r/Keychron • • 13h ago

Keychron Q16 HE 8K experience/question

0 Upvotes

Hi, I got the "Keychron Q16 HE 8K ISO" (in blue) 2 days ago.
This is a short review or (mostly) user experience that'll conclude in a question regarding software functionality (launcher.keychron.com, henceforth mentioned as launcher).

TL;DR: Primary issue I had is the Launcher makes it appear that LT(3,KC_CAPS) is supported, but it doesn't work on the Q16 HE because its firmware doesn't support this QMK functionality as far as I know, which I wasn't initially aware is QMK only (i.e. misleading on launcher) and documentation doesn't exist for that. Or my kb is indeed broken, which case I need feedback since documentation is not specific.

As for my kb needs: reason why I bought the keyboard was that I started playing osu! (a rhythm game) where I noticed that rarely I would get double taps, which I attribute to being if I don't fully release the key before pressing again I can be unfortunate at being near the actuation point in a way that makes it double tap unexpectedly. So I now had a reason to want HE switches and Rapid Trigger. And old mechanical kb is more than 8 years old.
I knew Wooting, but too expensive for what I wanted, and found Keychron an alternative recommendation which also should have good software/firmware.
I found the Q16 kb on a local reseller site that's 52% discounted, so 999 DKK or 134€.
There was also "Keychron K6 HE Wireless Tri-Mode" at 42% discount so 749 DKK, which I would've picked if I didn't find the Ceramic selling point of the Q16 more attractive/interesting. Both 65% layout, would've prefered 75% but on second thought I can manage with layer fn.
I only researched the V, K or Q representation and watched/read reviews of the Q16 basically and it seemed to be fine. Tried the launcher keyboard demo, which I now know is partially misleading unless you have QMK.
I knew the Q16 is proprietary firmware and not QMK, but not much else of QMK except it means open software and you can flash your own firmware giving you lots of functionality options. I now know that the proprietary firmware is very limited in contrast to QMK.

After using the kb: I like the Ceramic keys, the typing/sound and the HE with Rapid Trigger does solve my problem in osu!. I don't care about SOCD since it's banned anyway (CS2 and osu!).
I'm pleased with those features but will note I don't know any better, as in I'm ignorant and not knowing more niches regarding kb or experienced other high quality kb.

Now regarding the fact the keyboard is 65% and not 75%, i.e. missing f-row, then the default fn key beside the right alt key is too reachy for function keys, so need to bind fn layer for left hand.
CapsLock seems a common candidate. In the launcher applying MO(3), so while CapsLock is held it's layer 3. Problem solved, I luckily don't use CapsLock anyway so "good enough".

But I was scrolling through the launcher for other functionalities and was mislead to what I'd like to be able to do is LT(3,KC_CAPS), which is while held it is layer 3, but if tapped it's normal CapsLock functionality.
I expected it to work because the launcher shows as shortcut I can apply it as a key remapping in the sections. But that doesn't work, the key just does nothing when held or tapped. The launcher UI recognizes it as a valid functionality and says exactly what it's meant to do, but doesn't say it won't work on the keyboard. So I who didn't know about QMK is lead to think the keyboard is faulty, but the launcher just uses QMK lingo that it doesn't support on Q16.

Under (Keymap -> Layer) it shows shortcut to apply some layer switching.
https://www.keychron.com/blogs/archived/switching-and-toggling-layers-efficient-keyboard-customization
But only MO(#), TG(#), TO(#) is working ( # as layer number 2 or 3 ). And not LT(#,KC_SPC), TT(#), OSL(#).
I.e. it's very misleading that it shows you can apply those functionality to keys, but then it working with firmware.
There's also a (Keymap -> Hold / Tap) section, but none of those works either. This one isn't even in the demo launcher so even more confusing as in expecting it's a valid feature. (i.e. keycodes SC_LSPO, SC_RSPC, SC_SFTENT etc.)
They explicitly enabled that section and disabled others. It feels more like they have a template for their HE keyboards they just enabled without second thought.

Also the launcher has an ai agent/chatbot that's supposed to help, but it just gave a recursion limited to 25 error. Used ChatGPT to find out the reason it's because Q16 doesn't have QMK. Then tried to research whether I should've known this upfront, but I just couldn't find anything note worthy, except what QMK is, but not what it means for a keychron kb that doesn't support QMK in functionality except proprietary firmware and you have the launcher site, but NOT that some features on the launcher isn't always working and that you can map the keys but some might just not work.
Everywhere (reviewers) just says it (Q16) has good software functionality.
So I'm now writing this so others may be informed that the launcher is misleading for some of the functionality.

It's my experience, but I might be wrong in some aspects, so is there a similar functionality that works without QMK? Or confirm my claims. And I mean on the launcher and not a separate hotkey script application.

Overall, I'm happy with the keyboard. The ceramic keys, typing experience and HE switches with Rapid Trigger are all great. The software is good enough for my current needs, but I don't know if my kb is broken or otherwise find it misleading that the Launcher exposes functionality that doesn't appear to be supported by the keyboard's firmware, which ruined my day a bit so now I'm here. I know if I didn't see it in the launcher or there was warnings/errors I wouldn't have thought much of it and been more accepting that it's QMK boards only, but it's ambiguous.
I'm currently using MO(3) on CapsLock as a workaround. It works, but having LT(3,KC_CAPS) would have been more convenient.

What also would've been nice is if I could have 3 different layers, i.e. the default layer, a unique layer for CapsLock and another unique layer on fn button beside right alt. I did initially think I had the 4 unique layers as quick switch by key, but it's only 2 at once (Mac / Win physical switch behind keyboard). But that is documented, I just didn't notice.

(I'm waiting for Keychron support email.)


r/Keychron • • 13h ago

Keychron C4 HE

1 Upvotes

I found one for 60$. Does anyone here use it?


r/Keychron • • 14h ago

Keychron V3 Max broken on arrival?

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I just received my new Keychron V3 Max. I connected her via USB (and tried also via 2.4ghz). It looks like the whole key row with Q W E R etc. is not working. No input in the computer. The rest of the keys work perfectly. The firmware is up to date, and also no input recognized on the Keychron Launcher.

Anyone has encountered the same? Thanks...... :'(


r/Keychron • • 4h ago

Should i buy K10 HE standard edition directly from Keychron or wait for V6 hybrid ultra or just get something else?

2 Upvotes

For context. I want a full size or at least 99% HE keyboard that isn't too expensive like wooting two HE. I also want a good and frequently updated software, which i feel like keychron does have. 8k or not doesn't matter. I've tried Aula hero99 HE, the board and switch seem good enough but the software feel kinda buggy.

Every shop in my country only sell K10 HE special edition with gateron switch, but i want the standard version with keychron lime switch because it seem similar to graywood switch on the aula's one. The only option for me is to buy it from Keychron directly. But i heard that isn't a good idea.

Or i could wait for V6 hybrid ultra and hope that someone in my country will sell it.

Or just get something else.