Opening Kills
The movie opens on an elderly couple living alone on a farm. We see the wife texting someone called Tatum. On her phone, she texts Tatum:
"Yes, that would be great. Tell her we can meet at the coffee shop on X Avenue at 12 tomorrow."
Not long afterwards, the couple are terrorised by Ghostface and murdered.
Welcome back, Tatum and Sidney
After the opening, we catch up with Tatum, who's now attending Windsor College, the setting of Scream 2.
It's clear that Sidney has never fully opened up to her about what happened there. Sidney's been deliberately holding back as she doesn't want Tatum's experience at Windsor to be overshadowed by her own trauma, and she doesn't want her daughter constantly thinking about the murders that happened there.
Meanwhile, Tatum is still struggling with Ben's death. On top of that, she feels guilty about moving on and starting a new relationship. She tries talking to Sidney about it, asking how she managed to move on after Derek's death, but Sidney completely shuts down.
Tatum researches Derek
Since Sidney refuses to talk about it, Tatum starts listening to true crime podcasts covering the Windsor College murders. Through them, she learns more about Derek and begins to understand why Sidney gets so uncomfortable whenever college is brought up. Sidney clearly still carries guilt over what happened to him. Her reaction to Tatum wearing her old jacket in Scream 7 makes a lot more sense to Tatum now, and Tatum starts to believe that helping Sidney find closure over Derek could also help her process Ben's death.
One of the podcasts mentions that Derek was survived by his parents and a brother. The brother moved away years ago, but the parents still live nearby, only about forty minutes from Windsor. Tatum reaches out to them by email, hoping to arrange a meeting between them and Sidney.
They give her their phone number and explain that they'd considered reaching out to Sidney years ago after reading Out of Darkness, where Sidney admitted she still blames herself for Derek's death. However, they felt that reaching out at the time would probably do more harm than good. They also tell Tatum that Derek spoke about Sidney constantly and loved her deeply.
Not long afterwards, Tatum receives a text confirming that Derek's parents would be happy to meet Sidney at a local coffee shop.
The audience now realises that the elderly couple murdered in the opening scene were Derek's parents.
When Sidney visits Windsor, Tatum tells her what she's been up to. Sidney is furious that Tatum has been digging into her past, but eventually agrees to the meeting. Part of her wants closure, and she also feels that she owes Derek's parents that much.
However, when Sidney arrives at the coffee shop, they never show up. This really upsets her, as she's convinced Derek's parents couldn't even bring themselves to face her and she feels as though she's somehow hurt them all over again.
Later, Tatum texts them asking what happened. She gets a message claiming they'd been involved in an accident and couldn't make it. Instead, they send their home address and suggest Sidney come to visit them there. Sidney refuses. At this point she just wants to bury the whole thing and move on.
Tatum and Friends get attacked
Tatum, being stubborn, decides to visit the farm herself, hoping that if she can establish a relationship with Derek's parents it might eventually convince Sidney to do the same. She brings her boyfriend and a couple of close friends with her. Much like Sidney's friend group in Scream 2, they're very protective of her.
However, when they arrive, they discover the bodies of Derek's parents and are immediately attacked by Ghostface. A chase sequence unfolds across the farm, ending with two of Tatum's friends being killed while Tatum narrowly escapes alongside her boyfriend.
Past Survivors Assemble in Windsor
One of Tatum's friends is from LA and is the child of an NYPD officer, which brings Mark Kincaid to town. Sidney also calls Mark Evans and asks him to join her at her hotel near Windsor so he can help protect Tatum. Of course, Gale arrives as well when she hears about the killings. Mindy and Chad come with her, feeling connected to Windsor because it was the last place Randy lived before he died.
From here, the movie kind of splits into two groups:
Sidney, Gale, Mindy and Chad, who try to investigate the killings themselves given they're the most experienced Ghostface survivors.
Tatum, Kincaid and her boyfriend, who begin conducting their own investigation.
The Second Act
* On his way to Windsor, Mark Evans is run off the road by Ghostface and hospitalised.
* Chad and Mindy are killed in a double murder whilst with Gale. The scene starts as a callback to Randy's death, with the three of them together when Ghostface calls. Gale survives.
