r/JUSTNOMIL • • May 17 '25

MOD ANNOUNCEMENT Increase in moderation due to bot posts

213 Upvotes

Due to the increase in the number of posts and comments by bots and spammers we’ve increased the filter parameters temporarily. This will likely cause legitimate posts created by members using throwaway accounts to get caught in the filter. The mods will do our best to release legit posts as quickly as possible. Feel free to use Mod Mail to request a review. This will not irritate us it will let us know you’re a real person. 😊

If you spot a post you suspect is from a bot don’t comment calling out it is a fake that will result in your comment being removed. Use the report feature and ignore the post. Commenting at all gives the post karma which is what they are farming for.

The mods appreciate your help.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

Megathread ✌ Thank you, JNM! Megathread

4 Upvotes

Are you a lurker who has benefitted from the support and advice given to others? Tell us about that here!

Are you an adult child who had to deal with a heinous cunt and has come out the other side with the support of the sub, whether through running out of fucks to give, getting in touch with your inner granite, becoming a copy editor of the information disseminated to her, or voluntarily ghosting her? We want to hear about it!

This thread reoccurs on the 20th of each month.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 7h ago

RANT (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Ambivalent About Advice I found out the truth about JNMIL’s therapy.

70 Upvotes

In my eyes, it’s a little proof that JNMIL doesn’t truly wish to improve herself, but it may be my biased bile-tinted glasses.

She’s emotionally immature, creates drama to play her starring role as the victim, says cruel things like they’re “jokes”, and clingy to her kids in what I would say is an unhealthy way. DH actually had to parent her as a teen which ended up being an incredibly dark period in his life.

She has also never got to know me, and is only superficially nice in order to make herself not look like that bad guy. She treats me badly in more subtle ways. For example she asked me for a list of gifts and then decided none of them were personal enough for him (even though they are literally items DH has expressed an interest in), and decided she’d buy something on the fly when she was next out with DH.

DH is numb to her BS, and whilst he still loves her, is beginning to feel like spending time with her is only happening to placate her so she doesn’t complain.

Back to the actual story. She had a minor medical procedure (she’s okay) that required local anaesthetic, and she apparently reacted so hysterically just before the anaesthetic was applied that the doctor outright refused to perform it and wouldn’t unless she got on-the-books therapy.

Well she got the therapy and promptly refused to keep going after “getting over the hump” (and yes she did get the procedure done in the end) though she has the time and financials to do so, and even after multiple family members (my DH included) have outright with seriousness told her to get therapy.

The whole time I thought she was finally going to work on herself after multiple people telling her this, and improve, but finding out this information has made me think she still doesn’t see it and will never change. Drama after drama she apologises and says she’ll do better, changes for a little bit and bounces right back to her awful behaviour patterns. Her apologies mean absolutely nothing now.

It got me thinking: So a medical procedure is good enough to finally get some therapy, but actively complaining about your life to your family members and making them miserable with your drama to the point they’re saying you should see someone isn’t?

Maybe an ultimatum is the only push for her to do it? She thinks the relationships with her family are so great and “family is everything” but it’s hanging by a thread.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 6h ago

RANT (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Advice Wanted MIL CAN'T STOP

26 Upvotes

Hi. I gave birth 8 months ago. Since that day my MIL asks my husband 5 days a week " how is the baby, how he sleeps, what he ate.. etcetc", nothing else about her own son. I find this controlling and intrusive and I was adressing it to my husband but he is so blind that his respond was " it s no big deal". We had a huge fight because I feel he is a 30y old baby and I really feel that he needs to bring some limits to the table when it comes to her. She constantly buys stupid stuff and I was asking him many times to tell her not to, because one day I have to be the bad mom and tell the kid "no, you can t have this...".

My relationship with her was ok until she found out I am pregnant. Sincer then she is very toxic, negating me constantly and so on.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 43m ago

RANT (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Ambivalent About Advice MIL says she loves her grandson but acts like she DGAF about him

7 Upvotes

Day in day out she would only stay glued to her phone and TV, and by glued i mean SHE WILL NOT LIFT HER HEAD FROM HER PHONE EVEN IF SHE HEARS THE BABY CRY. I told my husband to talk to her about this behaviour and she kinda did change only when my husband's around. Once he's gone to work, it's back to pretending the baby isn't even there. My husband would ask her to take videos of our baby at home and MIL would tell me to record her playing with the baby. When she's done, she'll go back to her phone and TV.

I have an auntie that helps around, but we both couldn't even catch a break with MIL. This lady had 3 sons but has no clue how to even hold a baby 😭 she would yell asking for help while i'm in the bathroom cos she can't roll the baby from his tummy to his back. I taught her how to roll him, even how to make his formula and carry him with a carrier but she just said "nah, i'm not used to it."

MA'AM WITH ALL DUE RESPECT, WHAT ARE YOU USED TO DOING THEN???

I'm not asking her to TAKE CARE of an infant child but she could at least show that she cares like how she constantly tells her friends??? One time i had to take a quick trip to the office, when i came home, she was so immersed in celebrity gossip, i asked her where my son was and she panicked bcs she didn't know where he was. Thankfully the auntie took him to sleep upstairs 😡

You know what she talked about soon after? Celebrity gossip 😭😭😭😭😭


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 15h ago

RANT (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Ambivalent About Advice Contrary Mary in "I'm sorry, BUUUUT..."

94 Upvotes

Greetings my lovely Ladies/Gents/Other Humans. It is I, Your Friendly Neighborhood Sweetie, here with a new story. So sit back, get your furry/featherly/scaly babies, grab a stiff/soft drink and let's get into the tale! (Tw: Swearing, Blood test mention, shots mentioned)

Yesterday, I went to my doctor to get blood tests done. I went on the scale there....I gain 7lbs. A combination of that, along with anxiety, lack of sleep and tiredness due to the Blood draw (and complimentary flu shot, How lovely! heavy sarcasm) didn't really make me a "delight".

So, onto today. CM is in "fine" form, bugging me about my weight and other sundry topics. She then tells me I am "getting older" and "going though The Change" (I am 35 female (?) Btw). This REALLY isn't helpful, so I decided to talk to her.

I do not remember most of my words (because tired) so I told her what she says isn't really helping me. I do recall saying "sometimes you are as helpful as a bucket of rocks to the skull". That when she said "I am sorry, BUUUUTTT..." I told her that what she was saying was discouraging and demeaning, so she needed to stop it. She looked offended so I added "take what I say with a grain of salt or a spoonful of sugar. Just stop it."

Thats pretty much it. Tonight after walking the dog, I planned on taking a long,hot bath.....If only extremely hot water would melt off fat....


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 40m ago

Advice Wanted She admitted to hating me, and Christmas cancer?

5 Upvotes

She admitted it and Christmas Cancer (Again)

This is a post I posted somewhere else. In this one though I did add extra info that I forgot to add on the other post.

This is LONG! I’m sorry, But I hope it’s organized I tried my best to explain stuff and give context. This is a post where I’d love some input and like genuinely would appreciate someone who’s experienced this type of MIL and a SO who even though they see their mom as bad and see it more and more, still can’t stop themselves from going, did I do enough, say enough, to try and help them change. I’m afraid he will always feel like he should have done or said something more or different. And any advice on how I can like mentally and emotionally manage his reaction to the texts with her. And also it’s a rant and a way for me to clear my thoughts.

Side note: I’m pregnant with our second child, our first son! And we haven’t told anyone specifically because of her. But my hormones are making me more emotional than usual. And I wanna enjoy this pregnancy without feeling I have to stress about her or worry she’s gonna stop by or whatever. My last pregnancy she was insanely awful. To the point I blacked out from what she did. Still need therapy from it and I was diagnosed with PTSD due to her, and that whole situation, along with the other crap she’s done. He sadly can’t tell his family cause one they tell each other even if you ask them not to, and she also pries. And will literally manipulate things out of his dad. So he can’t tell his own family, if he wants to make sure she doesn’t know. It’s sad. He has told friends that he heavily trusts and knows they’d never say anything.

The only reason she was reached out to, was because she tried to break no contact and she was being directly confronted about it and my husband also wanted to see if she’s changed. I know she hasn’t but he said he needed to see and needed to let her know this is her last chance and that if she doesn’t admit this he’s done, but that if she ever does change, they can then have a relationship.

MIL admitted to blaming me and hating me. But instead of taking accountability and admitting it’s her, she then says “Oh it must be C (her son my husband) who has the problem.” Which she said in text, so it isn’t something we have to question if she truly said it or not. But then, after stating that, she texts me and apologizes for whatever hurt she caused me, offered to bring tacos and said what can she do to fix it. And then in texts where my husband is calling her out directly and not letting excuses be played, she then tries to bring me into the mix and said “I hope T (me) doesn’t see this, she’ll be sad” idk if she was trying to now make my husband out to be the bad guy now that she knows he’s the one all this time and not me or what and is now trying to be nice to me.

