r/TopCharacterTropes • u/liltanaka • 13h ago
Hated Tropes (Hated Trope) Singer gets cast in a role…only not to sing in that media
Lord Royal Highness (SpongeBob SquarePants, voiced by David Bowie): Despite the entire episode he stars in being a musical, this character does not get the chance to sing.
Uta (One Piece Film Red, English dub with AmaLee as Uta): One of the oddest examples of this trope: in the English dub of this movie, they cast AmaLee to play Uta, only for her singing to be Ado’s original Japanese vocals with subtitles. This is baffling, as some other dubs, like at least one Spanish dub, did dub Uta’s songs. For what it’s worth, AmaLee herself would eventually cover every song from the movie independent from the film.
Kelly Clarkson’s cameo in A Phineas and Ferb Family Christmas: Before she is able to sing, an Inator blows up in close proximity to her.



2.9k
u/goteachyourself 13h ago
Main character Ted (The Lorax) is voiced by Zac Efron, the star of "High School Musical", and his crush Audrey is voiced by Taylor Swift, who...yeah. The movie is a musical. Neither of their characters sing.
2.4k
u/YourMuppetMethDealer 12h ago edited 12h ago
Don’t forget the goat of this trope
They got Michael Jackson to voice a guy who delusionally thinks he is Michael Jackson, but then got an impersonator to do all the singing parts
Jackson did this basically to fuck with his brothers, and I respect it
141
u/Steampunk43 12h ago
To be fair, sometimes this is because the singer's voice is technically owned by their record label, meaning it's a legal nightmare since any song performed as part of a production would be automatically owned by the record label. This exact issue is why T-Pain was not able to perform as his own monster persona T-Pirainha/Autotuna in My Singing Monsters, because his record label contract would have meant that any songs T-Pirainha is involved in, including Water Island (which existed for years before Autotuna was added) would automatically be owned by them and BBB would have had to essentially pay royalties to some random record label for their own song. IIRC this is the same reason why Ke$ha couldn't perform Cotton Candy for Helluva Boss despite voicing the character who sings the song, and why she can't sing with Boy Throb despite being their friend.
856
u/Tech-preist_Zulu 13h ago
This is such a weird mix of examples. Ones a joke, ones a dubbing thing, and David Bowie.
253
u/AznOmega 12h ago
Yzma was voiced by Eartha Kitt in Emperor's New Groove. Now I get they probably didn't want to make the movie a musical, but it could have had two songs. In fact, originally Yzma was gonna sing "Snuff Out the Light" or something like that in the movie.
Seriously, you had Eartha Kitt and didn't have her planned song in the movie?
1.0k
u/Phantasmagoric_0 13h ago •
Sugilite in Steven Universe was voiced by Nicki Minaj. Although at this point, its for the best she didn't sing.
218
u/Werewolf_Knight 12h ago
I'm pretty sure A Phineas and Ferb Family Christmas tried to poke fun at this since she constantly offers herself to sing, only for the characters to insist not to do it because "they don't want to make her work on Christmas", if I remember correctly. Look, it's a thoughtful gesture... but your Christmas special took place in the middle of the summer.
299
u/Fragrant-Upstairs932 12h ago edited 12h ago
A particularly silly example: Bee/Beelzebub from Helluva Boss was played by Kesha in the first two seasons, and she even gets an elaborate musical number singing an original song. But, because of legal fuckery around her old record label, Kesha isn't actually the one providing the singing, it's a singer called Rochelle Diamente. Even though all of the spoken words are Kesha. To top it off, the legal dispute delayed the release of the final episode of season one by multiple years, and it finally came out halfway into season two.
73
u/GGthegreatester 13h ago
What if the person just wants to act?
72
u/Tonedeafmusical 12h ago
Idina Menzel in Enchanted yes shes a singer an actress but it funny that they cast a Tony award winner in a musical and never had her sing. (Especially since she won for one of the co-composers scores).
Also whenever they cast Brian D'Arcy James in a musical film for some reason. He probably had one of the best voices in the West Side Story remake and his character didnt sing! Same with Smash
67
u/ImWearingSandshoes 13h ago
Bernadette Peters, the voice of Sue in The Land Before Time X: The Great Longneck Migration.
277
u/Nothos927 13h ago
Aren’t all these people actors in their own rights as well as singers?
