r/TopCharacterTropes • u/spectrum0023 • 4d ago
Hated Tropes (Hated Trope) Beloved characters who are awful people
Sam Puckett- iCarly (Physically & verbally abusive to Freddy, lazy, & has a criminal record)
Santana Lopez- Glee (relentless bullying, cruel personal attacks, body shaming, and manipulation of others)
Jade West- Victorious (Toxic, abusive, & mean spirited)
2.6k
Upvotes



2.4k
u/AceofKnaves44 4d ago
3.0k
u/23MrBee 4d ago •
The entire cast of Its Always Sunny in Philadelphia.

602
u/unlevel-atmosphere 4d ago
365
u/bugmultiverse 4d ago •
Greg Heffley is a narcissist who refuses to take responsibility for any of his bad decisions and never stood up for his Best friend Rowley multiple times.
254
u/honeybadgerrulez 4d ago
Seinfeld is literally that. all of em are gigantic assholes. honestly kramers prolly the least bad
87
u/T10rock 4d ago
Not technically a "person", but...
435
u/BricksnBeatles 4d ago •
180
u/SunkenSprites 4d ago
Every character in Scott Pilgrim basically
1.3k
u/StardustSkiesArt 4d ago •
Characters like this really frustrate people who don't understand exaggerated tone and heightened reality in fiction.
They never talk about not liking unrealistic personalities, they specifically talk about these characters like they're in the real world, or something more grounded.
They're often surrounded by people being ridiculous cartoon characters, and yet people don't seem to understand this abstraction when it comes to them.
464
u/throwawayazzount 4d ago edited 3d ago
I am going to get a lot of hate for this.
Miss Piggy. She treats everyone terribly.
(I love the muppets btw)
237
u/Nothos927 4d ago
Glee: All of them. Just, every single fuckin one of them was a terrible person we rooted for anyway for some reason when that show aired
90
u/Dedezin031006 4d ago
Every GTA protagonist
220
u/ChinofThanos 4d ago •
Putting "lazy" next to "physically and verbally abusive" is kinda crazy.
774
u/Captain_Squirrel1000 4d ago
472
u/gothteen145 4d ago •
Man I just find the attitude on social media towards ficticious media exhausting sometimes.
Like when I see people go "well if this situation had happened in real life the person would rightfully be called out for being toxic", yeah and if all shows/films did that, they'd be boring as hell.
Obviously there's right and wrong ways to do things so that doesn't apply to every character ever. But it's just something I often think of when people get annoyed over something like Ross and Rachel in Friends. Yes, in real life they're bad people, but imagine if they'd resolved things in a healthy, real life way. Can't imagine that being overly entertaining.
115
u/manny_the_mage 4d ago edited 4d ago
For awhile at least - Negan from The Walking Dead
They had to create a hamfisted redemption arc for him because people fell in love with his charismatic narcist/sociopath persona
Quick list of horrible things he did at the height of his popularity:
There's probably more that I'm forgetting, but it's crazy how all of this gets forgiven and forgotten and he becomes a fan favorite just because he's Jeffery Dean Morgan.
147
u/PlayItDewey 4d ago
174
u/ShuffStue 4d ago •
iCarly makes me so sad. The abuse of the child actors during production, and the neglect of the poor actress for Sam…
385
u/Anthro-Elephant-98 4d ago edited 4d ago •
The How I Met Your Mother fan base is the worst at this. They all shit on Ted Mosby for trying too hard and being a “hopeless romantic”. Many people I know personally who criticize Ted are in relationships! You try be the only single one in your group!
Look, Ted is in no way perfect, nor is he meant to be. But to me, at least he tries to be a good person. And his bad deeds help him learn and grow.
Barney Stinson is significantly worse, however. Yet, the whole HIMYM fan base cuts him way too much slack! If Barney Stinson were real, he would 100 percent be a registered sex offender. In fact, I feel like nobody other than Neil Patrick Harris could make a character like that seem likeable. Also, aside from all of his sleazy sexual activity, he also marries his so-called best friend’s ex knowing that he still has feelings for her!
Edit: Also, Charlie Harper and Berta from Two and a Half Men.
68
u/goblintactics 4d ago
I wonder what people think of Cordelia from Buffy the vampire slayer. She started out terrible but was redeemed pretty well in angel.
