r/AskEngineers • • 5d ago

Discussion Career Monday (16 Nov 2026): Have a question about your job, office, or pay? Post it here!

7 Upvotes

As a reminder, /r/AskEngineers normal restrictions for career related posts are severely relaxed for this thread, so feel free to ask about intra-office politics, salaries, or just about anything else related to your job!


r/AskEngineers • • 6d ago

Discussion Call for engineers willing to be interviewed (15 Nov 2026)

45 Upvotes

If you're looking for engineers to interview for a school assignment or for your job hunt, this is the right place! The AskEngineers community has compiled a list of hundreds of practicing engineers across different countries, industries, and specializations to help answer your questions about what they do in their job, how they got there, and offer career advice to those that need it.

Note: Please be courteous when requesting an interview. Everyone on the list is doing it on a volunteer basis only, and they are not obligated to respond or help you. Our users reserve the right to deny any requests for interviews and/or personal information. Harassment will not be tolerated and will be reported to the authorities.

How to use this list

  1. Ctrl + F
    the engineering discipline, country (e.g. US, UK, Germany, etc.), or other criteria you're looking for looking for. If you need to be able to verify someone's identity, search for Available for e-mail?: yes
  2. Parse through each search result and message up to 3 users that you think will be able to answer your questions. DO NOT shotgun PMs to every user! If you don't intend to interview everyone, don't waste their time by sending messages that you won't respond to later.
  3. If the first few users don't respond within 24 hours, try messaging another user.

Interested in conducting interviews?

By signing up, you're volunteering to let high school students, prospective engineers, and new graduates PM or e-mail you with interview questions. Typically with students it will be for a class assignment (i.e. Intro to Engineering), so questions will be about about work, how you got into engineering, "do you have any advice for...", etc. Think of yourself as a STEM Ambassador.

You will receive anywhere from 1-4 requests per month on average, with some surges in January, July, August, and December due to new and graduating students. While these lists usually have over 100 sign-ups and is set to contest mode, which prevents the same users from getting bombarded with requests, engineers in an in-demand discipline may get more requests than average.

Requirements

  1. At minimum, you should have:
  • a BS / B.Sc in engineering or engineering technology, or an equivalent amount of self-study, and;
  • at least 3 years of professional engineering experience
  1. Commit to answering at least two interview requests per month. Don't list your information if you aren't willing to volunteer roughly ~2 hours per month to conduct interviews.

How much time does it take?

The first interview you do will take about 1 hour, depending on how detailed you are. After that, most interviews will take < 30 minutes because you can copy-paste answers for repeat or very similar questions. That said, please be sure to read every question carefully before using previously written answers.

How do I sign up?

Copy the template below and post a top-level comment below. Note: "Available for e-mail" means you're OK with the interviewer sending you a personal e-mail to conduct the interview, usually for verification purposes. If you want to stick to reddit PM only, answer 'no' to this question.

This is purely on a volunteer basis. To opt out, delete your comment here below. Once deleted, you will no longer receive requests for interviews.

This template must be used in Markdown Mode to function properly:

**Discipline:** Mechanical

**Specialization:** Power Turbines

**Highest Degree:** MSME

**Country:** US

**Available for e-mail?:** yes/no

r/AskEngineers • • 16h ago

Mechanical How high can you reasonably get a friction coefficient

66 Upvotes

I’m working on a project as a student where I need to collect experimental data relating to sliding friction (I’m not asking for any specifics on the setup or any help with the project so please don’t ban me)

Basically I’m wondering what’s the general estimate for the highest friction coefficient you’d expect that I could reasonably get considering that this has to be done within the facilities of a university. I don’t really have any experience in doing anything physical or experimental so I don’t have any reference for what is a reasonable number to expect (I’ve been researching this but none of the results have been particularly helpful as they’re not really aimed at maximising the coefficient)


r/AskEngineers • • 4h ago

Mechanical in TOM , while we balancing force in reciprocating engine, why we always balance it partially ( because if we try to balance it completely we just change the direction of unbalanced force from horizontal to vertical) i know but why we can't balance it completely without any unbalanced force?

