r/PickAorB • • Jul 25 '25

How to Use r/PickAorB: A Space for Real-Life Choices

16 Upvotes

r/PickAorB is a space that honors the real, often messy emotions we face when caught between life choices, A or B. But this isn’t just about black or white thinking. Here, you’re invited to share your inner conflicts, doubts, and uncertainties. Even more importantly, we’re here to explore the “third way,” a possibility beyond A or B that you might not have considered yet.
Whether you’re standing at a crossroads or simply seeking connection through others’ stories, this is a space for expressing, listening, and discovering together.

Core Values

  1. Express your real thoughts and doubts We welcome you to open up about the complicated emotions behind your choices. There’s no such thing as a perfect answer, only honest sharing.
  2. Respect others’ decisions and stay open to new possibilities Everyone’s background and values are different. We don’t judge what’s right or wrong. Instead, we honor each person’s decision while also encouraging you to look beyond A and B and consider creative or unconventional paths.
  3. Kindness first, no hate, no mockery This community is rooted in sincerity, empathy, and understanding. We don’t tolerate attacks, discrimination, or ridicule. Let’s keep this a safe space where people feel supported in being vulnerable.

Community Rules

  1. Post real-life dilemmas and honest reflections Your post should come from your own life or observations. The more details and emotions you share, the more others can connect and respond meaningfully.
  2. Use the A or B format in your title Your post title should clearly state your dilemma. This helps others quickly join the conversation.
  3. No hate speech or personal attacks Treat everyone with respect. Avoid insulting, discriminatory, or inflammatory language. If you see inappropriate comments, report or kindly remind others to keep the space safe.
  4. Promote supportive, thoughtful interaction When replying, aim to offer empathy, personal insight, or constructive advice, not harsh criticism or dismissal.
  5. Feel free to suggest a third way Sometimes the best path isn’t A or B. Don’t hesitate to propose a different perspective, idea, or hybrid solution. Your creativity might inspire someone else.

How to Post

  1. Start your post with an A or B question in the title Example: “AorB, Go back to school or accept job offer?”
  2. Share your dilemma or observation In the body of your post, describe the real-life situation, your hesitation, emotional struggle, and any background details. The more personal and specific, the more others can relate.
  3. Clearly define your A and B options Let people know what you’re deciding between, including pros, cons, and how you feel about each.
  4. Invite suggestions and third-way thinking Ask the community not just for a vote, but for fresh perspectives, a path you might not have thought of yet.
  5. Be open and real You don’t need to have it all figured out. This is a space for honest uncertainty. Your openness makes it easier for others to support you and feel less alone too.

And finally
If you're feeling stuck, try writing it out.
If you see a post that resonates, maybe your words will help someone feel a little more seen.
We're all figuring out how to make choices.
We're all learning how to take care of ourselves.
May this be a space where you feel safe enough to pause, reflect, and speak.
Welcome. Share your A or B.


r/PickAorB • • 14h ago

Pick a or b: I agreed to drive my friend and his wife to the airport and said I'd leave at 5:30 if they weren't out. They weren't. Now they want me to pay back their plane tickets

3.6k Upvotes

My friend and his wife had an early flight, and I said I'd drive them to the airport. I'd pick them up at 5. If they weren't out by 5:30, I was leaving, because I had to get to work after.

They're late to pretty much everything, so I made sure they heard that part. He said they'd be ready.

I got there at 5 and called them both. No answer. I knocked. Nothing. At 5:30 I texted that I was leaving, and I left.

They missed the flight. Later they admitted they weren't even packed. They got there on their own after that.

In the group chat they said I should've waited. His wife wrote, "The lights were on. You knew we were home. Ten more minutes and we would've made it."

I told them 5:30 was the time they agreed to. "I called you both and knocked. I couldn't be late for work."

Then they asked me to pay them back for the tickets they lost, $1,070. If I don't, they're done with me.

He's my friend, and I'm the one who drove off and left them there. Part of me keeps thinking I could've waited ten more minutes. I'd have been late to work, not fired. But I told them the time, and they weren't ready.

A. Pay part of it. He's my friend, I'm the one who drove off without them, and $1,070 is a lot for them to lose over one morning.