92
u/motownmods 4d ago
52
u/CrystallizedRose 4d ago •
I feel like this attitude is going to produce the blandest pieces of media in the next decade. Yes, these people are bad people. That doesn’t mean they can’t be funny or flip normal situations on their heads. Humor is going to decay into menial knock knock jokes.
94
u/Powerful-Ad-8737 4d ago
Despite literally being a parody of toxic masculinity, young men LOVE Patrick Bateman

24
u/OneRelief763 4d ago
Wait why is this a hated trope?
46
u/mikee_stash 4d ago
This bastard
199
u/HowDareYouAskMyName 4d ago
... Why is this a hated trope? I swear people these days yearn for a return of the Hayes Code
65
u/LadyRheanon 4d ago
I know that the definition of "trope" is extremely loose on this sub, but this isn't really a trope at all. This seems like it's just complaining about the fans liking characters who are assholes.
113
u/jayboyguy 4d ago •
Hey man, not to be whatever, but this is extremely common in television in general, and to complain about it would be to complain about how human beings interact with fiction itself. Ppl like the bad guys because it lets them vicariously explore a side of life most people don’t want to explore for real.
Don Draper, Walter White, Tony Soprano, Hell, the ENTIRE Soprano crew, Rick Sanchez, most of the Peaky Blinders crew, the Joker, the list goes on.
37
u/xSantenoturtlex 4d ago
Sometimes the 'Awful people' aspect is the part that people like, so long as it's funny enough.
34
u/LetTheDevilOut11 4d ago
Los 5 protagonistas de It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia
189
u/Ok-Letter3963 4d ago
What’s the problem? Do all beloved characters have to be moral?
15
u/DumbTransGirlie 4d ago
Yeah, he's pretty awful, but everyone loves him
15
u/Crown_Of_Pencils 4d ago edited 4d ago
Edward Cullen (Twilight series)
Stephenie Meyer intended to write Edward as the most absolutely perfect boyfriend in the world… but his actual behavior around Bella and his inner monologues in Midnight Sun have been raising many a red flag ever since back when the books/films first came out, ranging from “abusive stalker boyfriend” to “closeted psychopath”.
Bella also qualifies to an extent in certain scenes, but she was designed to be more of a plain cookie-cutter girl for the reader to insert themselves into, rather than a perfect SO on par with the likes of Edward (up until Breaking Dawn anyways).
14
u/Thompson97 4d ago
Scott Pilgrim canonically dated a high schooler
28
u/Thundersting 4d ago edited 4d ago
The entire friend group in Victorious is awful except for Andre.
13
u/BalancedScales10 4d ago
*“I never did anything,” she started softly, staring down at the floor, “that I didn’t have to do.” Again Jace found himself laughing, and laughing harder still at the hurt expression that flashed across her face. “Where do betrayal and murder fall on the list of necessities, Liliana?” he asked her.* (From Agents of Artifice by Ari Marmell)
Liliana Vess from Magic: The Gathering is mostly 'beloved' for the obvious reason but she actively a terrible character, which is unsurprising considering she's been the face character for monoblack mana - ambition, ruthlessness, power above all else - for over a decade. She was verbally and emotionally abusive to at least one intimate partner (Jace Beleren) and manipulated another to the outcome of their personally killing them (Khallist Rhoka).
Though she was technically a part of the Gatewatch - an group of planeswalkers that agreed to work together to defend worlds from interplanar threats, such as the eldrazi - she 'joined' explicitly as a manipulation tactic, meaning to ingratiate herself with the other members and get them to defeat her personal, planesbound enemies. When that predictably backfires, because she didn't bother to understand her own deal-with-various-devils before breaking them, she ends up leading the invasion of Ravnica during the War of the Spark. She turns on the elder dragon Nicol Bolas mid-battle, but instead of her own choices coming home to roost, Gideon Jura - the founder of the Gatewatch and planeswalker who recruited all the other members - saves her by redirecting the retaliation to himself. Since then, WotC has tried to make her charcter less....acrimonious, but hasn't really succeeded in redeeming her because they refuse to let her grow beyond the limitations of being monoblack.
Edited to fix quote for atting and add title/author of the book the quote is from.
