r/TopCharacterTropes
•
u/GoldenMilk-8765
•
4d ago
•
1
Hated Tropes (Hated Trope) Edgy without substance
- SpongeBob analog horror about Stephen Hillenburg killing his wife and her telling everyone by haunting an episode on 6/6/2006. Disgusting and evil. Dude got rightfully called out and clowned for it.
- Hatred- The guy we are playing as, who's a cynical and nihilistic mass shooter just wants to kill everyone just for the sake of it (basically Rick Sanchez if he was written even more shit) is called "Not Important"....Yeah. Even so, this game is just nothing but you shooting people left in right without so much as a story beyond that and the main character feels just as one dimensional as a line on a paper.
- I just thought of that awful Winnie the Pooh horror movie where it's called "Blood and Honey"
6.2k
Upvotes


30
u/Routine_Phase_8980 4d ago
OP is a repost bot who keeps stealing posts from other people https://www.reddit.com/r/TopCharacterTropes/s/vJKSjvrKdu
2.9k
u/[deleted] 4d ago
Technically the Hatred guy isn't actually named that, the game just starts with an edgy monologue where he says "My name is not important" and people call him Not Important to clown on that
1.1k
u/Literally_Anne 4d ago •
There’s a common genre of fan theory where whatever show the theory is about actually represents Hell. It’s so common that if you think of a show with a large following, it’s almost certainly present.
For me, Ed Edd n Eddy is an egregious one. It’s a show about kids playing in their neighborhood, any attempts to incorporate the seven deadly sins, nine layers of Hell, or a timeline of the kids’ deaths is based on baseless conjecture at best and frequently literally nothing.
829
u/_Goose_ 4d ago
Kai Leng - Illusive Man’s personal attack ninja who in Mass Effect 3 likes edgy one liners and doing flashy flips.
In the Karpyshyn novels he is a genuinely interesting character.
2.1k
u/Embarrassed-Phrase30 4d ago
99% of animated YouTube parodies
2.2k
u/caffeinated_dork 4d ago •
The Pizza Cutter, it's what I like to call this. All edge but no point
I'd like to nominate The Boys comics in there due to how it feels like an orgy of Garth Ennis just going on and on about how much he hates super heroes as well as This Is Why I Hate You by Onision which is nothing more than the journal of a 15 year old power fantasy
159
u/Mumu2148 4d ago
The Human Centipede 2. The first film actually has a plot whereas the second is made purely for shock value.
701
u/PlayrR3D15 4d ago
The Batman Who Laughs (DC Comics)
130
u/Interesting_Wind_337 4d ago
The painter by Urbanspook
357
u/JeffPlissken 4d ago
Remember the Rugrats theory? And then every single stupid theory was “x character is actually dead in y children’s media”. There’s people theorizing things like Animal Crossing is playing as a child in purgatory. And on a lesser note people have latched annoyingly hard to “Link is actually dead in Majora’s Mask”
119
u/TraditionalTree249 4d ago
Azel(God Hand): He's a bit of a parody of this trope. Acts like he's some deep philosopher who uses fighting to express himself.In reality,he's an edgy little dingus who's only useful to the villain because he has the left God Hand, Gene has the right one. He is one of the final bosses and is fairly competent it's just hard to take him seriously.
111
u/Shard226 4d ago
Pretty much every fan AU of something fun. My son is super into stuff like sonic.exe and deltarune character swaps. He's seen enough of it now that he can predict almost every time one of them starts going edgy for no reason.
416
u/BajaBlastoise09 4d ago
Honestly how i feel about all those R rated slasher films sent straight to dvd about bambi, popeye, grinch, pooh, its all just edgy, flavorless garbage
399
u/Katlyn_thekat 4d ago
The original X/Sonic.exe (this extends to Crimson as well sorry) genuinely just edgy slop with no substance at ALL. I would choose literally like any X rewrite (especially 2011x) over this mfs bum ass 😭
378
u/areateen 4d ago
272
u/SH4RPSPEED 4d ago
Suicide Squad's Joker
Though there's a case to be made that modern Joker in general falls into this.