I assume she did this because she was told all the years she thought I was supposedly trying to push her out the picture, I was actually the one trying to fix things between her and my husband so they could have a relationship because he’d wanna just ignore her and put his head in the sand and talked about himself cutting her off fully if she didn’t change, he just wouldn’t tell her that. Which at the time I thought well hey tell her so she knows and maybe she’ll change, BOY WAS I WRONG!

But then I eventually obviously stopped trying after I truly seen her for what she was, and that caused the 2 year no contact that is still in effect. But she also found out that during the 2 year no contact, I had healed enough to possibly open the door and see if she’d changed after no contact, but it was my husband who had said no he’s not ready and wants to heal more. So she directly got hit with facts of her son being the one keeping her in no contact, when the one she blamed was the one willing to open the door if her son was ready to.

Now she did admit to being rude and mean, never respecting our boundaries, trying to control us, pushing her opinion on things she didn’t agree with, being judgmental, never listening to us, and even as I states blaming and hating me and even said she’d wished she’d of treated me better, and that she should have treated me better. But, once she was called out for more stuff, nothing crazy, my husband wasn’t gonna address really deep wounds yet, he just wanted the basics to be out of the way, to see if she’s gonna show change. Like he had to make sure she admitted stuff like the being rude and mean and controlling and pushy and disrespectful, and hating me to even move forward. Cause you can’t move forwards to fix a relationship with someone who doesn’t even like your wife and wants to break you guys up. So it seemed like she was doing good, but then she said that her job made her rude to us all those years, he said how that job didn’t make her hurt him as a child, and expressed just a few things, nothing super crazy, just how she had hurt him and basically did the same stuff a few years ago while at that job that she did to him as a kid. So he took her excuse out the picture. Cause now she will have to go, you’re right, it was me. I am the problem. But instead She then immediately started getting angry. No I’m not surprised but sad because I know my husband was hoping for something different.

She brought up the time her ankle got twisted by him supposedly and she had to call her dad on him. Then she got called out and he said, “oh you mean the time you were forcing me on a school night to stay up all night to do whatever you were trying to make me do, to the point you were ripping the blanket off me to force me out of bed physically, and when I went to call my step mom, you literally jumped on top of me physically attacked me trying to rip and break my phone that I paid for, and when you did your ankle got hurt, and then when I ran out the house you called your dad to come and talk to me to convince me to comeback home.” She said nothing to that and completely dropped that topic, and then started saying she has no idea what he’s talking about, when he also proceeded to say “I wasn’t even gonna bring all that type of crap up, but since you wanna,” and brought up how she locked him in a dog cage as child and was high, and how the story on that has changed from her so many times. One minute it was cause her drug dealer came by and she got high and didn’t want him running around and the next it was cause she owed money and he was in there for ransom. Really weird crap, but when he brought it up, she said she has no idea what he’s talking about. And he said really cause you talked to Me and my sister about it and you even claimed to be sorry for it. So she directly lied. The only reason it was even brought up again, was because it was still something that was heavily unclear on what happened and still was traumatic and he needed closure and healing on.

It just seemed very convenient for her to admit those things over the phone years ago and in person, but over texts she denies it all. Said she doesn’t recall ever saying how he can’t amount to anything without her but then said sorry about it. It was weird that the abuse that was mentioned she directly said she doesn’t recall, but then also says sorry for being that type of person, mean and rude. The only thing she directly admitted was that she hated me and blamed me, but that wasn’t even full responsibility, because she then said it was my husband who was having the problem with her, not that she was the problem. She directly tried to gaslit him into believing she never those things or admitting anything.

But now, months later, he made a statement that maybe it was too aggressive. Cause maybe emotions were high and it was too intense with the texting. But no, it just was very direct. Never called her names, never even said she was a bad mom, never even brought up really intense details about childhood abuse cause that’s just not something for that time. Simply was calling out some stuff that happened, like the cancer scare, the hating and blaming me, the control and disrespect, the never listening. Things didn’t start getting intense till she felt she was called a bad mom cause he said your job didn’t make you hurt me as a kid.

Anyway that conversation went bad because once her excuse was demolished, and not useable, she flipped a switch back to how she always was. Blame shifting and gaslighting. So then he said don’t call me or text, or send things in the mail (she did that during the 2 year no contact) don’t drive by our house ( did that and tried to get my husband to talk to her when she seen him outside) and that she’ll never see us ever again.

We even went through the texts again, cause I truly was like okay if it was harsh maybe she only snapped cause she felt backed into a corner and it was too much at once, it made me question if maybe I was wrong. And at the beginning of rereading them I felt bad, she had admitted some stuff, it wasn’t super direct but it was different. It was her usually way of admitting stuff. It wasn’t sorry If I did this or that, it was I did this and I’m sorry. And she did seem different in the way she address stuff. I started to feel bad. Maybe she had changed, but then went I got the part where she flipped the switch and blame shifted, it started to become obvious what was happening.

But stuff seemed odd as I was reading the beginning of stuff because just a weeks ago or two, my husband dad said how the entire time we haven’t talked to her she’d been calling him constantly telling him to tell us to talk to her. But in texts, she said she was okay if we weren’t ready and that it’s on our timeline

I’ll erase names and put C for my husband and T for me and S for his older sister. Also where she said the hospitals name I’ll just put hospital and for her towns hospital I’ll put town town hospital

Her text: I will be honest. I did think it was T before and realized it has to do with you. I hope that you feel better and I am not trying to cause problems for you or anybody. If you aren't ready to work things out yet the it's okay. We can do it when you are ready. If you think you are ready, just let me know. I am open to now or whenever you want. I wanted to make sure you guys were ok after that derecho and see if you needed anything. I wanted to check the day it happened and I couldn't wait anymore. I had to know you guys were ok. I am sorry for making you feel that way

This was weird to me because she talks to his dad and knows his dad talks to him, I know for a fact she could have asked him and she probably did tbh, like I highly feel she did. So the excuse of having to see if he was okay, just sounded really stupid. Had she said I knew you were okay but the thought of you being hurt affected me and I really wanted to see you myself because I for real thought you could died (the storm was so bad there was people who didn’t make it), then perhaps it wouldn’t have been that bad. But idk, I still think her trying to talk to my husband off guard was not okay. She could have just drove by, and not said anything. She knows her doing that makes everyone uncomfortable.

Her text: I know I didn't listen to you guys about how you wanted things and I was judgmental. For that I am very sorry. I did not agree with so much and imposed my opinions a lot. I will not do that anymore. I am really sorry C. I am really sorry to T if I made her feel any less than she is worth. I hope she will give me a chance too.

Her text: If you guys want anything, I will get it. You do not have to talk to me until you are ready. Would T like anything special to brighten her day? The baby? U?

So in those texts she’s acting like she’s so calm and waiting on us, but behind the doors she was hounding my dad in law for him to try to push us to talk to her. And not tell us she was telling him to do it. It eventually told us, and then told us that she stopped doing it now, which he said she stopped idk a month ago or so, so sometime after my husband told her to never talk to us again. But then he just told my husband a week ago, that she is now having open heart sugary for a stent to be placed (I just found out that stent surgery isn’t open heart, so she may have lied, or the dad miscommunicated that) and is also taking pills for breast cancer. After she told us in texts a few months ago, that she had no cancer. And that she had AI to thank for it. Which idk if I truly believe that at all. Idk how AI caused you to not get cancer. So he also had said in texts how it was very uncalled for when she first tried to say she had cancer two years ago, the way she went about it, was so awful.

My husbands text: Why did you call me out of the blue to say you might have had cancer? You do realize I blacked that out, and I never replied to because I was mad how you did that and it made me black out and so I literally ignored it all! You don’t just call someone after not talking and say that, and then never respond and tell them nothing because you’re mad. That was awful! You don’t tell someone news like that without someone around them to make sure they are okay. I’m mad about all that! I was not okay, I know S told you not to do that and you did it anyways. I wish you’d of done that differently. You should have had S talk to me and or at least made sure that I had T around to make sure I was okay. Like that really messed me up. Doctors don’t even call and tell people that type of information without making sure they are around someone to keep them okay. I’m mad how you handled that, during and after. That was not okay. It felt like you did it on purpose to try and get me to talk to you, and then when I didn’t you just never called back. I still can’t believe you did that to me. You just don’t drop that type of potential news on someone.

Husbands texts: It was really suspicious. And it still is. It really feels like you did it on purpose. I’ve had people ask me if you lied about it even, just to play games with my head.

Husbands texts: Because it doesn’t make any sense that you’d do that.

Her texts: I am not the same person I was a few years ago either. I was working at that toxic shop and I think it was making me like them. I have never worked anywhere in my life that had so many mean people in one place. They do say birds of a feather. I did not belong there. I have been away from there for 3 years now and feel better. I also was going through A LOT of medical stuff that I finally land hopefully got resolved. TBH if AI had not helped me figure it out, I would've got cancer. Again, these aren't excuses. I am explaining stuff. I completely understand and I am sorry

Her text: Sry about that. I have had a very long road with many different types of medical stuff going on without resolve from these damn drs around here. They scared me. I thought I had breast cancer. I went to hospital and did a lot of research and medical stuff and got better. It is a long story that I will explain one day.

