r/RingsofPower • • 12h ago

Discussion The showrunners should have kept the storylines simple since the start.

0 Upvotes

There is no need for mystery box, adding characters that isn't supposed to appear for a thousand years later, love triangle, moralley grey foes and changing the main character so much. Frankly, had Payne and McKay played it more safe, I think more fans of Middle Earth in general wouldn't be vehemently oppose to the show. Examples:

-Galadriel should be stoic and wise. Miriel show is what I wanted Galadriel to be. She can still do her sword stuff.

-No Istari and no Harfoots.

-Elves with long hair. All of them. Even Arondir.

-Armor more in the dna of Peter Jackson's movies.

-Prologue of the First Age battle is longer and involves balrogs, fell beasts, eagles and trolls.

-Only three seasons instead of five. Start already season 1 with the forging of the elven rings with Celebrimbor. The mithril stuff is controversial but I think most people will ovelook it as long as the show try to stick so much to the lore as possible.

-Galadriel not hunting Sauron. She and Celeborn arrives to ME with many elves to find a new home.

-Bad guy will be a human warlord name Hallbrand. Sauron in disguise actually. He summons many Southlanders allied with Easterlings and Haradrim to spread terror and conquer lands. Working with Adar and his orcs as well. New origin story where Adar doesn't kill Sauron and all that nonsense.

-Instead of a sick Tar-Palantir, he will play a major role of being a elf-friend. Galadriel goes to Numenor with a few elves to convince him to send help against Hallbrand hordes.

-Season ends with Southlanders being defeated and Hallbrand supposedly killed. But since he's Sauron, he cannot be killed and is alive. Fleeing to pre-Mordor.

Season 2 will be Sauron using dark sorcery to awaken Oroduin and Mordor comes alive. The remaining Southlanders together with Adar's orcs overrun Eregion. Tar Palantir greets Gil-Galad and Cirdan and both of them agrees Sauron must be stopped. Sends a huge force to ME and together with Galadriel-Celeborn's army of Lorien elves, they defeat Sauron's army in the Battle of Gwathlo. Sauron escapes to Mordor again. Tar-Palantir dies and Ar-Pharazon takes over.

-Other storylines in season 1 and 2 will be the Khazad-Dum and Woodland Realm. Side stories about their culture and problems with orcs harassing them.

-Season 3 is about Pharazon capturing Sauron and bring him back to Numenor. Numenor sinks and we go straight to the Battle of Dagorlad. End of story.


r/RingsofPower • • 6h ago

Constructive Criticism From Valinor - insane directorial calls Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I’ve endured this for a while, but this episode was by far one of the laziest episodes in the series. Shots, edits, writing that made no sense;

  1. “We will need another horse” - an excellent way to establish a stealth mission, maybe some camaraderie with a former foe, build trust. Nope. Cut to a horse appearing from nowhere. It wasn’t even the horse she was going to take.
  2. An orc observes the torture? 08:34 - a head pops up behind Sauron. Out of focus, in shot, actor doesn’t appear in the scene, someone popped in? The take was so good they thought it wasn’t noticeable? Director took a pee break? Who knows.
  3. THAT dwarf. Lady Freya? What’s going on there? S1 established some pretty dope femme dwarves but S3, The costume is ridiculous, the being knocked out but not really knocked out bit is lazy at best. Did chat gpt write it? We need to 86 the dwarves, we’ve dropped every ball here. We’re going the way of the harfoots.
  4. Harfoots. No notes, so grateful we’ve mostly abandoned that by this point.
  5. Honestly I’m probably forgetting the rest. Let me know your thoughts

r/RingsofPower • • 5h ago

Meme ROP 67 easter egg S3 EP6 min 48:55

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 19h ago

Question New to LOTR, just finished S1....

30 Upvotes

Is it only down from here? My buddy said this show is trash but I really liked S1, I found the hunting for sauron only for him to be right beside her gimmick quite enjoyable and the characters likeable. (My friend says its because I havent seen the original movies that I dont mind it.)

So I guess my question is: Is this show hated because its actually bad, or because it strays from the original source material? A quick google search told me that its not even supposed to be cannon, but like I said im a newbie here so enlighten me.

EDIT: Thank you everyone for sharing your thoughts and opinions, Im excited to continue watching and develop my own opinion now after seeing all of yours!


r/RingsofPower • • 19h ago

Discussion Season 3 so far

3 Upvotes

I did not like S1 and S2. I did read the LOTR books and love the extended editions of the films so I consider myself a fan going Into the series with high expectations sadly… but I am ac tu ally enjoying S3! I wonder if the first two seasons were building up for this or if they truly were just crap pacing. :)


r/RingsofPower • • 46m ago

Discussion Where does the most money go to?

0 Upvotes

So just a general question. I just finished the last published episode of season 3.

And there were no large battles, crazy complex scenes but mostly dialogues between few people or so.

So I am wondering, like actually, where does the most money go into? Like the costumes don‘t look high quality sadly and the actors are mostly new.. they also copied a lot of other shows and ofc of Tolkien. So there isn‘t much originality in it either..

