r/MEPEngineering • • Aug 07 '26

Career Advice Anonymous Salary Database

25 Upvotes

r/MEPEngineering • • 21h ago

Question HHW Boiler Working Pressure / Relief Valve Mismatch?

2 Upvotes

I’m not sure if I’m misinterpreting something, but I’m looking at a heating hot water boiler submittal that says the max working pressure is 160 PSI but the relief valve pressure rating is 50 PSI. Will the actual max psi of the system be 50 PSI or 160 PSI? If it’s 160, won’t it never reach that due to the relief valve being set to 50 PSI? Am I totally misinterpreting this?


r/MEPEngineering • • 1d ago

Discussion contractors are now using AI to generate review comments and it's wasting my time

102 Upvotes

had a small restaurant project recently. pretty straightforward, nothing crazy. contractor uploads my drawings to claude or chatgpt or whatever and sends 100+ comments to the owner. owner freaks out thinking there's a ton of problems with the design.
i open the list and 90% of it is garbage. graphic stuff, abbreviation nitpicks, things that have nothing to do with the actual design of the building. spent 5-6 hours going through it just to respond "not applicable" to most of them.

this is going to become a huge problem. contractors and estimators are already doing this on every set now. they look thorough to the owner but it's just noise that gets pushed back onto us.

i started running my own sets through a QA tool before issuing just so i can catch the real stuff first and have responses ready when the AI-generated comment dump inevitably comes back. it cross checks schedules against panels and cut sheets and flags actual coordination issues (voltage mismatches, breaker sizing, CFM errors, that kind of thing).

anyone else dealing with this? how are you handling it.

edit: a bunch have asked what I’m using, DM for a referral link, gives a 7 day trial


r/MEPEngineering • • 1d ago

Looking for Freelance Building Services Engineers – Australia (Project-Based Work)

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/MEPEngineering • • 2d ago

Fire Smoke Damper Code flowchart - free

Post image
75 Upvotes

This thing is super helpful and has saved me so much time and annoyance. You can download it for free here. They’ve added updates for 2021 and 2024 IBC https://www.buildingcode.blog/blog/2018-ibc-fire-and-smoke-damper-cheatsheet

You’re welcome.


r/MEPEngineering • • 1d ago

Can hospitals use their cameras to verify I've been on site?

0 Upvotes

This project is to produce as builts for a hospital's fire protection system. The issue is it's like; 3/4 of a mile from my apt.

So some days I've gone to site but left after 30 minutes, and went home to nap or put together puzzles.

I've done a standpipe riser in a stairwell but noted "unable to verify due to surgery in progress" on the second floor, but that floor is offices with no surgeries. I was actually unable to verify because I have been going home and napping

The client hasn't been happy but I just wanna see if they can actually prove I haven't been there


r/MEPEngineering • • 1d ago

Discussion Global Facilities at Burns and McDonnell

1 Upvotes

Anyone work at burns and has any insight in this position? How much travel and where exactly is “global” lol. Thanks everyone


r/MEPEngineering • • 2d ago

Hey, I’m an Electrical Site Engineer working on MEP projects. I’m thinking about switching to a BIM Modeler role. Do you think it would be a worthwhile career move?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/MEPEngineering • • 2d ago

Corridor Fire Ratings & Duct Penetrations

Post image
12 Upvotes

Hey guys, wondering about something that I don't think the code explicitly defines or allows. But it also doesn't not allow it....can i basically redefine the "corridor boundary" by having the architect construct the corridor wall as a rated ceiling equivalent to the 1-hr fire partition? Would this eliminate the need for smoke dampers on transfer ducts that open to the above ceiling corridor space?

Relevant 2024 IBC sections:

708.4 Continuity - specifically #3 here states (Fire partitions serving as a corridor wall shall be permitted to terminate at the upper membrane of the corridor ceiling assembly where the corridor ceiling is constructed as required for the corridor wall" - this, IMO, essentially allows us to build a "tunnel" corridor, and anything above that (wall membrane, duct penetrations) does NOT need to be protected.

Table 1020.2 Corridor Fire-Resistance Rating (occupancy B, no sprinkler)

717.5.4: Fire partitions

717.5.4.1 Corridors

Table 716.1(2) and 716.2.2.1.1: Smoke and draft control (these sections trigger the smoke damper requirement per 717.5.4.1(3).

