r/TopCharacterTropes • • 5h ago

miscellaneous [loved trope] The writer stands behind a critically reviled decision but not just because it may be shocking.

Detroit: Become human

You may have missed this because the game is pretty but David Cage is a genuinely bad writer. Many of his scenes are quite compelling but they're often only included for the impact without much thought regarding the overall narrative.

For example, many of his games depict scenes of sexual assault with branching narrative paths. Instead of an opportunity for character study, the cagiverse concludes that would be really hard and so it doesn't really matter either way.

He is afaik still adamant that the game is not an allegory for civil rights. It's baffling that he could seemingly be so out of touch with his own art.

Star Wars prequels

The trade negotiations are pretty widely regarded as a slow start to a trilogy that is extremely light on well written dialogue to begin with. Despite this, it's clear from behind the scenes material that Lucas is quite proud of the story he is weaving.

Despite their apparent incompetence, these works contain powerful scenes and themes that clearly resonate with people. I have little more than contempt for the work of David Cage but I see these as two sides of the same coin. Both follow a society's descent into authoritarianism, Lucas has a compelling story in broad strokes but poor writing moment to moment. Cage's has scenes that are powerful but undercuts them with poor or half baked connections between plot threads.

853 Upvotes

113 comments sorted by

880

u/DrakeMayeLover7 5h ago

I guess he means it's not an allegory because it's not allegorical, it literally just is the Civil Rights Movement with robots superimposed on it

461

u/jbeldham 4h ago • Bravo

Fortunately you can lead the Android Equality Movement alongside such heroes as Rosa Sparks, Valvecom X, Car Tin Luther Spring Jr, and Chassis Owens

59

u/SopranosBluRayBoxSet 4h ago

Rosa Sparks fuckin bodied my ass

10

u/iamtheshadowking 2h ago

Car Tin Luther Spring Jr is the one that got me

91

u/eyesparks 4h ago

I haven't played this but i have played other Cage games where everything is on the nose and shitty, so I have absolutely no idea if you're joking or not.

65

u/Synister832 4h ago

Those names aren't really in the game but there is an actual android equality revolution that's basically the entire storyline for one of the main characters. It's also the most influential storyline for the rest of the game.

24

u/GachaHell 4h ago

It's a joke but not that much of a joke.

One of the main player characters has to contend with what type of civil rights leader he wants to be. Nonviolent resistance marches or military action against the oppressive police state. His speeches also feel very inspired by aforementioned civil rights leaders and the beats feel pretty familiar if you know your history.

46

u/SirYeetsA 3h ago

1/3 of the story is just a lobotomized speedran version of the civil rights movement, which throws any and all of the protagonist's prior characterization out the window all so that you can choose whether you want to do A Violence™ or A Peaceful™. Your co-protagonists include Genocidal Maniac, Suicidal Pacifist, and Complete Pussy. They will all follow you unflinchingly regardless of how much your leadership contradicts their worldview. You are also only able to romance the female co-protagonist, even though the other two co-protagonists make significantly more sense in the other route. This is because despite including two lesbians in this game, David Cage is still largely a homophobe who sees lesbians as hot and gay men as disgusting.

Okay, but, despite all of that, I do still recommend this game lol. There will be a good few eye-roll moments, but Connor's story alone is really engaging, and is the closest this game comes to actually exploring the differences in how humanity could manifest in a machine. If you don't want to give 40 clams for it (or wait for a sale), you should at least watch a Connor playthrough on YouTube.

16

u/LizLemonOfTroy 2h ago

It's a truism no less true for being repeated that it would've been a much better game if it was just Connor.

His storyline is the only one that's actually based on character work rather than just sweeping political allegories, and it does genuinely make you empathise with someone who has an alien, non-human mindset.

You could even still keep the story determinism by having Connor's actions and decisions influence whether the Android Revolution remains peaceful or turns violent depending on how ruthlessly and brutally you investigate and suppress it.

10

u/TheRavinKing 1h ago

1/3 of the story is Civil Rights Movement but robots, 1/3 of the story is the Underground Railroad but robots, and the final 1/3 is actually pretty good. (There's also a small sliver of the Holocaust but robots.)

To me, Connor's story feels like the only section that lives up to the title. Markus and Kara were already very human. They were just convincing other people of that. Connor is 100% a machine at the start, and he evolves past that as the story goes on.