Her texts: I didn't know what to think or expect when I did surgery and wanted u to know in case something happened. I was really scared and I hope S and T never have to go through any of that or anything, especially with these drs around here. A lot of them do not know what they're doing. Town hospital had me pretty angry

It just didn’t make sense to me. Because she claims she went to her towns hospital but then in another text said she went to one that I directly told her about because I mentioned it when I told her my dad had a double lung transplant. So I’m not sure. Of course maybe she was at her town and got referred to that one, but idk. Her story about that cancer scare when we went no contact 2 years ago had had different stories. Sure maybe her memory is foggy and maybe what her daughter told us she said wasn’t fully correct cause sometimes people mix stuff up. But it was one where it was them taking a sample of her breast, and how it’ll be like a month or more before they do anything for her, and before she even gets the results back also(which I found out by people on her that that’s now how doctors handle possible cancer. They usually handle it asap not within months and that results come in quickly cause they check it asap since it’s such a big medical thing) and then another where it was a whole surgery thing. First it was said it wasn’t a whole big thing, now she’s telling that it was. And she’s on meds for it now and even is having a heart stent put in? It just seems so odd on the timing.

Just odd that it’s near the same exact time of the year where she said the cancer thing 2 years ago when she seen we went no contact, and now it’s around the same time again, when she seen that her attempt to get us to talk to her failed and that my husbands dad wasn’t gonna make my husband talk to her. And even he told us that she eventually told him to stop and not try anymore to get us to talk to her, which he said was a month ago I think or maybe two, it was around the time where my husband said never to talk to us again. Not fully sure when she actually said to drop it finally or when she actually claimed this new medical thing but it was after those exchanged texts. But he told us about the medical thing like a week ago.

It seems clear to me that she hasn’t changed, even lied, tried to keep us in the dark about her trying to make dad in law make us talk to her, just idk. But my husband thinks that the texts were too aggressive. Which, when I relook at them, and I’ve asked opinion on them, I’m told they are just direct. Instead of going, “hey you hurt me when you blamed my wife.” It was “I know you blamed my wife, I’m angry about it, and if you don’t correct that we can’t talk.” Idk if she gaslit him into believing it because in the texts after she’s told that her job didn’t make her hurt him as a child, she said he was mean. So idk if that’s what’s making him think that, or if he’s got that idea on his own due to just how your brain seems to work after the abuse of a narcissist. Or both. Idk.

But idk what to say to him or do at this point. It’s like
No matter how many times she shows her truly colors, and does what she said, he always thinks he hasn’t done enough, or maybe if he’d of done things differently, maybe if he talked differently or said something else, always the what ifs. To the point he’s blaming the texts that were direct and honest for being aggressive when she began blame shifting. When never once was she called a name, ever, she wasn’t even called a bad mom. She’s the one who assumed that and started blame shifting. I know I’ll hear that I can’t make him see it, that I can’t get him to understand. But it’s becoming so heavy. He’s gone so far to try to make it seem like she’s innocent and changed that he even once tried to blame me until he seen how she texted me. But even though he seen that, seen her directly admit she was hating and blaming me and wishing she’d of treated me better, he still, STILL finds away to make it seem like she has changed and maybe it was the texts being to aggressive that made her blame shift and be the old her again. It’s always someone else, even himself, never her. She could probably directly say to him that she wanted to abuse him and admit it all full on, and he’d still find away to make her the victim. And try to fix her.

I think it’s starting to get to me. Because I’m wondering if he’ll ever really realize it. I just idk if I can’t keep on with that, even if she did change, I think he’d need some serious changing himself to even try to have a relationship again cause he could very well enable her if she even did make a mistake after changing. It’s like, everyone else is the blame but her. Even when he knows she’s messed up and did wrong, he still tries to go but what if, or well maybe she’s if we said this or that and said it that way and not that way, it starting to feel like even though she isn’t in our lives that she’s somehow in our lives. It’s truly hindering how I feel towards him. I’m trying to be understanding that it’s only even 2 years of no contact, and that she’s really really good and playing his mind cause she’s for it for 31 years, but man, it’s taking a toll. I love him, deeply, I just feel like it makes me not trust him. Because he’s even pointed fingers at me just to avoid admitting and seeing it’s her. And I cannot and will not do that again. He has apologized for that, but it’s like, would he do that again, if it came down to having to see her being bad or me being bad if it’s another situation where only her or I can be right and one of us is the problem. You’d think with her admitting she did blame and hate me and how I called it all those years and he never once believed it, that he’d start to wake up to the reality. He already wanted to text her with the idea of seeing if she changed, after breaking no contact, and also to let her know if she changes they can have a relationship. It’s like it’s never enough.

Idek why she finally admitted to hating and blaming me though, idk if it’s cause she knows he heard that she hated and blamed me and was caught, and knows if she’d a lied he’d of ended the convo right there or what.

Basically: MIL admitting to hating and blaming me, texts between her and my husband seemed like they were progressing, and she was changing, but when her excuse for abuse was taken, she flipped and blame shifted and gaslit, he said maybe the texts to her were to aggressive and that’s why she flipped the switch, she is again claiming cancer but adding a heart stent being placed as well, he can’t seem to ever blame her and always has what ifs about how they last talked, it’s starting to get to me!


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 17h ago

Advice Wanted Visiting In-laws after 5 years of NC

50 Upvotes

I’ve never really been welcomed by my in-laws, particularly my MIL and her older daughter (my husband’s half-sister).

My SIL has always resented her mother’s new family (my FIL and husband). She would refuse to visit whenever I was around and even emotionally blackmail my MIL into not celebrating Christmas with me. I’ve never met my SIL or her family, but she has consistently influenced and controlled the family dynamic, creating a lot of tension.

However, my MIL wasn’t just an innocent bystander. She was toxic in her own right, actively contributed to the problems and created a lot of the drama herself, while also enabling her daughter’s behaviour.

Eventually, I went NC with my in-laws. I’ve never had a relationship with my SIL or her family, and my only occasional contact was with my FIL.

Now, my husband and I are planning a holiday nearby. My FIL is unwell, and since we live abroad, my husband wants to spend some time with him. I completely support this and would also like to see him.

We might be staying in my MIL’s basement during the Christmas period. I’m okay with basic pleasantries and courtesy towards her, but I have no interest in rebuilding a relationship.

I’m planning to take gifts for my FIL, but my MIL’s birthday also falls around the same time, and we’ve been invited to the family Christmas party.

I’m struggling with a few things:

**MIL’s birthday:** Honestly, I don’t feel like getting her anything. The last gift I gave her was initially appreciated but later belittled, followed by unnecessary drama. However, I come from a gracious upbringing and find it difficult to visit someone’s home without taking a gift. I also don’t want to regret not getting her anything later. Would a generic, inexpensive gift be appropriate rather than something thoughtful or elaborate? Any suggestions?

**Christmas party:** Should I attend or politely decline, considering the wider family will be there?

**SIL’s children:** She has two young children, and I genuinely like kids. I’d quite like to take something for them, maybe a LEGO set for the boy and a small silver necklace for the girl. But is it worth the potential drama, especially since I’ve never even met them?

I basically want to be civil, exchange pleasantries, give any obligatory gifts and enjoy my holiday without getting emotionally involved or pretending the past never happened.

How would you handle this? Would you take the gifts, and what would you buy? Am I overthinking it?


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

New User 👋 CW: My MIL knew our newborn baby was in bad shape, but still expected my husband to leave the NICU to visit her in the ER. Months later, she still thinks she’s the victim.

184 Upvotes

Don’t accuse me of being a bot, English is not my first language and I needed help so this didn’t turn into a full novel.

