r/TopCharacterTropes • • 4h ago

building/location. (world building trope) this specific city/town/area is far worse than any place in the world.

Carcer city (Manhunt/GTA universe) this city is widely regarded as a living shithole to live in. The abandoned areas are filled with all kinds of criminals and areas specifically made for a snuff film company in which the protagonist has to fight for his life against crazed psychopathic killers some of which are pedophiles like The Innocentz, along with the corrupt Police force. There's many comments in the rockstar universe on how shitty carcer city is.

Hub city (DC) I don't know shit enough about DC but I did know that bludhaven and Gotham suck ass to live in but they had its heroes. Apparently hub city was so awful that the question couldn't handle it and he abandoned the city because of how hopeless it was. Not even the fire fighters could go out and take down a fire because they didn't have gas money. Honestly this is interchangeable because DC has some really shitty Cities but hub city is the only city that I'm aware of that was so bad that its hero abandoned it and is more grounded compared to the supernatural bullshit that goes on in Gotham. Also your never see a random guy trying to use a fucking dead baby in public to make money In Gotham.

Cates crossing, Tangipahoa Parish and its surroundings (vintage 8) is an awful supernatural filled place with an ancient sealed god trying to escape to reunite with humanity. Two super intelligent AI one of which is a devout follower of the god. An alien mind controlling virus created by the same god that plagues the galaxy and has taken over a majority of living alien civilization in the Galaxy to the point aliens made a deal with a super AI on earth for the cure because that's how desperate they were. Cates crossing just sucks ass in general because the place is just attracting everything and everyone. (I haven't caught up with the series recently, so for all I know it's gotten worse.)

243 Upvotes

105 comments sorted by

102

u/LtGeneral_Obvious 4h ago

Carcer City may seem extreme in the modern day, but it's basically a pastiche of films like Death Wish, which are themselves pastiches of the urban decay of New York in the 1970s. It was rough.

39

u/Kaos99 3h ago

Pictures of that era in New York blow mind. Some look like they're straight out of a warzone. The movie Warriors was based on this era iirc

14

u/froggyziller 2h ago

Yeah it's like that first scene in predator 2 with full on gang warfare in LA, with how bad it was back then it wasn't unbelievable

4

u/SeasonofMist 2h ago

that's so wild

3

u/SH4RPSPEED 57m ago

"There was, uh, a couple of Puerto Rican old gentlemen, they was sitting down, they were playing dominos...there was some kids, skipping rope, girls...some fellas down the street a little ways, they were tossing a football...out from across the street came two guys...and they start shooting at one another. Right down the middle of the street. The guys with the football sorta docilely skip to the side, the old men kept on playing dominos, the girls stopped skipping rope to watch, but nobody ran. It was not that unusual."

~80 Blocks from Tiffany's, 1979

238

u/PhanThief95 4h ago • Popcorn

Night City (Cyberpunk 2077)

Deaths are so high in this city that they made a lottery out of it. In Night City, there is no such thing as a happy ending.

82

u/Roborilla8000 4h ago

And within Night City is Pacifica.

But within Pacifica, is Dogtown.

36

u/SH4RPSPEED 3h ago

A real Russian nesting doll of bullshit

161

u/MarcusTomato 3h ago

Oh, buddy, noooo.

In 2077, Hong Kong is a walled off quarentine zone. The middle east is a nuclear wasteland. Chicago was decimated by a bioweapon and is now "plaugelands". Sacramento California and Detroit Michigan were FLATTENED. The mid west is a radioactive dustbowl.

Night City isn't even close to the worst place to be in 2077.

96

u/Phihofo 3h ago edited 3h ago

Australia is a failed state where warlords constantly fight over the remaining resources on lands turned into scorching deserts due to runaway climate warming.

Like it is unironically just Mad Max over there.

33

u/EdibleUnderpants 3h ago

Wait are we talking about the game or irl, because it’s the same, man

11

u/kargaz 3h ago

Sacramento mentioned.

