r/Smite • u/Coceptual_Insights • 1h ago
DISCUSSION My survey feedback on SMITE 2: Scaling, Item Bloat, and Aspect Suggestions - Focused on New Players/Retention
Hello Friends,
Sorry for the big read (there is a TL;DR at the bottom), but I felt the urge to create a new Reddit account after being disconnected for so long to give you all a breakdown of what I submitted to Hi-Rez in a community feedback Google Form a few weeks ago. Specifically, this is about where I feel SMITE 2 compares to SMITE 1, where it has lost its identity, and why it is pretty tough to onboard and retain new players.
In SMITE 1, I could tell a friend that warriors were generally physical bruisers, guardians were usually magical tanks, mages typically went mid, hunters were your ranged carries, and assassins usually jungled. There were exceptions, and some of them were a lot of fun. Still, those defaults gave you a starting point. You had a rough idea of what your god was supposed to do, what the other gods in the match might do, and which part of the shop to look at.
In SMITE 2, imagine you are new and you pick Ymir because he looks like a tank and is labeled as a Guardian. Then you see somebody playing him carry with crit and attack speed. That build can be hilarious, but what are you supposed to take away from it as a new player? You are already learning lanes, rotations, and objectives. Now you are also trying to figure out which of the dozens of items you can buy actually make sense for your god and the role you queued for. Frankly, I have had SMITE 1 veteran friends try SMITE 2 with me and they have wholeheartedly said it is way too much for them to find confidence and enjoyment reading through walls of ability text just to figure out what to buy in the shop.
I think SMITE 2 could get back to basics in one big way. When a new or returning player picks a god, they should have a rough idea of what that god does, how they scale, and what to build from a curated list of items that matches their scaling rather than a massive 100 plus item list they do not have the time or patience to read and keep up with. SMITE 1 gave us that starting point, and I feel this is a major area Hi-Rez should consider bringing back.
Here are my main talking points from my submission:
- Give every base god one clear scaling type and a shop that matches. Strength gods would get Strength items, Intelligence gods would get Intelligence items, and both could use a shared pool of defensive, utility, and adaptive items. I would move away from hybrid scaling in base kits that not every god has. A build can feel great on a hybrid god, then fall flat when you try it on another god because some of the scaling that made it work is missing. I like figuring out builds, but for new players and the goal of rebuilding the community, I think the shop could do more to show people where to start.
- Keep Aspects, because they are an absolute W... with a few tweaks. Aspects have brought so many awesome playstyle switches to SMITE 2 and are a breath of fresh air and a fun way to create some chaos with the gods. That said, I recommended some adjustments that could help solve the tension between build diversity and staleness. Agni is a good example of where I would take them. His Aspect pushes him toward carry, but his abilities still scale with Intelligence. If you build the usual Strength attack speed and crit items, your basics get stronger while your abilities miss out on the extra damage they would get from Intelligence. You might squeeze in an Intelligence item and grab an adaptive item like Executioner to get some ability scaling back, but that slot is also one you could have used to push your basics further, since they scale at 100% Basic Attack Power, 100% Strength, and 20% Intelligence. I would keep base Agni as an Intelligence mage and have his carry Aspect actually switch his ability scaling to Strength and open up the Strength shop. That way, the items you naturally buy as a carry also help the rest of his kit. Applied the same way, a god like Guan Yu, who currently has hybrid scaling, could go back to having his base kit scale off Intelligence for a healer or enchanter role, while his Aspect flips him to Strength scaling and lets players experiment with attack speed defensive items alongside Strength attack speed items for his 3. Overall, that would spare players, especially new ones, from guessing whether to stack Strength or Intelligence on a split kit, and keep irrelevant items out of their way.
- Give the devs fewer combinations to balance. With a roster around 100 base gods plus Aspects for most of them, and a shop of roughly 120 plus items open to every god, an item change aimed at one group of gods can make a completely different god take off. With hybrid scaling, Aspects, and that item count all mixed together, there are a lot of interactions to account for. I remember the complaints about everyone running the same builds in SMITE 1, and I get the appeal of opening things up. I just think there is room for meaningful build choices inside a smaller, consistent pool. If base scaling were locked to Strength or Intelligence and the Aspect unlocked the other side, the gods and Aspects themselves would drive the meta alongside cleaner item balance. Keeping adaptive items in the mix would still give SMITE 2 more total item variety than SMITE 1's final state, while cutting down the overwhelming wall of options for newcomers.
The players I keep thinking about are the ones who get pulled into SMITE 2, have fun in Arena, Assault, or Joust where things are more forgiving, and then jump into Conquest only to get roasted for buying the wrong items, causing them to close the game and never come back. Sure, they can lean on Auto-build, outdated in-game community builds, or sites like SmiteSource, but that only gets them so far. When a patch shifts the meta or they try a new god, they still need to understand why those items worked in the first place. Veteran players have years of context for that. A new player is trying to learn itemization while also figuring out when to rotate to Gold Fury and other objectives. If a new player relies too much on Auto-build and Hi-Rez does not keep those builds current, it can backfire badly when they are running outdated setups.
Overall, I would be curious where people land on this. Do you like having the whole shop open to every god? Would you miss anything if the biggest off-role builds lived in Aspects? And if you started with SMITE 2, how did you figure out what to build when you first got into Conquest?
TL;DR: I would like Hi-Rez to go back to basics and give each base god one scaling type and a matching shop, with shared defensive, utility, and adaptive items for everyone, then use Aspects for big role and scaling swaps. If Agni's Aspect makes him a carry, let his Strength items scale his abilities too. I think that would make Conquest easier to learn and give Hi-Rez fewer item interactions to balance while keeping off-role builds alive.
