r/PokeGrading • • 21h ago Bravo

First PSA submission. Is $600+ normal?

Thumbnail
gallery
192 Upvotes

I recently found my childhood Pokémon card collection and pulled out the 11 cards I think are worth the most. This would be my first time submitting cards for grading. When I entered them in the PSA app, the total came out to over $600. Does that sound normal for 11 cards, or could I be picking the wrong service tier?

My goal is to sell them and get as much as I can after grading fees. I’ve gotten mixed advice locally. Some people say to stick with PSA for resale, while others have told me to go with a different grading company.

For those of you who buy and sell vintage Pokémon cards, would you go with PSA, CGC, Beckett, or someone else?

I’d appreciate any advice before I spend $600 on my first submission.


r/PokeGrading • • 6h ago

Got my first ever submission back from PSA!

Post image
29 Upvotes

Twins!


r/PokeGrading • • 18h ago

What to expect when grading with BGS?

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

Got this clean Pichu 1st ed and thinking about grading it with BGS. Thought I’d post it here and ask what you guys think it would return as?


r/PokeGrading • • 20h ago

Quick question.

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

First off. Thx for looking and helping me out.

I collect everything gastly, haunter and gengar.

One of my fave gastly cards that I have double i am thinking about grading so I can display it in my "mancave"

Do ya'll think this card is good enough to get graded?

The Slabbed cards In my "mancave" currently have grades 8 and 9 and I would like to keep it like that with 8's, 9's and 10's.

Do ya'll think this card is clean enough that it would grade 8/9/10?

If not. i am not gonna waste my money and. look for a cleaner copy to grade.

(i am not selling or trying drive up the price, I just don't wanna waste my money grading this and get a 7 or lower)

(as a bonus, i posted some of my ghostly trio collection)


r/PokeGrading • • 10h ago

PSA 1 goals: is my 23k gold BK card too damaged to grade?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I have a feeling the answer is yes, but I understand that grading a 1 is more subjective. Looking for other collectors take on it! Don’t wanna send it out if it’s just gonna come back N9 Not Graded. That said, I’m a big fan of the “fossilized” look and would love to preserve this card if it can’t be slabbed. Any tips?


r/PokeGrading • • 14h ago

Advice on my 1999 embossed Meiji Promo cards

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I have all 24 Meiji embossed/"get card"/promo cards. I bought them over 20 years ago and they have remained in a binder in their original sleeves until today when I moved them to semi-rigids in preparation for grading.

From what I understand, there are very few of these in pristine condition because they were originally distributed in chocolate boxes, so most have surface wear. Some of mine do, but to my eye, some of them are flawless.

However, I don't really know how to pre-grade these. They aren't like normal cards, so I don't know how the guidelines would work. For example, how do I know if it is a well-centered card? I am also having a hard time telling what is a real flaw and what is just part of the card itself.

Examples, sorry these are really hard to take good photos of because of the embossing and holo:

Togepi Surface scratching or possibly some sort of print defect? Hard to tell. How much would you expect this to impact the grade?

Gengar Looks flawless, but maybe the centering is bad? The embossing is not centered, but like the background is edge-to-edge so what exactly is the thing that is supposed to be centered?

Ash/Misty/Pikachu Uploaded this one as an example of maybe good centering? You can see the embossing is centered better, but again, is the emboss supposed to be centered, or the image itself? And this one has *very* slight whitening in the bottom left corner, is it enough to knock me down a grade?

Just trying to figure out if I should only send in a handful, or yolo the whole set and see what happens.

Lastly, what grading company should I go with? I am hearing rumblings of PSA being hard on vintage cards. Would these fall into that trap? Should I try CGC instead?

Any advice is appreciated.


r/PokeGrading • • 3h ago

childhood collection, what’s the value here?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/PokeGrading • • 10h ago

Will Print Lines Impact This Giratina V Ultra Rare Grade?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/PokeGrading • • 11h ago

What grade do you think ill get?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/PokeGrading • • 16h ago

Warning for anyone grading through Fanatics Collect: Support admitted in writing they DO NOT itemize cards before shipping to BGS (3+ month Express delay)

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/PokeGrading • • 21h ago

First Time Grading Vintage Questions

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

So in 2020 I bought a bunch of legendary collection packs and opened them for fun. It was Covid years and my roommates and I wanted to relive nostalgia.

I have these cards, but I am unsure what the best advice is these days. Most of them are in the same condition as the one shown, but I am unsure if I should go through PSA or CGC? Is it even worth it? Does anybody have advice, it doesn’t have to be about these cards specifically since I did not take the best pictures of them all, but how does the vintage grading scene look these days?


r/PokeGrading • • 22h ago

Is this Gengar considered damaged, and is there anything I can/should do about it?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Hello, I happened to find what is obviously a pretty good card from when I was a kid in an old box.