I wouldn't recommend playing the game, but I had a great time watching a playthrough that was just Connor.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BCxhQpS5fQ0

13

u/SeasonofMist 4h ago

lol chriiiiiist dude that is so fucking funny. thank you for that. rosa sparks and chassis Owens about killed me. I needed that today .

1

u/sesoren65 50m ago

This guy futuramas

31

u/UnpricedToaster 5h ago

They were robots! Of course!

26

u/Medium-Access-4416 4h ago

The guy literally says "I have a dream" in a public speech.

44

u/SoutieNaaier 4h ago

Iirc he also accidentally implies that the reason given for Robots not having rights is actually true

19

u/MCCrackaZac 4h ago

This is favourite clip to support that!

4

u/SeasonofMist 4h ago

omg that clip is so rad

2

u/VidiVeni98 13m ago

The zaibatsu!

12

u/assjackal 2h ago edited 2h ago

I love David Cage's games for all the beauty and stupidy. I'm convinced most of the good parts of D:BH is just people around him working their hardest to polish the turd into something less brown.

Edit:grammar

11

u/Minimob0 2h ago

No, what he meant is he didn’t make a GAME about Civil Rights. He made an Interactive Movie about Civil Rights.

David Cage does not make games, he makes movies. 

8

u/Dull_Attention5150 3h ago

I think it's funny because this is no different than a compartment for bikes

10

u/AHistoricalFigure 2h ago

I mean, despite the downvotes, you're not wrong.

Whether society survives the next 20 years is largely going to come down to whether we can shun technology that can increasingly mimic humanity.

Just because your robot maid looks like a young Jennifer Lawrence doesnt mean you're a bad person for not being polite to her. She is, as far as you have any ability to tell, a fucking robot. She has no feelings, no preferences, and no inner experience.

Yes, some of the robits in D:BH do develop sentience, but this is an extremely recent phenomena in the game world and only effects a tiny percentage of robits. The "culture of oppression" depicted in the game is a culture that treats appliances as appliances and has only become immoral in the last 5 minutes.

8

u/LizLemonOfTroy 2h ago edited 17m ago

I would say that the modern debate over LLMs has completely recontextualised DBH, because we now recognise that even relatively basic AI can effectively mimic human writing and speech, so doing so alone is no longer an indicator of actual humanity and sentience.

When I hear people in real life calling for AI rights or equality, they sound like delusional dupes rather than heroic champions of justice.

3

u/FoxDanceMedia 1h ago

One of the logos you can choose for your android uprising is almost literally just the BLM fist logo

1

u/Kardinale 1h ago

That's not what he meant at all, David Cage is just a pretentious shitbag

274

u/sagejosh 4h ago

Become human is one of cage’s first games that he isn’t the only lead writer on. The co-writer says it’s about civil rights. Cage is insane and I have no clue how he is making a Star Wars game other than he loves racist Asian voices too.

65

u/Arks-Angel 4h ago

"Making a star wars game" is kind of a big stretch tbh

8

u/LizLemonOfTroy 2h ago

I genuinely think we'll get a sequel to The Rise of Skywalker before we get Star Wars Eclipse, if at all.

1

u/_Cit 17m ago

This isn't even a question, Star Wars Starfighter comes out next year and is set after TROS

12

u/woopwoopscuttle 2h ago

Oh God, you just made me realise he has access to NEIMOIDIANS, Toydarians and Muuns with their intergalactic banking clan… 😬

184

u/Avolto 3h ago • Regret


I’m old enough to remember the massive amounts of hate directed at Ahsoka when she was first introduced. Everything from sexism, to comments about her age and personality, even the choice to give Anakin a Padawan was hugely controversial at the time. However unlike Rose in the Sequels the writers did not bow to the hate and do away with her in the tv show. And slowly Ahsoka grew to become one of the most beloved Star Wars characters introduced outside of the movies.

87

u/DropoutRedMage 2h ago

Only to loop back around to being hated because she became overexposed.

29

u/Avolto 2h ago

I feel like on balance people still like the character it's just that as you say she is a little overexposed in recent years.

11

u/DropoutRedMage 1h ago

I still like her myself, I just don't know why she needed to show up in the Mandalorian. I did actually like her appearance in Rebels, thought that was a fitting end to her story.

5

u/LordHoughtenWeen 1h ago

If only it had actually been an end...

2

u/_Cit 19m ago

She never died in Twilight of the Apprentice, you see her exiting the temple in the episode itself.

Also, I don't understand how this many people think that killing Ahsoka off in the middle of her character arc, while she's consumed by vengeance, purely for shock value is a good ending.

