r/Maya • • Jun 22 '24

Modeling Topology Megathread

59 Upvotes

Topology is the geometric structure of a polygonal mesh. It is the layout of the edges and vertices which define the shape of a mesh. A particular shape can be represented by many different topologies.

Mesh topolgy can never be considered without context. It is necessary to consider how a mesh will be used and modified in the future in order to say anything true about the suitability of its topology.

There are no hard rules when it comes to topology. Some people will say n-gons (polygons with more than 4 sides) are always bad. Some will say triangles are always bad. Some will say that non-manifold geometry is always bad, or that meshes with holes in them are always bad.

None of these are true, because mesh topology serves a purpose, or multiple purposes. It is not a goal in and of itself. If the purpose(s) is/are served by some particular topology, then that topology is good, whether or not it is itself aesthetically and technically appealing.

Often users are advised to avoid triangles or ngons when building topology--to keep to quads. This is good practice, because quads are easier to work with, easier to edit, easier to create UV projections for, they subdivide more predictably, and, most importantly, easier to produce aesthetically appealing deformations from.

However. If a mesh will not need to deform, then there is far less pressure to keep to quads. If the mesh will not be subdivided, even less. If the shape is well-represented by the topology, and it either already has a good UV projection or will not be needing one, then quads and ngons don't matter, unless the mesh will be altered in the future.

It is much harder to modify a mesh which isn't quads than one which is. Especially if you want to alter topology. However, altering shape, to a small extent, usually is not sensitive to topology. It's also generally easier to do UV projection and alteration of quad topology than triangle/ngon topology.

It is still important to point out that having SOME non-quad (especially triangles) in your deforming, high performance mesh which may be altered and have UVs applied, is still just fine in many circumstances. If the trangle won't interfere with these things--then it DOES NOT MATTER and you should spend time on other things. Same with n-gons, although those have a higher chance of causing technical issues.

Regarding non-manifold geometry: it is generally a bad thing. Many, MANY operations and programs will not function correctly when passed non-manifold meshes. However, if your mesh is serving all your purposes, and you don't see those purposes changing, then non-manifold geometry doesn't matter. The circumstances where this might be true, however, are extremely rare, and it is best to avoid it.

Regarding holes in the mesh: again, context matters. Some advanced simulation or mesh operations require "watertight" meshes. Most don't, and it doesn't matter. Context and circumstance will dictate what's appropriate.

Mesh weight matters, as well. There's generally not much call for more geometric detail than your mesh needs to create the shapes you need, either statically or deformed, and it is best to keep poly counts as low as possible while not compromising on these things. However, this must be balanced with the effort it requires to reduce detail. If you have a poly budget of 100k triangles for an object, and it's 50k but a lot of those are not necessary, it's still not worth the time to reduce it further. People hours are worth more than computer hours.

Where topology really starts to matter a lot is in efficient hard surface modeling, especially where the asset will be subdivided. Not having your edge flows follow surface details will make life difficult, and having too much mesh detail will make modification increasingly difficult.

The point here is that every situation is different, and no real determination of acceptable mesh topology can be made without all this context. If you look at an image of a mesh and don't know anything about what it will be used for or how it might be modified, you can't say anything true about the quality of topology. These and other questions must have answers, in order to judge *overall* topology:

  1. Will it deform?
  2. If so, how?
  3. Will it need to be edited in the future?
  4. If so, how?
  5. Will it be subdivided?
  6. Does it have or will it need a UV projection?
  7. Will the UVs need to change?
  8. If so, how?
  9. Will it need to be exported into another application?
  10. Will it be used in any type of simulation?
  11. Does it meet performance (budget) requirements?

These questions must have answers in order to come up with useful conclusions about how good the topology is or is not. And again, there are no hard rules. Topology is not a goal, it is a tool to help reach other goals. If a triangle doesn't affect those goals, there's no point spending energy removing it.

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Original post:

This thread will be a clearinghouse for information about topology, both in general, and specific to Maya. It will be heavily curated and updated as I encounter more/better information on the subject.