1 Upvotes

Hey guys, my professor probably taught me wrong but could you please explain it to me or provide a good explanation video link pls ::)


r/AskEngineers • • 23h ago

Discussion What's harder to build from scratch, GPU or B2

3 Upvotes

I was in my class today and got in a debate with a friend over this topic . I want yalls opinion.


r/AskEngineers • • 1d ago

Mechanical Why do diesel DEF systems seem so much more failure prone than the rest of the engine around them?

5 Upvotes

Been hauling freight for 30 plus years and I swear the SCR/DEF setup causes more grief than the actual engine internals these days. NOx sensors, pumps, the whole emissions stack just seems like it was bolted on without thinking about vibration and thermal cycling out on the road. Anybody with an actual engineering background know if this is a design tradeoff they just accepted to hit emissions targets, or is it more of a rushed implementation thing from when the regs changed.


r/AskEngineers • • 2d ago

Civil Why is it so hard for Ukraine to destroy the Kerch railway bridge, despite several direct hits?

102 Upvotes

r/AskEngineers • • 1d ago

Mechanical How do I design a wire gate for a carabiner?

2 Upvotes

I know I can just cut apart some cheap carabiners to see what the undeflected shape is. Before I do that are there any resources y'all can point to like tables or something?

How necessary is doming the ends if the rest of the carabiner is wide enough? Is the hole fit really important?

I'm making a custom tool kinda like a happy hooker (https://panthermarineproducts.com/happy-hookers/) but it just grabs rather than passing a rope through an eye. Basically a carabiner on a pole with gate facing the front with some added features on one of the legs.

It's about 100 units and the loads are small so I think a 3d printed body with a wire gate is a good way to approach it. I'm trying some other approaches too: I'm just looking for help on this one.

I'm a mechanical engineering intern in Canada.


r/AskEngineers • • 3d ago

Civil How long would the Panama Canal take to build today?

97 Upvotes

Assuming the first real canal was never built. So no supporting infrastructure nearby, from scratch?


r/AskEngineers • • 2d ago

Discussion When a drawing calls out A992, do you accept A572 Gr.50 as a substitution on the MTC?

0 Upvotes

We see this weekly on RFQs: the drawing says A992, the mill cert comes back dual-certified A992/A572-50, or sometimes just A572 Gr.50.

My understanding of where the line sits:

  • A572 Gr50 meets all of A992's minimums, but A992 adds a yield ceiling (50–65 ksi), Fy/Fu ≤ 0.85, and CE ≤ 0.45% on the cert
  • For non-seismic work, most engineers accept the substitution (or just accept the dual-cert)
  • For AISC 341 seismic moment frames, the answer seems to be a hard no
  • And plate is always A572 Gr50 since A992 doesn't cover it

Curious how you all handle it in practice: do you reject certs that only say A572 Gr50 when the drawing says A992? Does it depend on the project's seismic category? Anyone had a fabricator push back on this?


r/AskEngineers • • 2d ago

Mechanical how do engineers decide which component should be the sacrificial failure point

0 Upvotes

Fuses, shear pins and crumple zones are the obvious examples: parts built to give way before something more dangerous or expensive does. The same logic shows up in consumer products, where a plastic gear, clip or coupling may be there to protect a motor or housing.

From the outside, though, a cheap part failing can look exactly like cost cutting or planned obsolescence. That's especially true when the part is hard to reach or can't be bought as a replacement. When designing a mechanical or electromechanical product, how do engineers choose the intended failure point? Is the decision driven mainly by safety and replacement cost, or do assembly time, noise, sealing, and service access carry similar weight?

I'm especially interested in examples where a cheaplooking part was actually a deliberate way to protect the rest of the system


r/AskEngineers • • 2d ago

Mechanical Looking for a blower for my tractor.