117
u/Farlybob42 13h ago
Jesse McCartney as Roxas (Kingdom Hearts 2)
Jesse McCartney, the second popular heartthrob next to Aaron Carter, voiced Roxas. However, he doesn’t sing at all. It is even weirder since they have the whole musical sequence in Atlantica where Sora, Donald, and goofy do a bunch of singing
terribly.51
u/idiotplatypus 13h ago
Weird Al as Darkseid in Teen Titans Go
49
u/sublime_in_all 11h ago
Idina Menzel in Enchanted
95
u/Simple_Channel5624 12h ago •
Jodi Benson in Enchanted
Best known for being the voice and singer of the little mermaid, is cast in the Enchanted movie as a secretary, doesn't sing once in the movie.
Apparently Adele Dazeem also doesn't sing a single time in the movie.
43
u/ItsAllSoup 11h ago
The movie is a musical, Christina Vee can sing. They hire a separate actress to sing
38
u/No-Shopping-4434 12h ago
Also David Bowie in Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me
Which is one of the strangest and coolest cameos ever
35
u/Gabeortiz628 13h ago
Taylor Swift as Audrey in The Lorax
29
u/CrashMK 10h ago
24
u/Motor-Rip7655 12h ago
"But she DID sing!"
Nope. Ke$ha did the voice, but the song was done by someone else. Something about her record label getting a bug up their asses about it.
23
u/different_tomatoes 12h ago
Idina Menzel had a role in Enchanted, but sang in none of the songs. She did mention something along the lines of being flattered by being cast on her acting ability, not her singing. She did sing in the sequel though
38
u/quesadelia 11h ago
Kristoff didn’t have a song in Frozen (this was rectified in Frozen 2) despite being played by Broadway icon Jonathan Groff
50
u/bclynch30 12h ago
Queen Beezlebub in Helluva Boss. She was played by Kesha but due to I think her label or something being messed up at the time, she couldn’t
16
u/GabeFoxIX 12h ago
Yzma, voiced by Eartha Kit. Doubly disappointing since emperor's new Grove was initially tooled as a musical
14
u/Patient-Paramedic803 12h ago edited 11h ago
Burlesque. Kirsten Bell, the singer behind Anna from Frozen, is cast of one of the performers and only lip sings.
48
u/AustinHinton 12h ago
Having David Bowie in your musical and NOT having him sing remains one of the most baffling decisions of that era of Spongebob. Though it's the least of that episode's problems.
13
u/Salt_Refrigerator633 12h ago
the devil's chord having the beatles (doctor who)
theyy decided to include the beatles as historical cameos but since their music is too expensive, the episode just has the villain steal all music. the Beatles barely play a role besides playing some piano notes at the end
11
u/AARose24 12h ago
The Once Upon a Time musical episode, where Rumplestilskin, played by Robert Carlyle who can sing, doesn’t sing. Everyone else sings in the episode!

11
u/Lord_Parbr 12h ago
Why is it hated? They’re all actors, too
19
u/CJtheHaasman 12h ago
One funny example of this is Paul McCartney on the Simpsons, when he asks Lisa if she'd like to hear a song to which she ecstatically says yes, only for Apu to start singing and playing his bongos
25
u/M1ck3yB1u 11h ago
Ed Sheeran in Game of Thrones.
Just kidding, but I fucking wish he shut his stupid fucking mouth.
8
u/WidderWillZie 12h ago
Bonus points to American Dad, who in the episode LGBTSteve cast Kristen Chenowith as a roller derby member, had an epic song involving only the core cast, and then let her sing "And I'm Devin" at the end as her only musical role.
8
u/MemeLordMango 10h ago
They’re calling it the worst formatting of all time
7
u/jayhof52 12h ago
Gladys Knight on 30 Rock (although that was the joke).
7
u/jchries 12h ago
Justin Timberlake is in Shrek the Third and doesn't sing in it.
6
u/KazePhantom 12h ago
Oftentimes this is due to the sheer stupidity of music law, their singing voices are often under a different licensing contract with a different agency than their one for acting and guest appearances. It's what screwed Helluva Boss out of getting Kesha to sing "Cotton Candy" and why when Bee was brought back they just recast her.
6
u/Optimal_Weight368 12h ago
I think the Phineas and Ferb example is supposed to be a joke, with the joke being that she doesn’t sing and that subverts your expectations.
6
u/flame_will_consume 12h ago
T-Pain in My Singing Monsters as T-Pirainha. As far as I know, Big Blue Bubble couldn't secure his voice for the monster due to copyright issues, so someone else provided the vocals. However, in terms of appearance, the monster is still officially based on T-Pain.
