r/TopCharacterTropes • • 6d ago

Hated Tropes (Hated Trope) Accidentally racist race swaps

  1. Making Butler black in the Artemis Fowl movie carried the implication that his ancestors serving the family were not so much hired as they were purchased.
  2. Snape in the Harry Potter reboot makes pretty much all the protagonists look racist
13k Upvotes

2.5k comments sorted by

4.3k

u/IronVader501 6d ago • Mindblown Bravo

Not only was Butlers casting accidentally racist, the Book ALREADY HAD a prominent non-white Character, HOLLY, which the Move chose to make white.

And that is still somehow only a contender for worst decision in that film.

1.9k

u/Sable-Keech 6d ago

Not only that, they decided to make it so that no one calls Butler "Butler" but instead "Domovoi", his real name, when in the books he explicitly refuses to tell anyone his real name!

564

u/BelleRouge6754 5d ago

Isnt Domovoi the name for a domestic household spirit that keeps the fire going/protects the house? It’s basically ‘butler’ translated into Russian folklore lmao. Although I guess if the parents wanted him to be a butler then they are impressing that onto him from birth. I’d be pretty annoyed if my name was my job and I wouldn’t want to tell anyone either.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (3)

371

u/VacaDLuffy 6d ago

Genderswapping Root and removing Hollies goddamn reason for existing

138

u/JTVivian56 5d ago

That's ultimately what ruined the movie for me. I was frustrated with the race swapping already, but whatever, I tried to look past it. But then to swap roots gender? Which just killed the whole dynamic and reason for Holly to be so gung ho with her work? It's like they intended for the movie to flop so they didn't have to worry about ever making a sequel.

→ More replies (8)

182

u/disneysatlantis 5d ago

That film is so absolutely dogshit that honestly none of the stuff you said even comes close to being a contender for the worst decision made making it

→ More replies (11)

117

u/Cheeodon 5d ago

Dont forget recasting Commander Root with Lady Dench, nothing against her she's a great actress, but it massively undercuts hollys story of being the first female LEP-RECON officer and having to prove women can do the job just fine thank you when the commander and leader of the LEP-RECON is ALSO a woman.

234

u/temlaas 6d ago

(Hated Trope): The Artemis Fowl movie :D

→ More replies (6)

123

u/GeniusLike4207 5d ago

And Butler also was mixed asian, explicitly described as "Eurasian" e.g. like someone who looks at home everywhere

→ More replies (11)

11

u/ExaggeratedSwaggerOf 5d ago

Butler himself is supposed to be of Eurasian descent

10

u/DeadRobotSociety 5d ago

Artemis Fowl, Ender's Game, and The Dark Tower are the holy trinity of movies I disliked so much that they hurt my enjoyment of the original IP.

→ More replies (24)

833

u/MeticulousPlonker 5d ago

I'm so glad to see the Artemis Fowl movie mentioned so often as such a series of incredibly idiotic choices. I will die mad about this God damned movie but I will be in good company.

250

u/Mooredock 5d ago • Bravo

All the infuriating choices of the movie aside, this feels like a good place to confess that when I was a little kid and first read the book I did imagine Butler as black, because i had just watched Lilo and Stitch and all i could picture in my head was mr.bubbles.

→ More replies (11)

101

u/omeany23 5d ago

This movie made me so mad.

- Butler being black when in the book he is described as Eurasian and goes to a training academy in China
- Commander Root being a man and ruining Holly’s storyline (because for the first few books Holly’s storyline was about being the first female cop in the LEPrecon, and having a female commander ruins that)
- Random McGuffins being thrown into the storyline, like there isn’t a bunch of material that can be used instead
- Making Artemis interesting in athletics/sports makes no sense. The kid had a tough time trying to practice fire a gun, ffs

And many more issues that just ruined a fantastic series. Hope Eoin got a big ass check, though.

→ More replies (2)

79

u/ThatInAHat 5d ago

It’s so infuriating. There was no reason for the movie to be as bad as it was. Like. They could have just made their own movie instead of “adapting” Artemis Fowl”

→ More replies (3)

106

u/Cheeodon 5d ago

I dunno where disney took "Life-long unpaid man-servant, tutor, and body guard to a rich white irish boy, whos family has been doing this for generations, all unpaid, all serving the same family." and decided "Yeah, that sounds like a good cast for a black guy" without someone in the casting room going "uh guys? maybe not a good look?

Granted, Butler is defacto one of the best characters in the book series, and had the movies actually treated butler like the awesome badass he's depicted in the books it might have been okay but, with as just god awful bad as the movie was (Seriously, they neutered like 2/3rds of the plot line, reveal a major villain early, and utterly fucked Hollys entire character arc with making Dame Judy Dench into Root) it just makes it so much worse.

Did Disney forget there's six more books to adapt?

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (11)

5.2k

u/yellowpig10 6d ago

I saw someone on twitter do a redesign or Scout from Tf2 as a black man. It looked good, only problem is scout is the single worst character you could choose for this.

He's an idiot who runs fast, jumps high, can barely read, doesn't know his dad and canonically loves fried chicken.

They could've picked anyone, but they chose him

3.2k

u/Azicald 6d ago

Here is my race swap of Pyro. I think i like this version best

1.3k

u/Thestohrohyah 6d ago • Bravo

Why would you make him Italian?

→ More replies (38)

176

u/West-Pirate-5480 6d ago

Interesting take but I really like mine more

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

120

u/supermurlo64 5d ago

Ands ends up as a single father, with like, 5 different children, all of different mothers. It really puts into perspective how racism kind of limits character writting, Its no wonder sometimes people end up writting flawless Black/gay/women characters

82

u/BhanosBar 6d ago

Also has 9 siblings and daddy issues

320

u/Agile_Oil9853 6d ago • Popcorn

The concept art for fem!Scout looks cool though

→ More replies (2)

288

u/wizardofpancakes 6d ago

To be fair, everyone is an idiot in TF2

229

u/LotharVonPittinsberg 5d ago

Heavy, Medic, and Engineer only sound stupid. And make stupid decisions. But are actually very well educated.

But yeah, Valve showed how the "idiot" part is not that big of a deal. When it's not the main trait of that character. We don't know how much of an idiot Demo is, because he's just too damn drunk all the time.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (4)

898

u/BJokester 6d ago

Not to mention, he himself has LOTS of children with different women, and he only narrowly avoids the deadbeat dad stereotype by being present in their life and getting his "income" from suing the city in the comics.

