r/Songwriting • • 6d ago

Weekly Lyrics Feedback Weekly Lyrics-Only Feedback Thread

11 Upvotes

Welcome to the Lyrics-Only feedback thread!

If you're looking for feedback on words that aren't yet set to music, you're in the right place! We encourage each other to bring lyrics and musical elements together as soon as possible, but sometimes you'd just like to show off that nice piece of poetry that just fell out of your head. The weekly Lyrics-Only feedback thread is here to help!

This post renews every Monday.


r/Songwriting • • 1d ago

Weekly Self-Promotion Thread

10 Upvotes

Have a new completed song (or album) to share? This is the place!

The promotional rules are looser here, so you can post links to your albums, social media platforms, songs, etc. Let us know what you've been working on recently!

Please support your fellow songwriters - give them a listen, a bump or a share. A rising tide lifts all boats!

Note: Promotional content posted as a new thread without explicit permission from the moderators will be removed. Repeat violators will be banned

This post renews every Friday.


r/Songwriting • • 10h ago Bravo

Feedback Request Still uncomfortable with getting loud but somewhat happy with how this one is turning out

30 Upvotes

Bonus content: Watch me fight fruitlessly to fix my capo mid song to stop the string buzz


r/Songwriting • • 8h ago

Feedback Request Mary Vangrave

13 Upvotes

This is a song I wrote a serial killer set in a fictional world which I created, I've been trying to sort of incorporate storytelling into my music a little more as a way to break out of my usual tropes of love songs and lullabies yk? I just hope this is interesting, I'm really happy with the little guitar riffs too, any thoughts? x


r/Songwriting • • 12h ago

Feedback Request Locket

16 Upvotes

Lyrics:

Im not, not that good for you babby

Cuz I know you got a heart of gold

And im a gold digger

I dig you up but i cant give you love

I wrote this song not to make you feel better

Cuz thats,

Not, what clears up the weather

Its a locket, you lock it away

You lock it so you keep it from a guy like me

Cuz ill dig you up but i cant give what you need


r/Songwriting • • 13h ago

Feedback Request song in progress

19 Upvotes

Hello! This is a bit of a song I’ve been working on/producing after nor songwriting for a little while (even though I’m singing quietly because of people around and the audio unfortunately cut out halfway through). Any feedback on quality/potential for release (?) would be appreciated!


r/Songwriting • • 10h ago

Feedback Request Is this catchy enough?

8 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • 6h ago

Discussion Topic Songwriter block for an advanced musician

3 Upvotes

I feel like when I knew less music and was less capable I didn’t have an issue writing songs but now I am struggling a lot. Couldn’t write an intro for a week, everything I write I just delete. Nothing of what I want to hear is being played by me, I feel completely lost.

It’s like I am never satisfied at anything. Any tips?


r/Songwriting • • 41m ago

Discussion Topic Writing a song about someone, worried for them to hear it

1 Upvotes

My EP will be released at the end of this week and I’m kinda worried, the best song on the EP was about a crush I had on a friend of mine, and me reading into things too much. I’m a gay dude and he’s straight.

The lyrics hint at it being about him, I say “voice of an angel, everyone knows you’re going far” (he’s a phenomenal singer).

I’m worried for him to listen to it, if he picks up on these lyrics and wonders “is this about me?”

Has anyone dealt with a similar situation?


r/Songwriting • • 21h ago

Feedback Request Dressed to Kill

29 Upvotes

Finishing up this song about a femme fatale. Love to hear your thoughts before I start recording.


r/Songwriting • • 20h ago

Feedback Request The Long Way Around

13 Upvotes

Or might just call it Long Way. Long Way 'Round? I don't know.

Let me know what you think. I finished writing a 10 song album (first and only - now time to practice and record!) and inspiration hit and think this will be song 11.

I have my thoughts as to the vibe this song has, but curious to get what others think. Any feedback is welcome. Thanks!