B. Pay nothing. They agreed to the time, I called and knocked, and I texted before I left. They missed the flight because they weren't ready.


r/PickAorB • • 2h ago

Pick A or B: I agreed to petsit a neighbours pup

10 Upvotes

I have a neighbour who is bit difficult but he always rescues dogs, which i admire. We had our ups and downs through the years but en general we are in ok terms. He is not a bad guy but he has 0 social skills and can be pretty rude.

I am disabled and have very limited energy. I also have two dogs, one of them reactive to new dogs but not agressive.

He has a foster puppy now but next week he needs to go for a few days away to the city. He could take him to his mothers apartment but the pup is a rascal (as they all are) or he could drive up and down (its only 1h drive) but since the puppy is so young he doesn't feel comfortable leaving him in the garden alone the whole day.

I understand and when he asked me if I could keep him in my home for two nights I agreed. It was going to be a huge sacrifice for me because pups are pure chaos and I am very ill. But what he does is very kind and I wanted to help.

Now it comes the problem. Last friday i wanted to introduce the pup to my reactive dog; she is ok with puppies (thats why i agreed) and I had pet guests in the past. But she barks a lot if she sees them coming so the introduction needs to be done in a very controlled way.

Our house (well my grans house, who can afford a home right?) faces two streets and has two floors. The lower floor is my house and we use the back garden, with its own gate. The upper floor is a separate appartment that my parents use in the weekends plus the front garden.

He insisted in doing the intro in the front door and then front garden. I explained that this was not a food idea because a) reactive dogs don't do well on a short leash. B) My parents also have a reactive dog and the neighbours as well so if we are in the front is going to be a chaos of dogs barking and my dog will not be relaxed.

I told him that i would meet him in my garden door, around the corner and we could meet in that street or better in my garden. My dog isn't territorial and then she can have a long leash and be comfortable and nobody will be barking in panic.

He insisted, rudely, three times that we either meet in the front or he gets inside my front garden, crosses the garden and goes to the back garden. I explained him again why not. Even if my dog isn't there if we pass my parents dog will bark and then the whole neighbour will awake.

Also i hated the intrusion. You don't get to demand where to enter my home. And least when I am doing you a huge favour. All he needs to do is walk around the block. Is around the corner. But he refused. So i told him to meet another day, I was very upset.

We are supposed to meet on monday for the introduction. His class in tuesday and wenesday.

So what should I do?

A: Bite the bullet to keep the peace. Meet in the front, risk that the introduction goes badly. And if after that he still wants me to petsit do it and then never agree to a favor again. I don't want to do this but it might be more peaceful.

B: Be firm on monday. The introduction is done on my terms. If he disagress then he can take the pup to his mothers. Still never do a favour for him. This seems the best solution and more mature one but I am afraid of endless arguments.

(What i should really do: Tell him that he was very rude and ungrateful and rescind my offer. Never do anything for him. But this might escalate into a nightmare, fighting with a neighbour is never a good idea)

Help me. I am stupid. All I wanted was to help a abandoned pup and instead all I am getting is a rude man demanding to enter my home.

(And no, this man is old and gay, he is not interested in me in any way. He is very volatile and rude but not creepy)


r/PickAorB • • 7h ago

Pick A or B: canned or fresh cranberry sauce?

21 Upvotes

I love making fresh cranberry sauce (cranberries, sugar, orange juice and some zest orange zest). A previous year I was surprised to see that my friend wont eat any cranberry sauce that didn't come straight from the can. I don't want to make or buy if but since she's coming again I've been advised to just make the canned one

What would you do?

A: make the canned one (be a gracious host)

B: make both (it's one of my favorite foods this time of year)


r/PickAorB • • 3h ago

Work situation: A or B?

8 Upvotes

I was late to work today. I work in behavioral health where we are expected to keep a specific client-tech ratio. I knew that I was going to be late; I had a thing to do. I arranged for a coworker to stay late and cover me. She agreed to it last Sunday.