2

u/Sekrious 1h ago

If I had a nickel for every time I’ve heard of a plaguelands Chicago due to some apocalyptic event, I’d have two nickels

35

u/jedisalamander 2h ago

I think 2077 really overused the whole "theres no happy endings in Night City" when Mike Pondsmith (creator of the whole setting) prefers "in Cyberpunk, you cant save the world but you can save yourself/your family"

11

u/SeasonofMist 2h ago

I actually love that about the tabletop. it's not about there being no hope, but that sometimes it's reasonable to bail and get yourself out of the business of whatever.

6

u/Gullible_Play8718 2h ago

Night City is a part of Cyberpunk, but not the entirety of it.

So what's true for Night City isn't true for the rest of the setting.

1

u/PigeonFellow 39m ago

That’s what I loved about Edgerunners II. The world might not change all that much, the corps will still continue or at best change forms, but D is finally happy with Capri, Weak and Talia form a bond beyond blood, Omi no longer has to worry about D, and Roman is reminded that there’s so much more to life still. Sure, it’s not perfect, but everyone seems content with how things went.

12

u/Moose_Cake 1h ago

Unfortunately Night City IS THE GOOD NEIGHBORHOOD.

According to lore Minnesota rains red acid rain all day. Michigan has been mined so hard that the only thing above bedrock is a thin layer of toxic slag. Detroit is a prison city. Chicago got ravaged by plague to the point that people gave up rebuilding several times. New York and DC are destroyed beyond repair. Kentucky is now protecting its remaining horses because starving people from local states began crossing over and eating horses into extinction. The south is literally just the south but with cyborgs. The southwest is full of dead towns and bandits by the tens of thousands. Everywhere is stripped of resources. Most animals are dead. People travel in packs to survive.

You ever wonder why people continued to live in Night City immediately after the bombing? Because it was better than the rest of the US.

10

u/pchlster 3h ago

In Night City, there is no such thing as a happy ending.

Sure is. If you've got the eddies for it, we can take care of that just down this alley...

6

u/DolphinBall 3h ago

Pfft, have you seen the NUSA?

75

u/DeaconBrad42 3h ago edited 3h ago • Bravo

Minas Morgul and the Morgul Vale from The Lord of the Rings. It is the City of the Ringwraiths, filled with horrors and lit by “a corpse light,” and even the flowers in the valley grow misshapen and evil. Drinking any stream that flows through the vale is a very bad idea. And the Pass of Cirith Ungol nearby, that leads to Shelob’s Lair, is just as bad.

19

u/LukeTheEpic1 3h ago

Counterpoint: hot goth spider woman

12

u/Evil_Midnight_Lurker 2h ago

Only in that one game.

3

u/AccordingBeing8481 2h ago

Maybe he has very low standards

1

u/PickerPat 24m ago

Christopher did I ever tell you about Shelob...

1

u/Minimob0 0m ago

Miyazaki making Dark Souls be like -

58

u/pacmanfunky 3h ago

Ravenholm - Half-Life 2

Crazy that in an alien-ran totalitarianism world things can get worse, but yeah this is still pretty bad. Basically it's a zombie infected ghost town that the combine leaves alone, either as a stark reminder what happens if you mess with them, or as too dangerous for them to deal with is unclear. But it is bleak grim and crawling (and climbing) with zombies, some of which you have never seen before and they are scary.

Father Grigori is there though and he's an absolute legend.

8

u/Toothless-In-Wapping 2h ago

I haven’t play the game since it came out, is there ever a reason for why those zombies are there?

6

u/pacmanfunky 2h ago

So the combine have missiles that land and open up with head crabs, they infect people and turn them into zombies by latching onto their head. They basically shelled this town with them, but I think they mutated into poison headcrabs. Which are much more dangerous, normal zombies are your classic slow George romero zombies. But poison headcrabs are quick and can climb up buildings so a lot more dangerous.

3

u/Toothless-In-Wapping 1h ago

Okay, so that’s why the Combine don’t go back in? They didn’t make these things and at this point, the town isn’t worth it cause there’s no resistance so let the zombies have it?

Maybe you can answer this for me, why does the combine mess around with Gordon and the others (and resistance areas like Ravenholm) instead of obliterating it with their weapons?
I know the combine needs some humans for their plans, but why headcrab missile Ravenholm anyway when leveling it would have killed a large rebel force with no loss of combine forces?