766

u/Quaelgeist333 5d ago

"Narrowly avoids the deadbeat dad stereotype" he's the literal subversion of the trope, the mothers of his children are deadbeats. He's a single dad

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

172

u/Bakingguy 5d ago

He can read, he has the beanbag taunt where he pulls out a comic book and in expiration date he reads the books while studying to seduce Ms. Pauling.

I know he can't read submachine guns, but there's an argument he has a concussion at the time

→ More replies (4)

174

u/Dragonfire723 6d ago

I mean. He does know his dad. Your point is well made but Scout does absolutely know his dad.

The man has a tendency to disappear from difficult situations, after all.

→ More replies (9)

49

u/OpeningHappy9692 6d ago

If Scout is redesigned as a black man then Spy also needs to be redesigned as a black man.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/Matrix_Rook 5d ago

Valve accidentally made the most racially weaponized character kit imaginable by just stacking every obnoxious Boston loudmouth trait together without realizing how dangerous a swap would turn out.

6

u/nodiso 5d ago

But he's had those traits before he was black. And it the connotations of why they race swapped is important. If they were doing it because of those traits then it'd a racist joke. If someone just wanted a black scout then it's whatever. There's nuance to everything in life.

→ More replies (27)

940

u/ChemistryTasty8751 6d ago

After someone pointed it out, it really does feel like they only Half-Read Artemis Fowl

Not as in "Oh yeah we skimmed this" as in they literally stop reading the sentence halfway through

Like they literally have Artemis... surfing... the villian who is described as "Surfing the web" and is terminally indoors, they went with regular surfing

They also made Root played by Judi Dench... cuz I guess fuck Holly's arc

294

u/that_annoying-one 6d ago • Bravo

There is adaptation, and then there's butchering a story, violating its corpse, throwing it in a blender and feeding it to kindergardeners.

80

u/hey_free_rats 5d ago edited 5d ago

I watched it with my young nieces and nephews, who hated it and whose takeaway was "yeah, I don't think I want to read those books".

Broke my chilly little heart. 

→ More replies (1)

135

u/scalyblue 5d ago

Hollywood is full of people who want to tell their own new content stories at any cost, that cost being the sacrifice of a property that’s close enough to hammer vaguely into the mold.

61

u/Anaguli417 5d ago • Mindblown

Brandon Sanderson also talked about this when he was approached regarding an adaptation of one of his works. 

https://old.reddit.com/r/lotrmemes/comments/1g1d1sk/peter_jackson_andy_greenwald/lrh2ubl/

So this writer never had a chance to tell his own epic fantasy story, though he wanted to. Instead, he found a popularish story that nobody had snatched up, and used it as a means to tell the story he'd always wanted to tell, because he'd never otherwise have a chance of getting it made.

I'm convinced this is part of the issue with some of these adaptations; screenwriters and directors are creative, and want to tell their own stories, but it's almost impossible to get those made in things like the fantasy genre unless you're a huge established name like Cameron. I'm not saying they all do this deliberately, as that screenwriter did for my work, but I think it's an unconscious influence. They want to tell their stories, and this is the allowed method, so when given the chance at freedom they go off the rails, and the execs don't know the genre or property well enough to understand why this can lead to disaster.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

61

u/SirCharlesofMonocles 5d ago

I low-key kind of want the animated series to reference Artemis surfing. They could have the opening scene be of Artemis surfing with some figures standing on the beach in a blink and you'll miss it shot. Then Artemis takes off a pair of VR glasses and makes some remark about how he would never be caught surfing.

Then at the end of the first season, Artemis's mother says that once Artemis's father come home they can all go surfing. Artemis could either double down on him never surfing, or him agreeing to do it.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/Just-Antelope-8069 5d ago

That's like making Goku a marshal instead of a martial artist

→ More replies (1)

12

u/gurush 5d ago

It felt like they had read the book thoroughly and then decided to go in the opposite direction every single time.

→ More replies (8)

719

u/Reviewingremy 6d ago

What's really hilarious with Artemis Fowl is without the Butler race swap it would still be diversity because he's euroasian.

And Holly is described as being Nut brown. Which, for the obvious "forced diversity"of Butler makes this even more hilariously terrible

165

u/veryannoyedblonde 5d ago

I think they read that as not brown

→ More replies (6)

19

u/Luppercus 5d ago

Hollywood only understand diversity in four colors:white, black, brown and yellow. 

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Far_Combination8395 5d ago

That adaptation completely missed every single piece of worldbuilding from the books and managed to step on every possible narrative landmine along the way.

177

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

121

u/Reviewingremy 6d ago

They gender swapped root, and made artimis the hero.

Why buy an IP if that's what you're going to do with it!

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

833

u/realclowntime 6d ago

Daphne and Shagg-I mean-Norville from “Velma”.

Daphne, at some point in her character history was pivoted from being a damsel in distress to a curious, romantic, resourceful fashionista with a black belt in karate. Her martial arts skills have been showcased by Scooby Doo projects in the past as essential parts of her character. As a result, when “Velma” turned around and made Daphne Asian, many Asian fans and onlookers alike were understandably less than impressed, seeing this race swap of the character to be one that relied on stereotyping.

As for Shorville, he’s an interesting case because you can see they wanted to be progressive, realised a race swap might reinforce problematic stereotypes and actively attempted to “fix” these by drastically altering the character, stripping him of almost all his identifiable features and personality in the process. Norville is Shaggy Roberts real name, one he has repeatedly said he does not like being addressed by. Shaggy is known for his athletic ability, anxious nature and his strong love of his food and his dog. Shaggy has been popularly joked to be a stoner over the years, but this has never actually been confirmed, although the Velma show acted as though it has due to its more adult focus.

In “Velma”, in an effort to avoid problematic right wing talking points (such as Black men not being brave, which is an emasculating stereotype springing from minstrel shows, or Black people being seen as being drug addicts, very much riffing off and misinterpreting Rastafarian culture) Shaggy is called Norville, his long hair is gone, he’s a shut-in who occasionally blogs about food and his firmly anti-drug use. His character instead revolves around simping over Velma, giving off “nice guy” sulking energy and dutifully doing whatever she wants for her attention, despite her treating him poorly.

This characterisation absolutely reeks of respectability politics. In trying not to reinforce problematic notions, the show spins the other way into harmful “assimilation” and “safe” representation talking points that strip Shaggy of everything that made him memorable and iconic and present him as a sheepish, entitled, blank slate of a character to blend into the background and be disposed of until the plot needs to happen.