I have spent six years dealing with my MIL’s behavior, but one particular incident has fundamentally changed the way I see her.
I would genuinely appreciate some outside perspectives, because even after everything that has happened, I struggle to comprehend how someone could behave this way.
Our newborn son’s fight for survival
When our youngest son was born, he developed serious breathing difficulties and had to be admitted to the neonatal intensive care unit.
What should have been one of the happiest moments of our lives became one of the most terrifying.
Our newborn baby was struggling to breathe. We were frightened for his life, and we had no way of knowing how things would turn out.
I had just given birth, hadn’t slept for approximately 48 hours, and was physically and emotionally exhausted.
My husband was trying to support me while dealing with the possibility of losing his newborn son.
Then my MIL decided that she needed him more.
The emergency room incident
On the same night, my MIL had been bitten by a venomous snake and eventually went to the emergency room.
She had waited approximately six hours before seeking medical attention and then spent several more hours waiting to see a doctor.
I am not suggesting that a snakebite isn’t serious or that she shouldn’t have sought medical care.
But she was already at the hospital, receiving medical attention, while our newborn baby was in intensive care.
Despite knowing our circumstances, she repeatedly expected my husband to leave us and come to see her.
When he explained that I hadn’t slept in two days and that he needed to stay with his family, she responded:
“If [your wife] is sleeping, surely you don’t need to sit there watching over her every minute. There are staff members whose job is to help.”
She also asked:
“Is it [your wife] who can’t manage without you?”
As though my husband staying with his critically ill newborn was somehow an unreasonable demand from me.
She even compared the situation to when her own parents had been hospitalized, saying that all the siblings had gathered at the emergency room.
When he didn’t come, she told him:
“I’m disappointed that you couldn’t come and at least say hello.”
And:
“I’m tired of always having to manage on my own.”
My husband was not out enjoying himself. He wasn’t ignoring her because he didn’t care.
He was sitting in a neonatal intensive care unit, terrified that his baby might not survive.
The part I find almost impossible to forgive
What makes this even more disturbing is something she admitted afterward.
She told us that she had actually researched the survival odds for a newborn in our son’s condition.
Think about that for a moment.
She was concerned enough about his condition to look up whether he might survive.
She knew how serious the situation potentially was.
And yet she still expected his father to leave him.
I cannot reconcile those two things.
How can you acknowledge that your newborn grandson might die, yet still consider your own need for a visit more important than his father’s presence?
When my husband later described that night as the worst night of his life, she responded:
“You thought it was the worst night of your life. Mine wasn’t pleasant either.”
That sentence has stayed with me.
Of course, being bitten by a snake and spending hours in the emergency room is frightening and unpleasant.
But why did it need to become a comparison?
Why couldn’t she simply acknowledge what her son had been through?
Why couldn’t she show compassion for her grandson, her son, or me?
Her explanations afterward — but never an apology
When confronted about her behavior, she has offered explanations involving her own distress and how incoherently she was writing that night.
She has expressed embarrassment about how her messages came across and has said that she understands why my husband stayed with our baby.
But she continues to return to the fact that he could at least have called her.
She has never offered an apology for what she said or for the pressure she put on my husband that night.
Not once has she simply acknowledged the hurt she caused without returning to her own circumstances or disappointment.
And that is something I find particularly difficult to accept.
I don’t expect her to undo what happened. I know she can’t.
But I would have thought that realizing how frightening that night was for her son, and how serious her grandson’s condition was, might have prompted some genuine remorse.
Instead, we are left with explanations, justifications and the continued implication that my husband somehow failed her.
The bigger picture
Unfortunately, this incident was part of a much longer pattern.
For six years, my MIL has repeatedly reacted with anger, accusations and guilt whenever my husband has made decisions she dislikes.
She has blamed me for decisions that were entirely his own.
More recently, the situation escalated dramatically. She has insulted me, accused me of destroying their relationship, contacted other family members and repeatedly tried to contact me despite my attempts to disengage.
She has even suggested that she might stop taking essential medication because she cannot bear her son’s decision to distance himself from her.
My husband has now chosen to step away from the relationship. He has also started seeing a psychologist to work through his experiences.
He has been very clear that this is his decision.
Nevertheless, she continues to blame me.
Where we are now
Our son survived, and I am incredibly grateful that we get to watch him grow up alongside his older brother.
My husband and I have a loving, supportive relationship, and we are united in wanting to protect our children and our family.
But I still find myself thinking about that night.
I think about how vulnerable our baby was.
I think about how frightened we were.
And I think about how his grandmother knew enough to research whether he might survive, but still expected his father to leave him.
I don’t think I will ever be able to see her the same way again.
I am not looking for advice on how to repair the relationship. My husband has made his decision, and I respect it.
What I am struggling with is understanding how someone can behave this way, repeatedly hurt the people closest to them, and still insist that they are the one who has been wronged.
Has anyone experienced something similar with a parent or MIL? Particularly someone who treated a serious medical emergency involving a child as though their own need for attention should take priority?
And how did you eventually make peace with the fact that they might never acknowledge what they did?


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 19h ago

Anyone Else? Making up problems in their heads

38 Upvotes

Does anybody else just kinda ignore their MIL (and FIL)? I don't mean in person, I mean all the "issues" they have with everything.

My husband and I just brush it off because it's so pointless to us and meaningless. Like they make snide remarks or do weird things, who cares. Not us. They make a big deal out of small things and we basically ignore it and move on.

I don't even react when they get worked up about some small thing (like who does what on Christmas).

In my opinion my MIL and FIL waste a lot of time fretting and discussing other people's lives (who don't care) or being hurt or angry while honestly we didn't do anything so couldn't care less.

It's just interesting how one sided it is. They have nothing better to do than build up odd resentments while nobody else in the family thinks twice because it's ridiculous.

We care about normal things like being kind and loving and welcoming, spending time with them, etc. While they are still upset about some random from two years ago or something.

Hope I'm more chill when I'm in my 70's.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 23h ago

Am I Overreacting? My in-laws are suddenly warm now?!

70 Upvotes

Ever since Halloween, I've been super distant and less engaged around them. Like way more than normal. I limited myself to saying hi or bye and if I spoke I would avoid eye contact. My in-laws are very intuitive, but they are the type where they are not sorry for their actions nor will they ever ask you what's wrong. So I wasn't sure how this was going to turn out because this is all new to me.

Here are some things that I've noticed over time:

- still say hi and bye to me (understandable)

- they're still active in the group chat (understandable)

- random direct messages from my MIL with pictures/videos of my girls, no text, jus media (but I don't respond anymore)

- MIL trying to make conversation with me at my house, like asking me questions which are new!!

And here's the kicker for me from this last visit. My husband and I came over to their house to drop off the girls. Initially they weren't home, (we have keys) so we waited in the living room.

When they arrived I stayed in the living room and wasn't expecting my MIL to come to me to say hi AND a kiss on cheek gesture. And again in the kitchen area she asked me if we had any plans that night.

Uhhhh so what's going on? Again this is all new to me and I can't tell if this is a PA "I'm better than you, I'm polite" or if they're that emotionally stunted.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

MIL Problem or SO Problem? I ended up crying in a hospital bathroom with my newborn because of my in-laws. Four months later, I still can't get over it.

838 Upvotes

I need to get this off my chest because I'm honestly at my breaking point.

My relationship with my in-laws has been difficult since pregnancy. My MIL made inappropriate comments, including bringing up my husband's ex and how she supposedly thought our relationship wouldn't last. There were also constant expectations about where we'd take our baby and how involved his family would be.

But nothing prepared me for what happened after I gave birth.

I had just delivered my first baby vaginally, had stitches from an episiotomy, and was physically and emotionally exhausted.

There was an issue with the hospital bill because my partner didn't have enough money to cover it. My mother stepped in to help, and somehow my MIL thought it was appropriate to comment that I wasn't contributing anything financially. Mind you, I'd lost my job during pregnancy and had already used my savings to help with expenses.

Things escalated. I specifically told my partner I didn't want to see his mother, but she and my BIL showed up anyway.

A confrontation broke out involving both families. My BIL raised his voice at my mother, my MIL started crying, and my partner went to comfort HER.

And me?

I was locked in the hospital bathroom, crying while holding my newborn baby. Just hours after giving birth.

That was supposed to be one of the happiest moments of my life.

Instead, it's a memory that still makes me want to cry.

Four months later, my MIL continues making comments about how I raise my baby, expects visits on her terms, and occasionally acts as though she can make plans involving my child without asking me.

Recently, my partner announced that his brother would be our baby's godfather without discussing it with me. Yes, the same brother who disrespected my mother during that hospital nightmare.

When I objected, he told me I could choose the godmother and he would choose the godfather.

That argument pushed me over the edge.

I told him I wanted to separate.

And suddenly, after months of feeling unheard, he showed up with flowers and a card thanking me for everything I do.

Why does it take a woman reaching her breaking point for her partner to finally acknowledge her?

The hardest part is that I lost my job during pregnancy, I'm currently caring for our four-month-old full-time, and I don't have the financial independence to simply pack my bags and leave.

I'm exhausted. I'm hurt. And I'm starting to realize that my biggest problem might not even be my MIL.

It's having a partner who doesn't make me feel like we're on the same team.

Am I wrong for still being so hurt by what happened at the hospital? Would you be able to move past something like this?


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

Advice Wanted Threatening w court and harming herself

169 Upvotes

UPDATE: MIL and her sister escalated after we went no contact, now threatening court (Belgium)

Hi all, some of you might remember my earlier post about my MIL. Things have escalated and I could really use some advice, especially from people in Belgium.

Background: my partner and I have a 7-week-old son. On the advice of my psychologist, we asked for a 3-month break from contact with my MIL. She has a long-standing alcohol problem (she's somewhat sober now, but not fully), and there has been a lot of conflict, including during my pregnancy.

