spy movie PRONTO, the way he had me questioning Plutarch’s motives even though I’ve read all the books!

Were scenes cut? Yes. Did the movie still hit me, a lifelong fan, like a freight train? Yes. The people on here acting like this is the worst thing to happen to the franchise are either delusional or (more likely) are farming for clicks. When books are adapted, scenes get cut. Grow up!

Anyway, time to up my antidepressants.


r/Hungergames • • 21h ago

Sunrise on the Reaping Joseph Zada SOTR Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I saw the interview where Joseph spoke about how much he didn’t want to say Lenore Dove’s full name because it felt too formal. He mentioned he replaced it with “darling” in most of his scenes. This absolutely ruined it for me in the movie, every time he said “darling” all I could think about was how much he must have misunderstood the character of Haymitch and the covey in general.

I also did not think his accent was great. It was giving Finnick in Catching Fire where I could hear Sam’s accent slipping through. Half the time Joseph was Australian and the other half he was mumbling.

Just my hot takes 🤷‍♀️


r/Hungergames • • 44m ago

Sunrise on the Reaping I don’t like how SOTR made everything so connected Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Specifically Katniss.

Turns out that Katniss’ dad was the BFF of her mentor.

Not only that, but since Burdock is related to LD, that means that Katniss also happens to be related to her mentor’s girlfriend who died.

But wait, that means a relative of Katniss’ was killed by Snow long before she was born and started her beef with him.

Hang on. Lenore Dove was also related to Lucy Gray. That means Katniss also happens to be related to Snow’s ex. She’s related to the girl her arch enemy was obsessed with.

You see what I mean. SOTR makes the entire franchise seem like the story of the Bairds/Covey and the people related to them and how intertwined their story is with Snow and the Games.

I really hope Suzanne does not make another book focusing on the Covey. Please don’t tell me a Baird was the reason Plutarch joined the rebellion


r/Hungergames • • 7h ago

Sunrise on the Reaping Big complaint about the movie Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I really enjoyed the new movie, but two related things really bothered me.

The first is Beetee. I can see why they didn’t kill him after he manipulated the arena in his games to get out. He was just trying to live,and they want to keep the victor alive if they can.

But in this movie, he knowingly as an adult orchestrates a plan to destroy the games and confesses, and they don’t kill him? Give me a fucking break. They say he’s “too important” to kill or something. What? He’s far too dangerous not to kill. I understand they need him alive for the later movies, but then have someone else take the fall for the conspiracy, or have the capitol think the kids figured it out on their own. But there is no world where beetee confesses to that and lives. I’m sorry. That is ridiculous.

Relatedly, with the way they wrote Plutarch, it isnt plausible that he could fly under the radar as long as he did. He has the subtlety of a gun in this movie. Plutarch works in the other books because his connection to the rebellion is so unknown. He seems completely devoted to the capitol and his role, and comes across as a bad guy because of it. He’s really cunning and underhanded and that’s how he pulls it off. In this movie he and haymitch are openly having little private chats, he’s visibly sympathetic to the tributes, and then he’s suspected of being involved in the conspiracy but then President Snow believes he wasn’t actually involved just because Beetee said so. Absolutely the fuck not. President snow isn’t a moron. If Plutarch was this suspicious he would be dead by the time katniss comes around. I guess they wanted it to be really obvious to us that Plutarch could be trusted, but it just ended up coming across like he’s really not good at hiding his shit. I don’t think they handled that well at all.


r/Hungergames • • 23h ago

Sunrise on the Reaping SOTR - so disappointing Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I was hoping they’d do justice or defend Collins’ writings - at least enough for us to get emotionally attached to the story line to understand the devastation of the book. Not even close.

I thought the cast meant they were fans of the books, not just the movies.

The best writing of the series made into a flop.


r/Hungergames • • 2h ago

Sunrise on the Reaping Haymitch completely lacking shrewdness in SOTR and is not at all reminiscent of the same character from the original trilogy Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Haymitch in the original trilogy is a traumatised, extremely depressed alcoholic who has not taken care of his own body or mind for years. And *yet* he is still always the smartest, most cunning person in any room. Despite his self-neglect he is still a shrewd and brilliant strategist.