0

u/LordHoughtenWeen 4m ago

She never died in Twilight of the Apprentice, you see her exiting the temple in the episode itself.

Yeah. If only you hadn't.

in the middle of her character arc, while she's consumed by vengeance, purely for shock value

I don't understand how you got any of that from this episode. She puts herself in harm's way to let Kanan and Ezra escape. Same thing Kanan does two seasons later.

17

u/WombatBum85 2h ago

This is what I can't stand about the more vocal reviewers - they're all like my 18 month old niece whose automatic reaction is NO until she realises what I'm holding. It's cute in a toddler, not so much in an adult.

3

u/Altruistic_Web3924 57m ago

Some of these adults have arrested development / developmental issues and are incapable of behaving as adults. We give the toddlers a pass because they’re cute. Some “adults” just need recognized for their limitations and handled accordingly.

5

u/Hiswua 2h ago

She is one of the few good things hat guy has done and he’s even drove her into the ground in recent years

0

u/_Cit 18m ago

This is an insane take lmao

1

u/Erlox 11m ago

I feel like Ahsoka at first felt like a 'Scrappy Doo', the showrunners adding a younger plucky team member to appeal to the kids.

However, she also serves to show the desperation of the Jedi Order during the war. That they're giving padawans to padawans just so they can get children into the warzone earlier. Shows a lot of the dichotomy of the series in a way, kids media but about the horrors of war in sometimes deep ways.

24

u/Validarian 2h ago

The Crucible

This is more of an explanation of the trope, but this work concerns the witch trials of Salemn, where people could basically be accused of witchcraft without actual evidence ('spectral evidence', such as dreams, was accepted), which lead to people being accused and put to death because their neighbor had an inkling without proof or simply did not like them.

While this was written as an allegory for McCarthyism, where an American senator would accuse people of being communists without proof during the cold war, when a Chinese person read the work, they remarked how it felt like an appropriate allegory for parts of the communist revolution in China.

59

u/SKEL_Nimitz 3h ago

Forever cursing David Cage because by God do I want to love Heavy Rain so badly, but there's just so much wrong with it.

47

u/Cazthedm 3h ago

SHAAAAAAAAAAAUN!

5

u/FixFun1959 1h ago

The “Press X to Shaun” glitch is fucking hilarious

6

u/Desperate-System-843 1h ago edited 1h ago

weakly "Dad, I knew you'd come and sa-"

"Millimetres from his face* "SHAAAAAAUUUUUUUUUUUNNNNNN!"

I always lost it at that.

1

u/FixFun1959 41m ago

“SHAUUUNN!!”

“I’m afraid that’s not possible Ethan.”

4

u/LizLemonOfTroy 2h ago

Also another good example in of itself, since Cage remained committed to the twist that one of the viewpoint characters is actually the killer, even when the rest of the game he was writing and making directly contradicted this.

69

u/Avolto 3h ago


The casting of RDJ as Dr Doom in the MCU. Of All the possible people they could have picked they went with the guy who was already one of the faces of the MCU. Despite all the complaints since then they never listened to criticism and RDJ remains Doom.

44

u/Slappathebassmon 2h ago

Casting RDJ does feel like a massive nostalgia bait / fanservice. This heavily hinges on if Doomsday actually delivers on the hype or is a ridiculous, convoluted mess. I mean, story wise. I'm betting on the second.

Annoyingly, it seems they're already being rewarded financially for it, with how box office is tracking.

4

u/Dear-Question-868 2h ago

Yeah totally since the one that was supposed to be the big villain got fired because of his conduct it feels like they are trying to fix the franchise, I'm thinking the same thing, it's going to be a mess.

0

u/Zephian99 1h ago

Agreed, I like RDJ, but his return seems a little like fancasting and ease of contract, since they've already contracted with him for so long, getting him written in for a new one must be easy for the directors.

I wish we got a different actor, (since it seems he'll be entirely a voice actor?), but I don't blame RDJ for wanting the money. 😅

4

u/efimer 2h ago

I'm not a comic book reader, does that mean ironman becomes doom or are they unrelated?

17

u/DoubleStrength 2h ago

They're mostly unrelated.

There is a parallel universe What If...? comic story where Tony and Victor go to the same university, and Tony's partying ways pisses Victor off, so Victor gets his revenge by swapping their minds/bodies.

But so far in the cinematic continuity, we don't know yet if they'll end up connected or not.