What happened since:

- After a stream of messages, calls and accusations, I blocked MIL and her sister (my partner's aunt) everywhere. I'm convinced MIL attacks us through her sister. They wind each other up.
- The messages and calls then kept coming through my partner, even though he stopped responding.
- An uncle was sent to ask whether my partner could take our baby to MIL without me. I find that disgusting.
- My partner's brother asked if we weren't overreacting. My partner explained everything to both of them, and they chose to stay out of it. They still downplay her behaviour, though ("you know how she is").
- The aunt threatened legal action, and MIL texted that in Belgium grandparents have the right to see their grandchild. That right exists, but only when it's in the child's interest.
- The aunt wrote that they would "put me in a bad light", that I'm irresponsible with my baby because of my "mental health problems", and that my partner only chooses me because I drag him into my problems. MIL then claimed she had nothing to do with that "harsh" message. I don't buy it.
- Then came what I think is their last resort. The aunt messaged my partner that if his mother harms herself, "which won't take long", he alone is responsible. MIL did make a suicide attempt in the past. It happened the same evening I told her she couldn't babysit our future child one day a week because of her drinking. We weren't even trying for a baby yet. She was hospitalised afterwards.

What hurts most is that I'm accused of deliberately shutting them out. Early in my pregnancy I made them a box with a onesie, a card, the test, socks and a bib saying "congrats, you're going to be grandparents". She was angry she couldn't come to the gender reveal itself, so the day after I bought blue gifts for his whole family and they opened them together. I've cooked for them. That's not someone trying to cut people out. The distance came from months of fights, comments and how they treated me.

They also claim I blocked them first and that they only started messaging after. That makes no sense. How could they have messaged me if I'd already blocked them?

I honestly wanted to try rebuilding contact after the 3 months. After all this, I don't feel safe around them anymore. It's really hard for my partner. He has now blocked his mother and aunt everywhere, and hidden his socials from his dad, who complained that I had blocked them.

As for court: I've contacted my legal expenses insurance, just in case. Their house is unhygienic (rat droppings, maggots), there's a dog with bite incidents, and there's the drinking. They also have financial problems. I can't see a judge sending our newborn there, and I doubt they'll spend the money and energy. But maybe I'm just trying to reassure myself.

It also feels sad to me that MIL hides behind her sister and lets her send bullying messages. The aunt isn't even the grandmother, yet she acts like she has a claim on my baby. Apparently I'm "irresponsible", while MIL saying she hoped my baby would end up in an incubator so they could see him was "well meant".

My questions:

  1. Belgians, or anyone who knows: do you think they'll actually go to court? What are the chances they'd get visitation?
  2. Will it calm down now, or could they show up at our door? (If they do, I'm calling the police.)
  3. I'm dreading the holidays. To them, I'm "ruining Christmas" and keeping their grandson away. How do we protect our peace?

TL;DR: We took a 3-month break from my alcoholic MIL on my psychologist's advice. She and her sister responded with harassment through my partner, court threats, accusations about my mental health, and finally blaming my partner in advance if MIL harms herself. We've blocked them everywhere. Will they take us to court, and will this calm down?


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

Advice Wanted MIL wants to monopolise Christmas Eve and Christmas Day. I think she needs to accept that she can’t have both.

662 Upvotes

MIL’s birthday is Christmas Eve. Every Christmas Eve she commandeers the entire day with my partner, literally from about noon until 10/11pm. This wouldn’t be such a big issue except the invitation is not extended to me; I am actively not welcomed in her house and it upsets me to be alone on Christmas Eve under those circumstances.

Then the next day, Christmas Day, she expects my partner to spend most of the day with her too. Again, I’m not invited, but even if I was, I don’t think it’s fair that I wouldn’t get to see my own family on Christmas Day. She expects to see him every single Christmas.

Our families are about an hour’s drive apart, so although it’s inconvenient we could theoretically drive ourselves between families however I’m not invited to her celebrations and also there’s the issue of timing. She always runs late for everything, and will weaponise it to keep my partner with her for longer. For example, two christmasses ago she told my partner to arrive an hour later than he’d agreed because she wasn’t ready. Then my partner came home three hours later than he said he would because their Christmas dinner conveniently overran. When he tried to leave she guilted him. This means that if we were to split Christmas Day between both of our families there’s a good chance my family would get the “leftover” time on Christmas Day and we’d essentially be beholden to her lack of schedule.

Unfortunately we can’t host our families for Christmas for a couple of reasons. The first is that if I’m not welcome in her house, she’s not welcome in mine. The second is that my partners extended family always spend Christmas together and are basically a package deal; in his family, it’s offensive not to invite everyone. Although I get on really well with the rest of his family, we’d struggle for room. Additionally, his grandmother has recent significant mobility issues and wouldn’t be able to travel the hour to us or use our bathroom (upstairs).

This is where I might be a bit shitty, because although I understand that it’s rubbish to have a birthday so close to Christmas, I feel like she can’t just continue to have the two most important days of the Christmas season and at some point the two events will need to be combined if she’s unwilling to include me (his partner of 10 years). We are both only children, and I don’t see why she should monopolise the Christmas period. My current proposal is that he visits his mother on Christmas Eve, he and I spend the entirety of Christmas together as our own family, and then we see my family on Boxing Day.

At the moment we spend the afternoon (or whenever his mother decides to release him) with our respective families and spend the evenings together. Basically I don’t see him for much of Christmas Eve and for half of Christmas Day.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

New User 👋 Update from original post about reactive mother - she cancelled the family vacation

277 Upvotes

Original post here

UPDATE: My mom told me never to speak to her again, so I blocked her to take some space. Now she's canceled our family vacation.

Following my previous post, I decided to block my mother after she repeatedly told me never to speak to or contact her again. After years of conflict and emotional exhaustion, I felt I needed some distance.
A few days later, my father called and initially tried to minimize the argument she and I had despite him witnessing it. When I reminded him of what she'd actually said, he eventually acknowledged that she hadn't handled herself well.

A couple of days after that call with my dad my mother sent a text through my father's phone to our family group chat, announcing she was no longer paying for the Disney cruise she'd generously offered to take us and our children/families on. Instead, she offered everyone the opportunity to purchase tickets at her cost. She ended the message with something like, "[My name], let Dad know since whatever…" — seemingly referencing the fact that I'd blocked her (I assume).

I absolutely don't feel entitled to a free vacation, but the timing and passive-aggressive delivery felt retaliatory and frankly petty. I actually haven’t acknowledged the text to her. I didn’t want to give her the satisfaction of a reaction.

My sister has since told me that my mother feels she "can't do anything right" with me. I recognize that I've become increasingly frustrated and reactive toward her over the years, but I'm exhausted by a relationship where expressing any sort of hurt feelings from her behavior or a simple boundary seems to result in defensiveness, hostility, or some sort of consequence—usually her icing me out until I practically grovel for things to be resolved. And, it’s ALWAYS on me to initiate repair regardless of who escalated things or crossed the line.

How do I navigate this moving forward? Am I wrong for blocking her and interpreting the cruise cancellation as retaliation? I genuinely don't know how to maintain a relationship with her when every disagreement escalates to this level. Like, I’m tired. I’m a single mom with a toddler working full time and trying to make ends meet. I don’t have time for it.

I'm open to suggestions and hearing where I might be contributing to the problem, too.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

RANT (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Advice Wanted MIL wants to be besties after baby was born

476 Upvotes

I’m in a situation that’s just been making me feel gross. MIL has never been interested in getting to know me/wanting to do stuff together before the baby was born.

She literally only texted me one to two times a year. She also shit talked me the ENTIRE TIME we were dating. Saying I made my husband quit baseball in high school (I didn’t), called me a crazy catholic and to not have sex with me bc I’d ruin his life, don’t propose to me, don’t move in together, etc etc. Fine, whatever I’m ok with not having a close relationship.

Now that baby is here she keeps trying to have “girl bonding time” with me but it’s clearly just a way to try and see baby. Yesterday she texted me saying she has something for baby and how she can come over today either the morning or afternoon, just let her know what works better. I said today didn’t work great but maybe we could get together over the weekend when my husband is off work. She didn’t reply and instead called my husband upset that I don’t want to hang out with her alone.

Like??????? I’ve been with your son for almost 12 years and you have NEVER had an interest in me before baby was born. Just because I had a baby doesn’t mean 12 years of shit talking me and history gets erased. It just feels gross that she’s now pretending to care about me and “girl bonding time”.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

Advice Wanted Need advice

23 Upvotes

So I just found out I'm pregnant with my second child. My husband and I both very much want this baby and it was planned but I am terrified of my inlaws reaction.

My MIL is one of the most narcissistic people I know right above my own mother. Now I've spent my whole life with my mom so her comments roll right off my back, but I can't say the same with my MIL.

Sparing unnecessary babble my MIL has always intruded into my husband's and my life and makes everything about her. For example I just gave my son his first large haircut and she told me she cried all day about it because it was "his whole personality" and gave a long story about how she still hasn't forgiven her mom for cutting her hair as a child.