11
u/catfishbreath 9h ago
Someone save me a search - when OP says amalee, do they mean Amy Lee? Or is there actually a famous singer named amalee?
5
u/lollipopmusing 10h ago
Frozen. They cast Jonathan Groff, an incredible Broadway performer, as Kristoff and didn't give him a song until the second film.
5
u/Ely_Hendricks 10h ago
So, a bit of backstory for Bowie
His kid at the time was a massive SpongeBob fan and in turn, he became one too. They watched it together and was either asked or asked them for a role. He didn't do it to sing, he did it for his child.
9
u/Sajintmm 5h ago
If I’m correct voice acting roles are not as expensive as a singing role for an established singer. Isn’t that why Bee in hellava boss was voiced by keisha but her singing wasn’t
8
u/Death_Lycan 11h ago
Michael Jackson in Simpsons
KESHA in Hellua Boss
4
u/Ok_Minimum3837 12h ago
Tom Petty playing Lucky on King of the Hill
4
u/Sketchy_Dog 12h ago
Ok but the Phineas and Ferb one was funny. She just keeps offering to sing a song and Phineas shuts her down like "No no you're our guest! You should just relax!"
4
u/SpaceBearOne 11h ago
Corey Taylor - Nostalgia Critic's The Wall (sort of)
Despite acting as the Pink surrogate on Nostalgia Critic's parody/review/reimagining of Pink Floyd's The Wall, he never actually sings on any Pink Floyd track. He only gets to sing the Spongebob Squarepants theme at the end.
4
u/Outside_Stage_984 11h ago
Eric Tomizawa in Lad:infinite wealth is voiced and have its likeness based on Satoru Iguchi from King Gnu, and he doesn't have a fking karaoke song, I don't know why
4
u/Novaer 11h ago
Trope is "I don't understand cameos"
4
u/Commercial_Gur_3304 11h ago
I love this trope it's hilarious
4
u/KirbyofJustice 10h ago
Takuya Kimura plays Takayuki Yagami in the Judgment/Judge Eyes games. Those games are a spin off of the Yakuza series which famously have a karaoke minigame. Despite this, the karaoke minigame is absent when most others (batting cages, mahjong, etc.) are in both series.
6
u/Broly_ 11h ago
[Liked Trope]
8
u/Double_Difficulty_53 12h ago
This is done because singers don't usually have the rights to their own singing voices, usually those are held by their respective record labels.
The few times when singers are casted and actually get to sing is for movies since they have a bigger budget and they can actually afford it. Even for a show as big as SpongeBob getting the rights for David Bowie's singing for just one episode would be way too expensive for the the considerably smaller profit.
Besides, David Bowie and Jesse McCartney at least have enough experience under their belt to be considered actual actors and not just star talents, even though they are mostly know for their music.
3
u/Kannaaaaaaaaaaaa 12h ago
I'm not mad about the Uta one, Ado's singing is good enough for me lol
3
u/LystroItsAMolerat 12h ago
Ice Cube on Anaconda
3
u/Manxy-42 12h ago
David Diggs breakthrew role was in Hamiltion on Broadway. In Snowpiercer several characters have a singing scene, David is not one of them.
3
u/Wide_Craft_9765 12h ago
Billy Ray Cyrus in Mulholland Drive
3
u/Corn22 12h ago
Extremely niche reference but….In the live play dnd series Dice, Camera, Action! they had singer Natewantstobattle play a bard. In hundreds of hours of play he never sang. His bard, instead, played bagpipes and castanets.
3
u/cryptid-ok 11h ago
The Phineas and Ferb one, that’s the joke. She keeps trying to sing and nobody lets her.
7
u/Neefew 13h ago
Ariana Grande was part of the main cast of Victorious and in all 4 seasons of the show, they never have her do a solo song
2
u/FreeOrbs_2nd_Coming 13h ago
nah that first one is really fucking funny
2
u/originalchaosinabox 12h ago
The 2010 film Country Strong is all about the country music industry. There’s only one real country music singer in the cast: Tim McGraw.
McGraw is literally the only cast member who doesn’t sing.
2
u/pound_cake69 12h ago
I think that’s more of a funny ironic trope
2
u/TbatitanicV2Rider 12h ago
I mean it depends on the show. singers should be alowed to voice act without needing to sing. now hiring a big name singer in a show with semi frequent muscial numbers and not having them sing is basically a wasate of money, which is what im guessing you're criticising. anway as a middling example, kamen rider actors are often former idols but they basically never sing in the show itself, given its mostly an action drama series. but they often sing insert songs that are played during combat. dont know if that counts. time judged all from kamen rider ooo being one such song.