I might just be missing or forgetting something.

2

u/pacmanfunky 1h ago

It's a little unclear, this is where it goes more theory than fact. But the general consensus is that while the combine are in control of earth they are stuck there and don't have a way to reconnect with the main fleet. However, they are known to adopt/adapt or brainwash other races into the fold of the combine.

For the time-being they are plundering the resources of earth and trying to find ways to create a portal, using the human race as a kind of slave class. Their are some other theories that they want to capture the scientists of black mesa who survived for their knowledge, if their is some way to get it dead or alive idk.

As for not doing anything with Ravenholm? I guess they think it would just be a waste of precious resources.

1

u/Fantastic_Ad_2084 5m ago

I’ve not heard the stuck there theory. Typically, in all the lore videos, discussions etc people usually say that the combine is stretched too thin/ doesn’t care that much about earth. In HL2 chapter 2 one of the main objectives is shutting down the combine portal. The main reason why the combine even really care about earth is they lack dimensional teleportation; they are fully capable of traveling inter dimensionally.

4

u/Soapy_99 2h ago

The town used to be a resistance base,the zombies are those were unable to escape after the Combine barraged the town with Headcrab canisters.

5

u/Evil_Midnight_Lurker 2h ago

We don't go to Ravenholm.

58

u/Potato_lovr 3h ago

The Zone in S.T.A.L.K.E.R. It’s a terrifying area. Incomprehensible horrors, bandits, the like. Thing is, the rest of the world is… just fine.

10

u/OAZdevs_alt2 3h ago

NOT BANDITS!!!!

7

u/Potato_lovr 3h ago

Worse than the incomprehensible horrors!

1

u/expositionalrain 51m ago

I've died to the bandits more than the horrors to be fair.

0

u/whereismymind86 8m ago

iirc this is implied to be the case with fallout as well. The nuclear war devastated the us and china, but most of the rest of the world is normal and just considers the us an exclusion/quarantine zone.

48

u/Theeljessonator 3h ago


It’s revealed in 28 Years Later that the rage virus has successfully been contained to just the British Isles.

So yeah… regular world but Britain is filled with scary zombie-like beings.

14

u/Gullible_Play8718 2h ago

We would've carpet napalmed the country to clean it of the virus by the time of 28 years later.

4

u/PickerPat 23m ago

This is the same universe without armed guards and protections for the sole infected they bring into their quarantine zone.

Perhaps there is a pre-Rage virus Stupid virus that starts with the intelligence loss only.

10

u/thegreatestdandino 1h ago edited 1h ago

So England is unchanged?

132

u/AccordingBeing8481 4h ago

Detroit, irl

46

u/110397 3h ago

It’s memphis nowdays

18

u/AnyAgency9835 3h ago edited 2m ago

Americans make up random cities nowadays, because what do you mean Memphis is a real place, and it has over 600000 people living in it

5

u/Toothless-In-Wapping 2h ago

Some cities are named using a local native language.
Like when you happen upon a welsh town name in the UK

9

u/AznOmega 2h ago

NO! NO NOT DETROIT! PLEASE! ANYWHERE BUT THAT!

4

u/ADMotti 1h ago

Pretty sure Carser City above is supposed to be a Detroit/Cleveland hybrid, based on the radio ads about it in San Andreas.

3

u/Evil_Midnight_Lurker 2h ago

Let's all give Doctor Klahn a great big hand!

44

u/MoonlightDahling 4h ago

Twin Peaks, Washington.

19

u/PuzzleheadedEssay198 3h ago

My favorite thing about this is the population.

You really think that this small of a town would have a population that of 50k? Like, I get that Lynch is from Burbank, but I grew up in a town with less than 10k and it STILL wasn’t as tight knit as Twin Peaks is shown to be.

23

u/TheGoddessLily 4h ago

Harran from dying light is basically been walled off because of a zombie outbreak and the survivors are trapped with thousands of zombies

22

u/squirt2311 3h ago

1998 war

1999, hit by a fucking asteroid shower

2003, massive war that involves the whole continent

2006, uprising in Erusea

2014, second attempted uprising in Erusea

2019, Lighthouse war

2019, Kessler event, Erusean civil war, narrowly avoided AI apocalypse

2029, another war, entire continent alpha striked by rods from god, brutal occupation, FCU collapses, Giant landslips wreck the housing market, Expo city wiped off the face of the earth.