93

u/Just-Antelope-8069 5d ago

And by having the only version of Shaggy to outright state he hates drugs be the one who lacks most of his characteristics they indirectly confirmed that the other versions like drugs

→ More replies (2)

349

u/Quaelgeist333 5d ago • Bravo

That entire thing is a shitshow because it's trying to seem "woke" while the executive producer is a self considered Conservative and transphobe

It's insane

→ More replies (14)

70

u/SaIemKing 5d ago

Daphne and maybe Fred would have been good choices to be black, and then Shaggy could have been the asian one, if they wanted. Seems like it should have been easy

59

u/realclowntime 5d ago

Now I’m not Asian myself so I won’t try and guess the logic too much, but there were a lot of people really attached to the idea that Fred should have been Asian instead, which inspired a lot of cool redesigns and rewrites inspired by his lovable, somewhat eccentric Mystery Inc counterpart. Unfortunately, that would have gone against this show’s tired ass angle of “straight white men bad so Fred bad too” 🙄

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/scottishdrunkard 5d ago

I could probably write a better “adult” Scooby Doo while drunk.

Sadly, the two people I wanted to play Fred Jones, Andre Braugher and Lance Reddick, were tragically taken from us before their time.

6

u/xombae 5d ago

They should've just made Daphne black. It would've gone over so much better.

→ More replies (9)

233

u/PeRfEcTlYbAlEnCeD 6d ago

I thought butler was like at the very least not European.... movie stuff aside, I might be wrong

269

u/Front-Pomelo-4367 6d ago

He and his sister were described as "Eurasian" and racially ambiguous to the point that they could blend in with a lot of different countries. Based on his first name, there was Russian influence, but there's a lot of countries in Europe and Asia that have that!

80

u/acebert 6d ago

Pretty sure the books say he's Eurasian 

→ More replies (1)

31

u/DreadfulDave19 6d ago

In the books he's described ad "Eurasian" in book one

→ More replies (2)

22

u/The-Regal-Seagull 5d ago

Butler was Eurasian, with a name that heavily implies Russian, at most Tatar heritage.

→ More replies (5)

18

u/Reviewingremy 6d ago

He's Eurasian

688

u/Applebeate 6d ago edited 6d ago

I couldn’t find an image, but there is this comic where they basically made Miles Morales into Thor.

However, that character can’t even be called Thor or even Miles because he is just a walking caricature of racial stereotypes.

730

u/ProfitEmergency4049 6d ago

By odins fade, even his hamma has graffiti

542

u/Project_Pems 6d ago

I can never let people forget that the line “by Odin’s fade” was totally unnecessary on the writers’ part because 1: He still has a beard meaning that they could’ve kept “by Odin’s beard” and that 2: he has no fade because HE’S FUCKING BALD

→ More replies (13)

127

u/Beneficial_Focus_910 5d ago

Reminder for everyone who didn't read. Yes Miles-Thor says by Odins Fade, yes his Odin is shown to be completely bald so the usual Thors by Odins Beard would have worked.

→ More replies (15)

95

u/Dismal-Specialist631 6d ago

OMG YEAH AND THEN HE SAYS SOME BS LIKE “by odins fade” 😭😭😭

66

u/KingCuerno 6d ago

What's worse? We later see that Odin is bald, he didn't even have a fade.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

69

u/TediousTotoro 6d ago

If I remember correctly, it was part of a What If? miniseries that imagined Miles as different Marvel heroes and Thor was the only one that wasn’t written by a black author.

→ More replies (3)

42

u/Sharajat 6d ago

If anyone involved in that had even a drop of melanin in them I will eat my whole shirt.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/HexBanana 6d ago

I’m from Asia so I’m often clueless about things like that, genuine question: why would Miles as Thor be a racial stereotype?

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (8)

575

u/faerieW15B 5d ago

This one still baffles me.

Historical figures are always going to be tricky to cast- there's always something you can nitpick. But making Anne Boleyn black felt like a choice.

Let's take the woman who was famously loathed and seen as a usurper, the woman who was 'responsible' for the religious crisis in England and caused Henry VIII to break away from the Catholic church, the woman who was known as the 'King's Whore', the woman who was accused of witchcraft and incest and adultery, the woman who was violently beheaded for these fabricated crimes- and make her black. Yikes.

77

u/Glittering_Dog_5057 5d ago

Guess who was also in that TV series as Anne Boleyn's brother?

The actor of black Snape

→ More replies (4)

109

u/MisterEinc 5d ago

Wasn't she sort of famously persecuted for not having a male heir and then run through an mock trial with a stacked court?

Like I always thought the takeaway from the history of Anne Boleyn was in demonstrating how corrupt the aristocracy was and the abhorrent treatment of women at the time.

Translate that into a post-suffrage context and aside from the "failure to sire a male heir" part I'd say we're talking about injustices that persist in the world today.

63

u/nagrom7 5d ago

Wasn't she sort of famously persecuted for not having a male heir and then run through an mock trial with a stacked court?

Oh yeah, the crimes she was convicted of and beheaded for were almost certainly fabrications, an excuse for Henry to get rid of both her, and some other people at court at the same time. Funnily enough, his 5th wife would end up being one of her younger cousins, who then got beheaded on similar charges, except she likely was actually guilty of them.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

125

u/GINBMAN 5d ago

I think we can all agree that it's silly to argue over changes to the race of fictional characters, but to me, it is absurd to change the race of characters in adaptations of historical events—like, "That's not a Harry Potter or Marvel character; that was a real person who actually existed."

→ More replies (35)

38

u/NewPhoneLostAccount 5d ago edited 5d ago

I think the weirdest part of that is... Are they saying Elizabeth was black and used white powder to pretend to be white? Also, that seems a manipulative way to say half of Britain didn't want her because they were racist and not because she was Protestant and she was considered illegitimate by Catholics. It's like U.S. wanted to say "our ancestors (British protestants) were actually CRAZY progressive, they had a black female ruler, and we are their spiritual heirs even thinking we abolished slavery almost 50 years after England, some decades after France and some eons after Italian cities".

→ More replies (1)

60

u/LycanIndarys 5d ago

It was definitely a choice. They said this at the time:

Thalissa Teixeira, who stars as Henry VIII's mistress Madge Shelton, recently told RadioTimes.com that the inclusion of Black actors in Anne Boleyn was not an example of colour-blind casting, but instead an example of being "identity-conscious".

According to Channel 5, identity-conscious casting "makes space for and embraces how actors and artists can bring their whole identities or even parts of their identities to a character. Actors from minority backgrounds that are not often represented on screen can therefore claim parts that correspond to their personal identities, without being limited by them".

Not bound by the "casting constraints historically adopted within period dramas," this approach gave the Anne Boleyn producers the freedom to tell Anne Boleyn’s story in a way that will "resonate broadly with a contemporary audience".

