r/Scream • • 15h ago

Discussion Which Ghostface motive do you think was the weakest/silliest?

5 Upvotes

For me, it might be Jill just not wanting to work, or Mickey just wanting to become a famous serial killer for the love of the game.

What are your thoughts?


r/Scream • • 11h ago

Discussion Everything that bugs me about Scream 5

7 Upvotes

I love Scream 5. A lot. There are things I adore that they did incredibly well, including the performances of everyone who returned from 4. Loved everything with them.

But story-wise, there are some plot holes or at least glaring issues with story choices. Below are things that bother me:

  1. Stab 8 is the most recent movie that doesn't include Sidney. Stab 7 existed before Scream 4. But Wes says his mom is a character in one of the sequels. Which one? Can't be.
  2. Dewey did NOT have to die for Sidney to return. The way they killed Dewey is so dumb. He still could have died in a heroic way in the third act because the fact is, all legacy characters should have particularly cared about RANDY'S FAMILY. The twins should have been the catalyst, but they are treated as very small side characters. The problem I have here is some will say, "Well, it's about the connection to Billy, so Sam is the lead." Yeah, and that's fine, but we can't just ignore things that don't line up. Dewey should have had an established relationship with them. There is nothing on screen that suggests the twins have ever met anyone related to the past murders. It's just weird how overly ignored they are.
  3. Even if none of the kids ever saw Stab, and most have, common town knowledge would surely be enough for every single character in the movie, including SAM, to know that they were the original murder house. That house would be famous. As soon as someone in their friend group was attacked and a new murder spree started, everyone would be like, "Amber, don't stay home and we ain't going there!" There is no logic that leads to any scenario where every single character wouldn't know that house. There are many famous houses in my hometown, and none of them were in movies, just known for events that happened.
  4. When Sam is first attacked in the hospital break room, the cop is literally right outside those double doors. They make it look like a slightly longer chase because she leaves out the other side and runs around, but he literally turns around where he is standing and opens the double doors to the break room where she was just screaming and tossing furniture around to dodge Ghostface. LOL. So stupid.
  5. Gale was shot and Sidney was stabbed in the stomach, the same place that made her bleed out and pass out in 4, but just needs a magic blanket and no hospital visit in 5. LOL. Tara is the only one of the 4 main women who did not get any new stab wounds, cuts, or gunshot wounds, but she is the ONLY one on a stretcher and going to a hospital for care. LOL.
  6. The Hicks double murder is overall a very good sequence, but the fact that no cops showed up to the SHERIFF'S HOUSE in ALL that time Judy was driving back, the fact that she had nothing concealed in her cruiser to take with her, and the fact that Wes still had his half of the sequence long after she alerted more cops to her house and they never showed up. UGH. So frustrating.
  7. Ghostface towers over Tara in the opening, but it's supposed to be Amber. I do suspend disbelief, but they could at least try not to have people with that much difference in height be the killer.

r/Scream • • 10h ago

Discussion Who is the richest/ most famous character

4 Upvotes

Who are the richest and most famous scream characters and how famous do you think the cast of scream 3 really was like Jennifer and also what is Gales net worth


r/Scream • • 11h ago

Discussion John Milton’s Office

Thumbnail gallery
20 Upvotes

We know he had an incredible Hollywood mansion, but did anyone else think that John Milton also had a 10/10 office and view ?


r/Scream • • 22h ago

Discussion Who is this stalking Sidney and Tatum?

Post image
81 Upvotes

Sure you can headcanon it's Roman but he didn't wear the costume until he had his own killing spree in 3.

It's either a prankster or a meta moment because Billy had just killed Himbry, Stu was inviting people to his party


r/Scream • • 21h ago

Past Spoilers Which Ghostface is the most monstrously vile? Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
71 Upvotes

r/Scream • • 14h ago

Discussion Where did Roman go ?

Post image
46 Upvotes

Did Roman hide on set after the lights came on after he tried to kill Sidney ?

Somebody would surely have spotted him coming out of a stage door and backed Sidney’s story.

If he was trying to make people doubtful of what Sidney saw then hiding on set would reinforce the idea that she imagined the encounter.


r/Scream • • 13m ago

Discussion Scream 3 Ultimate Trio

Post image
9 Upvotes

Parker Posey, Gale Weathers and Dewey Riley.

Has there ever been or will there ever be a more iconic trio ?

My thoughts are no. This was peak scream.