Only when I got to work today, she was gone. Iirc, I clocked in 34 minutes late. She left exactly when her shift ended. I suppose she forgot. Do I:

A: email my supervisor telling him I had that half hour or so covered and I don’t know why she didn’t stay

B: wait for him to ask why I was late


r/PickAorB • • 14h ago

A or B: A coworker keeps cooking for me and my own groceries are going bad. Would you keep taking it or ask him to stop?

36 Upvotes

A coworker of mine cooks for me a lot. He'll leave food on my desk, sometimes three full meals at once.

It's good food, and he means well.

The thing is, I plan my meals out every week. I do the shopping and the cooking myself, and now the stuff I bought is going bad in my fridge while I eat his.

I tried passing some of it around the office, but that got weird. He only cooks for two people, him and me.

I told him he really doesn't have to do this. He said, "It's no trouble, I'm cooking anyway."

Part of me thinks I should just say thanks and take it. He's being kind, and saying something could hurt his feelings.

Part of me hates throwing out my own groceries.

I don't think either way is wrong. It's really taking someone's kindness versus sticking to my own plan.

A: Keep taking it. He means well, and it's not worth hurting his feelings over some food.

B: Ask him to cut back or stop. I've got my own plan, and letting food go bad is worse.


r/PickAorB • • 1d ago

A or B: My coworker is collecting $100 from each of us for our boss’s family vacation. I offered $20 like last year and she said “It looks bad if one person does less.”

1.7k Upvotes

There are five of us on the team, and for the past few years, we've had a tradition of getting our boss a Christmas gift. I never really had a problem with it. It's a small team, and I don't mind contributing something to show appreciation.

The gifts have gotten more expensive every year, though. A few years ago, we got him an expensive bottle of whiskey. The next year, it was a table made from a whiskey barrel. This year, my coworker wants to collect money toward a vacation for our boss and his family.

She's asking everyone for $100. Last year, I contributed $20, which seemed perfectly reasonable to me. I was planning to do the same this year. For comparison, when we collect money for a coworker's birthday, everyone usually puts in $5 for a gift card. So going from a small birthday gift to $100 per person for the boss feels like a pretty big jump.

My coworker is organizing the collection and wants everyone to contribute by the end of the month. I told her I could give $20, like last year, but she said, "It looks bad if one person does less."

I pointed out that this is supposed to be voluntary. She said, "It is. But he's going to see the card."

That's the part I'm stuck on. Technically, nobody is forcing me to pay $100. But if I give less, everyone will know, and apparently my boss will know too. It's hard to call something voluntary when there's an expectation that everyone should contribute the same amount and the difference will be visible.

My boss hasn't asked for any of this. I don't know if he even knows how much we're collecting. I also don't want to turn a Christmas gift into an awkward workplace issue. We're a team of five, so it's not like I can quietly disappear into a crowd.

Part of me thinks I should just pay the $100 and avoid making this a bigger deal than it needs to be. It's one contribution, and I still have to work with these people. But another part of me thinks the whole thing has gotten out of hand. I was happy to contribute to a gift. I'm not comfortable paying $100 toward my boss's family vacation just because the gifts have kept getting more extravagant.

A: Pay the $100. It's a small team, everyone else is contributing, and making an issue out of the difference could create unnecessary tension at work.

B: Stick to the $20 I offered. A gift is supposed to be voluntary, and I shouldn't have to match an amount I'm uncomfortable with just to avoid looking bad.


r/PickAorB • • 1d ago

A or B: Shared Xbox at home or work?

22 Upvotes

This is honestly so stupid lol. So much so that I’m genuinely okay with it going either way, but I’m more viewing this as an interesting conundrum of relationships, money, and technology and would love to hear some outside opinions. I’m leaning towards option A because this is so unimportant.

Context: This weekend the new Grand Theft Auto came out and it happened to fall on the same weekend as my husband’s birthday. We knew this was happening for quite some time and made a joint decision that we’d buy a new tv and Xbox in preparation for the game. We had a tiny tv beforehand, and our old Xbox had a lot of issues so it wasn’t just for the new game, but we probably wouldn’t have prioritized it otherwise.

However, since this was falling right around the same time as my husband’s birthday, and I am more financially fluid than he is right now, I offered to pay for it as a gift for his birthday. This consisted of over 3 months of searching for a tv on sale, shopping for it together, finding an Xbox on Facebook marketplace, and then buying the game. My husband helped a lot in these tasks, but I did put up 100% of the money, which all in was about $1000.

