long ramble ahead. i'm an uber-casual-scrub kind of player. i've recently returned to paper magic about a month ago and am looking to get recommendations for improving decks i'm building for commander.
i got into paper magic around Rivals of Ixalan (2018), and stopped at March of the Machines (2023). during this i had little periods of time where i'd play modern in MTGarena. i generally know how to keep up with the flow of most games as well as shenanigans with mechanics. (i just read the card and it explains itself, no problem there).
in the past, however, i only ever 'incorrectly' played modern with friends at home using kitchen-counter decks. i also wasn't actively buying or trading cards so i just kept shifting around things from what i owned into my already shaky decks on top of a very inconsistent playtime. i mostly own cards from Ixalan, Dominaria, and a little less from Guilds of Ravnica. i've been given cards from other players at my LGS from more recent sets, but nothing crazy.
anyways, i aim to only play at bracket 2-3. bracket 2 seems comfortable for me, but i wouldn't mind getting my ass beat in bracket 3. most pods at my LGS also play at similar levels, though most players have access to cEDH decks if prompted. i've also had a lot of catching up to do with newer card mechanics, and various rules with the rest of the people at the shop that i've met.
below are links to two decks i mainly play right now. cards marked green i already own. cards marked blue or red i do not have yet. within each deck in the links below are cards in the "maybe board" section that i thought would be good upgrades. i'd like general opinions (more card recommendations to substitute what i have, things to consider with my strategy, etc.). i understand that this is a bit tricky given there's only so much i can do while wanting to stick to themes and flavor (and a 7dollar or less limit per each card). i'd appreciate any input. oh and i wanna stay away from Universes Beyond cards, though i understand they're quite strong.
https://archidekt.com/decks/28205889/spoopynivmizzyedh2nov2026
(orzhov, niv mizzet commander, vampires and vraska)
niv morzhov might not be the best commander, but this was a pure flavor pick and i really want to make it work. this was something i threw together from a 60card vraska black/white planeswalker deck years ago. as such, vraska is also in here as a planeswalker and i'd like to try to keep her in the deck. i also wanna try sticking to the whole vampires, skeletons, ghosts, etc. schtick.
https://archidekt.com/decks/28261844/kuntykumenieedh2nov2026
(kumena tyrant of orazca, brain-off merfolk)
i don't mind turning it into a brain-on deck. i also don't mind swapping kumena out for a better commander, but i do wanna keep him in the deck. i stubbornly also keep trying to make polyraptor (i understand it'll do better in a gruul deck), timestream navigator, nezahal, and enter the infinite work. if i absolutely have to-i'll swap them out, although it was worth a shot.
in any case, most of my games have all been very very close, i often just get powercrept and or knowingly keep a bad hand for fear of delaying the pod (especially since i slowly mash-shuffle).
anyways, apologies for the long read and rather obtuse request. i appreciate any advice!