We seem to have become remarkably good at forming opinions and increasingly reluctant to examine them.
Books become declarations of allegiance. Films become ideological battlegrounds. Art is praised or condemned according to whether it confirms what we already believe. Arguments are won by volume, certainty, or how quickly someone can produce an appropriately devastating response.
And somewhere along the way, curiosity gets pushed aside.
I find that profoundly uninteresting. I'd rather encounter an argument that forces me to reconsider something than another comfortable affirmation of what I already think.
Literature should occasionally offend our assumptions. Art should disturb our expectations. History should complicate our cherished narratives. And criticism should do something more ambitious than distribute praise and punishment.
That doesn't mean every opinion deserves equal respect. Evidence matters. Intellectual honesty matters. An argument should survive scrutiny, especially from people who disagree with it.
But disagreement isn't an intellectual failure. Sometimes it's where the interesting work begins.
I've spent much of my professional life reading, writing, and thinking about literature. Increasingly, though, I find myself interested in the uncomfortable spaces where books, films, art, history, and contemporary culture collide.
What troubles me is not disagreement. Quite the opposite.
It's the growing tendency to treat conviction as a substitute for inquiry. I have little patience for opinions that cannot survive examination, including my own.
So here's my question:
When was the last time a book, film, artwork, or genuinely persuasive argument made you change your mind about something important?
Not merely reconsider it for five minutes. Actually change your mind.
And what made that happen?