We’ve been playing it since it came out together, both enjoying it and taking turns with him playing maybe 75% of the time. It’s his birthday today so that’s totally cool in my opinion!

The issue is that my husband works out of town for 10 days at a time, and after turning the game off tonight he mentioned he wanted to bring the new Xbox with him back to work. My reaction to this was frustration because I’ve been using the Xbox to watch tv and I was kind of looking forward to playing my own version of the game (without impacting his character of course!) since it cost so much and is a pretty cool game! However, I do recognize that it was a gift, and my husband’s job has a lot of boring down time in the winter so I know he could use the game as a great way to stay busy, which I totally would support.

So, I can see both sides. What do y’all think?

A. It was a gift so he should take the new Xbox to work with him so he can play the game there.

B. The Xbox lives at home and should stay there so both people can play the game when they are home.


r/PickAorB • • 1d ago

Which Christmas Lights? A or B?

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

For what it is worth, this is a 1984 built house. In my mind, the multi color lights looks 1984. Right or wrong, I associate white lights with more modern construction


r/PickAorB • • 1d ago

A or B: A close friend asked how much I make because they're considering applying for a similar job. Do I tell them my exact salary or keep it private?

36 Upvotes

He is thinking about applying for a job in the same field, in a role similar to mine. We’ve known each other for years, but never discussed our exact salaries.

He asked, “How much do you make? I’m considering a similar job and want a real number to compare with.” I understand why he wants to know. Online salary ranges can be broad, and an actual number from someone in a similar role would help him know what to expect and ask for.

I’m not used to sharing my exact income, even with close friends. I’m happy to talk about the job and give him advice about applying or negotiating, but I’m not sure I should tell him what I make.

Part of me thinks we’re close enough that I shouldn’t make this a big deal. The other part feels like friendship doesn’t mean sharing every personal detail.

A. Tell him the exact number. We’re close, and it could help him negotiate.

B. Keep it private. I can help him without telling him what I earn.


r/PickAorB • • 2d ago

A or B: My ex dropped off my stuff with a note taped to the box that said “Flight was $412. Venmo’s fine.” It’s the Thanksgiving ticket he booked for me before I broke up with him, and the credit’s in my name

489 Upvotes

He left a box of my stuff on my porch. Taped to the top was a sticky note in his handwriting: “Flight was $412. Venmo’s fine.”

Earlier this fall he said we should do Thanksgiving at his parents’ this year. They’re a flight away. He found the flights, said “I’ll book it,” and put both tickets on his card. Mine was in my name. Neither of us said anything about me paying him back.

A few weeks before Thanksgiving I ended it. He’s still going home.

That kind of ticket, if you just don’t show up, it’s gone. If you cancel ahead of time the airline gives you credit, and the credit goes to whoever’s name is on the ticket no matter who cancels. So I canceled. There’s $412 of credit with that airline in my name now, good for a year. He can’t use it. Only I can.

I called him after I found the note. I said he bought that ticket and I didn’t say I’d pay for it.

“You’ve got $412 sitting in your account. That’s my money. You broke up with me and you get to keep a free flight?”

I said it’s not a free flight, it’s a credit with one airline I wasn’t planning on flying, and it expires.

“So use it. Go somewhere. Just pay me first.”

His sister texted me the next day. We get along. “He’s being petty about it, I’ll say that. But you did end up with the money, kind of.”

He planned that whole trip. I didn’t pick the dates or the airline. If we were still together he wouldn’t be asking me for this. Now that we’re not, he’s calling it a loan. He’s texted twice since asking if I’ve sent it.

A. Pay him the $412. The credit’s in my name and I’ll use it eventually, so that money did end up being mine. And I’m the one who ended it.

B. Don’t pay it. It was his idea and his booking, and he didn’t call it a loan. What I’ve got is a credit for one airline that runs out in a year, not $412 in my pocket.


r/PickAorB • • 2d ago

A or B: If a kid asks you straight out whether Santa is real, do you tell the truth?