Now I KNOW she's not going to be happy about this pregnancy for a number of reasons. 1. Because her oldest son (who is her angel child) hasn't had a kid yet. Which is by his own choice btw. And 2. Because her and my FIL have this impression that we are dirt poor. No matter how many times we explain to them that we aren't doing bad (we make 5k a month between the 2 of us and live in a more affordable state; note we are originally from NY). Like we are definitely not rolling around in money but we also aren't necessarily struggling. We would not have planned another child if we didn't think we could handle it.

I guess my main thing is how do I manage their reaction when they find out? I have always been a people pleaser and take it incredibly hard anytime she says anything negative or treats us poorly (she is known to give the silent treatment sometimes for weeks at a time).

I'm trying to keep this pregnancy as stress free as possible and I'm already incredibly anxious just thinking about telling them to the point where my BP was high today when I went to urgent care.

Sorry for the long post. Any and all advice is appreciated :)


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

Advice Wanted I don't want to be your friend

99 Upvotes

My MIL hasn't done anything particularly egregious (yet). For a little context, she has a complicated relationship with my husband / her son; it's long-winded, but involves her second husband being an addict and my husband requesting to go live with his dad when he was a kid. (She's since remarried and her current husband is a perfectly nice guy.) She desperately wants a closer relationship with her son, but without doing any deep and meaningful reconciliation (i.e. he's proposed therapy but she refuses and doesn't take accountability).

Anyway, I get the sense that she's hoping to have the kind of relationship she never had with her own son with her grandchild. My son is 2 y/o and special needs (+medically complex).

MIL moved to be closer to us about a year ago - they're about an hour from us. They want to see us constantly. I get texts / phone calls / voicemails almost daily of her asking if she can come over for a visit, or if we can come out there (and spend the night). I'm glad she at least asks rather than popping in.

She's definitely disappointed we don't see them more often (I'd say at this point it's 3-4 times a month - and that's with us turning them down many many times). She wants to go shopping with me, to go get our nails done, to treat me to a spa day. It doesn't matter that I tell her that honestly, none of those things interest me. She really wants us to go to church with them, even after we bluntly said we're atheists with no interest in attending church.

Now it's gotten to a point where every time we see them, she complains about not seeing us more often, or that she doesn't feel like she really knows me (keep in mind, she does little to make an effort to get to know me through conversation - just tries to force her own interests on me). She frequently says to my son that "you need to tell your parents you want to see Grandma!" (He's nonverbal and has severe developmental delays, so I don't really worry about him understanding this, but it's still egregious.)

Another piece of important context: my parents live 3 blocks away, and we see them frequently and have always had a very positive relationship with them. She's definitely jealous of this.

In short, I don't know how to convey that I am simply not interested in any kind of friendship-level relationship with her. She doesn't interpret our repeated "no"s as indication that we don't want to do certain things with them. We're happy to facilitate a relationship with our son and let them visit / visit them with some regularity, but we have no interest in the extra stuff - especially when it feels so superficial. Am I being the asshole here? How can I get my point across WITHOUT being a huge dick?


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 2d ago

Am I Overreacting? Surgery

241 Upvotes

My nightmare MIL- dammit. I’m having a hysterectomy due to a variety of uterine health issues that have made my life miserable for years. I am no contact with my in laws because they’ve been cruel to me the whole time I’ve been with my husband. See my previous posts for some insane examples.

My husband told them I’m having this surgery. Yes, I’m upset about that, yes it’s been resolved ish.

His mom ‘offered’ to him via text to show up on my surgery date stating “I know it would stress (me) out and she wouldn’t like it but also you need support just as much as she does. She won’t even know we’re there”

I am so angry I feel like I’m going blind. My husband said no and shut it down but the insane disrespect through this ‘offer’, acknowledging that she KNOWS it would stress me out - the person HAVING THE SURGERY - and also treating it like some disgusting scheme with my husband and assuming he would agree to that is making me so mad I’m seeing stars. There’s absolutely nothing to be done about it, I’m already no contact, but I’m having a really hard time processing how angry I am. Like I just can’t get over it and it’s distracting me from my life, which makes me even more pissed off. They are on the security list at the hospital to not be allowed in but I can’t believe I even have to do this. Now on top of being terrified about this life changing surgery (and my first one at that), I have this extra thing on top of it that I DONT NEED. I just hate them and I don’t know where to put all this anger. 😭 no one’s ever treated me like I’m so invisible and meaningless before and it contributed to me being in a mental health program this year, it’s damaged my self esteem so badly. I can’t take it.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

Am I Overreacting? Pregnant, emotionally exhausted by family dynamics, and constantly feeling like I’m the problem. Am I overreacting?

8 Upvotes

I’m writing this because I genuinely need an outside perspective. I don’t know whether I’m being too sensitive, whether I’m communicating poorly, or whether I’m simply emotionally exhausted from everything that’s been happening.
I’m currently pregnant with my first baby, and lately I’ve been finding family dynamics increasingly difficult to handle.
I live with my husband and mother-in-law. My MIL does help around the house, cooks, gives me space in certain situations and does things for me. I genuinely appreciate those efforts, and I don’t want to dismiss them. But there are certain behaviours and everyday interactions that leave me feeling uncomfortable.
For example, recently there was a small incident involving food. She had prepared porridge, but I didn’t feel like eating it and chose to make dosa instead. I eventually ate the porridge later as well. However, I sensed that she was upset about my choice. This isn’t necessarily about the food itself. It’s about how even small everyday decisions sometimes seem to turn into situations where I feel I have to explain myself.
Yesterday, I decided that I would calmly talk to her and ask why she gets upset over such small things. I wanted to clarify that I never intended to hurt her feelings.
I couldn’t speak to her yesterday because of work, so I approached her this morning.
However, the conversation immediately went in a different direction.
She said I was making a big issue out of one small comment. Then she started saying that I’m difficult to communicate with, that I always speak angrily, that I react to everything and that I don’t appreciate what she does for me like a mother.
I felt extremely defensive because I wasn’t trying to have an argument in the first place. I was trying to communicate something that had bothered me.
What hurt me most was that instead of discussing the particular incident, the conversation became about my entire personality. Past incidents were brought up, and I felt like I was constantly being labelled as an angry, difficult and ungrateful person.
I admit that I became defensive too. I said a few things out of frustration that I didn’t intentionally mean. At one point, I even said that I wouldn’t stay there anymore. It was an emotional reaction because I felt cornered, not something I had planned to say.
My MIL then brought my husband into the conversation and questioned why he was just sitting there listening.
My husband feels that I should have communicated more calmly and shouldn’t have become so tense. I understand that point, and I’m not saying I handled everything perfectly. But I also wish he would understand why I became defensive in the first place.
This isn’t the only family situation affecting me.
I also have a difficult relationship with my own mother. She can be short-tempered, emotionally reactive and sometimes crosses boundaries. Conversations with her often turn into arguments, where I feel unheard or blamed. I’ve had to distance myself emotionally from my parents to protect my peace.
Now I feel like I’m experiencing similar emotional exhaustion in my marital home as well.
I sometimes feel like I’m caught between two families, constantly trying to manage everyone’s feelings while struggling to express my own.
My husband is generally supportive, and I know he is tired of these recurring family disagreements too. But sometimes I feel that he focuses more on how I should react rather than understanding what is making me feel this way.
I’m also pregnant, approaching my delivery, and I honestly don’t want to spend this important phase of my life feeling emotionally drained.
I find myself thinking that perhaps my husband and I should eventually establish a separate household. Not because I hate my in-laws or don’t appreciate their support, but because I want some privacy, independence and the freedom to make everyday decisions without feeling that I need to explain myself.
At the same time, I question myself.
Am I genuinely difficult to communicate with? Am I overreacting to small things? Am I expecting too much from people? Or have I reached a point where repeated experiences have made me defensive even before a conversation begins?
I don’t want to be ungrateful. I don’t want to fight with anyone. I don’t want to create divisions between my husband and his family.
I just want to feel emotionally comfortable in my own home and be able to express myself without every disagreement becoming a judgement of my character.
I’d really appreciate honest perspectives, especially from women who have experienced complicated MIL relationships, joint-family living, pregnancy and marriage dynamics.
Please feel free to tell me if I’m missing something or if there’s something I need to work on. I genuinely want an outside perspective rather than just validation.

Caption : Chatgpt( shared my query it created the draft)

TL;DR: I’m pregnant with my first baby and emotionally exhausted by family conflicts. I have a difficult relationship with my mother due to her short temper and boundary issues, and I’m now experiencing similar dynamics with my MIL. Small disagreements turn into accusations that I’m angry, difficult and ungrateful. I admit I sometimes get defensive, but I feel constantly misunderstood. My husband is tired of these recurring issues too. I’m considering separate living for some peace and independence. Am I overreacting, or is wanting emotional space reasonable?

