r/TopCharacterTropes • u/BlankTank1216 • 5h ago
miscellaneous [loved trope] The writer stands behind a critically reviled decision but not just because it may be shocking.
Detroit: Become human
You may have missed this because the game is pretty but David Cage is a genuinely bad writer. Many of his scenes are quite compelling but they're often only included for the impact without much thought regarding the overall narrative.
For example, many of his games depict scenes of sexual assault with branching narrative paths. Instead of an opportunity for character study, the cagiverse concludes that would be really hard and so it doesn't really matter either way.
He is afaik still adamant that the game is not an allegory for civil rights. It's baffling that he could seemingly be so out of touch with his own art.
Star Wars prequels
The trade negotiations are pretty widely regarded as a slow start to a trilogy that is extremely light on well written dialogue to begin with. Despite this, it's clear from behind the scenes material that Lucas is quite proud of the story he is weaving.
Despite their apparent incompetence, these works contain powerful scenes and themes that clearly resonate with people. I have little more than contempt for the work of David Cage but I see these as two sides of the same coin. Both follow a society's descent into authoritarianism, Lucas has a compelling story in broad strokes but poor writing moment to moment. Cage's has scenes that are powerful but undercuts them with poor or half baked connections between plot threads.


880
u/DrakeMayeLover7 5h ago
I guess he means it's not an allegory because it's not allegorical, it literally just is the Civil Rights Movement with robots superimposed on it
274
u/sagejosh 4h ago
Become human is one of cage’s first games that he isn’t the only lead writer on. The co-writer says it’s about civil rights. Cage is insane and I have no clue how he is making a Star Wars game other than he loves racist Asian voices too.
184
u/Avolto 3h ago •
I’m old enough to remember the massive amounts of hate directed at Ahsoka when she was first introduced. Everything from sexism, to comments about her age and personality, even the choice to give Anakin a Padawan was hugely controversial at the time. However unlike Rose in the Sequels the writers did not bow to the hate and do away with her in the tv show. And slowly Ahsoka grew to become one of the most beloved Star Wars characters introduced outside of the movies.
24
u/Validarian 2h ago
The Crucible
This is more of an explanation of the trope, but this work concerns the witch trials of Salemn, where people could basically be accused of witchcraft without actual evidence ('spectral evidence', such as dreams, was accepted), which lead to people being accused and put to death because their neighbor had an inkling without proof or simply did not like them.
While this was written as an allegory for McCarthyism, where an American senator would accuse people of being communists without proof during the cold war, when a Chinese person read the work, they remarked how it felt like an appropriate allegory for parts of the communist revolution in China.
59
u/SKEL_Nimitz 3h ago
Forever cursing David Cage because by God do I want to love Heavy Rain so badly, but there's just so much wrong with it.
69
u/Avolto 3h ago
The casting of RDJ as Dr Doom in the MCU. Of All the possible people they could have picked they went with the guy who was already one of the faces of the MCU. Despite all the complaints since then they never listened to criticism and RDJ remains Doom.
79
u/sonofaresiii 5h ago
> You may have missed this because the game is pretty but David Cage is a genuinely bad writer. Many of his scenes are quite compelling but they're often only included for the impact without much thought regarding the overall narrative.
All I remember is that I was really invested in this game literally until the end when everything just fucking ended out of nowhere and I was so confused.
Like literally in the path with the robot girl and the little (also robot) girl, I wandered over to the wrong place and chose to show the guard my ticket and got a sudden death ending when the cops came over, realized I was fake because of my heat signature (??? where the hell did that come from???) and shot me and the little girl What the fuck. I had absolutely no way to know that that one single decision right there would be an automatic death.
You'd think if my heat signature was a dead giveaway, someone at some point through the course of the game would have mentioned it, given that they mentioned every other danger they possibly could have run into.
7
u/DepressedDynamo 2h ago
Does trope just mean "thing related to media" now?
26
u/missingjimmies 3h ago
Writers standing behind a decision is not a trope
6
u/tonkledonker 2h ago
I feel like youre talking about three different things at once. The more I read about your post the more confused I became tbh.
3
u/JohnHenryMillerTime 4h ago
He is away from keyboard?
2
u/BendyAu 2h ago
I love thr concepts david cage has , he jjst fails the delovery
2
u/Iostaa 1h ago
I think David Cage backed himself into a corner with Detroit: Become Human. Either he can admit it’s an allegory for civil rights, at which point he’s making the argument that real people are so different to other real people that robots are an effective allegory (which would basically be screaming “I’m a giant racist,” which he might be idk), or he can pretend to be an ostrich and that he doesn’t understand his own art. That way at least, the criticism is that he’s stupid, not malicious
1
u/silly-NR-gee 1h ago
.m
1
u/Frequent-Camel7669 35m ago
Lucas 'only' needed a competent writers' room around him to turn his scripts into elevated versions of what we got. He does have a very compelling story to tell, and we get those profound moments for a reason.
With a competent writing staff (and a willingness to listen to them), he could have shown us (instead of just telling us in a handful of throwaway lines) how the whole Old Republic system was sclerotic, dominated by corpo interests, and ultimately corrupt. He could have shown how vast reaches of the Outer Rim were essentially kept as hopeless, inescapable backwaters for trillions, where the corpos did what they wanted. He could have shown us how the sparks of separatism would quickly become a wildfire, and how a Republic that's completely out of touch can only respond with war. I think he actually did a good job showing Jedi complicity, no notes here.
But that writing staff and/or willingness to listen did not exist, and we got what we got. Which is fine! I cringe at many lines of dialogue and some storytelling decisions in the prequels, but overall, they enrich the canon and world of Star Wars, and I'm glad we have them.
Not like the sequels.
-3
u/DoradoPulido2 3h ago
Not a trope, just OP's rant on their opinion. Detroit was a fun game, get over it.
-1
u/ThatAdamsGuy 1h ago
I know that David Cage is not a good writer, that his games are not great, etc but there is still something I very much enjoy about playing them. I loved Heavy Rain the first time, wish I could play it again fresh, same with Detroit (if less so)
-15
u/sir_odanus 4h ago
Meh, you cannot ask muchbout of star wars, it is made for 5 years old. The exception being Andor. How the did they manage to get something sogood out of disney studio?
177
u/HellbirdVT 5h ago
I don't know why people say this. The Jedi barely have time to sit down and sip their drinks before the shooting and gas attack starts.
Nobody negotiates dick, and shit starts exploding three and a half minutes after the opening crawl!
76
u/Evielikesfilm 5h ago
The Boys, Annie gets mad at her boyfriend for being sa'd by a shapeshifter. Fans got angry and writers stood by Annie. This came after the first rape that happens to Hughie where they also played it for comedic effect and the writer said "wow thats a dark way to look at it."
15
u/GodsavEVE 4h ago
I think game will be much better if it was detective bromance story about konnor and old man.
Fuck Marcus fuck the woman. I don't want play with them