r/RingsofPower • u/Elendil_686 • 12h ago
Discussion The showrunners should have kept the storylines simple since the start.
There is no need for mystery box, adding characters that isn't supposed to appear for a thousand years later, love triangle, moralley grey foes and changing the main character so much. Frankly, had Payne and McKay played it more safe, I think more fans of Middle Earth in general wouldn't be vehemently oppose to the show. Examples:
-Galadriel should be stoic and wise. Miriel show is what I wanted Galadriel to be. She can still do her sword stuff.
-No Istari and no Harfoots.
-Elves with long hair. All of them. Even Arondir.
-Armor more in the dna of Peter Jackson's movies.
-Prologue of the First Age battle is longer and involves balrogs, fell beasts, eagles and trolls.
-Only three seasons instead of five. Start already season 1 with the forging of the elven rings with Celebrimbor. The mithril stuff is controversial but I think most people will ovelook it as long as the show try to stick so much to the lore as possible.
-Galadriel not hunting Sauron. She and Celeborn arrives to ME with many elves to find a new home.
-Bad guy will be a human warlord name Hallbrand. Sauron in disguise actually. He summons many Southlanders allied with Easterlings and Haradrim to spread terror and conquer lands. Working with Adar and his orcs as well. New origin story where Adar doesn't kill Sauron and all that nonsense.
-Instead of a sick Tar-Palantir, he will play a major role of being a elf-friend. Galadriel goes to Numenor with a few elves to convince him to send help against Hallbrand hordes.
-Season ends with Southlanders being defeated and Hallbrand supposedly killed. But since he's Sauron, he cannot be killed and is alive. Fleeing to pre-Mordor.
Season 2 will be Sauron using dark sorcery to awaken Oroduin and Mordor comes alive. The remaining Southlanders together with Adar's orcs overrun Eregion. Tar Palantir greets Gil-Galad and Cirdan and both of them agrees Sauron must be stopped. Sends a huge force to ME and together with Galadriel-Celeborn's army of Lorien elves, they defeat Sauron's army in the Battle of Gwathlo. Sauron escapes to Mordor again. Tar-Palantir dies and Ar-Pharazon takes over.
-Other storylines in season 1 and 2 will be the Khazad-Dum and Woodland Realm. Side stories about their culture and problems with orcs harassing them.
-Season 3 is about Pharazon capturing Sauron and bring him back to Numenor. Numenor sinks and we go straight to the Battle of Dagorlad. End of story.