Please share your opinion on this.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 2d ago

Advice Wanted MIL won’t stop texting us

138 Upvotes

My partner and I met at university around 7 years ago. He has a lovely family who I genuinely love, but the issue is that his mum can be quite overbearing.
My partner has since moved down to where I live and we’ve moved in together. Since retiring, his mum doesn’t seem to have much going on in her own life and, as a result, is constantly texting both of us. I have quite a stressful job and, honestly, it’s been driving me crazy.

The thing is, this isn’t a new issue. It was exactly the same when we were at university, although things calmed down for a couple of years afterwards. Recently, however, it’s started up again.
Last night, after my partner received around 8 consecutive texts containing various questions, including “why are you ignoring me?”, we realised it needed to be addressed.

My partner sent her what I thought was an incredibly gentle message, essentially explaining that we’re both very busy at the moment and can’t constantly have our phones pinging or be expected to respond immediately. He wasn’t rude or confrontational; he was simply trying to establish that we can’t always be available to text.

One of the most frustrating parts for me is that if he doesn’t respond to her, she’ll then message me asking questions about his day or asking me to pass things on to him. It makes me feel like I’m being treated as his secretary, and I really don’t want to be put in the middle of their communication.
She’s reacted quite badly to his message and has essentially responded with “fine, I won’t text anymore, I get the message”, clearly very upset and angry.

I feel like we’ve reached a point where something needed to be said, but now I’m left feeling guilty and awkward, particularly because I do love his family and don’t want there to be any animosity.
Are we being unreasonable for wanting a bit of space? How would you handle this, particularly when she starts messaging me if he doesn’t respond to her?


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 2d ago

UPDATE - Ambivalent About Advice Well, it took me 24 hours to “ruin,” the holidays

574 Upvotes

Hello, it’s me again.

I appreciated all of the advice on my latest post, but this update is so insane, that I need to share it with you.

It’s me. I’m the newly postpartum mom of two who went no contact with my MIL who relapsed during my pregnancy and blamed me for it. A couple of weeks ago, MIL’s sister (AIL) reached out to confront me about how much of a horrible person I was for keeping my kids away from MIL, wanting to destroy the family, etc. AIL didn’t know about the relapse and the horrible things that MIL said until she sent that message. MIL was trashing me to everyone because she was “ashamed” not to have any information about or access to my kids. We went no contact with AIL when she refused to take accountability for her comments and role in the fallout.

We have some plans to see my husband’s cousins (AIL’s kids) and their kids during the holidays. We asked AIL for space if she’s with us, to not make it uncomfortable for everyone, but she refused that. We originally didn’t tell the cousins about MIL’s relapse because they don’t have a close relationship with MIL, but they only see her at events or in passing. We came to learn that MIL was with one of the cousins and their kids recently. As suggested by some other commenters on my earlier post, my husband texted that cousin to let him know about the relapse.

Cousin received the messages. He told my husband that he would call us after his kids went to bed. Cousin wanted to know if we were “sure” MIL relapsed. She admitted to it multiple times in writing and blamed me for it, so we are as sure as we can be without seeing it ourselves. Cousin asked for the messages, and my husband forwarded them to him. There’s no damn doubt at all when you read them. AIL also confirmed to us via text that her sister (MIL) confirmed it separately to her.

Per cousin, AIL told her children that I’m badly suffering from postpartum depression/anxiety. I’m not, but that’s beside the point. Because of my “mental health issues,” I won’t let MIL have anything to do with my kids because I have a “preconceived notion” that she will put them in unsafe situations. My AIL has been bringing MIL to events and things with her (AIL’s) kids/grandkids because she’s been saying how alone and hurt MIL by my decision and because she thinks it would be good for MIL to show everyone that she’s not a safety concern, I’m just mentally ill. Cousin thought that MIL tagging along was a bit odd, but all her kids are currently no contact, and he can’t just tell her she isn’t welcome at the trampoline park on a Saturday. Apparently, AIL has also been bringing MIL around to his siblings/their kids.

Cousin didn’t want to inquire about this from us because he didn’t think it was true, but even if it was, you don’t go asking about anyone’s PPD/PPA. Cousin’s wife struggled pretty badly with PPD, so it’s a sensitive subject for him. Cousin apparently talked about this with his wife, and she told him she could definitely see how that could be possible (my MIL isn’t the best person as demonstrated and she’s had a fucked up past) and a symptom of PPD/PPA (which again, I don’t have and I’ve never had). Cousin and wife have been nothing but lovely.

Cousin was irate when he read the messages. AIL has been bringing a relapsing addict around her kids/grandkids, and for what? Because she’s so committed to making me the bad guy? Because I’m not “family”? Because I have the nerve to see something wrong with this? Cousin didn’t seriously think his mom would bring her sister (MIL) around his kids if she was a safety risk. Cousin doesn’t think his siblings know, because they would not want MIL around if they did, and they would share the information with him. He is going to reach out to his siblings to tell them.

After cousin got off the phone with us, read the messages, and talked to his wife, he texted AIL uninviting her to some earlier scheduled plans. When she asked why, he asked her when she was planning to tell him about her sister’s (MIL) relapse and why she was affirmatively trying to encourage a relationship with him and his kids after all the unforgivable shit she said to me. They aren’t close. Why would anyone want a relationship with someone who treats their own child like MIL treats my husband? She’s his fucking mom.

Cousin let AIL know that MIL is not welcome around him or his kids, and AIL will need to have a conversation with him before he decides what to do about her. He doesn’t know if he’s going low contact, taking a break or what, but she’s really damaged that relationship. He let her know that he either has or is reaching out to his siblings about this. AIL sees nothing wrong with bringing MIL around the kids, so long as she’s not drinking in front of them. I don’t know what that means, but I think MIL is still on a bender, she’s either not drinking “in front” of the kids or she’s drinking it from her water bottle/covered cup.

While we had AIL blocked, we switched it to “mute” so we would still have her messages, but we wouldn’t get the notifications when she texted us. Well, I apparently am “ruining” the holidays for the grandchildren, just want to destroy husband’s family, and everything MIL said about me turned out to be true. We won’t be responding, but it seems like good evidence for the fuck you binder.

At least MIL won’t be alone for the holidays. She can sit with AIL, her chief enabler, and discuss how everyone else (but principally me) is terrible.

It’s me. I’m the JustNo apparently.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 2d ago

UPDATE - Ambivalent About Advice Update: No more wedding drama, they un-invited themselves

514 Upvotes

Previous post: https://www.reddit.com/r/JUSTNOMIL/s/dNya43nQ3w

Hi everyone, thanks for all of the useful advice a few months ago. A lot has transpired the past four months since my first post. I showed my fiance this post recently & he was surprised but had mentioned wanting to do something similar in a shitty parents sub. We thought an update was warranted. It was validating to see similar stories with others dealing with impossible in laws or even their own family.

JNIL’s finally agreed to meet with us, however, this was an issue within its self. We wanted to have an hour talk about wedding planning, fiancé offered to show up after work with a pizza. This was shut down, JNMIL said we’re not allowed to visit their house & pushed for us to meet at a “safe space”. This meant a bar.

Fiance and I had discussed a game plan aka him telling them that his sibling (B, f25) could not have a plus one. B is the sister that has acted as the attack dog, constantly lashing out at anyone her parents point her towards. She is the epitome of a toxic person, you never know what you will get.

When they arrived it was fine, we had light conversation at the table. Eventually we got to the guest list, which went smoothly. We had even allowed them to put 4 extra people on. Then the mood changed quickly as JNFIL began his monologue.

He made a comment that he knew I was upset because of my face (rbf) and that he didn’t care. He went on and on about how family is the most important thing, they’ll be able to control B, her boyfriend wouldn’t be the plus one but a friend who we don’t know, how they have a huge family they can invite (they don’t have great relationships with their own extended family, and only about how fiance is not close with sister B despite her being “such an amazing & kind” person. yadda yadda yadda

He said they will have to rethink their involvement in the wedding if the daughters do not get plus ones. Either by implementing a cash bar or token system?
I asked if that was a threat. He said no but we’ll have to talk about it. My fiance was holding his own and repeated no. He reiterated that his relationship with B is independent from his relationship with his parents. JNFIL continued to repeat himself & get loud. People at the bar started to look at us. He thinks because he’s louder, he’s in the right.

I have held my tongue throughout the whole relationship, I believe each person in a relationship should handle their respective family issues. But I spoke up, asking JNILs why my family can give without expectations but they have ultimatums? JNFIL looked at me smugly and said “I guess we have different priorities”. I said that’s pretty obvious. I said it’s sad you even have to “control” your daughter at the wedding, you cannot control another adult & haven’t done a great job in the past. JNMIL kept saying they don’t want to be the villains but how B is treated on our wedding day is unacceptable & she is talking about not coming.

I used the bathroom, they accused me of texting my fiance while in the bathroom. Which I denied, even if I did it’s none of their business? We got the check and left. They said we’ll talk again about this.

It was radio silence for 3 months, fiancés parents resort to silent treatment when you’ve upset them. B reached out asking what she did wrong, fiance ignored. He wanted to tell her to scroll up on the messages & reread all the awful/crazy shit she says.