I think I might have messed a few lyrics or melodies up, definitely a few chords, but after ~10 takes, I had enough, lol.

Chorus

Maybe I'll take the long way round

Hope to change my point of view

Spend good days for memories

And won't stop until my spending's through

Verse 1

Sometimes I wonder if I've wandered

Won't always draw the straightest lines

Lord knows that life sure needs some color

I'll take my time

Chorus

Maybe I'll take the long way round

Hope to change my point of view

Spend good days for memories

And won't stop until my spending's through

Verse 2

Rise with the skies soaring colors

Walk through a story never told

The next song starts, keep on singing

On down the road

Chorus

Maybe I'll take the long way round

Hope to change my point of view

Spend good days for memories

And won't stop until my spending's through

Verse 3

Slow down and stop for conversation

Hear how they carry all they know

Not every question needs an answer

See where it goes

Chorus

Maybe I'll take the long way round

Hope to change my point of view

Spend good days for memories

And won't stop until my spending's through

Instrumental (didn't do this in my recording)

Final Chorus

Maybe I'll take the long way round

Hope to change my point of view

Spend good days for memories

And won't stop until my spending's through


r/Songwriting • • 11h ago

Feedback Request Very crude attempt at an Irish folk song. Still trying to figure out where to take this. Any ideas welcome

2 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • 9h ago

Discussion Topic lo fi keyboard with male pop vocals

1 Upvotes

hi. this is my keyboard style i got with no lessons other than a couple weeks in a keyboard class in high school. it's a set of songs i did for my dogs messing with the chords that i always play. this was a successful run. i really like being influenced by some daniel johnston and some stuff by the mountain goats, some atom and his package and a lot of the moldy peaches is really good for lo fi that gave me the courage to do this, but this is kind of like old school synthy cheap keyboards. i'm sure people do stuff like this, but i haven't heard a lot of this in what gets recommended in the popular underground scene, and i think this is really good. maybe these are not real chords or i am playing out of tune. i like it.

keyboard for dogs. spring 2026. dog doo on your shoe and other hits - YouTube


r/Songwriting • • 20h ago

Let's Collaborate! Looking for lyricists/vocalists to genuinely collaborate on a concept album (Alt-R&B/Pop)

7 Upvotes

Hey guys! I'm a producer and pianist currently working on my first concept album -
The Ghost of a Life I Once Lived

I'm trained in piano and have been playing for around 10 years, and I'm largely self taught in music production.

The album is a narrative driven pop/alternative R&B project exploring how a life that once felt whole gradually unravels through mistakes, loss, changing relationships, and the consequences of things that cannot be undone or made up for. It follows different stages of that experience, with each track having its own story, perspective, and sonic identity, while contributing to a larger narrative.

I have the production, concepts, and overall direction for most of the project in place, but I'd like to approach the songwriting more collaboratively, particularly with lyrics, toplines, melodies, and vocal arrangements.

I'm looking to connect with lyricists and vocalists who are interested in narrative-driven songwriting and would enjoy developing ideas together, experimenting with different approaches, and building songs through an actual creative exchange. My influences lean towards alternative R&B, synth R&B, and pop, including The Weeknd, Frank Ocean, and SZA, though I'm open to working across genres.

To be transparent, I'm still a student, so I unfortunately don't have the means to offer payment at the moment:\ I'd really love to find people who connect with the project and would enjoy creating something together. Everyone's contributions would be acknowledged through songwriting credits, and I'd hope for it to be a genuinely collaborative experience for all of us.

I'm not looking for someone to simply write or record over finished instrumentals. I'd prefer a collaborative process where we bring ideas to each other, develop them together, and have creative input on the songs.

I'm happy to collaborate over Discord, exchanging demos and ideas, or just working out whatever approach works best for both of us.