2
u/Future-Bumblebee-865 12h ago
Long John Baldry as Doctor Ivo Robotnik
He hardly ever sings…
2
u/HeroFizzer 12h ago
The new 3D Zootopia experience at Disney's Animal Kingdom has Shakira voicing Gazelle even for her brief role, but they do this exact joke and say it's "due to copyright reasons".
2
u/Hello_Hello5678 12h ago
Casting Sophia Anne Caruso as Sophie in The School For Good And Evil.
Sophia acted and sang as Lydia in the mainstream Beetlejuice musical. Her feats alone in the song "Home" were incredible.
Book Sophie was desperate to become a princess, and sang to animals often. The movie didn't have even a couple lines of her attempting to serenade wildlife.
2
u/AndrewH73333 12h ago
2
u/P4rtyxxan1m4l 12h ago
In the TV show Hilda, Annie Lennox and Dave Stewart of Eurythmics voiced a couple of giants in the first season, and did no singing whatsoever. This was pretty much their only major acting role.
2
u/Logan-Lux 12h ago
While he did have a song, Michael Jackson was not given any dance moves in The Wiz
2
u/BestFaithlessness814 11h ago
Beelzebub from Helluva Boss is voiced by Kesha (the pop star). She was unable to sing the song that was a part of that episode due to legal reasons. So, they had to get a stand-in to sing for her.
2
u/BasicAssQuestion 11h ago
Mandy Moore voicing herself in that Christmas (or "Snowflake Day") Clone High very special episode in the original season one run.
She just plays a hot homeless woman who people misinterpret to be the spirit of Snowflake Day, and when the main cast are all hiding out together she and her homeless coterie ransack the house and steal everything, lmao
She never sings once during the episode (though Jack Black does sing rock as a raisin-pushing drug dealer in a previous episode 🙃)
2
u/sesoren65 11h ago
.....isnt thay the joke?????
2
u/SeonaidMacSaicais 11h ago
Broadway star Matthew Broderick was cast as Simba in Disney’s Lion King…yet they didn’t feel his singing voice was “right” for a lion. Jerks.
2
u/HobbyGobbler 11h ago
The Vorta Yelgrun on Deep Space 9, played by Iggy Pop.
2
u/97andCPW 11h ago
Jonathan Groff as Kristoff in Frozen (1). Has one song less than a minute long.
2
u/ArcadianBlueRogue 11h ago
Can we could Patti LuPone a bit in Agatha All Along? She only has singing bits when the other characters do, but there is a song where they are all playing instruments and they of course get Pattie to play....the triangle....a tambourine...
You know, big stage and theater instruments.
2
u/twec21 11h ago
House MD, Dave Matthews
No singing, but the piano section was great
2
u/Born_Procedure_529 11h ago
Nah the Kelly Clarkson bit was funny as hell, genuinely the best joke from lategame Phineas and Ferb
2
u/LeftWeather3244 10h ago
lol the uta one is wild, i saw the english dub and kept waiting for amalee to sing and got ado’s japanese vocals with subtitles instead i think i’d be more annoyed than the lord royal highness case honestly, at least he never had a song to lose
2
u/theflyingurayuli 10h ago
Heather from over the hedge - voiced by Avril Lavigne yet the soundtrack is by Ben Folds
2
u/ThePrimeReason 10h ago
Miraculous Ladybug movie. Main character voiced by Cristina Vee who's a great singer. French voice actress sings instead.
2
u/DELTA_HORNET 9h ago
Nono, in Phineas and Ferb it was part of the gag lol
2
u/Myusernamebedumb 8h ago
I mean, with Kelly Clarkson in Phineas and Ferb, that’s the joke, she offers to sing a bunch of times during the episode, and they keep brushing her off.
2
u/Kazumi_Tamura 8h ago
El cameo de Michael Jackson en los Simpsons
Cómo por contrato no podía cantar, así que tuvo que cantar un imitador
2
u/SednaBoo 7h ago
B. D. Wong in Mulan.
2
u/whereismymind86 7h ago
Ke$ha in Helluva boss s1e8, they had to get a soundalike because her label would not let her sing, she was only allowed to do dialogue. Even that resulted in a lawsuit and the episode was delayed several months while it was sorted out. She's returned to voice the character a couple times, but her character hasn't had a song since.
2
u/OCGamerboy 3h ago
Taylor Swift and Zac Efron in The Lorax