Speaking to RadioTimes.com, Teixeira stressed that casting Queen & Slim star Jodie Turner-Smith as the ill-fated Anne Boleyn helps highlight how the real-life queen was “othered”.

https://www.radiotimes.com/tv/drama/anne-boleyn-channel-5-casting/

And this absolutely annoys me, mostly for the dishonesty on display. Don't pretend it's for nonsensical pseudo-philosophical reasons like this; either admit it's because you don't care about historically-accurate depictions of race, you're hoping for some free publicity from the decision (which I suspect was the real justification for this), or argue that prancing around in pretty frocks is fun and therefore shouldn't be restricted to white actresses.

And also, we should accept that this applies the other way around too - if you accept a black Anne Boleyn, then you're not allowed to complain about John Wayne as Genghis Khan, or Scarlett Johansson as a cyborg in a cyberpunk Japan. Because audiences can spot the double standard a mile off. Either anyone can play anyone because it's all just make-believe; or everyone has to stay in their ethnic lane in the name of accuracy. One approach or the other, we can't have both.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (15)

370

u/boondiggle_III 5d ago

The film adaptation of Stephen King's Dark Tower

The movie adaptation cast Idris Elba as the Gunslinger Roland. The problem with a black man portraying Roland is that a another main character, Detta, is a black woman transported from segregation era US to Roland's world, and Roland in the books is white. This is a major source of conflict between the two. Detta calls Roland names like honky and whitebread, and even tries to kill Roland because she thinks he transported her there against
her will (because it's the sort of thing a white man would do to her)

So how does the movie adaptation deal with the incongruity of a black Detta mistrusting a black Roland and calling him honky? Simple. They just cut Detta from the script entirely. Poof, problem solved. They get to claim they support black actors, and they did it by cutting a black woman's role in order to hire a black man instead and avoiding having to address any race issues in their movie at all. Nice and sanitary and safe. You might even call it whitewashed

80

u/NeedsToShutUp 5d ago

Reminds me of HoD's decision to make the Velaryon got combined with a cast culling decision.

So in the show HoD, the Velaryon family is all played by black actors, including children with members of the family.

There is actually a character who is supposed to be black, Nettles, in the story, who is a favorite of many fans.

However, they decided to focus on certain plots, condense characters, and change focuses from the book to more elaborate on the rival Queens than the expansive view. They also have a really hard time letting the Queen be the bad guy, and are adopting a narrative that she's view as a tyrant due to sexism in the history books.

As a result, they cut Nettles and give all her plots to one of the Velaryon daughters of prince Daemon.

Nettles was also competent and low born, with more than a suggestion she lacks any of the magic blood line. She, however, was smart and able to tame the dragon sheepstealer by feeding him Sheep and building trust, becoming a talented dragon rider. In the book, she's suspected by the Queen of becoming a lover of her husband, Prince Daemon. It feeds into the Queen's madness and paranoia, and Nettles eventually flees after orders come for Daemon to kill her. It feeds into Daemon's break with his wife.

The show, by giving her plotline to one of Daemon's daughters, focuses again on it being magic blood that lets her ride the dragon. It also makes Daemon's daughter incompetent as a dragon rider, having no control, and causing a number of friendly fire incidents which kill her step-brother who is pledged to marry her sister. She goes mad after this.

So rather than get a talented black woman who uses her brains to tame a dragon and implies the magic bloodline is bullshit, we get a crazy black lady whose incompetence gets people killed.

→ More replies (10)

26

u/UwasaWaya 5d ago

They cut literally everyone from the script except for Roland, Jake, and Martin. Eddie and Oye deserved better. And they didn't just cut characters, the entire plot was changed.

That movie wasn't white washed, it was crap washed. Elba should have been a slam dunk casting choice in that role, and that movie was just an insult to movies.

My wife turned to me and said she expected Roland and Jake to jump up and high five into a freeze frame at the end.

I don't think I've ever left a theater so angry.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (14)

58

u/stewieatb 5d ago

The entire Artemis Fowl movie is just baffling.

It came out 15 years after the books were at their peak popularity. The people who loved the books were now adults with no interest in a very child-oriented film. It spent over a decade being mullered in Development Hell by Weinstein's lackeys, and it ends up with a Disney plot that bears no resemblance to the books.

And then they start race-swapping characters at random and make the one explicitly brown-skinned character white.

Even by the standards of Disney schlock it's difficult to make sense of.

10

u/Shinard 5d ago

Tbf, a decent amount of older fans of the books probably have kids of their own, that they would absolutely take to see an Artemis Fowl film. The adaptation is 90% problems, but being child oriented isn't one of them.

2.9k

u/NerdyPuth123 6d ago edited 6d ago • Bravo

I honestly don't get why they made Snape black

This makes no sense

(Oh my goodness it's only been ten minutes and I already have 16 notifications)

1.8k

u/BaneNF 6d ago

Especially when Dumbledore was right there. He's such an easy character for race blind casting.

1.3k

u/EvioliteEevee 6d ago

I think there’s like 10 different characters they could’ve swapped, maybe even a whole family like the Longbottoms.

→ More replies (165)
→ More replies (126)

620

u/realclowntime 6d ago • Bravo

Because if they do this big display of progressiveness then maybe you’ll forget Everything Else Wrong.

→ More replies (27)

274

u/Nerdy_Valkyrie 6d ago

They lost the progressives because of J.K. Rowling. And then they decided to also lose the conservatives with a race swapped casting.

→ More replies (60)

73

u/FullBrother9300 6d ago

I more so have a problem with the fact that he doesn’t look weak and sickly yknow like what Snape is supposed to look like

→ More replies (1)

107

u/Shamscam 6d ago

They could have changed nearly any other character to be portrayed by a black person and it would have made more sense. Snape was the only character that made the show have racist undertones.

→ More replies (69)

63

u/Dry_Hyena_8836 6d ago

I'm pretty sure there is a secret competition between filmmakers at "who recasts the least fitting character as black"

→ More replies (8)

107

u/VampireSharkAttack 5d ago • Bravo

I think it’s deliberate outrage marketing. They race-swapped the people that they knew would be controversial in order to get attention. If they’d picked Professor Sprout, nobody would’ve noticed. If they’d picked McGonagall, we’d all simply dismiss the objectors as racists and move on. And it worked: here we are, talking about it

Also, don’t watch the show. Rowling is using her power as a billionaire to attack trans people, and we don’t need to give her any more money or influence to weaponize

→ More replies (22)

76

u/DifferentAd4844 6d ago

Why not Hagrid? No one would have had any issues with him at all.

→ More replies (47)

40

u/Most_Neat7770 6d ago

Plus doesnt him being white as a vsampire in contrast to his dark hair make him more sinister?