*Tatum keeps receiving Ghostface calls and messages from Derek's parents' phone.
*A character is stalked and killed during a cat-and-mouse sequence through Windsor library at night.
* Sidney survives an attack at her hotel, leading to a chase through the corridors and an elevator sequence.
After Evans is taken out and the twins are killed, Sidney makes Kincaid promise he'll protect Tatum the same way he protected Sidney during Scream 3. Kincaid stays glued to Tatum and her boyfriend.
Meanwhile, Sidney and Gale investigate at Derek's parents' farmhouse.
The reveal
Just as Sidney suspected Derek in Scream 2, Tatum starts becoming convinced that her boyfriend is the killer. After finding something incriminating on him, Kincaid arrests him and says he'll keep him locked up overnight.
Back on campus, Tatum tells Kincaid that she's not convinced it’s her boyfriend as that’s not a typical Ghostface reveal. She’s tired of the games and wishes Ghostface would just reveal themselves so they can die as usual. After she says that, she turns around to walk away. As she walks away, her phone vibrates and a message from Derek's parents' phone appears:
"Fine. Let's speed things up. Ghostface is right behind you."
Tatum turns and sees Kincaid smiling at her, waving the phone in the air at her, revealing himself as Ghostface. He runs after her, but Tatum fights him off. As she runs off, a second Ghostface appears in front of her, but instead of cowering in fear like she did in Scream 7 when two Ghostfaces surrounded her, this time Tatum pulls a pocket knife out and stabs the second Ghostface in the shoulder and kicks his leg out. However, Kincaid comes up behind her and knocks her unconscious.
At the farmhouse, Sidney looks through old photographs of Derek. While searching the attic, she discovers a family photo album. Inside are pictures of Derek, his parents and his brother. Then she finds a photo taken shortly before Derek left for college. She sees Kincaid in a photo with Derek and his parents, and realises that Derek's brother, who disappeared after his death, is Kincaid.
Kincaid sends Sidney a text claiming that Tatum has run off to the theatre. Sidney and Gale pretend to believe him and say they're on their way.
Kincaid’s motive
When Gale and Sidney arrive at the theatre, they realise it's the exact same theatre where Derek was murdered. Inside, Tatum is tied up on the stage. Her boyfriend is suspended in the air exactly the way Derek was.
As Gale and Sidney free Tatum, Kincaid steps out and reveals himself. He already knows they've figured out who he is because he was watching them through cameras he'd secretly installed in his parents' house before Tatum's visit.
Kincaid reveals that he's spent years blaming Sidney for Derek's death. He started blaming her after seeing an interview Cotton gave after the events of Scream 2, where Cotton revealed that Mickey manipulated Sidney into believing Derek was involved in the killings. From that point onwards, Kincaid blamed Sidney for Derek's death because, in his mind, her mistake got his brother killed.
His parents never blamed Sidney, though. That disagreement drove a wedge between Kincaid and his family, especially when he kept speaking about getting revenge on Sidney. That wedge eventually caused him to leave for Los Angeles. For him, Sidney didn't just take Derek away from him. She also destroyed his relationship with his parents.
Kincaid explains that when the murders in Scream 3 started, part of him was actually happy because he thought they might finally draw Sidney back out into the open. He fully intended to get revenge on her but Roman got there first.
Then he met Sidney and saw that she still wore the necklace Derek had given her and realised she genuinely loved him. That changed his view of her, and he no longer wanted revenge. Over time he fell in love with Sidney himself. However, he felt guilty because he believed he was betraying Derek, so he eventually broke things off and left town.
Sidney asks what changed. Why does he suddenly hate her again?
Kincaid explains that he'd finally managed to move on from Derek’s death and his family being destroyed when Sidney disappeared from public life. Then he saw her interview with Gale in Scream 7.
Seeing Sidney happily married with three children reopened old wounds because Derek never got the chance to have any of those things. As he found himself thinking more about Derek, he reached out to his parents and finally reconnected with them.
Months later, during a phone call with his mother, she mentioned that Sidney's daughter had been in touch and was trying to arrange a meeting between them and Sidney.