If this interests you, feel free to reach out. I'd be happy to share some of the work I've been developing and hear yours as well :)


r/Songwriting • • 19h ago

Feedback Request Recorded this recently with my band, what instrument do you hear taking a solo in the instrumental breaks? (Song not mixed yet)

5 Upvotes

Passing Time

I was just a young boy,
like many you would know
Raised in my days of youth,
many years ago

Weaving through the white sheets
hanging on the line
Now iv come to think on
the passing of time

I looked out in wonder
from my mothers home
When all the troubles of the world,
where still left unknow

Now I feel a force grow
with every rung Ive climbed
It’s unbroken, marching,
with the passing time

Passing Time
Passing Time
Have you felt it passing by
Passing Time
Passing Time
always passing by

Iv see. the pulling of the tides,
cycles of the moon
Iv watch the season change
through the window in my room

And I Feel the blood pumping,
deep within my heart
With each beat sands falls
through the hour glass

Time takes my everyday,
and brings me every night
never looking backwards
just marches by my side

Passing Time
Passing Time
Have you felt it passing by
Passing Time
Passing Time
always passing by

I look from my window
to the street below
I see the children playing,
so little do they know

They don’t fear the coming winds,
even when they cry
someday they will fear
the passing of time

Passing Time
Passing Time
Have you felt it marching by
Passing Time
Passing Time
It’s always passing by


r/Songwriting • • 10h ago

Feedback Request Quite proud of this chorus, love to know whatcha's think of it?

0 Upvotes

https://sydoniamusic.com/

My band sounds like Radiohead had a baby with Sepultura and the Deftones.
See what you think and maybe find us on the Spotifies if you like the sound?
We've toured with StoneSour, Slipknot, Korn, Lamb of God and more.

#shoegazemetal #Ozprog


r/Songwriting • • 1d ago

Discussion Topic many ppl seemed to like this so i uploaded it to soundcloud & this is how i recorded it

38 Upvotes

listen to it here: https://soundcloud.com/6dchair/temperaonpoly?si=38fc7555eddd48e9aad298cfd078fedb&utm_source=clipboard&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=social_sharing

whenever i record my songs, i always wish i had more time or that i was somewhere else, but it makes me happy nonetheless (tho not as happy as writing does)

thanks! :)))

------------------------------
11/22/26|1602 edit: i just set up a bandcamp account and released this track there too
https://6dchair.bandcamp.com/track/tempera-on-poly


r/Songwriting • • 1d ago

Feedback Request I want to re-record this one but I can’t capture the same emotion

23 Upvotes

I’ve been combing through old songs and I’m really liking this one. I just would love to know what it needs…


r/Songwriting • • 1d ago

Discussion Topic an idea to a song (?)

12 Upvotes

r/Songwriting • • 21h ago

Let's Collaborate! [AVAILABLE] Aspiring Poetry & Lyric Editor offering FREE edits for portfolio practice & testimonials

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

By day, I work full-time as a communications representative, and by night I'm building out a passion project: specializing in line and developmental editing for poets and songwriters.

I'm officially kicking off formal training through the Editorial Freelancers Association (EFA) this week (starting with Tools for Editing Poetry and Line Editing), and I'm looking for 3-5 writers or songwriters willing to let me edit their work for free so I can get real-world practice.

What I can help with:

  • Individual poems or short chapbooks (up to ~12-15 poems): Feedback on rhythm, line breaks, imagery, stanza flow, and overall sequencing - always aimed at sharpening your voice, never flattening it.
  • Song lyrics (1-3 songs): Feedback on syllable cadence, rhyme schemes, hook strength, and emotional arc.

What I ask in return:

  • An honest testimonial (if you found the feedback helpful) that I can use as I build my portfolio, and/or constructive criticism on how I can make my editorial notes clearer and more useful for writers.

My goal is to sharpen my skills over the next couple of months before transitioning to paid rates to help fund more advanced EFA and multilingual poetry courses.