9

u/aerosolsp 2h ago

They're unrelated.

3

u/WombatBum85 1h ago

That's the thing, nobody has seen the movie yet so nobody knows what they've done - have they stayed with the comics or done something original?

But it's 'cooler' to chuck a tantrum at every announcement 🙄

1

u/Termedclover611 34m ago

Dr. Doom became Iron Man for a little bit in the comics, but that's about it. They're otherwise unrelated.

79

u/sonofaresiii 5h ago

> You may have missed this because the game is pretty but David Cage is a genuinely bad writer. Many of his scenes are quite compelling but they're often only included for the impact without much thought regarding the overall narrative.

All I remember is that I was really invested in this game literally until the end when everything just fucking ended out of nowhere and I was so confused.

Like literally in the path with the robot girl and the little (also robot) girl, I wandered over to the wrong place and chose to show the guard my ticket and got a sudden death ending when the cops came over, realized I was fake because of my heat signature (??? where the hell did that come from???) and shot me and the little girl What the fuck. I had absolutely no way to know that that one single decision right there would be an automatic death.

You'd think if my heat signature was a dead giveaway, someone at some point through the course of the game would have mentioned it, given that they mentioned every other danger they possibly could have run into.

76

u/Tomatillo12475 4h ago edited 3h ago

You turned off Alice’s “temperature sensors” when she complained that she was cold.

The bus terminal is pretty unforgiving and you have to avoid the guards at all costs. It’s possible to avoid the guards so that they never check your ticket but if they do then it’s an automatic game over if you turned off Alice’s sensors.

The last checkpoint is determined based on your choices with Markus. The guard scans you, notices you are all androids but Kara pleads with the guard that “we just want to be free.” He looks at the TV and sees either a violent revolution or a peaceful protest that determines his opinion of androids. If he called it in, it was because Markus was leading a violent revolution.

It’s a pretty cool butterfly effect moment if you have the full context but if it’s your first time, there’s no way to know which actions have which consequences so it doesn’t hit the same

17

u/SeasonofMist 4h ago

Jesus that's brutal. also makes perfect sense

17

u/SirYeetsA 3h ago

THERE'S A FAIL STATE FOR THAT??? I THOUGHT THE TEMPERATURE SENSOR DID NOTHING BECAUSE I GOT ALICE SEEN AS A HUMAN THROUGH CANADIAN TSA DESPITE HAVING HER TEMPERATURE TURNED OFF. AND THROUGH THE GUARD POST IN THE STREET WHERE THEY HAD TEMPERATURE SENSORS. WHY THE FUCK IS THAT NOT EVENLY APPLIED?!?!

7

u/DepressedDynamo 2h ago

Does trope just mean "thing related to media" now?

26

u/missingjimmies 3h ago

Writers standing behind a decision is not a trope

18

u/Rival_Defender 2h ago

Anything’s a trope with enough upvotes.

6

u/tonkledonker 2h ago

I feel like youre talking about three different things at once. The more I read about your post the more confused I became tbh.

3

u/JohnHenryMillerTime 4h ago

He is away from keyboard?

9

u/Sim5672 3h ago

afaik means "as far as I know"

2

u/BendyAu 2h ago

I love thr concepts david cage has , he jjst fails the delovery 

2

u/Iostaa 1h ago

I think David Cage backed himself into a corner with Detroit: Become Human. Either he can admit it’s an allegory for civil rights, at which point he’s making the argument that real people are so different to other real people that robots are an effective allegory (which would basically be screaming “I’m a giant racist,” which he might be idk), or he can pretend to be an ostrich and that he doesn’t understand his own art. That way at least, the criticism is that he’s stupid, not malicious

6

u/PineappleNice6588 1h ago

The civil rights thing doesnt have to come from the "real people are different" since, yk, its an allegory, that can use a bit of hyperbole lol

3

u/Nice-River-5322 1h ago

eh to be fair he's French

1

u/LycanIndarys 29m ago

There is a third option; "I prefer to let my work speak for itself".

Though obviously, non-committal silence can end up pissing everyone off...

1

u/Frequent-Camel7669 35m ago

Lucas 'only' needed a competent writers' room around him to turn his scripts into elevated versions of what we got. He does have a very compelling story to tell, and we get those profound moments for a reason.