263 Upvotes

My 8yo niece caught me alone and asked, “Is Santa real? Don’t lie.”

I said, “What do you think?” and changed the subject.

Later I told my sister. She said, “She’s eight. Let her have one more Christmas.”

Part of me feels like if a kid asks you straight out and says don’t lie, you don’t lie to her. Part of me knows she’s my sister’s kid, and that’s my sister’s call to make. I don’t think either way is wrong. It’s really telling the truth when you’re asked versus leaving it to her parents.

What would you do?

A. Tell her the truth if she asks again. She asked straight out, so she shouldn’t get lied to.

B. Don’t answer it. Tell her that’s a question for her mom, and let my sister handle it.


r/PickAorB • • 3d ago

A or B: My aunt wants to sell my grandfather's old answering machine, but it still has messages from relatives who died years ago

465 Upvotes

My grandfather passed away last year and we've slowly been clearing out his house. My aunt found his old answering machine in a kitchen drawer and apparently some collector offered her $180 for it because it's a pretty rare model.

Here's the thing though. It still works, and there are about 20 messages saved on it. Some are from my grandmother who died in 2014, others from relatives we haven't heard from in over a decade.

I offered my aunt $100 from stake to let me keep it, but she refused because she doesn't feel right taking money from family. She still wants to sell it though, saying the money would help cover the costs of clearing out the house. She suggested I record the messages on my phone first, which honestly sounds reasonable.

But something about getting rid of the actual machine bothers me. My grandfather used it for nearly 30 years and never deleted those messages.

A: Record everything and let her sell it. The voices are what matter, not the plastic box.

B: Try convincing her to let me keep the machine. There's probably a reason he held onto those recordings for so long.


r/PickAorB • • 1d ago

A or B: Gta6 vs Poe2 Which one will you choose?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Which game will you choose to grind first? Dont say both I don't have that much time


r/PickAorB • • 2d ago

A or B: helping an alcoholic drink

1 Upvotes

So I don’t actually know if she was an alcoholic… but it was noon.

Was traveling home when a stranger near me asked me to help her open a little airplane sized bottle of liquor. Seemed like she was trying to make a little Irish coffee. Being the gentleman that I am I was totally willing to help.

The lid was really stuck on there. Like really stuck. My stop was coming up next, so I said I’d try until it came. But as I’m struggling with opening it, I start wondering if I’m doing the right thing.

She even joked that the lid being stuck might be divine intervention. I could have given up and just returned the bottle to her still sealed… but I love a little project and hate telling people no. So 5+ minutes later I get it open and hand it back to her.

What would you have done? Is it my business what a stranger does if it’s not hurting anyone? Should I have (A) “tried” and returned it to her unopened instead of (B) getting her the drink she wanted?


r/PickAorB • • 2d ago

A or B - wedding or family portrait

7 Upvotes

For the last 5 years, we have had a large-ish canvas print of our wedding portrait hanging above the fireplace mantle. We recently had our third baby and got family portraits done. Hubby now thinks that we should replace our wedding picture with a family portrait. What does reddit think? A - keep the wedding picture or B - replace with a family picture

74 votes, 2h left
wedding portrait
family portrait

r/PickAorB • • 3d ago

A or B: My coworker keeps asking me to cover her shifts last minute. The one time I said no, she said “Must be nice to have all that free time. You don’t have kids.”

122 Upvotes

My coworker asks me to cover her shifts a lot, usually last minute. For a long time I said yes.

Most of her reasons didn’t sound urgent to me. The few times I needed someone to cover for me, she couldn’t. She’d say she had something going on.

Then she asked again and I said no. She said, “Must be nice to have all that free time. You don’t have kids, so it’s not like you’re busy with anything important.”

I told her, “Just because I don’t have kids doesn’t mean I don’t have a life.”

Since then a couple of coworkers have been taking her side. Little comments about me not being much of a team player.

When I covered for her before, I wanted to help. And I know she has kids. Sometimes she really can’t get out of things. Idk, do I keep covering for her?

A. Keep covering sometimes. Getting along with the team matters, and with kids she really does get stuck sometimes.

B. Stop covering. She doesn’t cover for me when I need it, and my time off counts too.


r/PickAorB • • 4d ago

A or B: Tell the people buying my childhood home that the "historic" feature they're paying extra for is completely fake?

2.3k Upvotes

My parents sold our old house about eight years ago. Last week while I was on moon I randomly found it listed for sale again and noticed the description makes a huge deal about the original 1890s stonework above the front door.

Here's the thing. My dad bought that stone at a garden center in 2006. It has 1894 carved into it and he thought it looked cool, so he installed it himself.

The house was built in 1978 lol.

The listing has multiple closeup photos of it and mentions the home's historic character like five times. I have no idea if the current owners genuinely believe it or they're just trying to make the place sound more valuable.

A: Contact the realtor and explain where the stone actually came from.

B: Mind my own business. It's not my house anymore and the buyers can do their own research.

Would you actually get involved in something like this?


r/PickAorB • • 3d ago

A or B: Get a Potential Cancer Diagnostic now, or Wait a Month for 2027 for Additional Healthcare Benefits?

35 Upvotes

I just had a colonoscopy, and the doctor found a mass in my colon that could be colon cancer. They weren't able to test it during the procedure because of its placement, so I have a CT scan scheduled for Friday.

However, we're doing medical benefits enrollment right now, and there's a new section to our benefit package: Critical Illness. For $15/mo, I can get $30k if I get diagnosed with cancer (or something else) during 2027.

I currently feel fine, no health effects so far. We had broached the subject of waiting till Jan 2027 so that the deductible didn't reset (yay American healthcare; having to make decisions on what makes sense financially, not just health-wise), but the doctor doing the colonoscopy said to get it diagnosed as soon as I can.

So, should I:

A: Go through with the CT scan, see if it's colon cancer, and ignore the critical illness benefit. We're well enough off that we can afford the max out-of-pocket that we'll hit ($7k) + the remaining deductible this year ($1k), but it's money that we're earmarking for other things and will set us back.

B: Cancel the CT scan, reschedule for Jan (5 weeks away), and get the benefit to offset the max OOP plus any costs associated with cancer.

Edit: Looks like the policy has a 6 month look-back clause, so any tests taken during that time would invalidate the claim. Thanks for the added information.

2nd Edit: Got my CT scan this morning. Hoping for results tonight. Thanks for all the good advice to not wait.


r/PickAorB • • 3d ago

A or B: Should I apologize or let the broach the subject?

5 Upvotes

I live in an apartment and am getting ready to move units. I was informed that maintenance would need to enter my apartment to do an assessment to see if they just want to clean it or strip it and update it. Yesterday I gave them authorization. Today I received notification on my phone that “Movement was detected in my apartment” and I checked the web cam to make sure it was just maintenance. It was. The maintenance team is composed of two ladies, one of which I believe may be a “butch”.

When I opened the camera, one of them was checking out my office desk (don’t know what that has to do with updating the floors and countertops, but whatever) and I hear her say “This guy has one of those naked boob calendars”. The other says “Really??” In a tone that seemed more interested than disgusted.

Yes, I have a naked titty calendar on my office desk. It is a very small calendar 2”x3” so most people that aren’t looking around the desk completely miss it.

So here’s the choice….

Should I

A: go to the office tomorrow (or look around the property) and find the ladies and apologize to them admitting it was inappropriate to leave it uncovered

Or

B: leave it be and only apologize if they bring it up?

I’m concerned that A would also tip them off that I had a webcam. The only reason this concerns me is because society is different today. Even though it’s my apartment some people could say it was an invasion of privacy. They also seemed to be slightly envious of some of my work related swag (which they would probably use in their line of work) which I would also like to give them, but how do I broach that?

“Hey, I saw you on my webcam admiring some of this stuff. Would you like it?” That also seems creepy….


r/PickAorB • • 4d ago

A or B: Someone left an unsigned letter in our mailbox saying they’ll cut down our trees if our leaves keep blowing into their yard. We think we know who

1.5k Upvotes

We have a few chestnut trees in our yard. They’re on our property, and every fall a lot of the leaves blow over into the yard next door.

We rake them up, just not always right away.

Then a letter showed up in our mailbox. No name, no stamp, no return address. All it said was: “Your leaves are all over my yard again. Deal with it or I’ll deal with those trees myself.”

