I want someone to be mad on my behalf
I (25F) am in a relationship with A. We met on a dating app. A introduced me to D&D and a other TTRPGS. He introduced me to his close friend S as the best game master he knew. He added me to her TTRPG community. She is a core member there. I was excited to meet her. I spectated an online campaign which she was hosting and A was a guest player there. I loved the sessions because all the players there were so good. I spent a lot of time making props for his character (firbolg ears, brass knuckles, magic quill pen, etc.) so that he got to cosplay during the game. Now that I think about it, that is when the defensiveness started. He kept insisting that the game was interesting because S was a good dm. I didn't disagree but I kept telling him that the game was going so well because of the players. He said that I feel that way because I am not interested in D&D. That hurt because I had ruined my sleep schedule just to watch his games. He would, very frequently accuse me of being bored of D&D, and almost always added to that by saying, "Not everyone can be as passionate about D&D as me and S are".
A few days after that, S posted about hosting an online Candela Obscura mini campaign. A shared it with me. I signed up. I re-read a few of my history books and made a character with a really detailed, historically accurate backstory. A never really listened to it. And now that I'm writing this down, I'm remembering that A only ever discussed characters in details with S and never with me. Whenever he told me about his characters, they would be short and the discussion would end as soon as he got a few ideas or recommendations from me. Anyways, Candela Obscura started. I noticed right away how bad she was at writing stories. I never complained about it because every time I tried to talk to A about any loop holes and stuff, he would shut it down immediately. We only played 3 sessions of that game. S had cancelled 6 sessions in between. Everytime I complained to A, he would immediately shift the blame to other players, saying that this was how most campaigns died and S was an experienced dm so she must have understood that other players were bored. None of us were bored. All of us looked forward to those sessions. Even when S ultimately cancelled the game because she was bored of writing the story, A passionately defended her. The funny thing is, I had seen how during his own D&D games, whenever a session got delayed or cancelled because of another player, he would say that the player was not serious enough about D&D. And when I tried to explain to him that life happens, he would drop the conversation.
After Candela Obscura ended, one day, A asked me if I wanted to play an online D&D oneshot with him, hosted by S, because one player had dropped out last minute. He was strangely hesitant about it though. I happily agreed, made my character sheet within 15 minutes, and even dressed up a bit as my dragonborn. 5 minutes before the game started, A asked me in vc to "cover up properly because people complained that your cleavage made them uncomfortable". I immediately asked him who these people were because I no one in his D&D group had seen me by then. I had only turned on my camera once during an informal meeting with very few people, to show my kittens to them. A got extremely angry and absolutely refused to answer who these "people" were. And even during the session, he constantly texted me to keep my cleavage in check. When I told him that there were other women there with cleavage, he said that was different. I spent the whole session paranoid about people looking at my chest, unable to enjoy the game. I wanted to abandon the game but I didn't want to ruin it for other players. I was so distracted that I didn't even register it when other players called me pretty and adorable. As soon as the session ended, I went back to A and kept asking him until he was forced to tell me that it was S. Not "people" just S. This mf made me believe that multiple people who had never seen me in their entire life were discussing my chest and slt shaming me behind my back. He didn't see an issue with it and said that he framed it that way simply because he didn't want me to have a conflict with S or "misunderstand her intentions". That was my first experience with D&D, and I'm surprised that I still stuck to it after that. We fought about it for multiple days. I kept asking him why he didn't defend me. He kept saying that it wasn't a big deal and that he "doesn't worship me so he won't unnecessarily defend me or take my side". He continued this argument until I used the phrase "sexual harassment". He went and "talked" to her. He said that she said that it was because she grew up in a conservative family. That was it. That was the whole conversation they had. He continued to say that it was not a big deal. Back wheb we started dating, I had told this person about being sexually harassed for 5 and half years in school because 2 of my classmates had spread a rumor that I was a slt. I had told him that while hiding my face and crying in his arms. He remembered that. And when I asked, "did you not think that sl-t shaming me would be traumatizing to me?", and he said, "I don't understand what something that happened in the past has anything do with the present".
That conversation lead to more fights, and that lead to several jabs at me during random times, as if he was mad at me for having the audacity to be mad at her. He called me insecure in many different ways. I eventually pretended to forgive S just to stop the jabs. I was tired of crying after every jab.
Then I went to an irl Call of Cthulhu oneshot. I loved it. I befriended everyone on the table and we are still tight. Anyways, S told A that the players in that game had complained about me back seat gaming. I asked the dm of that game if there were any complaints about me and he said no. I talked to the players and they were offended that I would even think of them as snitches. Not only did they not have an issue with me, but two of them had decided to join that TTRPG community specifically because I was there. Moreover, they were all new players and did not know what backseat gaming meant. A didn't understand why S would lie. It was also the time when S had lost her job and I was trying to help her find one. She is a therapist. I'm not a therapist but I did study therapy under certain organizations as my PhD area is Trauma and Coping. I gave her name to the HRs of those organizations and one of them even asked for her CV. She never sent her CV. Even then, A kept implying that the problem was that I disliked S.
Around that time, A was going through withdrawal and was having depressive episodes, wanting a break from D&D. Deciding to not bother him, I directly texted S, wanting to ask about some upcoming game, mentioning that I don't want A involved. S said that she was going through a mental health crisis and didn't want to talk to me. I said it was okay and ended the conversation. The next day, S lied A that I wanted to gossip about A's depression behind his back. I was not expecting that and I was furious. I was so badly trying to make A feel good and S just railed over it like it was a game. This b-word did not give a single fuck about how a depressed person, especially her so-called "friend", might react to people discussing private stuff like. I realised at that moment, A is just a toy of S. She doesn't see him as a person, she sees him as free emergency crisis management supply. A, however, did not see the issue. He said that S knows him for a long time and I don't understand their bond. He believed (and still believes) that she would never do anything that harms him in any way. I stopped talking about it because the jabs had started again.