1.7k
u/MoonlightDahling 4d ago
…end of thread.
“Oh no, you don’t understand! It’s actually a METAPHOR, for the Serbian government!” 🙄
284
u/fishing-for-birdie93 4d ago
Nemesis by Mark Millar. The most pointless, mind numbing, edgy fuckfest of a comic book I have ever read.
Millar is a hack writer and this is his worst story, at least that I've read.
53
u/Nothatcreative55 4d ago
Like almost 99% of all infection AU’s I’ve seen especially ones based on Kid show media
There’s also this one cat in the hat analog horror which is just Gore & Scary screamers & literally ends with just the same trope & formula as the first 2 episodes but just use pre-existing characters from the movie
154
u/Chaitywatt 4d ago
Citizen Vigilante.
If it had substance, that substance came out of a rectum.
This movie is genuinely a load of McBain/Colt Luger-type bullshit. It feels more like a parody of generic 2010s action movie shlock you'd see in a satirical dystopia. The stuff that would be playing on a TV BJ Blazkowitz destroys while shooting up Nazis.
The main character is a racist rich ultraviolent asshole who targets immigrants. He murders an entire family including a child because one of their members was a rapist. But he let's white rapists go away with a stern warning.
Furthermore he's a slumlord who wants to cut red tape when dealing with his tenants. Furthermore don't let the name of the movie fool you, he isn't a citizen, he's an illegal immigrant exploiting Europeans for profit.
He has no likeable traits, he's like a shallow attempt at being badass. He kills a bunch of cops trying to maintain law & order, & he kills a random driver on the road just to prove a point.
It's all, worthlessly "badass", like the director wanted to create a weird power fantasy because he got angry at a scenario he made up.
101
u/supercellx 4d ago
Hatred was obviously made trying to make something similar to postal 1 and 2, probably 1 and failing to understand what makes it good. It didn't have the outlandish absurdity of 2, or the subtle absurdity of 1. It's violence with no substance
95
u/Due-Veterinarian8375 4d ago
Pretty much 99% of Creepypastas back in the 2010s
Jeff The Killer, Ticci Toby, Eyeless and Smiling Jack, Sonic.EXE, Play With Me, Clockwork. I can keep on going btw
128
u/tsmdev 4d ago edited 4d ago
The first take of the Max & Ruby 0004 Creepypasta, by SeeLight4Guy.
While it gathered lots of attention and enthusiasm back in the peak of the lost episode creepypasta days, and it did lay the grounds for potential retakes in the present… rewatching it today; it’s all essentially screamers and lengthy silent film. His remake is a little better though.
(Forgot to put my own two cents; I don’t necessarily hate this trope. I find it entertaining. At least it’s not AI.)
44
u/-The-Bloody-Nine 4d ago
The Painter, a horror YouTube series by Urbanspook. A shitty ripoff of the Pouhhkeepsie Tapes (which also fits this trope) that dials up the edgy ultraviolence even more.
109
u/chuluigi 4d ago
Jeff The Killer
One of the OG examples of this
137
u/EmmaFrostsLegButter 4d ago edited 4d ago
The OG Auschwitz in Mincraft video.