So what’s the expensive part? Like game of thrones didn’t cost that much for all of the seasons (correct me if I’m wrong).


r/RingsofPower • • 11h ago

Discussion I feel that the show writers kind of shot themselves in the foot with the witch king

0 Upvotes

I feel that Theo will likely have a redemption arc but this puts the show writers in a dilemma as to who else they can make the witch king as they all know we want to see the witch king’s origin

But the issue is that they just don’t have too many characters with depth that they can use at this time - the only other option I see is Kemen or Belzager

Alternatively (which I highly doubt) they may just introduce a random character next season and just give him a strong character development and eventually show him becoming the witch king 🤷‍♂️

I strongly see Theo becoming the King of the Dead… becuase of his character arc and Sauron hinting at him becoming a “king”


r/RingsofPower • • 1h ago

Discussion I guess casual audience and mainstream outlets likes what the showrunners have done with TROP?

0 Upvotes

I watched interviews of the showrunners from various media outlets. NONE of them ask critical questions about the lore breaking and controversial things they invented like the 'love triangle', mithril plot and the Istaris being in the Second Age. So I guess it's just people with knowledge of Tolkien's work are angry about the changes while normal audience who just know the word LOTR either don't care or are happy about all the changes.


r/RingsofPower • • 51m ago

Discussion Amazon had one chance to do the right thing. And it didnt.

0 Upvotes

Amazon should have cancelled the show after S2. Fired the Showrunners. Apologised to the fans. And started fresh. That would have been a proper reboot!

Not whatever Amazon did with S3.


r/RingsofPower • • 11h ago

Discussion Favorite characters so far?

16 Upvotes

My top three are:

  1. Elrond - I love his character depth - I feel that the show really does a good job of showing his emotions including frustrations he faces, the emotional tug he felt when going to Numenor
  2. Adar - we cannot forget him! One of the strongest character arcs out there - he had lots of people rooting for him and the orcs
  3. The nuzgol - they are aura farming everytime!

r/RingsofPower • • 3h ago

Newest Episode Spoilers Well...

Post image
34 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 14h ago

Discussion S3 Galadriel looking like Legolas?

0 Upvotes

The episodes I’ve seen of S3 so far, I’ve felt that Galadriel is looking really similar to Legolas. More so than the other series I think.
Anyone else?
Or maybe I’m late to the party and this has been mentioned before!!😂


r/RingsofPower • • 5h ago

Discussion I think Rings of Power is dangerous for true Tolkien fans

0 Upvotes

Hey guys, I actually think it's quite dangerous to watch Rings of Power. It pollutes the brain and twists the facts, and at some point your memory no longer knows what was true and what wasn't.

I watched the first episodes of season 1 because I was so looking forward to it. When I realized how bad it was, I skipped the rest of season 1 and all of season 2. I started season 3 because I heard some positive reactions. But now I see it's just as twisted, such a lie. So many things are absolutely fake, not true, idiotic. I'm stopping and not continuing.

In my view, if you're a true admirer of what Tolkien did, you shouldn't watch it. Don't pollute your brain, don't poison your heart.


r/RingsofPower • • 22h ago

Newest Episode Spoilers Thoughts on latest episodes Spoiler

15 Upvotes
  1. I am having fun with the latest season, here are some of my favorite parts of the series:
  • The visuals are top notch.
  • The music is spectacular.
  • The orcs are my favorite part of the show.
  • Love all the nature scenes, especially Lorién.
  • Mordor looks very cool.
  • Númenor plot line & politics is much better this season.
  1. While I have been enjoying the season, there are some aspects that I have not enjoyed as much.
  • Celeborn being captured a second time was unnecessary but it's obvious it was used for the plot development. Too many characters being captured & imprisoned in general.
  • Durin IV's son being annoying & using that as part of moving the narrative forward was not needed.
  • The time compression & narrative changes of Tolkien's work is starting to show even more so this season.
  • Too many call backs to the Jackson films.
  • Arondir's ending was underwhelming.
  • Too much contrived drama.
  • Too many scenes of Galadriel hiding. We get it lol.

r/RingsofPower • • 22h ago

Fanart This is what Sauron was doing right before he deceived Celeborn Spoiler

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 14h ago

Constructive Criticism Celeborb's recapture

57 Upvotes

Am I the only one who thinks that after Galadriel and Celeborn fly off on a giant eagle, them being dropped off smack in the middle of wilderness without any protection from Sauron's army is weird? Why didn't the prince of giant eagles drop them off in front of the gates of some well protected elven city ? Did the eagle get lazy all of sudden and was like "well guys I'm dropping yall off here good luck walking a couple of weeks back to civilization, I'm off". maybe I missed a detail, but sounds like a major plot hole to me


r/RingsofPower • • 23h ago

Discussion Ring of power season 3

0 Upvotes

Am i the only one who thinks the king of khaza dum king can do better and her wife ohh goodness, she is ill,

Anyways how you guys are finding this new season so far

#ringofpower


r/RingsofPower • • 7h ago

Fanart I made a Middle Earth Google Map (free & open-source)

9 Upvotes

I always had a hard time understanding the geography of Tolkien’s world. Whenever a place came up in the LOTR movies, I had to pause and look it up on one of the maps, which were raster images. It took a lot of effort to find each place.

With the new series out, I decided to build (tbh, vibe-code) an interactive map for Middle-earth, kind of like Google Maps. You can search for places, follow journeys, and find encyclopedia links or images for key locations. There are even 3D “street views” for some of them! Click any point along a journey to see the estimated date and what happened there. This was only possible thanks to earlier work on GIS maps and elevation data for Middle-earth.

It’s free and doesn’t require a login or registration. It’s also open source on GitHub, so you are welcome to contribute!

https://peymvn.github.io/middle-earth-interactive-map/