Would love input from somebody who has specifically dealt with this issue. Thanks!


r/MEPEngineering • • 1d ago

I had MEP-AI and 6 sub-agents draft the water supply and sanitary drainage project for a guest house

0 Upvotes
Drawings, valves, vent stack, riser diagrams, legend, and even the BOQ... Here’s the result.

We’re still at the very beginning — we keep building...

r/MEPEngineering • • 2d ago

jacobs cities & places

4 Upvotes

long shot here, but i wanted to see if anyone in here works for the cities & places team at Jacobs, specifically in the texas/south region

just wanted to ask for insight about their team as im currently applying to their intern program! or if anyone has insight on how their engineering intern program is

Jacobs seems to be a reliable firm that offers internships in building performance / energy modeling


r/MEPEngineering • • 2d ago

Personal residence MEP

3 Upvotes

So ive officially hit the point where I want to make blueprints for my personal residence. Another senior EE told me we all hit this point where after doing this, you kind of want to do your own home.

Several questions:

  1. has anyone else done this?
  2. Im a EE, so I am going to buy a circuit tracer and set up the basic architectural layout and go from there.
  3. gonna use Autocad, so any tips and tricks are recommended. I plan on updating lighting controls and adding more receptacles. Im sure once I see the wiring, I'll want to fix alot more.

r/MEPEngineering • • 2d ago

Which AI model should I use?

0 Upvotes

I primarily use ChatGPT but have recently started exploring Claude and Copilot. Curious to hear from anyone using these for electrical design engineering or MEP project management. Which do you prefer and why? I’ve heard great things about Claude’s Excel add-in, but are there any other features I’m missing out on?


r/MEPEngineering • • 3d ago

have you ever added something like FUCK THIS to specs or a dick ductwork on drawings and accidentally left it in

44 Upvotes

r/MEPEngineering • • 3d ago

I built a free browser tool for drawing HVAC / energy system schematics in 2D and 3D (beta) — feedback welcome

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm an undergraduate student in Architectural Engineering at Pusan National University in South Korea. My lab works on heat pumps, geothermal, PVT and desiccant systems, and I kept losing hours redrawing system schematics for papers and posters in PowerPoint and CAD. Every time the system changed, I had to redraw everything — and keeping a 2D diagram and a 3D figure consistent was even worse.

So I built a small web app for it, and I'd love to get feedback from people who actually design these systems.

🔗https://hvac-schematic-studio.vercel.app/

⚠️ Currently PC only — the layout (toolbar + side panels + drawing area) doesn't fit on small screens yet, so it won't display properly on phones or tablets. Please open it in a desktop browser

What it does:

- 139 equipment symbols (heat pumps, chillers, PVT collectors, desiccant rotors, borehole HX, tanks, pumps, AHUs, cooling towers, PV/ESS, fuel cells…)

- Click two nozzles to connect them; pipes, ducts and wires auto-route orthogonally

- 22 example systems (GSHP, chiller + tower + AHU, DOAS + radiant, ice storage, solar absorption, data-centre free cooling, etc.)

- The same model in 2D and 3D: a concept (isometric) view, and a dimension mode with real sizes in mm, clash check and pipe length take-off

- Operating modes: highlight which pipes are active in each mode and export (a)(b)(c) panels in one figure

- Export for papers and posters: SVG / PDF (with a black & white mode that separates fluids by line type) and high-res PNG (up to 600 dpi, transparent background)

- English / Korean / Japanese / Chinese interface

A few notes:

- It's a free beta, open until Feb 28, 2027. You sign in with Google — your email is only used to manage beta access.

- Everything runs in your browser; your drawings are not uploaded anywhere. Save your work as a .json file.

- Exported figures carry a small "Made with HVAC Schematic Studio (beta)" note.

- Works best on a desktop browser (Chrome / Edge).

I'd really appreciate any feedback — missing equipment, wrong symbols, things that feel clumsy, or what would make this useful in your actual work. You can leave a comment here, or email me at loveko4583@gmail.com if you prefer.


r/MEPEngineering • • 2d ago

I took a BIM/ design coordination problem to Meta's AI Global Developer Hackathon and came 3rd

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/MEPEngineering • • 3d ago

Should I mention my disappointment with the pay & industry politics during my performance review or stay quiet?

6 Upvotes

Only been a year but really regret leaving Aerospace for building systems engineering just to be in a flashy city (VHCOL) but only making 75k with 3-5% annual raises. Do I express this to my boss or will u be seen as a flight risk


r/MEPEngineering • • 3d ago

Question Engineering Retirement

26 Upvotes

Hello there!

I am an active electrical professional engineer in my state, licensed since 1999. I retire in a couple of years at age 65. I'm wondering whether to do a little electrical consulting work or something completely different. Several of my peers died shortly after they quit working completely.

What are your thoughts on this matter? Frankly, I love what I do, but dealing with customers is the hardest part of my work; I'm okay at that skill.

Thanks all and good luck.

Philip in Georgia


r/MEPEngineering • • 3d ago

Does MEP life good in india ?

0 Upvotes

I am a mechanical engineer with BIM MEP experience for 7 months , how is the stream going , does it pays well in positions ? And whata are the opportunitys out there , if you read please reply I'm very confused.


r/MEPEngineering • • 3d ago

Tips on finding revit 2020 families for Hvac, fire protection and plumbing equipment

0 Upvotes

Hello there fellow engineers, I am mechanical engineering graduate looking forward to start a career in MEP and I would appreciate some advice as to how to obtain free equipment families if possible or if I should create a replica for the following equipment: 45 ton VRF unit + 20 ton unit VRF 500 GPM diesel and electric fire pump 50 gpm jockey pump. I want to make a decision between creating replicas identical to real life equipment incase i Don't find available models or if i can find catalogs online. Revit is currently a requirement as of date and i am grateful to learn from your experiences as to how i can navigate my way through it. Thank you in advance.


r/MEPEngineering • • 4d ago

I built a 3D + 2D browser simulator (with Gemini Argon) to visualize pump flow-stealing, the 3D separator rule, and why Qp > Qs kills boiler condensation

6 Upvotes

I put together a single-file 3D + 2D hydronic simulator (Three.js + 2D Canvas P&ID) using Gemini Argon to help visualize primary-secondary decoupling and low-loss header regimes for junior engineers and students.

**What is modeled and analyzed:**

- **Direct-Coupled Pump Conflict (No Separator):** A primary boiler loop (DN65) tied directly to 3 secondary zone pumps with different shutoff heads: Z1 Panel Radiators (55 kPa), Z2 AHU Heating Coil (110 kPa), and Z3 Underfloor/FCU loop (38 kPa). When primary flow lags and Z2 ramps up, manifold pressure drops to `-30.7 kPa`, starving Z1 to `56%` and pulling `-0.68 m³/h` backwards through Z3 (with a toggleable non-return check valve on Z3).

- **Caleffi 3D / 10D Sizing Rule:** Adjustable `DN50–DN100` headers and `1.5D–4.0D` separator body ratios showing internal velocity (`v = Q/A = 0.100 m/s` at `3.0D` vs `≤ 0.15 m/s` threshold), air microbubble venting, and dirt separation efficiency.

- **Coupled Enthalpy Balance across the 3 Separator Regimes:**

  1. `Qp = Qs` (`12.0 m³/h`): `70.0 °C` supply / `52.5 °C` return (`< 54 °C` flue dew point → condensing active at `91.0%`).
  2. `Qp > Qs` (`13.8 > 6.95 m³/h`): Hot downward bypass mixes `70 °C` supply into `46.4 °C` building return, raising boiler return to `58.1 °C` and killing condensation.
  3. `Qp < Qs` (`7.2 < 13.45 m³/h`): Upward return recirculation blends secondary supply down from `70.0 °C` to `58.9 °C`.

Live browser simulator (single HTML file, no install):

https://www.meptasarim.com/hydraulic-separator-simulator.html

*Disclaimer: Informational & educational model only — not for engineering design.*

For those of you commissioning condensing boiler plants: how often do you still find constant-speed primary pumps running in Regime 2 (`Qp > Qs`) and preventing the boilers from ever condensing?


r/MEPEngineering • • 4d ago

Steam Condensate Drain Below Pump Inlet

5 Upvotes

Title. I have 4 steam coils on the return of an AHU (don’t ask). The drain outlets on the bottom two sit about 6” off the ground and the inlet to my condensate pump sits about 18” off the ground. I do not have much experience with steam and haven’t had much luck asking colleagues. Would a solution be to drain the two coils into reservoirs and pipe that to the pump with a check valve downstream of the reservoir? Or do I need a pump for my pump…