Edit: for those who haven’t seen
https://youtu.be/v-XW72XN2dk?si=hpJVCRbJQ-FOL65b
219
u/Ill_Pool_9019 4d ago
All of the early dceu
35
u/Kindly-List-1886 4d ago
Sonic punishment by redbromer TD
I dont remember every detail but I'll try
The story is about some dude that discovers a snes cartridge about sonic on the mushroom kingdom making fun of mario, mario then drags him on a dungeon inside peach's castle where a series of tortures takes place leaving sonic as a charred mutilated corpse
Then the story talks about the creator of the game named andrew chubuck (who's online name is "god kill us please") who is a insane nintendo fan that made the game because he hates sonic and has an obsession with anything mario related to the point of having lots of drawings on his room
And here the story derails when the guy decides to grab 2 pistols and starts a shooting on a sega convention on september 10 where only 3 kids i think were harmed/killed then chubuck committed suicide
And the story explains the reason that no one knew about this event because 9/11 took place so it became unknown
Years later the cartridges were rediscovered gathering a cult folowing for chubuck in a soyjack party ish thing named "nintendo enterprises" where one of the members kidnaps and murders a youtuber in a similar fashion to mario killing sonic on the game, and the nintendo enterprises group celebrated this by making a anthem with soyjacks of the event
Needless to say that the story was heavily criticized not only for how ridiculous it is but also because was edge without substance and the ai images didn't help, then the people went to make retakes on the story
69
u/Correct_Pangolin_725 4d ago edited 4d ago
Velma (Velma)
34
u/Zemenu135 4d ago
The thing that bugs me the most about Hatred is that despite all the controversy and the coverage and all the talk about Hatred, it's just boring af
140
u/Waterlemon1997 4d ago
Have this
106
u/8champi8 4d ago
Happy Tree Friends honestly. While watching an episode for the first time might catch you off guard and make you laugh because of how gruesome it becomes, there is not other joke in the series. Over the top gore is the only thing that happens in every episode.
99
u/Wrong-Mouse-6499 4d ago •
Crossed. ESPECIALLY the later entries.
26
u/IsaacTheBacon 4d ago
There was another one called Void Descendance, which wasn't subtle when describing who caused the incident; which is the main problem, Stephen was one of the sweetest and nicest persons ever in Nickelodeon
94
u/Anxious-Seaweed7388 4d ago
I'm going to nitpick a bit here, but a piece of paper has two distinct dimensions. Not Important is as one dimensional as a line
258
u/Open-Echidna6483 4d ago •
47
u/atrocityexhibition39 4d ago
The Winnie the Pooh horror thing was interesting the first time and got less and less interesting the more it got talked about. And now we’ve become bombarded with the same boring, generic, “what if public domain icon from childhood is actually scary” slop for the last however many years now and I’m absolutely over it. Just because you can doesn’t mean you should.
23
u/Plane_Neat 4d ago
Almost every slasher creepypasta ever.
Just gets to a point where it offends people more than it makes people scared
46
u/Valkisser 4d ago
Where the dead go to die
It's an animated horror anthology movie. It's typical extreme shock horror stuff but with ugly cgi animation and trippy visuals.
I honestly like this type of stuff though, edgy shit for the sake of being edgy is kinda like my version of trash tv, and this one is fun.
20
u/mushroomwig 4d ago
Apparently the game Hatred isn't edgy enough because one of the most popular mods replaces the final mission (which is a nuclear power station) with a school, and it's exactly what you think
57
u/l4m3nt4t10n367 4d ago
Marvel Ruins
56
u/gosh_particle 4d ago
Surprised no-one's mentioned 'Super Columbine Massacre RPG!' yet. Basing a videogame on a piece of real-life historical horror is as edgy and tasteless as it gets
145
u/ScraggySkuntankFan 4d ago
Just… FLASHGITZ.
34
u/Esagonoso 4d ago
Then again Hatred with substance was already made 18 years before with Postal 1
288
u/BritishBandit 4d ago
The terrifier movies. Garbage goreporn movies with shitty plots. The worst people I know say these are their favourite films. The only valid excuse to say these are okay movies would be if you were really really into special effects, or if you were into the slasher genre and have been starved of an original slasher villain since the 90s
160
u/Neither_Category843 4d ago
Might be a hot take. But Star killer from force unleashed.
He’s the embodiment of the super dark and edgy original character who can beat every other character.
.
16
u/BFTROPguy1 4d ago
A lot of stories on the Lost Episode Creepypasta wiki mostly just shoehorn sensitive topics into their stories for shock value.
16
u/salamandersandwichy 4d ago
The Unfunnies, and just about everything else written by Mark Millar
30
u/SpookieSkelly 4d ago
The first Terrifier movie. I hear that the later movies have more substance but the first one just felt needlessly edgy and aimless to me.