The back looks okay but the front has some obvious problems, mainly the ripple/crease going across the text box. There is also a bit of whitening and a small indent on the right middle edge. It looks better at most angles, especially inside a toploader sleeve, but it's very noticeable at some angles, like in the third pic.

I don't know very much about grading as I've mainly been more of a tcg player than a collector. Is this level of imperfection considered a damaged condition? Is there anything I can or should do to fix it?

Thank you!


r/PokeGrading • • 23h ago

My Pop 1 PSA 10 Error Mewtwo featured in PSA Magazine

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

Thanks to catchemallkyle for letting me know it was featured in the September issue


r/PokeGrading • • 39m ago

1999 Base Set Unlimited — PSA grade predictions?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/PokeGrading • • 46m ago

Is this real or fake?

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/PokeGrading • • 56m ago

Rough Cut Edges

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Hi! I've only graded once and I actually had a pretty solid return / got lucky. I subbed 9 cards and only 3 received 9's. I've already got a pile set aside for my next submission but I wanted to see if anyone has submitted cards with a slight spot of rough edges. I'm not sure if this comes across in the photos well, but along the borders of this card at the top. There are almost like little specs of paper fuzz that stick up from the edge. As if the edge is slightly fuzzy from being cut with a rough edge. Aside from that I do believe this card has the centering and corners to have a shot at a 10 assuming there aren't surface defects I'm not seeing (always possible I know.) If anyone has any advice, please let me know. I also have some one piece cards in my collection that have the same thing and show this better on camera


r/PokeGrading • • 4h ago

First time grading - do I send it?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Thinking about sending in a childhood card of mine - not in the best shape, but many claim to "always grade gold stars". Would be my first time ever sending something to get graded.

Since I'm from Europe - do i send to PSA? Beckett? CGC?

Also what grade would you guys guess it gets? The Holo is clean and the card overall looks good, but once you check it under a microscope it does have a bunch of flaws.

Goal is to ultimately sell it - all help appreciated


r/PokeGrading • • 11h ago

Would you guya buy this to send out for grading?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

New to the hobby snd grading in general, have the opportunity to pick this up for $1100, if it was modern I wouldnt bother because of centering, but being vintage, would you roll the dice on it?


r/PokeGrading • • 13h ago

Need advice 🙏🏻

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Picked up this card a few days ago and only just noticed a faint print line under grading lighting conditions.

Would this affect the PSA grade, particularly the chances of getting a PSA 10? Cause the card itself is clean with psa 10 centering.


r/PokeGrading • • 14h ago

Favorite Card is the Reverse Holo Quilava from Pokemon Sandstorm. How Best to Find one to Send in to Grade in a 10?

1 Upvotes

Hey y'all, so I'm totally new to this space, but randomly been watching DeepPocketMonster on YouTube and it's making me want to collect too haha. I want to grade my favorite card/artwork in a 10, which is the Reverse Holo Quilava from Pokemon Sandstorm. I'd be open to buying one in a PSA 10 but unfortunately it's literally a pop 1 lol so I doubt I'll ever find the guy and I wouldn't even know if he wanted to sell it.

Also after watching YouTubers, I really want to get it in a TAG 10 since I just love the look of the slab. I just don't really know where to start as I'm assuming I'm going to have to grade it myself since I doubt this card is a popular card to grade.

Would it be best to just go to card shops or look online for some near mint copies and try to develop a good eye for what a grader would like?


r/PokeGrading • • 16h ago

Input on grading these?

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

I’ve wanted these cards from my personal collection binder to be in PSA slabs and would like input on what the estimated grade could/would be? I know these aren’t in pristine condition but, I’d like to see at least some PSA 7s if that looks possible. It is my first time grading with any company and would love all input! (Images taken from PSA uploads. Some cards have specs on them from the sleeve. I don’t know if that hurts my grade.)

It’s been about 6 business days and they’re already on the stage “Holder & label review”.

(And yes there are two Dialga EX cards. One is clearly in worse shape than the other)


r/PokeGrading • • 16h ago

Brand new to grading

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Sorry if the pictures arnt the best lol, I was wanting to get some fresh eyes and much more experienced opinions on this Mewtwo I picked up the other day. If I were to send it in, where should I send it? Ive seen the countless PSA hate posts, along with the fact idk if I can afford the grading fee if this were to get a 10. Is a 10 unrealistic on a card like this? Ive been considering TAG and CGC. Let me know guys!! All comments greatly appreciated, I just wanna get pointed in the right direction.


r/PokeGrading • • 18h ago

Worth getting this Yuka Morii Psyduck graded?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes