r/PickAorB • • 2d ago

A or B: helping an alcoholic drink

So I don’t actually know if she was an alcoholic… but it was noon.

Was traveling home when a stranger near me asked me to help her open a little airplane sized bottle of liquor. Seemed like she was trying to make a little Irish coffee. Being the gentleman that I am I was totally willing to help.

The lid was really stuck on there. Like really stuck. My stop was coming up next, so I said I’d try until it came. But as I’m struggling with opening it, I start wondering if I’m doing the right thing.

She even joked that the lid being stuck might be divine intervention. I could have given up and just returned the bottle to her still sealed… but I love a little project and hate telling people no. So 5+ minutes later I get it open and hand it back to her.

What would you have done? Is it my business what a stranger does if it’s not hurting anyone? Should I have (A) “tried” and returned it to her unopened instead of (B) getting her the drink she wanted?

0 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

2

u/Sevennix 1d ago

If she had said that to me, id ask her if she just wanted it back, or let me take it for her. Divine intervention works both ways!

1

u/wateryoudoingthere 1d ago

Yeah it was that comment where I started to really question whether I was actually helping her or not

8

u/Secret_Morning_2939 2d ago

As you stated: she was a stranger. You didn’t know her at all so why make a judgment about her drinking habits. You were being courteous. Why not leave it at that? Go with B (which you did so it’s in the past anyway).

5

u/IdkJustMe123 2d ago

There’s no reason to assume she’s an alcoholic.

And even if she is, she’d have gotten that open one way or another. You not helping wouldn’t have changed anything. You were just being nice, don’t sweat it.

As a woman with no upper arm strength who often struggles to open all kinds of bottles and lids, I appreciate your kindness!

3

u/Dry-Welder-5035 2d ago

Not your business.

1

u/PianistNo8873 19h ago

B- there’s nothing to say this person was an alcoholic. Maybe a nervous traveler who needed to take the edge off anxiety, maybe a holiday drinker who wanted a wee nip in her coffee. Or maybe she’s actually someone who has a schedule that makes morning or early afternoon drinking look like something it’s not for example: my husband is a graveyard worker 5pm-6am and so yes getting off work at 6am and having a drink or two before going to bed at 10am seems wrong & to some like there’s an issue but it’s his after work time just like me getting off work at 5pm and having a drink or two.

1

u/ChickyBoys 5h ago

You don't owe a stranger anything.