West Side Story
It certainly needs to be viewed as a product of its time (1957).
And its portrayal of Puerto Ricans is…flawed, to put it mildly. Especially in its earlier incarnations.
(Stephen Sondheim himself deeply regretted not doing more research into Puerto Rican life and culture. Also: the 1961 film even used BROWNFACE…yeah 😬)
But, in spite of this, the musical does still have a sizeable Puerto Rican fanbase.
And the 2021 film adaptation actually sparked a lot of discussion, about how many of the story's themes (of racism and prejudice) are every bit as relevant now as they were back then.
For what it's worth: Rita Moreno (who is genuinely Puerto Rican) clearly has a complicated relationship with it. But she has still emphasised that Anita was the first time she got to play a fully-fledged human being.
And she even chose to return, as another character, in the remake, so she obviously doesn’t reject it entirely.
-
Death Note
L is never confirmed to be autistic.
And, moreover, his portrayal fits a lot of the “autistic savant” stereotypes, which have come to be seen as more and more harmful, in the years since Rain Man.
…buuuuuuuuuuuuuuuut a ton of autistic people still absolutely ADORE him, and find him badass.
(I'm one of them, and I know that I certainly did, when I was thirteen)
-
Rebel Without a Cause (1955) and The Children’s Hour (1961)
Really, I could list any number of early queer characters here. But these two stand out, as exceptionally sympathetic examples.
While their portrayals are certainly imperfect, I have seen plenty of queer fans state that they relate to Plato, and, in particular, Martha.
Also: Plato's actor, Sal Mineo, was either bisexual or gay himself. And spoke about the character with fondness.