13
u/negrote1000 4d ago
Have you considered people like them because they’re awful people?
36
u/chickenkebaap 4d ago edited 4d ago
How i met your mother
Barney:- certified creep
Robin:- wanting men she can’t have and then dumping them
Ted:- Obnoxious and self centred
Lily:- Controlling
Marshall seems to be nice and his worst qualities seem mild compared to his friends and wife.
33
u/Anglofsffrng 4d ago
I feel like saying Xander from Buffy the Vampire Slayer is low hanging fruit. But I'm going with Xanders hyper judgemental ass.
23
u/CrazyPlato 4d ago
The cast of Seinfeld.
The last episode kind of pushes this, that they're all kind of selfish and self-absorbed, and the only reason they were able to be that way for so long was because they lived in New York City, which is also presented as kind of selfish and self-absorbed.
149
u/galamoth911 4d ago
Sheldon Cooper of course. Just an awful, awful human being in every sense.
The whole main cast of Community. There are a number of episodes focused on how self-absorbed they are, to the point that everyone else in Greendale is negatively affected by them.
Severus Snape. I don't think I need to explain why, but the fact that Rowling tried to redeem him by revealing that he was in love with Lily Potter, thinking that that would erase the fact that he enjoys torturing literal children on a regular basis and sympathizes with the wizard equivalent of Hitler, is so dumb.
22
u/mystireon 4d ago
Okay I fully misunderstood the prompt and was bout to get so upset on Jennette McCurdy behalf
22
u/Leviathan_slayer1776 4d ago
Orikan The Diviner- warhammer 40,000
11
u/TopRevenue2 4d ago
21
u/ReminaBlueSFW 4d ago
Does anyone else remember that one Victorious episode where Jade was Tori's understudy for a play and Robbie had to go to the hospital and Tori went to do a blood transplant for him so Jade basically snuck in and misplaced the blood so Tori had to keep drawing and almost died of blood loss? As much as we talk about Sam Jade actually shouldve been arrested too on multiple occasions✋️😭🤚
21
u/SuddenlyThirsty 4d ago
10
u/dontpanda 4d ago
Gina from Brooklyn 99
54
u/workieworkwork 4d ago
I feel like you don't understand that fictional people who are interesting characters having bad morals isn't morally wrong.
Wanting only good people is going to lead to complete shit media. Just boring crap.
9
u/theaviationhistorian 4d ago
Every single one in Seinfeld is an asshole. Maybe even Newman as well.
9
u/Few-Big-8481 4d ago
You talking shit about Sam?
9
u/Fun-Region2179 4d ago
Darth Vader
29
u/supervillainO7 4d ago
Trailer Park Boys
Like, every single of them are greasy
8
u/loudpaperclips 4d ago
This is more of a phenomenon than a trope, because writers can make a jerk character, they can even write it with the intent of making it lovable, but they aren't in control of the response to the character. You're mad at the fanbase, not the character.
Generally, if there is subjectivity required to define the trope, it's not a trope.
8
u/Glad_Objective_4525 4d ago
'Hated trope'? Really?
Anyways, all of the main cast in The Sopranos.
43
u/NindeNoxx 4d ago
But have you considered... Hot?
Jokes aside people really do give too much of a pass for characters they find attractive. My contribution to the post would be Vala Mal Doran. Introduced later in the SG1 series many people have got rather heated in trying to convince me how great she is, but all I see is her stealing, lying to her team, sexually harassing one of the members of the team, and just generally being a minor antagonist throughout despite ostensibly being a "member of the team" after her initial introduction as a miinor villain
15
u/AbsolutelyNotAPossum 4d ago
Bojack Horseman
14
u/Financial-Square7085 4d ago
heather-total drama
14
u/Kitkat090116 4d ago
Dude I misread the title, and had a near heart attack. Thought it said, “ loved characters played by awful people”
7
u/Muted_Study5166 4d ago
IASIP cast

7
u/optionalhero 4d ago
7
u/Aesthetictoblerone 4d ago
Morally corrupt characters are often more interesting than the morally good characters.
33
u/QuinnFWonderland 4d ago
It is a choice to only show women for this trope...
28
u/DemandParticular 4d ago
Jinx from League of Legends/Arcane
68
u/Jedifartcontrol 4d ago
So I’m not allowed to enjoy villains? Do you not understand how to separate reality and fiction op?