→ More replies (14)

6

u/im-sorry-watt 5d ago

A white guy would have been seen as a poor imitation of Alan Rickman, he did that good of a job.

You might as well head off in a totally different direction. No-one would have liked it anyway.

24

u/BarristanTheB0ld 6d ago

For real, Snape was the worst choice. They could've made pretty much anyone else black.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (234)

95

u/The_Upward_Arrow 5d ago edited 4d ago

As an Artemis Fowl fan, no one watched the movie.

7

u/KaleidoArachnid 5d ago

How bad was the movie adaptation?

→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (8)

429

u/Excellent_Pea_4609 6d ago

Snape one has waaaaay bigger implications people ignore Snape is a black man raised in 60s UK and decided to join the racist group hell bent on eradicating muggleborns and call his best friend/ crush a slur.

269

u/Exotic-Plant-9881 6d ago

Also implies that Harry's father bullied one of the only black kids in Hogwarts

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (25)

37

u/Coldfact192 5d ago

The episode where they show Harry’s dad and his friends bully Snape using magic, because James is jealous of Snape’s friendship with Lilly will certainly be uncomfortable.

19

u/No-Comfortable2704 4d ago

I might be misremembering, haven’t read those books since middle school, but didn’t they specifically hang him from a tree for it? Did the show runners not think that might be an issue?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

569

u/Confuseasfuck 5d ago

Harry Potter, the white kid from the predominantly white school, suspecting the only black teacher of being a thief based on nothing but not liking him is definetly giving off very different vibes than the og

Cant even make it a "what did we learn today" about not being racist because Snape was, in fact, 100% a valid option - even if Harry's reasonings were a little stupid - for anyone with half a brain just by the fact that he used to willingly work with wizard hitler for shits and giggles

235

u/Automatic-Working-81 5d ago edited 5d ago

Same for Hermione, if you make her non-white, the mud-blood and racist prejustice against her blur into one thing

Hear me out: if they want to cast a black actor for the main character, it should be... Harry and his dad.

Look, Potters even became rich by creating potion to tame frizzy curly hair. Harry looks like dad besides his eyes and dominant features are more likely to show in children of mixed couples

And it will not mix magical and racial discrimination, and you will have a representation morally good and well-off black family in media.

→ More replies (19)

13

u/howispellit 5d ago

And they could have gotten around it if they cast any other teachers as black

→ More replies (4)

24

u/gohurot 5d ago

Based on nothing? Are we forgetting suspicious Snape getting to fluffy and being bitten - and that was before they knew about stone. And later threatening Quirell in forest after second game?

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (49)

385

u/AngevinMatthew 5d ago • Bravo

Not the point OP is making but I hate zippers in Harry Potter so much, they imply they have access to industrially made clothes which kills the vibe of a culturally isolated/isolationist magical world

81

u/Grumpylatxa 5d ago

I hate so much that they added muggle clothing after the third movies. Theh should have made a clear separation between muggleborns and purebloods. Like Hermione and Harry having muggle clothes is very smart detail. Draco having suits is very dumb

150

u/Deya_The_Fateless 5d ago

It just looks so...Muggle as well. Like you'd expect to see it on muggleborns, not halfbloods like Snape who were raised in the wizarding world.

Also, as seen in other promotional material of new Snape. Snape is wearing fuxking jewellery...outside of maybe a sygnate ring, book Snape would NEVER wear jewellery.

→ More replies (21)

51

u/Nyoteng 5d ago

The plain clothes used throughout the movies really bothered me as a kid that always read the books before the movies came out.

In the books they were always in wizard robes, unless they were in Privet Drive or making their way to Hogwarts.

18

u/LeviHolden 5d ago

wow, embarrassing. the statute of secrecy in the 1600s gives you soo much to play with too

→ More replies (16)

32

u/Darthplagueis13 5d ago

Speaking of Artemis Fowl... while not a race thing, they also removed a major narrative about sexism and misogyny by making Commander Root female.

Like, there's a major plot point about how Root always holds Holly to unfairly strict standards, and how Holly thinks it's because he's sexist, just to then realize that he's not in fact, but he's acutely aware that many of his higher-ups are, which is why they're treating her being the first female recon members as a test case, so if she messes up, it would make them feel confirmed in the prejudice and possibly set back the entire cause for female integration into the LEP by decades. Hence he can't afford for her to mess up, so he gives her a dressing-down even for small mistakes he'd normally overlook if it were a man making them.

Making the LEP Commander female completely does away with the whole character dynamic and plotline.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/SnooFoxes1831 5d ago

I refuse to believe Black Snape was accidental. The entire internet told them it was a bad idea.

129

u/ajensorjay38 5d ago

Everyone in Avatar the Last Airbender.

All because an exec wanted to launch her daughter and they chose Katara of all character

65

u/Pataconeitor 5d ago edited 5d ago

I agree, the proper protocol if you want to launch your daughter is to employ a catapult or perhaps a cannon.

→ More replies (3)

27

u/Minebloxnerd5theII 5d ago

I assume you're talking about the movie?

→ More replies (7)

21

u/Rikiaz 5d ago edited 3d ago

I don’t think any adaptation of any media is as bad as the Artemis Fowl movie. Don’t get me wrong, there are plenty of bad ones, but Artemis Fowl was like they specifically engineered it to piss off readers of the books as much as possible. Like every single possible bad choice they could have made was made.

→ More replies (2)

83

u/PhilippinePatriot 5d ago

Two for me

Jada Smith’s cleopatra. At the time, Egypt was ruled by the Ptolomeic Dynasty, essentially European colonizers who instituted a caste system and were so reluctant to share power that they had brother-sister marriages.

Queen Charlotte from Bridgerton, especially when they act as though this marriage somehow solved racism

62

u/mrturret 5d ago

were so reluctant to share power that they had brother-sister marriages.

Um. That was standard practice for literally every Egyptian dynasty. The Pharaohs have always been masters of incest.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/Nice-River-5322 5d ago

The brother-sister marriage thing was to adapt to local customs I believe.Generally you don't want to adopt weird alien practices with a populace unused to it

→ More replies (16)

18

u/Darcosuchus 5d ago

The live-action Lilo & Stitch remake. By replacing all the white characters with Hawaiian people, they took away what the film had to say about the colonisation of the islands and the commodification of their very people and their culture.

64

u/gothteen145 6d ago

I feel like we get this exact post with the exact same characters every couple of weeks or so. I get that people see different posts so not blaming people or anything, but this "trope" always posts the exact same characters, AKA the Butler and Snape.