Haymitch in SOTR has no aspect which makes me believe that he could grow into the troubled but intelligent mentor that he is for Katniss and Peeta.

This guy should be oozing with competence and cunning even more so than the older haymitch we see in the original trilogy. It's fine if he is naive especially when it comes to the evil workings of the capitol. It's also okay if he isn't a sarcastic nihilist because we can expect that his trauma added those attributes to his personality in the aftermath of his games. But if I'm expected to believe that he's the same guy from the original trilogy prior to him becoming traumatised then it's absolutely necessary for him to be nothing short of a natural born genius.

IMO Collins really missed the mark here. This character was originally someone truly special who was able to overcome insurmountable odds by outwitting other contenders who were physically much stronger and had been raised and trained to compete in the games from birth. I believe this story could have been a lot better if Collins had taken more care to ensure that the character she wrote in this book was a naive but gifted, and proactive protagonist who is more reminiscent of the original Haymitch.


r/Hungergames • • 21h ago

Sunrise on the Reaping Was SOTR underwhelming? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Even though I have watched the first 4 movies too many times to the point I remember the plot frame by frame, it stayed engaging. Since I loved the saga and would watch the movie in IMAX, I had high expectations for SOTR and thought I'd love it. I did not have any spoilers other than the fact the book is considered the "darkest" in the series.

The good:

  1. Roman Roy, sorry, I meant Kieran Culkin. I loved his performance and "liked" him more the Caesar.
  2. The cinematography: it is certainly the most colorful movie of the saga and IMAX did help convey that.
  3. The acting: not talking about the plot (more on that later) or what the actors were given, but no one was bad.

The bad:

  1. The Newcomers did not look like what they were hyped to be since most of them were never shown and the few that did, had a short appearance and were killed. Maysilee, Ampert and Lou Lou (and her "clone") should have been more important to the plot than they were and it doesn't look like the plot would change much if they were missing. Rue and Thresh worked out well as characters in the original movie: the former was a friend and we had moments to show it while the latter killed of a stronger opponent and that was all.
  2. Bringing the younger versions of Wiress, Mags, Beetee and Plutarch seemed like a fan service and I would rather have new characters than trying to bring in the cast from Catching Fire and District 12 together. This extends to the ending with Peeta and Katniss and think it would be more impactful if the movie ended with Lenor's death and Haymitch screaming Snow's name or something like this

r/Hungergames • • 23h ago

Sunrise on the Reaping Strong Oscar contentions? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I know the past performances in Hunger Games are amazing and singular, each one. From Donald Sutherland and Jennifer Lawrence to Elizabeth Banks and Stanley Tucci, they deserved at least an ensemble performance award. While there've been no Oscar noms, I do think that needs to change for SOTR - and not just in costuming or score.

I'm not just saying this as a fan of the franchise, but also as a lover of film, the output of Jo Zada's performance is competing with this years performances from Matt Damon, Andrew Scott, Rob Pattinson, etc, at least for me. Speaking purely in terms of acting. Of course those 3 were able to showcase formidable performances in their respective stories, but with this type of story, I do believe it makes its way to the top. Not just in performance but in technicality as well and intention. If action films were lauded as much as dramas I do think that there would be some contention, and hopefully this changes that at least with For Your Consideration conversions.


r/Hungergames • • 17h ago

Sunrise on the Reaping Joseph Zada Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

I thought this was fun haha


r/Hungergames • • 8h ago

Memes/Fun posts Dear Suzanne Collins, please do NOT give us a book and movie about Finnick

8 Upvotes

Sunrise on the reaping emotionally wrecked me. I DO NOT NEED A BOOK AND MOVIE ABOUT FINNICK! FOR THE SAKE OF MY MENTAL HEALTH, DON’T DO IT!!!

Edit (cause I fear it needs to be said because people won’t get it unless it’s told to them): this is not a serious posts. It’s a light hearted funny ha ha post, not meant to be taken seriously.


r/Hungergames • • 22h ago

Prequel Discussion The "expert axe thrower" had no idea how to use or throw axes.

0 Upvotes

Was anyone else taken out by the fact that the actor who played silka had no idea how to hold or even throw axes in the movie?