Then there was this huge irl event. I went there with A. I sat next to him during his game, and towards the end, I held his hand. The next day, S told A that I was getting too physical with him and that made everyone there uncomfortable. I reminded A that during the event, S was sitting on her boyfriend's lap and smoking hookah. A just said, "oh". He then said that S had said that another core member of the community had objected to the way I dressed. I asked A what part of my outfit was objectionable. He said he did not remember what I was wearing. I was wearing a hoodie, baggy jeans and a bunch of silver jewellery. I asked my friend who was a dm in the next table. He said that some girls at some point had commented on how cool my outfit was and that was it. The guy that S was talking about, had seen me only once and that too when my head was down (everyone was smoking and I have asthma). I told A what my friend said and he admitted that S probably made that up. I remember that I cried so much that day that I threw up. Meanwhile everything was normal between A and S. They would talk on call, text each other, watch a movie, etc. as if she was not draining his girlfriend little by little. I forgave everything just because long ago A had told me that after his 6 year long relationship ended, he met S and he left like he needed to protect her because of how fragile and vulnerable to look.
Now before I go to the incident that broke the camel's back, I need to mention that it took a long time for me and A to adjust to each other in bed. I was not used to intimacy and it took me many days to actually get wet. But after I did warm up to him, we would sometimes orgasm together and that made both of us very happy. He would say sweet things like I was his home and stuff. Then he went on a two day trip to S's area and lived with her boyfriend. He back all happy and cheerful, boasting about how much fun he had talking to S alone after such a long time. He ended the conversation with "Why do you dislike S again?". As if it was one small thing that happened which slipped his mind. When we got intimate that day, we finished together. He was not happy. He looked at me with pure disgust and said, "I pity you. You are so starved of affection that you will cum if someone even touches you a little". He was cold for many many days after that. He swore up and down that the trip he took had nothing to do with that opinion.
I went for another irl CoC oneshot with people from that community who I had never met before. My character was a woman from the mafia pretending to be a man. She was not trans, only disguised. The entire session was just people making transphobic jokes, not letting me finish my sentences, laughing at me etc. The dm skipped my turn multiple times. I barely got to say anything. After the game, S called me accusing me of backseat gaming again, saying that I make other people uncomfortable. When I stated mentioning the transphobia, she called me defensive.
Then a huge online pvp event happened. After I died in the game, I muted myself and went to sleep. I was very sick that day. The next day S called me and said that after I died, I was backseat gaming. I told her that I muted myself as soon as I died and I had no clue what had happened in the game after my death. She said very calmly, "No. I was there. I saw you myself. You were backseat gaming". She said that after any game I play in, she was going to personally ask every other player from the community if they had any issue with me and if any of them did, she would kick me out. I told A that S was lying about me again. He had a talk with her, came back and said "oh, she is just mad because you were backseat gaming". I reminded that I told him that my mic was off after I died and I had already told him that she was lying. He just shrugged and said that he forgot that part.
Things got a little better after he bought himself a new used laptop. We went on a date. In that date, he swore that he would never take a trip with S again. When I returned home, I was so happy. Then A casually texted that he was on call with S for 2 hours. I started shouting at him. He called me controlling and insisted that S was still his friend. The resolution of that fight was for A to tell S, without consulting me first, that she should never talk to me directly again. Yes, "me", not "him", once again acting like I was the issue and talking to her was the most innocent thing a person can do in this world. He even said he was aware of the fact that S was trying to manipulate him but it did not matter because he was not letting himself get manipulated. I asked him if he can ever tell S that he loves me more than her. He said "no" without thinking twice.
After his child (cat) died, he "cut her off". He didn't block her or anything. He just sent her a random paragraph, basically saying that he is the issue and it has nothing to do with her. That paragraph didn't even mention that he was never talking to her again. Whenever we discussed this after that, he would angrily say, "I cut her off, didn't I? Then why do you keep bringing her up?". I asked him a hundred times if I was the reason he cut her off and every single time he said "no". If he didn't cut her off as a solution to our problem, then why should I stop talking about it.
A couple of months after this, I brought it up again and asked him if he remembered what S did to me. He said no. I told him the whole thing from the beginning. He admitted that S is "bad". I know he doesn't belive in good and bad so that word is meaningless to me in this context. I asked him what he thinks about S or to describe S to me. He gave me silence. He said he would never be able to hate S as she is someone he used to care about. He said that if S ever approached him in the future, he would confront her. I said no. I said it is too late for a confrontation. If S did approach him, I need him to accuse her. And even now, throughout this conversation, he never once uttered one bad word about S. This person who had lashed out at me for being late for a movie, for not reading a comic in the right order, for talking during a cut scene, who sees himself as a very angry, who has been mad at me so many times on her behalf, had no anger towards her on my behalf. The same guy who threatened to slap his cat once when he ran away, had not one spark of rage for the person who hurt the woman he claimed to love. I remember that the only time he was slightly disappointed at S was when she had decided to marry her boyfriend. And that was it. Absolutely no other resentment towards S.
So I have decided that if he can be mad at me but not for me, I'll ask other people for their rage. Because I need it.
Now at this moment, we are having this conversation again. A himself is calling S a manipulative narcissist. He said he will not change his mind about her this time. I don't trust that. Even he thinks that if he ever sees her in person, he would instinctively try to protect her. But if he thinks for 2 seconds he can stop himself. He is currently mad at himself for admitting what he just admitted. I will see what happens.