→ More replies (10)

127

u/raddoubleoh 6d ago

Snape situation is even worse when you think the Death Eaters are pretty much a terrorist supremacist group.

It basically turns Severus into magical uncle Ruckus.

7

u/EchoesofIllyria 5d ago

Only if you assume all the other Death Eaters will be white

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (5)

66

u/alphadou 6d ago

Clayton Bigsby - Chappelle Show

16

u/hey_free_rats 5d ago

"we just don't have the heart to tell him" 

→ More replies (1)

166

u/That_Conclusion_8414 6d ago

Making Cleopatra black when her leadership led to Egypt being conquered by Rome until 1395 AUC.

90

u/cry666 6d ago

The Ptolemaic dynasty could very well be described as colonisers. At the very least they were foreign invaders. Of all the dynasties to race swap this was truely the worst option

→ More replies (8)

33

u/AdobongSiopao 5d ago

That show made a lot of Egyptians and Greeks angry. IIRC, an Egyptian lawyer sued Netflix for distorting the history of Egypt. It's not nice to raceswap historical figures especially in documentaries.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/CoalEater_Elli 5d ago

Is it that one show where one of the creators admitted that their Grandma basically made her think that Cleo was black?

Like, what?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

116

u/Anaguli417 6d ago

Raceswapping is never an accident, it's always an intentional choice. 

A straight white male lead remains straight white and male because it is also an intentional choice. 

16

u/IfusasoToo 5d ago

Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity, incompetence, ignorance, or neglect.

Sometimes it's intentional. Mostly they're trying to be inclusive or edgy but never think of the implications.

47

u/Evil_Patriarch 5d ago • Bravo

Not always

Captain Hiller, the lead role in Independence Day, was originally offered to Ethan Hawke. When he turned it down, they decided to go with Will Smith instead.

This had no effect on the character whatsoever because Captain Hiller was actually a well written character and his race was completely irrelevant. They also didn't feel any need to insert racial politics into a subplot in the movie or exploit it in the marketing.

Just a friendly reminder of how far backwards shit has moved since the 90s

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

40

u/Ok-Arrival-4365 6d ago

Out of all the teachers they could have chosen to race swap Snape I the WORST choice they made 🫣

32

u/hey_free_rats 5d ago

McGonagall would've been perfect. 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

31

u/Djaja 6d ago

Is Butler the same actor in... Sweet Tooth?

22

u/ChemistryTasty8751 6d ago

Yes that is Big Man gus

→ More replies (7)

70

u/Interesting-Jaguar68 6d ago

The Velaryons used as a "gene-pool breeding" house by the Targaryens for centuries. Making them black makes the Targaryens looking like american women who intentionally try to babytrap black people to have mixed-colored children. The original reason is not much better(basically the Targaryens being so into themselves they are marrying their family or the house which exactly looks like them), but still, it feels weird.

Also they essentially deleted the only real black person during the Dance(Netless) and merged her with another character, successfully destroying both of their identity in the process.

26

u/comrade_batman 5d ago

IIRC, one reason they made the Velaryons black was to help differentiate them from the Targs (all being platinum-haired Valyrians), for casual viewers. They skipped straight to that rather than relying on costume design and colours to differentiate between the two families, or having Velaryons have beards, and different hairstyles to the Targs.

And they get worried about people being confused but then make Princess Rhaenys light-haired, when she’s got her Baratheon mother’s dark hair in the book. Not only does it show Targs can be dark-haired but it also it’s also a point used to support Rhaenyra’s Velaryon children’s dark hair, inheriting it from their “grandmother.”

The race swapping also brings up issues in-universe concerning the family trees. Jaehaerys I’s (the old king seen during season 1’s prologue) mother was a Velaryon, but he was very obviously white. So was she just mixed-raced and why she would have light-skinned children? The more you look into the in-universe applications of making the Velaryons black, the more issues it actually makes and really makes it seem as though the creators didn’t think things through.

22

u/verygenericname2 5d ago

It also turns the Strong Boys situation into a sitcom bit, instead of the intentionally ambiguous version presented in the books.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/Miss--Magpie 6d ago

The Velaryons being black had me hysterically laugh at the stupidity of the show. I should have known it would be a trainwreck from the get go

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)

82

u/Krammondo 6d ago

“Snape, his skin is so pale.”

*Turn Snape into a Black person so Harry family became the racists who bullied Snape.

What is wrong with you, Western media?!

→ More replies (2)

21

u/Faceofferrus 5d ago

Wasn't Butler always supposed to be racially ambiguous?

I also recall a point where Artemis says that he could picture Butler serving under Shaka Zulu.

26

u/Junivra 5d ago

Described as a racially ambiguous Eurasian man with a [spoilers] Slavic first name. At one point, for one of Artemis' schemes, he poses as a mixed European/Chinese businessman with Artemis playing the role of his son and no one questions it.

70

u/Werewulf5678 5d ago

Amber from Invicible. Amber was originally white in the comics . In the show they made her Black. However, they made her fall under the disposable Black girlfriend trope since the writers knew Mark and Eve are endgame. Plus it didn’t help how they written her reactions to Mark revealing he’s Invincible. I understand her reasoning but they should had done it better because it cause a lot of hate throw her way.

25

u/Valentils 5d ago

at least it wasn't the redhead as usual.

altho rex was a redhead in the comics and he is hispanic(?) in the show.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/fraidei 5d ago

Tbf I kinda liked the development of Mark and Amber relationship. It didn't really feel likea disposable girlfriend.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/Nice-Mycologist5226 5d ago

Could be said the same about Robin from The Boys, don't you think?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Ppleater 5d ago

They put a lot of effort and complexity into her character and story. Just because she's a black woman who he happened to date and then not end up with in the long run doesn't make her a disposable black girlfriend. That's like trying to claim that any show where a black character happens to die is burying their gays. There's more to a problematic trope than a generic sequence of events happening. Never allowing any black character to have a story where the relationship doesn't end up working out wouldn't help anything.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Miss_anonymous_cat 5d ago

That was my biggest issue with black Snape. The racist subtexts that weren't in the book now actively in the show.

7

u/ReadWriteTheorize 5d ago

They had a couple race swaps in Disney’s live action Beauty and the Beast, among the Beast’s staff. Problem is they tried to tout the new interracial couples as Disney’s “first interracial couples” despite the fact that John Smith and Pocahontas, Phoebus and Esmeralda, Kida and Milo, AND Tiana and Naveen all predate the remake by almost 20 years. Also despite having AUDRA MCDONNELL in the movie, they choose to have Emma Thompson sing the title song. Audra gets the opening song and one verse.