Eventually it will be turned into another wiki and be the redirect for the majority of topology threads we get here, in order to avoid repetition.

If you are a subject matter expert, please post images, videos, links, or your thoughts here. Feel free to copy parts of old comments or posts you have made.


r/Maya • • 2h ago

Rigging How can I rig it so that the selected part can slide and spin along the shaft it's attached to? As opposed to doing it in relation to the world.

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/Maya • • 13h ago

Issues I hide an object and I can’t find it

Post image
10 Upvotes

Did I accidentally delete it after I save the proyect or why can’t I find it?


r/Maya • • 16h ago

Question Autodesk's student licensing terms for Maya, exporting Maya models into other 3d modelling softwares? (read whole post)

2 Upvotes

Before anyone answers, I am not looking or asking for ways around Autodesk's licensing terms.

If I need to remake it all from scratch in a free 3d modelling software before selling it, I am completely willing to do so. As of right now I have study commitments I need to finish for the next two weeks, so help and even getting information will help a lot.

Context:

I'm studying a course that provides a student version of Maya. Over the last few months I've modelled around 10 game props to eventually sell as packs, currently I have 25 more to go, these are just furniture, clutter and decorations rather than characters or complex rigged things.

Only recently have I learned that the commercial use of maya's student version is not allowed, and I have read old discussions on the topic and learned about Autodesk's data flags and file markers.

My questions are the following:

  1. Can I export the current maya models into different 3d model software, would the maya markers follow the exported formats?
  2. Suggestions from anyone who has had to move from Maya to 3d model software because of this?
  3. For someone who is more used to Maya, are there any 3d model software tools, add-ons or even helpful workflows for hard-surface prop modelling?
  4. If I was to work from scratch what is the way I would model to get the exact shape to my maya model?

I've only seen 4-6 years old discussions on this topic so I'm curious to see current experiences and up to date advice.

Even video tuts on moving from Maya to 3d model software would be nice so I can put them into a playlist for when I have time.

Any clarifying questions I will try my best to answer!

Thank you for reading!


r/Maya • • 1d ago

Question How to model this detail in Maya?

Post image
36 Upvotes

I'm trying to model this detail in Maya (red circled) but but I can't figure out how to make the sharp, slanted part that comes out of the hole.

I already know how to make the hole itself. I'm mainly struggling with the geometry of the protruding part.

Could someone show me how they would model this, preferably with a topology or wireframe example? I'd also appreciate any tutorial recommendations that cover similar details.


r/Maya • • 18h ago

XGen XGen Help - Collection follows in viewport but not Arnold render?

1 Upvotes

New to XGen so I have no clue what I'm doing. My hair is following perfectly fine in the viewport but in the Arnold render, it's stuck in the starting position.

I made it using the Interactive Groom feature. Is it a cache thing? How do I go about making the hair follow my character in a final render?

In Bind Pose

Deformed (Only follows in viewport)


r/Maya • • 1d ago

Discussion Maya file trojan - any experiences?

15 Upvotes

Hi,

My Windows flagged and quaranted ''maya_secure_system.py''?

Is it much like the vaccine one? There does not seem to be much information on this one yet and I am getting mixed result googling.

Some say it's ''harmless'' for anything outside of Maya but I saw a post mentioning that it could download info stealers etc run ran.

Anyone else with experience on this one?


r/Maya • • 1d ago

Looking for Critique Try make spectacular spider man style. How it is?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/Maya • • 2d ago

Showcase Made a Cute Little Stylized 3D Juicer in Maya + Arnold! 🍊🧃

36 Upvotes

-------------------------------------------------------------

Checkout More Projects On 👀

-------------------------------------------------------------

After finishing the stylized toaster, I decided to create another kitchen prop based on another illustration by the same Ukrainian illustrator, Irina Kotko. This time, it's a cute little juicer!