0 Upvotes

I have exhausted my internet and phone skills so I am asking here. I want a PTO powered blower that will produce around 1000 cfm at 1-2 psi, roughly what the largest Stihl backpack blower makes. It needs to fit between the cat.2, 3 point hitch arms and be able to attach a flexible hose 3-4 inches in diameter. PTO can run at either 540 or 1000 rpm. Dimensions are 16” wide, 12” tall and 24 inches long including driveshaft. Does anyone here know of a product that may work? Plenty of power is available.


r/AskEngineers • • 2d ago

Discussion How should I price an industrial robotics simulation POC?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/AskEngineers • • 2d ago

Mechanical Is it possible (and worth it) to motorize this manual adjustable standing desk?

0 Upvotes

https://imgur.com/a/o8WFJ0I

I bought this adjustable standing desk for my at home dj setup. I like to dj standing but like to sit down to do stuff like library management, editing, music production, etc.

The height of the desk is adjusted by manually lifting the top of the desk while tilting it forward slightly to “unlock it” and pulling or dropping it into the desired position.

The problem is that I recently upgraded my equipment which is much heavier than my old setup so lifting it out of the locked position is much more difficult, especially when trying to lower it.

I dont want to buy another desk so I’m wondering if it would be possible and worth it to try to motorize it? I’m pretty handy and have worked with small electronic motors in the past and love learning new things but I’m not at all an engineer so wanted to get some professional advice on this.

Is it possible and worth it (time, money and effort wise) to try to motorize the adjustable height functionality? If so, how would I go about it?


r/AskEngineers • • 3d ago

Electrical How long could an industrial electric fan motor last with minimal maintenance running 24/7?

36 Upvotes

I'm trying to cool or create airflow for an electrical cabinet in a remote non-human accessible installation that needs to run independently for 10-12 years.


r/AskEngineers • • 3d ago

Mechanical Looking for a specific part

5 Upvotes

Hi, I am working on a costume and i need to find a specific part for the wings. It is a small round button that is approx. 2 inches in diameter, about an inch tall, spins freely when pressed, and locks into place when released. (Sort of like a clicky pen) I want to attach her wing armiture to it to be able to open and close the wings with the simple push of a button, as the weight should allow them to fold down easily.

Alternatively, I have some experience with blender (not a lot though)and I could make a model and 3d print of the button itself, but i am not confident i could make something functional without several test runs. If i was to make the model, what sort of spring should i use for this?


r/AskEngineers • • 4d ago

Discussion Sourcing very low cracking pressure check valves rated for biogas

10 Upvotes

Hi all,

I'm looking for a source for a low cracking pressure check valves inert to biogas (mixture of mainly CH4, CO2, H2S and NH3). For my application I need ~0.1 PSI or less.

I've found compatible sources for 0.5 PSI CP valves and tested them in my setup, but these either have stiction issues or the pressure rating is too high for my application and causes undesirable behaviour.

To give an idea of what I'm looking for, I found and ordered this from mcmaster-carr. It was perfect and working very well until H2S corroded the brass and the valve seized. Going through mcmaster-carr's filters doesn't seem to show anything with similar dimensions or suitable compatibility.

I've also reached out to Qosina, specifically about this product, but they confirmed none of their low CP valves are rated for gases. I can get a free sample and I will test them anyway but I don't have much hope for these.

Anyway, if anyone has recommendation that would be greatly appreciated.


r/AskEngineers • • 5d ago

Mechanical Is the damage to the Crimean Bridge fixable?

39 Upvotes

There was a large drone attack on the Crimean bridge today which damaged one of the arches so much that the entire structure bent visibly.

Can this realistically be fixed without rebuilding this entire part of the bridge? Could the bridge still be safe to use in a limited capacity despite the damage?

Pictures of the alleged damage can be found on OSINTtechnical on Twitter. I don't know if links are allowed here so please look it up yourself.


r/AskEngineers • • 6d ago

Mechanical Can you use periscope with thermal vision camera? And why is it not more common with regular infrared cameras?

14 Upvotes

I was thinking with armored combat you might want to hide expensive image sensor inside vehicle and only expose a lens and a mirror via periscope. Why is this not done more often and can this be done with thermal vision as well?


r/AskEngineers • • 5d ago

Mechanical How would you support a variable cantilever?