95

u/Neurospicy_Nightowl 5d ago

What, the reboot of the book series with the happy slave species and the hook-nosed bank goblins, written by the mold-brained queen of bigotry, that defends holocaust deniers on Twitter, is racist?

Shocker.

Anyway, my pick has to be Carcer from The Watch, an "adaption" of Terry Pratchett's Night Watch-series.

So, Carcer, in the books, is basically pure evil. He is a serial killer that loves killing people for fun.

So when I heard he was cast with a black actor, while the entire city watch was cast as white, I already had... concerns, to say the least.

Turns out, though, that the show somehow made it even worse: In this version of the Discworld, Carcer is a political activist that hates cops and wants to fight back against the oppressive regime of Ankh-Morpork. He is still fully framed as a villain and becomes the archetype of "Anti-authortarian that goes too far and becomes just as bad as the people in power™️".

Clearly, what happened is that the writers felt insecure about writing a cop show for their largely leftist audience of Discworld fans, and wanted to add some moral nuance to avoid accusations of copaganda. Instead, they succesfully avoided implementing pretty much any of the pointed social commentary that the books already had, and instead wrote a show about heroic white cops hunting down evil black leftists that want to burn the city to the ground.

This show should be studied as an example for how to not write an adaption.

29

u/ThatInAHat 5d ago

Whuf

It’s almost impressive to have failed that hard.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/_HalfBaked_ 5d ago

I can't believe that this is how I find out that my favorite book got a TV adaptation.

As a stereotypical Discworld leftist, I always thought Vimes's firm stance against police overreach and overreaction was a thing I wanted more of, and that part of the problem with too many real-world cops is that they're like Carcer, and see badges as a way to hold power over others.

Hell, one could make the case that Vimes's resistance to oversight is copaganda, but I'd argue that in the context of Ankh-Morpork, it's pretty sensible. Any oversight committee in Ankh-Morpork is gonna include Lord Rust or Doreen Winkings, and they're not serious people.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/RShini 5d ago

What they did to Sybil Ramkins is a fucking crime.

They turn the Big, stocky woman (whose bosoms rose and feel like empires and built like an operatic valkyrie) with a fancier's adoration for ugly little swamp dragons, and a MASTERCLASS in Soft Power (to where she is literally the only person who can get away with calling Vetinari by his given name Havelock) to a skinny vigilante who has a desire to murder all assassins and nary a love for dragons in sight.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Nice-River-5322 5d ago

I mean, implying HBO isn't going to make bank and print money for the next 7 years

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Devilfish268 5d ago

I'm sorry, they did what to Carcer? Why the fuck even call him Carcer at that point? There is nothing left of the original character there at all. 

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (15)

43

u/Former-Cockroach-285 6d ago

O problema do Snape é que parte do background dele é ser racista, ser tão racista que se junta a um grupo de supremacistas raciais, sendo a versão bruxa de grupos aqui a vida real. Esse é o maior problema com essa adaptação, não que vão suspeitar do único professor negro.

28

u/Dull-Inspection9203 6d ago

Snape doesnt join becuz he's racist he joins for power.

Snape very clearly in the books as an adult tells the portrait not to use slurs for Hermione.

As a kid he was turning to the side of evil so he uses these words, but the author very clearly implies that he doesn't beleive in blood purity

→ More replies (5)

6

u/Slippery_Syrup_89 5d ago

But in real life there’s Black white supremacists and black Neo Nazis and what have you, as weird as that seems.

Black people can be racists. Racism is mental. The colour of your skin doesn’t inherently change your thoughts.

→ More replies (2)

65

u/Ilovewomenwhobreakme 6d ago

All the characters in Harry Potter were racist anyway just not towards black people.

38

u/Nothos927 6d ago

“We are part of a racist, human supremacist society. So I am going to become a cop” - Harry Potter

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (8)

17

u/Lucky-Surround-1756 5d ago

Snape is bizarre because all the other casting choices were super book accurate and they expressed an interest in doing it that way. Then they just said 'fuck it' with Snape.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/AhjummaSaucier 5d ago

Anne Rice book nerd here.

Louis de Point du Lac being black in the tv show undermines the thematic purpose of his character entirely. As a vampire Louis tends to be seen as "the good one" because he sees the other vampires feasting on humans as treating people like cattle, choosing rats as his primary fare. This is a revelatory post-death opinion for him because he was a slave-owner of a plantation prior to being turned.

Making him a pimp doesn't carry the same weight, though I recognize they wanted to film scenes in New Orleans which necessitated moving the story up more than a hundred years (i won't digress into why the timeline change makes Lestat's character less sympathetic overall, but i could).

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Old-Bread2178 5d ago

Netflix's Sandman race swapped Lucien, the loyal manservant

5

u/Garchompisbestboi 5d ago

I know complaining about race swaps makes someone an "incel nazi" but I really don't think the Snape race swap was very necessary. My only guess is that it's similar to the Robin Williams/Will Smith Genie-from-Aladdin situation where they knew they would never top the original so they went with something completely different. Alan Rickman did a phenomenal job in the films. I just hope they don't completely rewrite the character in light of their new casting choice.

5

u/idrawinmargins 5d ago

Dark Tower movie Roland is black thus negating a lot of interactions with Detta. Weird choice which doesn't seem to have a point to it other than a casting decision.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Subject-Recover-8425 5d ago

New Mortal Kombat movies. Twin sisters/clones, one is rational and civilized while the other is savage. Looks racist af and makes zero sense.

Bonus: the 2021 movie for a franchise indebted to east Asian cinema and mythology only had one role for an Asian actress that wasn't an OC damsel in distress and out of all the roles, that's the one the studio race-swapped.

5

u/Desperate_Jury_449 4d ago

I love Lance Reddick but idk if Albert Wesker was the right role to race swap considering how Eugenics factor in to his hole "perfect world" idea.

98

u/Odd-Statistician4268 6d ago edited 6d ago • Popcorn

Jessica Drew - Spiderverse. Jessica was pregnant in the spider verse movie. This is in reference to her Spider-woman run of which she's also pregnant. The father of her baby was very intentionally ambiguous because they were trying to play on the Strong independent woman type. This had the unintended effect of leaving movie Jessica as a Black single mother whose baby daddy is nowhere to be found.

89

u/TheBlackDemon1996 6d ago

One of the first things Jess says is that her husband wants their baby’s gender to be a surprise, and that he’s “so corny but so hot”, so clearly they’re still together.