One of the more challenging parts was getting the ice cubes and the juice inside the transparent glass to look right. Achieving the desired result in Substance 3D Painter and seeing how everything would translate into Arnold took a bit of iteration and experimentation. But after spending time tweaking the details and getting everything to come together, I'm really happy with how this little juicer turned out!

Created in Autodesk Maya, textured in Substance 3D Painter, and rendered in Arnold.

And with this little juicer, that's officially the end of this stylized prop series! 😬 I eventually moved on to explore something different, which you'll get to see in the upcoming days. Stay tuned, I'll be back with more work soon!

-------------------------------------------------------------

2D Concept Art / Illustration Credit:

-------------------------------------------------------------

The End


r/Maya • • 1d ago

Arnold Substance to Maya in 2026 - how are you all doing this?

2 Upvotes

I have been using the plugin for previous versions, but am seeing that the 2026 plugin does not exist. I know there is a new openPBR workflow but I am not understanding how this is supposed to work. Anyone have a minute to explain?


r/Maya • • 2d ago

Arnold Light not showing up in renderview or when rendering the image sequence, what do? Im sure this gets asked a lot but im serious the methods i usually use do not show the lighting, please help

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/Maya • • 1d ago

Issues Blend parent not showing in channel box

0 Upvotes

Hello!

I feel like I'm going a little crazy, I'm trying to constrain the cloche to the FK wrist control but the blend parent box doesn't show up in the channel box despite already keying the controls. Should I just go to support?

I'm using Maya 2024.2 education License


r/Maya • • 2d ago

Animation "No, we have Arcane at home." The Arcane at home:

78 Upvotes

Goofing around with my flour sack animation assignment :)


r/Maya • • 2d ago

Showcase Two months trying a Maya to MetaHuman workflow: test renders, and why I'm going back to my usual pipeline

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

A month ago I posted two progress videos of a Mass Effect character fan project I was building in Maya using Unreal Engine's MetaHuman workflow. I promised I'd share the results, so here they are: two quick test renders (front, side and back). To be clear, these are test renders, not final shots.

What I learned:

  • MetaHuman Wrap is cool, but it has limits. It works most of the time, but I kept running into its ceiling. I've seen people do amazing things with it, so some of this is probably down to my own skill.
  • Its big advantage is real: everything just works natively inside Unreal Engine.
  • The downsides for me: it uses a lot of memory, it has a lot of restrictions, and you have to pre-plan a lot before you even start.
  • Posing in Sequencer humbled me. I thought I knew how to pose characters. I do not. 😅

A bit on the Maya side:

I kept the topology as simple as I could since this is for a game engine workflow. For the armor, I made the character mesh a live surface and used Maya's Quad Draw tool to manually retopologize the armor panels right on top of the body, then extruded and refined them from there. The boots were modeled manually using an old shoe template for the silhouette: I positioned the template, retopologized over it, deleted the original, and tweaked the new mesh to fit. Shoes are definitely still my weak spot and something I plan to focus on improving in my next project. I forgot to grab wireframe and viewport shots before rendering, so let me know if anyone wants to see them and I'll share them.

Where I'm going from here:

I'm going back to my usual pipeline: sculpt in ZBrush, model in Maya, texture, then auto-rig or retarget inside Unreal. I'll keep practicing MetaHuman on the side, along with the new skills I picked up on this project.

I'm nowhere near calling myself a pro, but it was a great learning experience. If you've had better luck combining Maya and MetaHuman, I'd love to hear how you approached it, and feedback on the character is welcome too.


r/Maya • • 3d ago

Animation Why Do All of My Walk Cycles Look Like Limping?

117 Upvotes

Can someone explain this? But Also dumb it down so I can understand lol


r/Maya • • 3d ago

Animation The mesh stopped following the rig controls, even though the controls themselves are still moving as expected.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I was animating a kick, and everything was working perfectly until I moved my keyframes further down the timeline to give myself more frames to animate the movements leading up to the kick. Suddenly, the mesh stopped following the rig controls, even though the controls themselves are still moving as expected.