Fiance called recently and told them of our decision to pay for the alcohol & rehearsal dinner ourselves. JNMIL repeats again and again how fiance treats B, how he is not involved with their family, & only calls when he needs something (the addresses of THEIR friends they wanted to invite)etc. she hands phone to JNFIL who proceeds to yell at fiance, they aren’t moving forward unless JNFIL & fiance sit down and talk man to man. Fiance says no, he’s never been so embarrassed of their actions. He says that their behavior towards me is unacceptable & started yelling back. JNFIL hangs up.

Fiance gets a text the following morning saying something along the lines of “we don’t want to be involved in the wedding in any way, we will not be attending to avoid any drama our presence brings, fiance has chosen not to be apart of their family, blood is thicker than water, love mom & dad”. He did not respond & will not. Fiance is obviously upset on some level but is also done with the drama & asking his parents to act like adults. He will remain no contact, they won’t be involved in our lives. Even if they rear their ugly heads again, apologize, or decide they want to attend the wedding.

Fiance has decided to reach out to the individuals he wants to attend off the guest list. JNILs have begun to spin the situation, I told fiance the people that truly know us won’t believe the lies. It’s exhausting even after all of this the rumor machine aka JNMILs mouth keeps running. We even heard from his other sister they had a tarot/psychic party where they brought up us & the rift. Aka an opportunity for pity from their friends. She has since reached out to fiance with sappy posts & saying she loves him. It’s all been ignored.

Fiancés other sister (who is also a bridesmaid) has been supportive to a point. She thinks what they’ve done is shitty & realizes the gravity of the situation. But still has lightly pushes for fiance to fix it.

They should be studied, I have never met people like this. It’s like they are in their own reality. The lack of power & control over their adult son was too much for them to handle I guess.

I’m so grateful for my fiance through this all, he has dealt with them for his whole life. He is an amazing partner & friend.

Sorry this is so long but a lot has happened & context is needed. We are finally enjoying wedding planning. We’re looking forward to the holidays, no more split time, complaining, passive aggression, & drama.

Happy holidays!


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 2d ago

RANT (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Advice Wanted Had my first baby and both mom and MIL are driving me crazy

75 Upvotes

My husband (31M) and I (31F) just had our first baby. This is also the first grandchild on either side so understandably everyone is excited. Neither of our siblings wants kids or even to get married so I’m sure that is contributing as well. Baby boy came unexpectedly early via an emergency csection after I went in for reduced fetal movement. We have now been home from the hospital for 2 days and both my mom and MIL are driving me crazy for different reasons. In our culture a new mom is not supposed to do any work other than taking care of baby for 40 days following the birth so one of my mom and MIL has been here at all times. They both live close by so they basically just take turns.

My MIL:
She honestly means well and is very helpful. She has been baby crazy since we got married 4 years ago so I’m not surprised by how excited she is but she is so involved that’s she’s up in EVERYTHING. To be honest this is par for the course for her personality I just don’t usually have to deal with it constantly. She cannot sit still at all and talks constantly. I generally am a little more introverted and generally very independent. I value my alone time and space which is why this is driving me up the wall.

She is constantly needing something to do. Laundry, cooking, cleaning which while all very helpful, can only be done so many times per day. When it’s not these things she constantly wants to wait on me hand and foot, and give me a million rules about what I can and can’t do. I’m not allowed to use the stairs (2 story house so I’m basically confined upstairs), don’t sit like that, go lay down, constantly trying to make me eat or drink something around the clock even when I’m trying to sleep. I’m not allowed to drink anything cold, but also not anything hot, room temp or warm only, can’t eat anything with spice, don’t lift anything (I literally was moving a plate). Yesterday she even said don’t talk otherwise your head will start to hurt. Not allowed to go outside, baby is too cold, put a hat on him, swaddle him like this and on and on.

Baby wakes up almost immediately after being put in the bassinet so someone is up with him basically at all times and she will come in basically constantly asking if she should take him now if he makes any noise even if I’m just trying to change his diaper. I am breastfeeding but supplementing with formula so I can get a little bit of sleep and because my milk hasn’t come in yet fully so she is constantly telling me she will just feed him formula and to hand him over so I can rest. She will tell me to put him in the bassinet so he will wake and she will have an excuse to pick him up. When she does have him she does not stop talking AT ALL. Constant baby talk at all times. Which petty, but for some reason annoys me.

My mom:
Even before this she has always had a victim mentality where the glass is always half empty. I understand where it comes from because she’s had a hard life but it bleeds into other things. She always tells me I don’t have any time for her or talk to her despite me usually being the only one making an effort while she never calls or tries to make plans with me. She normally doesn’t really overstep and is also being helpful, cooking/cleaning, taking the baby at night so me and hubby can get some sleep. There’s two things that she has done that annoyed me.

First, I didn’t want to tell anyone baby’s name beforehand because I knew we might get some negative opinions and I am sometimes easily distressed/influenced but those kinds of things. Despite this her and my sister were the only people who knew what two names were considering and she never said anything about them. On day two I was in bed resting but I overheard her telling my husband that we should have gotten opinions from at least immediate family because the name we gave my son has a “bad” meaning if you break down the syllables in our native language. This really upset me even though she didn’t say it directly to me. What was the point of saying that after we already named him?

The second thing is that I have, from the beginning, told everyone that we are not co-sleeping and if someone is taking the baby for a few hours at night not to sleep with him. Either hand him back or put him in the bassinet if you’re sleepy. Everyone has been on me saying they always slept with their kids etc. The third time it came up I snapped at my mom and said “you guys got to do it your way, now let me do it my way”. She didn’t say anything but I could see she got upset and then she left soon after despite initially saying that she would stay the night the first few days. I felt bad and texted her saying

“Sorry I didn’t mean to snap at you. The sleep thing just makes me anxious and I don’t want to do it”

She ignored it for over 12 hours and then replied:

“I am sorry too. You have the full right to raise him your way. I have already decided that I am not going to say anything as I know my value in my kids life . I still keep making mistakes of saying things. I will improve and try hard from now on. Everyday I hear that I didn’t raise you guys well. I forgot that How can I be a good grandma when I couldn’t be a good mom.You are a better mom.God Bless you and your family.”

For context I have never once said or implied anything about her not being a good mom. My sister and I are only a year apart but they clash a lot and she acts like everything either of us has ever said can be attributed to us both. This is likely something that they have fought about. I don’t even know if it’s worth replying or even what to say.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 3d ago

RANT (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Ambivalent About Advice MIL spent one night with our 10-week-old and decided he needed a feeding intervention. His doctors disagree, but Granny knows best.

617 Upvotes

My mother in law sent this text the day after we spent the night at her house with our 10 week old baby.

A little bit of context: this was our babies second time ever not sleeping in their own home. We were there with him but it obviously is still a new environment for him. MIL knows we were JUST at the doctors and baby is perfectly on trend with his measurements and weight gain for his percentile, his bowel movements are normal according to them, and we are excited because he is consuming a higher ratio of breast milk now than he was (which is our GOAL and why we’re working with doctors and a lactation consultant).

He was not in fact fussier, perhaps if you compare him to the sleepy potato he was when she saw him like 3 weeks prior when he was a NEWBORN. Also yes he was struggling to nap but omg could it have been because he’s in a new place and is overstimulated by a strange lady wanting to hold him for hours on end and not give him back to his parents? No we are not force feeding our baby formula after he’s full so he passes out longer and so she can hold him longer holy moly.

“Hey guys. Thanks so much for coming down our way. We really enjoyed having you all.

After you left our place —— and I were talking about how adorable ——— was, and I commented to —— that —— was definitely a lot more restless than the last couple of times we saw him. —— replied that he thought he was just hungry. Which got me thinking…. —— has the same leanness that both —— and ——— had at his age and he is not pooping much (because he is using all the nutrients up). He was more settled before when he was getting some formula. Maybe you should consider giving him a little bit of formula each day for a little while and see if he becomes more content. Just a thought… as trying it again should not hurt him, but it may make your lives easier.

Love to you all,
Granny❤️❤️❤️”

My partner and I basically said we’re not interested in unsolicited advice from anyone but the child’s doctor and lactation consultant. To which she replied with the classic “I’m just trying my best I feel like I can’t do anything right I just want to be a grandmother” etc- the classic all-about-me response that has nothing to do with any of the boundaries we set or any ounce of accountability for stressing out new parents who are, believe it or not, already hyper fixating on worrying if their baby is happy and healthy. She’s struggling to comprehend that why we don’t need any more noise from people who have not had a baby in 30 years, have no medical training, and how I especially don’t need added conflict with someone who has never done therapy in their life when I’m 10 weeks post partum.

Please rant with me and don’t hold back, I’m post partum and feeling spicy.

*also I have absolutely no problem with formula. It is just mine and my husband’s preference to offer our baby as much breast milk as possible.