0 Upvotes

Hi folks, senior mech student here! I was wondering how you would go about supporting a cantilever that changes in length. For example if you had a vertical plate that can be adjusted to extend out from a block, how would you mount it in a way theres minimal deflection? What about if theres bidirectional linear motion? At first I had considered telescopic rail systems but forgot to account for deflection while in motion, and I wasn't sure how you would maintain sufficient support if the plate was pulled out to full extension


r/AskEngineers • • 7d ago

Civil Why arent thermochromic paints a thing for houses?

51 Upvotes

From an energetic perspective it would make sense to paint a house white in summer and black in winter. Of course painting a house twice a year doesent make sense. But we have pigments that change colour depending on temperature.So there has to be a catch, right?

Ist it price? UV/Wheather resistance? Do we lack a usefull color combination? Or is the changeover temperature unfit?

Im curious and im sure its obvious if you got knowledge about thermochromic pigments :D


r/AskEngineers • • 6d ago

Mechanical How should I attach my 3D printer to my lasercutter's ventilation system?

3 Upvotes

Earlier this year, I purchased a small lasercutter (Acmer P2), and I had to build my own enclosure for it as they did not have one that could fit it with the extension kit attached. The enclosure I made feeds directly into a standard air filter, through a flexible air duct into a fan (AC Infinity Cloudline Pro S6), finally passing through another flexible air duct to the window.

I'm planning on buying a 3D printer soon (Bambu X2D), and I'd like to hook it up to the ventilation system I've already built for my lasercutter. However, I'm not 100% sure how I should go about doing that such that fumes from the lasercutter don't go into the printer and vice-versa. My gut feeling is to connect it between the standard air filter and the fan and to make sure the fan's running whenever either device is active, but I'm not sure if I should do more (e.g. install blast gates on either input side of the T-junction to improve airflow to the device being used by sealing off the other one). Any advice would be appreciated.

(Automod said to say I'm from Canada, though I doubt that'll be relevant)


r/AskEngineers • • 6d ago

Electrical Building DC resistive load banks for battery/charger testing ;what components do I need and where do I source them

2 Upvotes

Hi all, I'm planning to assemble DC resistive load bank for battery discharge and battery charger testing. I'm trying to work out the full parts list and where to buy the raw materials.

What I have so far in mind:
Resistive elements (stainless steel or nichrome grids/coils?)
Enclosure/frame
Cooling fans and motors
DC contactors/switches and fuses or breakers
Control panel, metering (voltage/current), and protection (over-temp, fan failure)
Terminals and cabling
A few questions:
Am I missing any key components?
What material is best for the heat-dissipating elements? I assumed copper/aluminium, but I've read they're not ideal for the resistive part. Is aluminium just for fins and heat sinks?

Any experts in this field , please give advice.


r/AskEngineers • • 6d ago

Discussion Course and materials guide to learn how to use esp32's and other related electronics?

0 Upvotes

Hi, I'm a first-year biomedical engineer in Canada, and I know that a lot of biomedical applications have electronic components to them. I've been seeing a lot of videos on Instagram of people building cool little projects like desk buddies, moisture sensors for plants, and Spotify displays on what appear to be ESP32s. (examples below) I'm mainly looking to learn something over the summer when I'm off school because I find this topic interesting, not necessarily for career purposes. I'm not familiar with electronics at all whatsoever, so I'm a little lost as to what I should be looking up to find out about, both what materials I need to order and courses that I can take to actually learn how these things work. I have a few main questions:

  1. (To your knowledge) Are there any colleges/universities in Canada that offer a class/certificate on this specific topic? Can it be taken online?
  2. Are Arduino, Raspberry Pi, and ESP32 the same thing? Is one thing more valuable to know than the other?
  3. What should I look into buying in order to familiarize myself with this topic? I'm aware there are different sensors and stuff. I'm willing to pay for the education and the pieces.

Im just completely clueless in this topic so any guidence is appreciated.

Example one of what I've been seeing

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DfbZwCaxDdo/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link&xtok=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==&srtk=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==

Example two

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DeNBCvTqggy/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link&cplk=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==&srtk=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==