We’re pretty sure we know who wrote it. The neighbor on that side has caused problems for us before. He hasn’t said a word to us about the leaves.

If he had talked to us nicely about it, we would’ve raked the leaves up a bit more.

We put up cameras after the letter. It’s the middle of leaf season, so the leaves are still coming down.

A) Rake more often this season and keep the leaves on our side. We haven’t always gotten to them right away, and it’s not worth turning this into something bigger.

B) Take the letter to the police and put up no trespassing signs. The trees are ours, and that letter is a threat to destroy them.


r/PickAorB • • 4d ago

A or B: Let my pottery teacher sell a mug I made by accident or tell her it's literally a mistake?

378 Upvotes

So I've been taking pottery classes for about two months and I'm genuinely terrible at it.

A few weeks ago I made this mug that came out completely crooked. The handle is way too big, the rim isn't even and it honestly looks like something you'd find at an archaeological dig.

My instructor apparently loved it.

She put it on a display shelf at the studio and last week told me three people asked if it was for sale. Now she wants me to make a few more for the studio's Christmas market.

The problem is I have absolutely no clue how to recreate it. I wasn't trying to make anything artistic, I was watching my moon position and I just suck at pottery lol.

She keeps calling it my signature style and I haven't had the heart to correct her.

A: Tell her the truth and risk killing her enthusiasm.

B: Attempt to recreate the disaster and see if people actually buy them.

I genuinely can't believe this is a decision I'm having to make.


r/PickAorB • • 3d ago

A or B: Do you still give your mail carrier something for the holidays?

4 Upvotes

Growing up, my parents put some cash in a card for our mail carrier every December. I was going to do the same this year.

Then I looked it up. Mail carriers aren’t allowed to take cash or gift cards. They can accept a gift worth $20 or less per occasion, and that’s it.

When I told my partner, they laughed. “So now we’re baking him cookies? He’s got a federal job. He’s fine.”

I also saw a survey where only about a quarter of people said they planned to tip their mail carrier for the holidays.

I don’t think either of us is wrong. To me it’s a once-a-year thank you. To my partner it’s his job, and now there are rules on top of it.

A- Give something. A small gift under $20, once a year, as a thank you.

B- Skip it. It’s his job, and with all the rules it’s not worth the hassle.


r/PickAorB • • 5d ago

A or B: My neighbor is moving and apparently I'm inheriting 11 people's spare house keys without anyone asking me

1.7k Upvotes

So the elderly woman across the street is moving after 27 years. She's basically been the unofficial emergency contact for our whole street. Locked yourself out? She has a key. Need someone to let a plumber in? Call her.

Yesterday while I was watching kick she knocked on my door holding a biscuit tin with 11 labeled house keys inside.

Apparently she's decided I'm taking over because I work from home and I'm "the responsible one."

I laughed thinking she was joking. She wasn't.

The funny part is one neighbor has already texted me asking if I'll be available Thursday to let someone into their house. I haven't even agreed to anything yet lol.

I don't mind helping people but I barely know half these households. I also don't particularly want to become the street's unpaid receptionist.

A) Take the keys temporarily and ask everyone to collect theirs unless they actually want me to hold onto it.

B) Refuse the whole arrangement. She collected those keys, she can return them before she moves.

Would you take the biscuit tin?


r/PickAorB • • 4d ago

A or B: When you live together and one of you makes more, do you split rent 50/50 or by income?

56 Upvotes

My girlfriend and I live together, and we’ve split everything 50/50 since we moved in. Rent, groceries, utilities.

She makes about a third more than I do. After the bills, she’s putting a lot more into savings each month than I am.

I asked if we could split by income instead. She said, “We’re partners, not a charity. Half is half.”

Part of me gets it. 50/50 is clean and it keeps things even between us. She sees it as us being equals.

Part of me thinks if we each paid the same share of what we make, we’d be carrying the same load.

I don’t think either of us is wrong. It comes down to whether fair means the same amount or the same share.

A: 50/50. You live together, you split it evenly. Simple.

B: By income. Whoever makes more pays a bit more, so it’s the same share for both.

How do you do it?