Every time she threw an axe, there was no weight behind it at all, even the stance was off.
All I could do is laugh every single time she "threw" an axe or appeared as a "threat."

The menacing silka from the book was robbed by how foolish this portrayal seemed.


r/Hungergames • • 8h ago

Sunrise on the Reaping Two parts? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Anybody else think that they should have split this movie into two parts like mockingjay because of the sheer amount of substance and double the tributes?


r/Hungergames • • 12h ago

Sunrise on the Reaping The biggest retcon in Sunrise on the Reaping Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I think the worst concept about SOTR is that we see him being best friends with Burdock Everdeen. Since I read that name I kind of knew where the ending plot was going, but instead of feeling excitement it just kind of felt really forced upon the story.

Instead of adding up depth to the character, it just seemed more like he's cruel. I really like the fact that after his games everyone he loved died, so he became alcoholic and grew more distant with everyone around him. But the fact that he saw his best friend's daughter selling food to survive at such a young age after the dicease of Burdock, and didn't care enough to help, not in the slightest, but had no problem going to the Hobb to buy more alcohol and get wasted, it's just cold even for him.

Not only that but after Katniss is reaped, the only thing he has to say after she asked for an advice it's just "stay alive", in the most sarcastic way. Yes, it's an iconic dialogue but only used as a joke after they have formed a relationship. The moment he said that, Kaniss was just hating his guts and you can't blame her for that. She and Peeta had to show him their skills just so that he could at least care to try to help them.

Yes, he did sobered up in the end in order to get sponsors but only because he saw a potential in Katniss of winning. Yes, he eventually open his heart for both Peeta and Katniss, but it's because throughout the story they get to know each other better and go through hard times together. I understand the fact that he was afraid of getting someone else he loved hurt, but not only he didn't tried, he was a sarcastic asshole about it.

All of this negative traits I've mentioned are things that I really like about Haymitch's character arc. He was in this self centered destructive path, never wanting to get attached to the next couple of tributes because he knew they where going to die, so he stopped trying and got to be a very neglectful mentor. Seeing him grow out of this behavior at least when Peeta or Katniss needed it (most of the time) feels really appealing and makes him more realistic.

The problem with the prequel is that it makes it feel like the connection between him and Katniss doesn't feel genuine anymore like in the original trilogy. Haymitch just happened to care since the beginning and all of his behavior contradicts his thoughts in the epilogue and definitely not in a good way.

I want to know if someone thinks the same ways as me, or if there's a good narrative side of this retcon.


r/Hungergames • • 17h ago

Sunrise on the Reaping Now that we’ve seen the movies let’s rank them Spoiler

3 Upvotes
  1. Catching fire
  2. Hunger games
  3. Mocking Jay part 2
  4. Sunrise on the reaping
  5. Mockingjay part 1
  6. Ballad of songbirds and snakes.

I was so disappoint with SOTR mostly because the book was so amazing and the movie just fell so flat.
Also, I never read the ballad of songbirds and snakes so I have nothing to compare to besides, what I saw in the movie. Mockingjay part one is low for me just because I feel like it just should’ve been one movie.


r/Hungergames • • 12h ago Bravo

Trilogy Discussion Effie Trinket is a bad person

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

THIS IS ABOUT BOOK EFFIE PLEASE READ

Effie Trinket is a fundamentally bad person and being brainwashed does not excuse her corruption. To began i want to clarify i am not talking about the movies nor do i see Effie as purely evil. I am aware she is complex and i am aware she is a repersentation for the brainwashing of the capital. However, while i can recongize her complexity she is still a bad person.

Effie is a women who stood by for 25 years watching the games occur. No i do not expect her to single handely dismantle the capital. While she may of believed they were for the greater good i dont think that is an excuse to particpate in a eregious cycle of violence. In one Effie's first scenes she mocks children who died and how they ate. These children died in the games she watched them die and she knows their past yet she still finds it acceptable to joke about. At the age of 45 to 50 can brainwashing really be an excuse to particpate in a cycle of death then be ignorant to children who are being sent to their deaths?

Every bigoted behaviour or belief people hold can come from brainwashing when they were younger. These negative beliefs were installed in us from a young age but after a certain point its your own responsability to be better. I mean after watching kids meet a brutal end time and time again how can you be justified?