44

u/fishbxnejunixr 6d ago

That feels like a stretch lol. I haven’t read the Jessica Drew comics but I assumed her man just isn’t a spider-person, considering the only context we see Drew in within the film is when she’s hanging out with the other spider-people it’d be weird for her partner to be there

→ More replies (2)

42

u/erossnaider 6d ago

But her relationship status isn't ambiguos, one of her first lines is "we don't know the sex yet, he is really corny" we just don't see her husband cause he isn't relevant for the plot.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/BhanosBar 6d ago

Now to be fair, there are many Variants of Spiders.

There’s a white Jessica drew going through same thing most likely

27

u/OctaviousBlack 6d ago

Nothing in the film hints that the dad isn't present, they're just not shown on screen. It's kinda weird you jumped to this conclusion.

90

u/ICumBBQSauce 6d ago

? She's not a single mom. She says "we don't know the sex yet."

She's just ridiculously irresponsible.

→ More replies (9)

51

u/demaxzero 6d ago edited 6d ago • Bravo

This had the unintended effect of leaving movie Jessica as a Black single mother whose baby daddy is nowhere to be found.

They mention she's married and has a husband multiple times throughout the movie.

So the fact you jumped to that conclusion says far more about you than it does the movie

→ More replies (3)

11

u/PeterAnthony_Jackson 6d ago

Kinda related but IRL, miss dynamite was a UK rapper in the early 2000s and like with k pop stars, management tried to keep her relationship hush hush to not spoil the alure that you could perhaps meet and woo here (no I don't know what they were smoking) and so she gets pregnant and instead of having him come out of the shadows, they kinda painted her as a single mother.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Jetengineinthesky 5d ago

Iirc in the movie she mentions her husband?

6

u/Former-Cockroach-285 5d ago

?

Isso não faz nem sentido, ela ESTÁ casada e fala do parceiro algumas vezes. A Jessica está lá para ser uma figura mentora para Gwen, quase como uma MÃE e que papo merda, cara.

→ More replies (9)

27

u/Bardoseth 6d ago

Switching Jet Black's skin colour to black in the Cowboy Bebop real life adaptation was dumb as hell. What, he's called Jet Blsck because he's black?

12

u/Pandaburn 5d ago

Jet was always black if you ask me. Anime artists just don’t draw black people dark.

→ More replies (3)

20

u/Daztur 6d ago • Bravo

The actor was perfectly fine, nothing that made the adaptation bad was his casting.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/Emergency_Act2960 5d ago

How was jet black not black?

There’s a character who explicitly calls him black in the movie/show

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (17)

7

u/Zhule88 5d ago

So honest question about the Snape thing. Do they change anything about him/ the people who interact with him? Or is this just a case of “you’re not allowed to have a black person be a villain”?

→ More replies (6)

7

u/OrthusGsmes 5d ago

The entire remake DIDN'T NEED TO HAPPEN it's literally the exact same story just with different actors. The original movies are already classics that transcend generations like Star Wars. It infuriates me. The fact that it will make Snape's story seem racially motivated is the absolute worse thing that it could do.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Ewankenobi25 5d ago

harry didn’t just decide he didn’t like snape off vibes. he was told that snape was an asshole by multiple people and the first thing snape did was act like an asshole.

3

u/theysh00th0rses 5d ago

the long walk: not so much that they made peter mcvries black, but because they ALSO changed his backstory from having a loving family and having a crisis from feeling emasculated to growing up on the streets and getting into fights 😬

3

u/LaserShark42 5d ago

BBCs Night Watch adapted (cartoonishly) loosely from the Watch Discworld books by Terry Pratchett did this in the most baffling way. A major theme of the City Watch is it's one of the first organizations to accept non-humans into their ranks. So you already have a strong foundation for cultural and racial allegory. One of the characters, Cheery, is an openly female dwarf. In the books, dwarves traditionally all present as male, and her choosing to go against this practice makes some of her own people not consider her a true dwarf.

So of course what you do is have a gender-fluid actor play Cheery as a non-binary character.

Am I saying non-binary and gender-fluid people/characters have no place in this franchise? Of course not! If anything, the Watch would be a great place for it! But between the series feeling very much like a case of "The writer's original idea can't get off the ground without piggybacking off of a popular IP" and the fact that Cheery's character and arc is so incredibly specific, this choice was bonkers to me.

3

u/Apprehensive_Fill628 5d ago

Bold of you to assume it was Accidental lmao

3

u/MorriganGoth 4d ago

New.... "Snape...." idk yall read the books?

3

u/Samfu 4d ago

I'm 100% convinced they made Snape black(and IIRC Hermione actress is mixed) for the express purpose of causing controversy. I mean seriously, there is quite literally two characters in the entire HP franchise that you can't make black without causing issue, and they went for both.

Snape and the hanging, Hermione and the elf slavery bits. Legit any other two characters and there isn't anything questionable. Ron, or Harry, or Dumbledore, or Voldemort, or Hagrid, or anyone else and its all fine. Except the two chosen.

3

u/MixJealous4552 4d ago

Like Snape is bullied because he likes Harry’s mother, who is white and he is now black, and people bully him for it and put him in a tree

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SemVikingr 3d ago

Also, Snape's hair, throughout the entire book series, is specifically described as greasy, and considering the shit Black people have gone through with society and their hair, it's not the best optics.

3

u/Dreamtrain 3d ago

Black Dumbledore was actually a perfect swap if they really had to do one gun to their head. The Ministry of Magic just hates him for no logical reason. So the man uses his position and authority to fight the system.

Kingsley's "he got style" line gets better too

3

u/PickleEnjoyer5000 3d ago

I’m late but I truly hated the race swap in the film adaptation of The Girl With All The Gifts. In the book, the main character girl Melanie is white and her teacher Miss Justineau is black. She idolizes her teacher and mentions how beautiful she finds her dark skin.

In the movie, they decide to swap their races and make a little black girl look up to her white teacher. Why??? It feels icky and racist. Melanie grew up outside of the societal systems of racism, so she genuinely doesn’t see her teacher any differently—and that’s what makes it so special. It normalizes a black woman as a strong, capable and influential character, a teacher and mentor who is the center of a young girl’s universe. Reversing the dynamics makes the power dynamic all weird and wrong.

3

u/ParticularOkra7432 3d ago • Bravo

Now I'm not racist but WHY IS SNAPE BLACK? ISN'T HE DESCRIBED AS LIKE DEATHLY PALE IN THE BOOKS?

Actually, I shouldn't even be surprised at this point about the shitty remake, I've heard enough about the poor taste in the cafeteria scene

21

u/Robcobes 6d ago

I'm willing to bet they'll make Sirius black as well to "even it out". and next year everybody will have forgotten all about any controversy.

56

u/Generic_Username_659 6d ago

Oh, I'm sure that making the man falsely imprisoned for murder black will go over swimmingly...

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)