13
u/Screwballsquirtle 4d ago
13
u/Medium_Judgment_891 4d ago
18
u/Sushiroll16 4d ago
The main cast of Seinfeld, honestly, that’s part of what made the show so beloved. Shitty people doing shitty things in comedic ways, even when it would be easier to not be shitty haha
6
u/the_best_superpower 4d ago
Beloved in or out of universe? Because the cast of always sunny is beloved, just not by the people in the show.
16
u/BlueRoseLad 4d ago
We will have no Sam Puckett slander in this household, She was the best character on the show.
21
u/JustACookie 4d ago
So, it might be a surprise, but these are fictional characters. And you don't have to support, or agree with a fictional character to like them
14
u/Pr_fSm__th 4d ago
Beloved out of universe? Pretty much any charismatic villain. Aizen, Madara, Doflamingo etc are very popular in their fan bases
5
u/blueteamk087 4d ago
The whole cast from It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia
5
u/smokeontheslaughter 4d ago
5
u/graphomaniacal 4d ago
From Hamlet to Hannibal Lecter, it doesn't matter if you're a shitty person, what matters is that you're interesting to the audience. There's a reason people bitch about Mary Sues... good people can be fucking boring. Especially if those good people have nothing to learn about the world, no growing to do.
5
u/PromiseThomas 4d ago
Are we not supposed to enjoy characters who are bad people now? Man, I’ve been doing this all wrong. Like almost exclusively all wrong.
9
u/mimosho 4d ago
39
u/Writerhowell 4d ago •
THANK YOU for talking about Santana. I've never known how she became so popular, and why people loved her relationship with Brittany. They both cheated on their boyfriends to be together. It's so toxic how so many characters on 'Glee' were beloved after behaving abominably.
8
u/LegoBattIeDroid 4d ago
genuinely hate people who think I have to hate a character just because they are a bad person
like fuck off. A character's quality lies in their writing, not their morality.
4
u/mega_desu 4d ago
Zack Morris is TRASSSSSH.
4
u/Tessorio 4d ago
Joker and Harley Quinn
4
u/Artoriazz 4d ago
Everyone from It’s Always Sunny
4
u/AriTheLady 4d ago
you could put literally everybody in glee up here
4
u/_ASG_ 4d ago
99% of the cast in Glee is (periodically) awful, but that's kind of intentional.
And Santana gets called out plenty in the show for being terrible. Are fans going out of their way to justify her behavior or something?
4
u/ThePokemonAbsol 4d ago
Gina from Brooklyn 99. Was so happy she left the show.
4
u/Dunkar404 4d ago
Nah, I love this trope. They are usually the funniest characters.
4
u/Crush-117 4d ago
Chloe Price from Life is Strange. Girl had some issues to deal with but holy crap she is so abusive to Max and literally likes her less for not taking money from a fundraiser for physically handicapped students.
4
u/blackmobius 4d ago
While the show was still fairly popular- Big Bang Theory was stacked wall to wall with nearly every single main cast member and many of the secondary/recurring characters (except maybe Amy) was a straight up asshole to everyone around them and wouldnt have friends irl.
4
u/nothing_in_my_mind 4d ago
I love a morally flawed character, as long as the writer is aware of it.
4
u/echoIalia 4d ago •
Considering the existence of Snapewives, I’m gonna say him:
10
u/Disposable-Squid 4d ago
(Hated Trope) People online unable to view a character through the lens of fiction, so they feel some compulsion to moralize about them if said character is popular
12
u/SeriousFinish6404 4d ago
I’m surprised on how beloved Childe is here. Didn’t he willfully attempted a 9/11 in Liyue and then some?
7
u/SantosBaggins 4d ago
Eric Cartman
7
u/VashtaNeradaMatata 4d ago
Alastor is a self serving demon in the Hazbin Hotel series, but he's become such a fan favorite that many choose to interpret him as more of a lovable rascal character over the soul-dealing villainous overlord he is.
I don't think he's meant to be seen as well intentioned or that it's ever implied he would choose his so-called "friends" over achieving his own goals. Yet people seem to think so!
7
u/pinkpink0430 4d ago
Paris from Gilmore Girls (bully, cheater, mean as hell)