I've tried various troubleshooting methods, searched through forums and YouTube tutorials and looked on this subreddit, but nothing has worked so far. I've also restarted my laptop multiple times with no luck.

The model was provided as a premade rig for educational purposes, and it was working perfectly fine before this happened. I'm really hoping someone can help me figure out what went wrong and how to fix it!


r/Maya • • 3d ago

Issues Playback Issues with Evaluation Modes

1 Upvotes

I am trying to animate a rigged character and I need the playback timing to be correct which it usually is when I have my Maya in parallel evaluation mode thanks to the cached playback. However, in parallel mode, once the animation is played and cached, the viewport lighting gets all messed up when replaying the cached playback. This lighting issue does not happen in DG evaluation mode, but in DG, there seems to not be cached playback and my animation plays back too slowly. Is there any way for me to fix this lighting issue in parallel or to get my animation to play back more smoothly and on time in DG? Or is there something else I should be doing entirely?

How the character looks in the Viewport normally
How the character looks in the Viewport during cached playback

r/Maya • • 3d ago

Rigging Horse Legs Control Critique...

8 Upvotes

I'm sorry for the weird title, I'm trying to make the minimum limit.

So I made a simple system in and I use the hoove control to rotate the upper and lower ankles. Will this break or confuse animators who use this?


r/Maya • • 3d ago

Issues Why does my quad draw look like that?

1 Upvotes

It looks clear / transparent instead of blue. I started my quad draw on computer 1 yesterday, opened the scene on computer 2 later that day to continue working on it, and opened it on computer 1 again today only to find this. I've never had this specific issue before, does anyone know how to fix this?


r/Maya • • 3d ago

Question What's with this blank window?

1 Upvotes

Sometimes, when I open a scene file, it opens this window alongside whatever I had open last time I had the scene open (Render view, UV editor, etc). If I try to close it in any way, the entirety of Maya freezes and doesn't close until I either run MayaCrasher or kill the process in Task Manager. It doesn't seem to happen if I just open Maya, then select a scene, instead of opening a scene directly. What is this? Please help.

Running Windows 10 LTSC IoT 2021 (don't mind the windows 7 theme), and Maya 2024. Resetting my preferences did not resolve the issue.


r/Maya • • 3d ago

Issues Need help on transferring chainmail details on to to the final version of the character.

Post image
4 Upvotes

Hi I'm currently working on this character for my portfolio.. the thing is I want to keep the chainmail on his body in the final rigged version.. so how do I make it to maya from zbrush and rigg it for posing? Do I have to bake it or is there any other way for this? I've never created chainmail before.


r/Maya • • 3d ago

Rigging Rigging showreel of a bike i myself modelled in maya

10 Upvotes

You saw the models, now watch it move! 🦾🔥

​After dropping the renders, I couldn’t wait to show you the full breakdown of this sci-fi bike. This one hits a bit differently because unlike my previous car rig, I handled both the modeling and the rigging from scratch for this machine! 🏍️⚡

​Every controller, switch, and custom hydraulic line was built to bring this mechanical beast to life. Pulling together a complex asset from the first polygon to the final rig is an unmatched feeling. 💻✨

#3drigging #mayarigging #3dmodeling #3dartist #autodeskmaya

Let me know what you think of the mechanics in the comments! 👇


r/Maya • • 4d ago

Showcase [Tool / Free & Open Source] Collect Files for Maya (CFM) — After Effects-style 1-Click Scene, Texture & Reference Collector (Maya 2022–2027)

Post image
32 Upvotes

r/Maya • • 4d ago

Animation Maya Facial Rigging support any advance skeleton or just basics are fine

2 Upvotes

Hey guys I need help with the facial rigging either a basic or advance skeletons are fine but I need a help like immediately if possible...My character just need a mouth movement not much of a rig but I cant figure this thing out anymore and I've spend my sleeping time just to figure this out..if you saw this I can maybe get a direct contact to discord or just a google meet to help with my facial rig. thank you