30
u/Common_Exam_1401 4d ago
Wulf, son of Frecka (War of the Rohirrim)- dude was all edge and that’s what they thought would make him memorable, it only made me wish they wrote him better
37
u/ShepardTheCorporal 4d ago
To be fair, Hatred is so over the top edgy it's probably satirical
13
u/BarnabasShrexx 4d ago
I don't know if Happy Tree Friends counts but, it counts for me anyway
12
u/BlackberryCrafty9138 4d ago
21
u/TaylortheSwiftie 4d ago
The vast majority of people on reddit, discord and 4-chan
55
u/volcanicsquad09 4d ago
Solo Themed leveling
16
u/kuflak 4d ago
The Painter by Urbanspook
8
u/Charflower21 4d ago
Urbanspook - The Painter; a analog horror series thats basically just text descibing a crime scene/found body with a accompanying image made by the villain. It very infamously featured this description of a dead 11 year old among other things like a infant being hanged by its own umbilical cord.
202
u/Accomplished_Ad7149 4d ago
Why do people take Hatred seriously and treating it as a work of satan? It's just an intentionally mindless edgy game. Can't we move on and accept it as just a funny little edgelord fantasy game with fun destruction physics?
The same 5 criticisms, the same 5 fucking criticisms
15
u/ProfIanHadrian 4d ago
Pizza Cutter stories- all edge, no point.
21
u/Zander_Tukavara 4d ago
Another trope with “Hatred” another comment reminding people that his name is Jeffery CuddleTrousers.
20
u/opossumcarrion 4d ago
Opposite of this trope is "The Magicians" novel series by Lev Grossman.
A kid obsessed with legally-distinct-Narnia graduates highschool, wishing magic was real. He finds out legally-distinct-Harry-Potter world is real and goes to legally-distinct Hogwarts.
Except, the fantasy world is written like hard sci-fi, in that it's forced to contend with the laws which govern the world. There are mature themes which naturally emerge from that, (albeit some are contrived).
14
u/ServantMatthew 4d ago
Honestly the best thing about Hatred is a video where they put quotes from Tommy Wiseau from the Room as a voiceover, actual comedy gold and the amount of respect this game's premise deserves.
14
u/Ken471 4d ago
sorry to break it to you, but paper is two dimensional. only lines are truly one dimensional.
7
u/OkWinter5690 4d ago
I'm a devoted fan of the Crossed comic, which has been heavily criticized for exactly this. And not unjustifiably so. The people who read it and hated it have more than good reason to.
However, fans have some grounds for defense. If done right, Crossed becomes a nuanced study of humanity. How does morality survive in a moral apocalypse? Furthermore, it can, if done well, serve as a deconstruction of the zombie genre. The Crossed are not zombies. Characters who treat them as such don't live long.
Unfortunately, many spinoffs fully live up to that critique. David Lapham's Crossed: Psychopath and Crossed: Family Values are even blamed by Crossed fans for causing irreparable harm to the franchise.
The thing is, the original series had extreme imagery and a very bleak tone. However, Garth Ennis had levity. Moments where the characters actually sit down and talk to each other. There's a scene I have pictured here that I particularly love where the main character finds a dog and instantly falls for it. Moments where there's still beauty in the world.
David Lapham has little to none of that subtlety. Psychopath is a particularly egregious example of how to do Crossed wrong. There is next to nothing but horror after horror with no levity or substance. Even the fanbase has largely disowned it.
7
u/FlynnJarona 4d ago
Without context, “SEE YOU IN HELL - STEPHEN HILLENBERG” is a fucking hilarious image
12
u/ZealousidealGuide854 4d ago
The Sadness
I'm into horror movies and this was recommended to me one day.
But ngl it's just pure edge without substance, and sometimes I have a suspicion that it is just a fetish film since there's a lot of SA scenes in the movie just for the sake of "ooh everyone is so horny and freaky because the virus makes everyone an animal".
Same thing with the "Crossed" comic series. Which I think the Sadness was inspired from?
6
u/Additional-Bit-8615 4d ago
Jason Todd (Arkham Knight, Pre-Red Hood)
6
u/Satans-Dirty-Hoe 4d ago
Introvert: A Teenage Simulator.
Not only does it suck and pretty edgy, its gives a negative stereotype that quiet, introverted kids are bad.