With a competent writing staff (and a willingness to listen to them), he could have shown us (instead of just telling us in a handful of throwaway lines) how the whole Old Republic system was sclerotic, dominated by corpo interests, and ultimately corrupt. He could have shown how vast reaches of the Outer Rim were essentially kept as hopeless, inescapable backwaters for trillions, where the corpos did what they wanted. He could have shown us how the sparks of separatism would quickly become a wildfire, and how a Republic that's completely out of touch can only respond with war. I think he actually did a good job showing Jedi complicity, no notes here.

But that writing staff and/or willingness to listen did not exist, and we got what we got. Which is fine! I cringe at many lines of dialogue and some storytelling decisions in the prequels, but overall, they enrich the canon and world of Star Wars, and I'm glad we have them.

Not like the sequels.

-3

u/DoradoPulido2 3h ago

Not a trope, just OP's rant on their opinion. Detroit was a fun game, get over it.

-1

u/ThatAdamsGuy 1h ago

I know that David Cage is not a good writer, that his games are not great, etc but there is still something I very much enjoy about playing them. I loved Heavy Rain the first time, wish I could play it again fresh, same with Detroit (if less so)

-15

u/sir_odanus 4h ago

Meh, you cannot ask muchbout of star wars, it is made for 5 years old. The exception being Andor. How the did they manage to get something sogood out of disney studio?

177

u/HellbirdVT 5h ago

The trade negotiations are pretty widely regarded as a slow start to a trilogy

I don't know why people say this. The Jedi barely have time to sit down and sip their drinks before the shooting and gas attack starts.

Nobody negotiates dick, and shit starts exploding three and a half minutes after the opening crawl!

66

u/BangBangMeatMachine 4h ago

Quite a while ago I read something from a critic that really stuck with me. It wasn't about this film, just about criticism in general. When people don't like a film, they tend to cite irrelevant details as their reasons. This plot point, or that character, or this tone. When in reality, it's usually for something much more fundamental than that.

The trade negotiations are an easy-to-see example. The deeper problem is that the film was very poorly written and directed, with a bunch of characters that aren't interesting and dialog that is so surface-level and stupid that it's painful to watch.

18

u/mangopabu 4h ago

i see this happen so often. i teach academic ESL and one of the pain points in my class is covering critical thinking, especially in academic discussion, where you can't just simply say 'i agree/don't agree with you' without first understanding what they're saying. then, backing up further and reinforcing the point that people can't actually understand you unless you support your opinion with something that actually supports it.

and i think that's where so much discourse breaks down, with a lot of people just jumping to agreement/disagreement without first trying to understand what the position actually is and what evidence supports it. i've been in so many discussions where i have to say things like 'it sounds like you DO agree with it...'

1

u/LizLemonOfTroy 2h ago

You see this all the time where a new film is criticised, including for certain plot points or character actions, and its defenders will say "But Beloved Classic X also had examples of these!"

And yeah - the difference is that Beloved Classic X was a great film and so no one cared enough to nitpick these details. If people are nitpicking, it's because they're already not enjoying the film.

26

u/THE_LEGO_FURRY 5h ago

Yeah the Simpsons and fans in general blew it way out of proportion, I still think phantom menace is the weakest in the prequel trilogy but I still like it.

19

u/Strange_Potential93 4h ago

… Attack of the clones still exists

15

u/HellbirdVT 4h ago

I like the Prequels, I tend to agree AotC is the weakest.

It's mostly the Anakin-Padmé love story that slows it down, but honestly the action sequences on Coruscant, Kamino and Geonosis... it's freaking awesome.

There's not a ton of meat to the story, ironically since it's setting up the Clone Wars, but the fact it's basically non-stop action from the moment they unleash the beasts in the Arena to Dooku's escape on the solar sailer is genuinely so much fun I don't care.

4

u/THE_LEGO_FURRY 4h ago

See I think that one was better. Though to be fair I'm a sucker for all things prequel trilogy.

5

u/Strange_Potential93 4h ago edited 4h ago

I mean I am too but I think episode 2 suffers the worst of Lucas’s terrible dialogue and bad actor directing. It lacks Liam Neason elevating the scenes like episode 1 and unfortunately Ewan McGregor and Ian McDermott don’t have nearly as much screen time as they do in episode 3 so we are stuck with Hayden Christianson and Natali Portman putting on a community theater rendition of Dr. Zhivago where the leads have no chemistry.

5

u/Defiant-Magician6092 4h ago

You lose Neeson but gain Lee.

3

u/Strange_Potential93 4h ago

He has what 12 minutes of screen time?