A real world example for this is racism and slavery. If someone lives in a racist society where slavery is normalized and is taught that does not make it okay. It would be normal to think the people supporting slavery and racism even while brainwashed are bad people. Furthermore, would Effie not be completely aware what happens to victors after they win. Her title is an "escort" and its clear from Drusilla's line "you have no idea whats in store for you" to Maysilee. Escorts know alot about the innerworkings after the games and are not children unaware of everything.

My point is Effie while brainwashed and ignorant is not a good person by any metric and people need to stop making excuses for her. Effie willingly chose to be apart of this cycle and while we can talk about her complexity its time we stop pretending shes a good person or making excuses for her.


r/Hungergames • • 15h ago

Sunrise on the Reaping SOTR Just seen Spoiler

0 Upvotes

SPOILERS
I just saw the movie tonight. Huge fan of the book cried throughout
HATED the movie. The lack of details made it impossible to have any emotion during the more difficult scenes
No bloodied crowd going into the shops
No birthday cake
No Wyatt snoring
No sleeping together as a team
No bread scene
Training centre lack of bleachers
No food being stolen
Chariot scene didn’t even feature haymitch holding louella
No “it’s okay to cry in front of mags”
No training scores
No potato pack
No parachutes
No glass or ice cream or anything
No baked potatoes
The volcano didn’t have any major impact there was no ice or diamonds or whatever
The first visit to the forcefield didn’t even make sense
No mini truce
Welly being killed off screen
No rabbit
No bread and milk or Lucy gray
And the epilogue was awful the iconic ending paragraph is what gave it all feeling instead it just felt uncomfortable.
Why did they make Peeta fat?

I get they can only put so much on screen but they didn’t put ANYTHING I don’t mind the lack of gore - the other movies have never been gory. But this was BORING.
It was like whoever wrote the film never even glanced at the books the title is the same and they kept some plot and characters but that’s all
This film has been overhyped and under delivered
I was buzzing for it. And it was shit. The acting was good. The direction and script was awful
If you’re a fan of the book don’t go see the movie I feel like the franchise has been ruined


r/Hungergames • • 8h ago

🎬 HG Actors Discussion Lenore and Haymitch had no chemistry. Prove me wrong

0 Upvotes

First of all, it starts with them just looking into each others eyes, being cheugy, and kissing each other over and over and over again for like the first 15 min of the movie - and even with all that being so intimate, I felt nothing for their relationship. There was more intimacy and love in Maysilee and him tending to each other’s wounds than whatever kind of love they were trying to convey in those first 15 min. It felt so plain. (I’m not linking him and Maysilee romantically, more so that love - platonic, romantic, or familial, can be conveyed in much minor, but impactful ways that are truly felt.)

Unfortunately I also just felt nothing coming from Lenore’s actress. It was so obvious when next to Haymitch’s who’s like .. hyperventilating, snot coming out of his nose, face all wet with tears. Every time the camera panned to Lenore I had no idea what emotions she was feeling. It was so bad that at the end, since I hadn’t read the book, I thought that Snow’s gang had Hijacked her and she was pretending to cry when they reunited again and was gonna be like SIKE I’m actually out to get you. She had a crying face on but no tears (maybe like 2 or three) so it looked kinda disingenuous .. even as she was actively dying. (again in comparison to Haymitch it just stood out a lot) I’m sure she’s a great actress and maybe there was a reason behind the lacking - but it was so so so noticeable.

Idk that’s my take and I’m wondering if anyone else saw it too or if you can explain why that was the case.


r/Hungergames • • 13h ago

Sunrise on the Reaping Box office. A billion?

Post image
42 Upvotes

What’s crazy is this really could have been the first hunger games movie to cross a billion if they just gave us a better cut of the movie. I wouldn’t say the fan base is split but argue around 30-40 percent are more negative towards the film. Do you think they release the 4 hour cut to get butts in seats to cross a billion or fall on there sword? Me personally I don’t think a longer cut of the film will ever see the light of day because if it does well and is received better the studio and Lawrence don’t want to look bad. Thoughts?