Same game devs that made Garten of Banban btw
6
u/AceofKnaves44 4d ago
Basically all conservative “comedians.” Just hateful bigotry without any real substance or actual humor.
11
u/ShyArtMusicBat 4d ago
I'm tired as hell, I read "Hatred" as "Hetero" LMFAO
15
u/SnyderpittyDoo 4d ago •
I think Hatred was meant to be a satire or intentionally dogshit. The devs make way better games now.
15
u/MaeSolug 4d ago
Probably an unpopular opinion but I found The Sadness as a bunch of bullshit happening again and again
I hated it, there's something goofy about the whole thing, random scenes that are there just to show something violent. It doesn't help the movie loses steam by the third act, so you go from energetic scenes to a slow game of sneaking around and resolve the story in the last 15 minutes
Also also like any of these movies the acts are hidden by quick cuts or camera angles, they are implied. Wich is fine, I didn't really want a static shot of that eye scene, but it's really not that graphic as one might assume by the poster
The part where I realized it lost me was a scene where a guy is being tortured with a medical saw. Blood splashes everywhere, the victim is yelling and all the fuzz, but then small white bits start flying to his face. Thinking how a medical saw might be breaking the ribs into pieces that small instead of, you know, being scared, made me realize I just wanted to see what trick they might pull, because that's what the movie is, just a parade of effects
I watched a daily horror movie during october and I couldn't vibe with this one at all, but that's probably me. Incantation has a lot less gore and that one fucked me up for days
15
u/236800 4d ago
Severed face Joker from the New 52. Just gratuitous, gross and stupid. He's also dressed as a car mechanic because...?
10
u/Fluffy_Leadership300 4d ago
Not to mention they didn’t put a flash warning in the first one
5
u/Emain_Ablach 4d ago
I fucking love how over the top and edgy the Hatred monologue is. It's been a brain worm for me for years. As for the rest of the game, I couldn't care less about it.
5
u/TonightSimple7701 4d ago
You'll be shocked to find out what inspired Hatred
5
u/Grouchy_Exit_3058 4d ago
The thing I hated most about Blood and Honey is that the opening of the movie, where they describe Christopher Robin leaving for college and them going mad and starving over winter and eating Eeyore, would have been a fucking awesome movie in its own right! I wanted that movie!
5
u/Conman_k 4d ago
This pizza cutter
5
u/steeltheprotogen 4d ago
Marilyn Manson's entire persona
5
u/Blupoisen 4d ago
That's what 90% of the creepypastas are
Especially lost episodes like the Dead Bart one, but I agree this one is especially evil
15
u/Antagonist132 4d ago
I call them Pizza Cutters, because they have all edge but no point.
23
u/Boring_Sir_572 4d ago
4
u/KurtTingles 4d ago
I think Hatred is a fantastic example of how media-manufactured notoriety can inflate something's popularity. Hatred is a mid twin-stick shooter at best and Not Important feels like a parody he's so over-the-top edgy. The game's ending is honestly hilarious it's so bad. Props to the devs for riding that high because without it Hatred is a 6/10 forgettable indie game that doesn't make the front page of Steam on launch.
4
u/True_Salt2180 4d ago
The audacity of Hatred to copy the DOOM font 🤮
The demon of Babylon disguises itself with the coat of the righteous.
4
u/ikindahateusernames 4d ago
Isn't "Edgy without substance" just an easy way to describe a lot of media in the 90s?
4
u/radraz26 4d ago
Most things written by Mark Millar and Warren Ellis.
4
u/Important_Guess9787 4d ago
The Human Centipede 2. The worst of the three movies due to violence and how disgusting it is. The third film is a dishonorable mention as the film has a racist main character and the violence is too much (not as awful as the second film)
4
u/Boccs 4d ago
The Homestar Runner parody on Robot Chicken.
Not only did it come out like ten years after HR's popularity and updates had waned, it just came off as mean spirited and lame.
4
u/Yoshichu25 4d ago
Too many Pokémon fan works to count.
17
u/TheUnluckyFarmer 4d ago
That stupid ass Class of 08? It's an anti visual novel novel? It's just a piece of shit.