Hey everyone
I'm making this post to see if anyone can help interpret my hornresp results for the SKRAM subwoofer. I'm gonna post some graphs, it might get technical. I understand if this is not your cup of tea, no worries there.
I found a few really helpfull posts in the SKHORN DIYAudio forum for the initial input parameters; LINK
I simulated the driver B&C 21DS115-8ohm since that's the one I'll be using. The reason i wanted to check hornresp results was to first of all see how much power this cabinet will actually need (since the driver performance can change drastically once you put it in a cabinet), secondly to see at what point the driver will exceed its Xmax and thirtly to play around with filter settings and its effect.
The inital acoustic power graph looks realistic to me, I couldn't find another graph online that simulated tihis specific driver, only the 4ohm version of it. I'm by no means an expert on this stuff but hornresp makes it quite easy once you got the initial parameters right.
I numbered all the graphs, quick index:
- Driver parameters 21DS115-8
- Input parameters (1 Watt)
- Acoustial power (1 Watt, no filter)
- Schematic diagram
- Diaphragm Displacement (1000 Watt, no filters)
- Loudness in Phon (1000 Watt, no filters)
- Filter Wizard (1000 Watt, BW4 HPF 31Hz, LR6 LPF 130Hz)
- Acoustical power (1000 Watt, filters applied)
- Loudness in Phon (1000 Watt, filters applied)
- Diaphragm displacement (1000 Watt, filters applied)
- Driver electrical input power (1000 Watt, filters applied)
Let's discuss these results shall we, please correct me if i'm wrong. I hope we can learn some stuff from these results together :))
- Fairly confident these are correct. Just copy and paste from the spec sheet.
- Taken from the link above, haven't double checked them, they seem quite realistic to me.
- We can see the useable range of the cabinet. About 29Hz to 150Hz, above which we have some resonances (to be fixed with filters i suppose).
- Interesting to see how this form is litteraly folded up inside a rectangular box. It helped me understand a small step on how one can design a speaker from scratch, or modify an existing cabinet's dimensions to your liking.
- We can see that at a 1000 Watts input power the driver is already exceeding its Xmax (13,5mm < 14mm). The driver is rated for 1700 Watts RMS, but due to the effect of the cabinet (front loaded horn, rear vented chamber), it becomes more efficient at certain frequencies. I suspect this is due to the horn and chamber influencing the impedance. Very interesting
- With 1000 Watts input power the cabinet gets loud, very fkn loud. It measures 132dB at 100Hz 'in Phon' which to my knoweldge corresponds to a measurement taken at 1m from the cabinet on-axis. This means that to hear 95dB (which is often the legal limit), you would have to stand about 45 meters from the cabinet.
It made me realise that i will probably never push this cabinet towards such levels in the coming years.
7) I apllied some filters; HPF to protect the driver from frequencies below its tuning frequency which cause it to exceed its Xmax rather fast. The SKRAM can go quite high so i also applied a LPF at 130 Hz.
HPF BW4 at 31Hz
LPF LR6 at 130Hz
Do you think these setting somewhat represent real world settings? I have knoweldge in music production so i mainly played with these setting until the graph looked somewhat reasonable.
8) The acoustical power doesn't change to much, apart from the bandpass filters' effect being visible.
9) Loudness with filters also didn't change much. we are sitting at 130+dB still with them applied. Again, very very loud.
10) Displacement with the filters changed quite a bit. The problem area is now 38Hz with 12mm of displacement. This is within the driver's Xmax of 13,5mm but i wouldn't push it much further then this.
11) This one was quite interesting to me, we can see that the driver eats quite a lot of power at 63Hz (about a B1 note); almost 1500 Watts. This frequency is somewhat in the middle of the cabinet's bandpass. I suspect the acoustical and electrical bandpass cause the impedance to drop near the cutoff frequencies, so it checks out that the middle frequencies need the most power since the bandpass isn't causing the driver to be more efficient here.
What does this information mean for the amplifier? At first i thought 1000 Watts would be the most it needed, since all these graphs are plotted with 1000W input power. But after seeing nr.11 I now know that at certain frequencies the amp need to deliver quite a bit more. Does this mean that if I were to push this cabinet to these levels, I would need to size my amp on the 1500 Watt figure? And possibly quite a bit higher to not max out the amp and come close to clipping it?
Anyways, thanks for the read if you got to here, feel free to share your thoughts and discuss.
Cheers and enjoy the weekend!!!