Today I came across a video of Weaken talking about the state of Smite 2, and one point that really stood out to me was his belief that enchanters will never work in Smite 2. His main argument was that tanks, particularly support tanks, simply do way too much damage. I actually agree with that criticism because it’s a big part of why enchanters struggle, but I strongly disagree that they’ll never work.
I think the bigger issue is how Hi-Rez approaches the balance between these two support archetypes. Tanks and enchanters are supposed to offer fundamentally different things to a team. Tanks provide frontline presence, engage, crowd control, disruption, and durability. Enchanters provide healing, shielding, buffs, and team utility. Both should have meaningful strengths and weaknesses that make choosing between them a strategic decision.
But that’s not what we’re seeing in Smite 2.
Tanks seem to have very few meaningful limitations for everything they bring to the table. They can initiate fights, disrupt enemies, absorb tremendous amounts of damage, and still deal enough damage to threaten or bully their opponents. Meanwhile, enchanters have seen their damage reduced, their early-game pressure weakened, and their supportive mechanics left underdeveloped. Healing and shielding don’t consistently scale, and their itemization doesn’t always support the playstyle they’re supposed to represent.
That’s the double standard: tanks can retain considerable damage, durability, and utility without sacrificing much of their overall effectiveness, while enchanters are expected to sacrifice offensive pressure simply because they provide healing and shielding. One archetype gets to be a threat while fulfilling its support role, while the other struggles to justify its presence.
Traditionally, enchanters had enough early-game damage to contest lane, punish aggressive tanks, and potentially bully them out of lane. That pressure was an important part of their identity. They weren’t supposed to match tanks in durability or engage potential; their advantage was applying damage and gradually transitioning into their supportive strengths. By weakening that early-game damage, Hi-Rez has removed one of the few tools they have to compete.
Then there’s the fact that Hi-Rez hasn’t adequately addressed the underperforming enchanter aspects of gods like Nut and Chronos. Combined with the inconsistent scaling on healing and shielding, it becomes increasingly difficult to justify investing in the archetype at all. These aren’t minor inconveniences; they’re fundamental problems with its design and functionality.
I don’t think enchanters need to be exceptionally powerful to compete. They simply need to excel at what they’re designed to do and have enough offensive pressure to make opponents respect them. Tanks should have their strengths, and enchanters should have theirs. Neither archetype needs to invalidate the other.
This is where Hi-Rez deserves criticism. Instead of meaningfully addressing enchanter damage profiles, scaling, itemization, and class identity, they’ve seemingly allowed the archetype to remain underdeveloped.
I don’t buy the argument that enchanters will never work in Smite 2. That’s treating a design and balance problem as an inherent flaw with the archetype itself. You can’t neglect its fundamental mechanics, strip away its defining strengths, and then conclude that it doesn’t belong in the game.
The question shouldn’t be whether enchanters can work in Smite 2. It should be why Hi-Rez has made it so difficult for them to compete in the first place. Until that changes, enchanters aren’t being given a fair opportunity to establish themselves.