r/PokeGrading • u/zaull • 16h ago
Cracked 5 CGC 10s and a CGC 9 to resubmit to PSA... got wrecked. Resubmit or cut my losses?
Took a gamble recently on some cross-grading arbitrage. I picked up 5 CGC 10s and 1 CGC 9, cracked the slabs myself and sent them in raw to PSA hoping to convert a few into PSA 10s. The grades:
5x PSA 8s
1x PSA 9
0x PSA 10s
Pretty brutal return. I was careful cracking them, so I'm shocked that CGC 10s dropped all the way to PSA 8s. Whether I got a tough grader, missed surface/print issues under CGC's holder or dinged something during the crack.
For those of you who do a lot of crack and resubmits, what’s the move here? Resub or cut my losses?