Kincaid begged them not to meet her because, in his eyes, Sidney was once again dragging his family back into the past. They'd finally moved on from Derek, and now Sidney was reopening old wounds in his family whilst she enjoyed her perfect life with her husband and children. His parents refused to listen. They wanted to help Sidney and give all of them some closure, as it’s what Derek would’ve happened.
After another argument with them, he snapped. He decided that if Sidney and Tatum wanted to live in the past so badly, he'd bring the past back to them by starting a new wave of Ghostface killings. He, therefore, killed his parents and decided to use them to bait Sidney out. He feels the only way he can move on with his life is if Sidney is dead.
The Second Ghostface…
Gale then points out that she's still alive and knows exactly who he is. Kincaid responds by shooting her three times in the stomach. He then turns his attention to Tatum's boyfriend, who's still hanging in Derek's position.
Just as Mickey tried convincing Sidney that Derek was a killer, Kincaid tries convincing Tatum that her boyfriend is the second Ghostface. He claims arresting him was all part of the plan. He even offers Tatum the chance to untie him, but insists that the moment she does, he'll attack her. Tatum starts doubting herself. As she backs away, Kincaid smiles and raises his gun, preparing to recreate Derek's murder all over again.
However, Sidney realises exactly what's about to happen and won't let her daughter live with the same guilt she's carried for thirty years. Before Kincaid can pull the trigger, Sidney attacks him.
Whilst Sidney and Kincaid are fighting on the ground, Tatum unties her boyfriend, believing Kincaid is lying and simply trying to recreate what happened to Derek. Tatum and her boyfriend run for the theatre exit whilst Sidney continues fighting Kincaid.
Sidney eventually gains the upper hand and stabs Kincaid several times, leaving him seriously injured on the floor. She then gets up and follows after Tatum and her boyfriend. However, as Sidney catches up to them near the exit, Tatum's boyfriend suddenly turns around and stabs her, revealing himself as the second Ghostface.
This effectively puts Sidney into the exact situation she was worried about in Scream 2 i.e. if she'd untied Derek and he had turned out to be one of the killers.
The Second Ghostface’s motive
Tatum’s boyfriend explains that his motive has nothing to do with Derek. His issue is that he feels their relationship has never had a chance because Tatum is still grieving Ben. From his perspective, he's spent their entire relationship living in Ben's shadow. Every conversation comes back to Ben. Every attempt at moving forward gets tied back to Ben. No matter what he does, he feels like he's competing with someone who's dead.
After Kincaid killed his parents, Tatum's boyfriend snooped through her phone and found Derek's parents' number. Originally, he contacted them because he didn't want them responding to Tatum as he felt that reconnecting Sidney with Derek's parents was only going to pull Tatum deeper into her grief and make it harder for her to move on from Ben.
Instead, he ended up speaking to Kincaid, who was using their phone.
Kincaid eventually proposed a plan. The plan was that if he helped Kincaid kill Sidney, Tatum would finally move on from Ben because her grief over losing her mother would be so much bigger than her grief over losing Ben that Ben would stop being the defining loss in her life.
She’d then have nobody left to rely on except him, which would bring them closer.
He tries to turn Tatum against Sidney by arguing that Sidney is to blame for a lot of Tatum’s struggles. He argues that if Sidney had opened up about Derek years ago, Tatum might have had a healthier example of how to process grief and move forward. Instead, Sidney buried her trauma and left Tatum to deal with hers alone.
He tells Tatum that they can still have the future they’ve talked about and can still be together. The only thing she has to do is finally choose him. Not Ben, and not Sidney. If she chooses him, Sidney dies and there’s no Ghostface attacks anymore, meaning Tatum will never have to worry about losing him like she lost Ben. Kincaid will also get to walk off into the sunset, with no more Sidney or Derek baggage.
Where things go beyond there, I’m not sure. But that’s my pitch for Scream 8. Every Scream has meta commentary and the meta commentary here would be that people just don’t know when to move on. They don’t like letting go. The clear commentary there being on the fact that Scream fans do not want to let go of Sidney, Gale and Dewey. Sidney can never truly let go and move on, because the fans won’t let her character rest.