Edit: just checked he only has 9 minutes of screen time in AotC

6

u/rolltide1000 3h ago

I know people talk about how "X in X was severely underutilized", but Christopher Lee as a disillusioned ex-Jedi leading a populist movement, manipulating it for his and his masters own personal dark gain, all while presenting an emotional dilemma for Obi-Wan as he's a spiritual grandfather and the closest living thing to his old master?

That could've really been something.

4

u/Defiant-Magician6092 4h ago

Worthy of record in the Jedi Archives

1

u/LizLemonOfTroy 2h ago

The only actor more wasted in those films than Lee is Terence Stamp.

2

u/THE_LEGO_FURRY 4h ago

I don't really know what zivhago is unfortunately, but I always kind of liked their scenes. Plus jango fetts mystery (which yeah gets solved very fast) and the clones I really liked

3

u/Strange_Potential93 4h ago edited 4h ago

Dr. Zhivago is one of the greatest romantic epics in the history of cinema and what George Lucas explicitly based AotC on, unfortunately as is often the case with the prequels his actors, his writing and his directing talent were not up to the task of his ambitions

4

u/THE_LEGO_FURRY 4h ago

I'll have to look into that, I've been meaning to watch classic cinema since I'm in the process of making my own indie animation project. Last week I went to go see the cabinet of Dr caligari.

3

u/SeasonofMist 4h ago

Dr.Zhivago is a stand out if you dig old cinema. It's a whole ass thing. It also portrays a Russian revolutionary as a tragic figure, and it paints the whole situation as genuinely a tragedy rather than something awesome. At the time, that really clashed with what the Soviet Union was trying to say, so it's also kind of neat in that way.

4

u/Strange_Potential93 4h ago

2

u/THE_LEGO_FURRY 4h ago

Oh I definitely see the resemblance

→ More replies

10

u/GarlicStreet3237 5h ago

It started talking galactic politics (other than empire bad, now rebellion) for 3 minutes so people checked out

1

u/BlankTank1216 3h ago

It's just because they stick out as implausibly low stakes. Which by association make the action seem kind of lame too.

5

u/ChancelorReed 4h ago

Yea I mean I guess reading the opening scrawl is more boring than usual but that opening scene on the ship is overall really well done and tightly paced.

You just then go very quickly into a sequence of Jar Jar and then young Anakin with loads of awful dialogue.

3

u/mangopabu 4h ago

yeah i'd say it's the whole senate stuff is what people mean but even then, it is important to the story and honestly doesn't drag on that much. i think it just gets lumped in with everything else's genuine complaints and then 'oh this stuff wasn't super exciting, so it gets dragged down too'

1

u/LizLemonOfTroy 2h ago

It's moreso the galactic politics rather than the negotiations themselves, which should be interesting (they were in the beginning of A New Hope), but latter-day Lucas has simply no idea how to shoot a scene on Coruscant without managing to turn everyone on screen into inert mannequins (Manakins?) regurgitating wooden dialogue with all the character and enthusiasm of a nativity play.

1

u/WrethZ 58m ago

Still the opening crawl has the epic star wars music and is talking about taxes and trade routes.

Compare that to the original opening crawl with talks about an evil galactic empire, a rebellion for freedom and a planet destroying space station, the phantom menace opening crawl is definitely dull.

76

u/Evielikesfilm 5h ago

The Boys, Annie gets mad at her boyfriend for being sa'd by a shapeshifter. Fans got angry and writers stood by Annie. This came after the first rape that happens to Hughie where they also played it for comedic effect and the writer said "wow thats a dark way to look at it."

15

u/SeasonofMist 3h ago

that shit broke my mind for a minute as it was happening. like are y'all outside your god damned minds?! How fucking dare you play assault for laugh and THEN have Annie angry with HIM for the assault he experienced with someone commuting rape by deception?! like this whole story begins with what bullshit that is because it happens to Annie, right?! the fuck. I hated that. and from then on i saw it more and more as some director or something really likes to film people being uncomfortable.....I think he's roped me/the audience into watching for some reason. Uhhhhg. I was kinda done with that series at that point. I haven't finished the last season I just.....don't care

9

u/Afrodotheyt 3h ago

I never get shows that want to portray Rape as both something that is incredibly traumatizing and awful in one instance, but then try to play it for laughs or downplay it in general in others. Like, Starlight of all people, should understand.

15

u/GodsavEVE 4h ago

I think game will be much better if it was detective bromance story about konnor and old man.

Fuck Marcus fuck the woman. I don't want play with them