If you have a draft sitting in your notes that you'd love a fresh, thoughtful pair of eyes on, drop a comment or send me a DM with what you're working on (poem count or song genre) and we can get started!


r/Songwriting • • 2d ago

Discussion Topic Just make music.

42 Upvotes

All my life I had this struggle to find “my sound” and I was always searching for it but this only led me to making songs that sounded exactly the same and I felt it wasn’t me, I was just trying to copy what everyone else was doing but a year or so ago something clicked, I stopped making what I thought I should be making and started writing songs I actually wanted to write, not giving a fuck if they sounded different from each other or if it sounds like someone else. I felt I had drifted away from the main point of making music that is having fun and enjoying the process, not only wanting the results. Since then I’ve expanded my genres to Soft Rock, Indie Rock, Synth Pop, Psychedelic, Stoner Rock, Doom Metal without caring if I sounded like someone else because I’m still the one writing so it’ll always have my touch on them. I’m not saying you won’t hear Pink Floyd, Queens Of The Stone Age, John Frusciante or Tame Impala in my songs tho hahahaha.
I stopped trying to make music for others to listen to and started making music that I’m proud of, even if others think my catalogue is too vague lol
Just make music!!!!


r/Songwriting • • 1d ago

Discussion Topic Been making music for 8 years but still struggle with vocal mixing. Any advice?

7 Upvotes

Hey everyone!
I’ve been making music for close to 8 years now, and for the past 2 years I’ve been producing my own instrumentals as well.
One of my biggest struggles lately has been vocal mixing. I find myself getting genuinely discouraged and losing motivation to finish songs because I can never seem to get my vocals sounding the way I hear them in my head.
I mainly make indie/folk and alternative music, and I’m really drawn to those clean, warm, intimate vocal mixes that sound natural and sit perfectly in the instrumental But whenever I try to achieve that sound, my vocals end up sounding muddy, boxy, or just disconnected from the rest of the track.
The frustrating part is that I’ll make an instrumental I’m genuinely proud of, but once I start recording and mixing vocals, I feel like I can’t do the song justice.
For context, I use FL Studio and record with a Warm Audio WA-47jr. My room is untreated, which I know isn’t ideal. I’d say I have a decent understanding of mixing in general, but I still struggle to identify exactly what’s making my vocals sound amateur.
I’m not looking for some magical plugin or preset. I genuinely want to get better at understanding vocal mixing rather than just blindly tweaking things until they sound somewhat decent.
Has anyone else struggled with this? What helped you take your vocal mixes to the next level? Also, if anyone knows of any good YouTube channels, tutorials, or other resources that really helped them understand vocal mixing, I’d love some recommendations!
Any advice would be seriously appreciated!

I have some of my music here as a reference to what I’d like to sound like:

https://open.spotify.com/track/0wxfgBv2tD7wSlJC9DeJa5?si=Fq75RytIQGqby5bvPmNB0Q&utm_source=copy-link

And here’s my Spotify if anyone is interested in hearing my mixes:

https://open.spotify.com/track/5NB3lJ499DOkkXKFo9JExq?si=EuSG_PAXR2GmOdxQhye-wA&utm_source=copy-link


r/Songwriting • • 19h ago

Discussion Topic Is it fine that learning DAW takes long?

0 Upvotes

I’m a girl. I know that men learn it so fast! But for me it takes much longer…


r/Songwriting • • 1d ago

Discussion Topic How many times have you rewritten/ re-recorded a song?

8 Upvotes

I have a bunch of songs that range from 7-2 years old and I love them when I first write them and record demos, but when it comes to the final recording I’m always left dissatisfied and either change the song completely or re-recording them with the same result.

Do other people have this problem?

When people write songs, do they write quickly and move on? Or is working 7 years on a song normal?

I worry there’s a golden period and if you work on something for too long the magic fades.

My next approach is to write and record myself and then send them off to be mixed. I find it’s at the mixing stage where It goes wrong for me.