2030, war over, corpo's start digging their grubby hands into everything

2039, Corporate war starts

2040, NEMO is released into the Electrosphere.

4 Ace pilots

Roughly a dozen super weapons

Why in the living fuck, were people still emigrating to this place again!?

(Usea from Ace combat)

19

u/Frugal_Caterpillars 4h ago

Meteor City - HxH

Its really a giant junkyard that outcasts made a city out of. People who live there do not exist in any way, shape or form to the outside world. You come here when you want to escape something, or when you never had anything to begin with.

19

u/Dry_Criticism_4982 3h ago

Ravenholm (Half-Life 2):

A lot of places in Half-Life could take this spot (given that the world of Half-Life has gone to complete hell), but Ravenholm stands above all of them.

This place used to be a save haven for refugees until it became flooded with HeadCrabs when The Combine came and now it’s a ghost town with the only residents being Headcrab Zombies and Father Grigori (the only human left in the town who is crazy, but prepared enough to fight back.)

37

u/WhentheTropesAndFavs 4h ago

Reverse example:

Madness Combat takes place “somewhere in Nevada” but the creator confirmed it’s actually “the most normal” part of the world

18

u/Full-Aid 3h ago

Bloodstone (Fable II and the upcoming Fable game)

No matter which continuity, it's one of the worst towns to live in. In Lionhead continuity, it is an outlaw town surrounded by Wraithmarsh from three sides and inhabited mostly by pirates and prostitutes.

33

u/optimushime 3h ago

Don’t know if this is still the case, but when Reddit is asked what the worst place in the US is, the answer has been, quite consistently, Gary, Indiana.

I can’t say from experience, but it apparently has a couple of huge contributions to this reputation: a serious meth problem, and being on the border of the state right by Chicago, IL.

Why the latter? Chicago is a city with a serious gun violence issue in a state with strict gun laws. Indiana, however, has extremely lax gun laws. So if you’re in Chicago and want to shoot someone, the answer is right across the border in Gary.

10

u/Evil_Midnight_Lurker 2h ago

This may explain why it was the original setting for the Vampire: the Masquerade RPG.

9

u/Toothless-In-Wapping 2h ago

As someone familiar with Gary, yes. It’s what Detroit would have been if it had no sense of pride or shame.

1

u/Munchkinasaurous 1h ago

The only thing I knew about Gary Indiana prior to this, is that's where Harold Hill, the conman protagonist from The Music Man claimed to be from. 

1

u/NoWeb2576 39m ago

Albuquerque, New Mexico

14

u/myownworstenemy15 2h ago

Planet Catachan from Warhammer 40k. Everything on the planet is hostile. 75% of the population does not reach adulthood.
Here is one of the local species known a barking toad. It is not the worst creature on the planet

The barking toad explodes when startled, releasing a cloud of gas a kilometer wide that penetrates all forms of protection.

4

u/Toothless-In-Wapping 2h ago

So how does anything grow?

4

u/myownworstenemy15 2h ago

It grows quickly and viciously

3

u/Toothless-In-Wapping 1h ago

The non worst creature annihilates every living thing in a cubic kilometer when if it gets startled is insane.
If the answer is just “random 40K science”, just say so.

1

u/Bigbydidnothingwrong 1h ago

Well yes 40K nonsense, but that is also the answer: the growth of everything on Catachan is insane. Imperium outposts need to be maintained near constantly against encroaching (malicious) flora. I presume the birthrate of basically all fauna to be absolutely insane.

Their biggest land predator, the Catachan Devil, might be a tyranid species, maybe.

1

u/Aquaberry_Dollfin 2h ago

I wish to pet this creature

1

u/LilyInPortland 1h ago

"Step away from the toad brother"

1

u/KenseiHimura 1h ago

Catachan is so shit that when most of its population left to fight, Chaos attempted to take it over and most got killed by the wildlife. I believe even Tyranids and FUCKING ORKZ avoid the planet because they know they won’t survive long

12

u/Bodkin-Van-Horn 3h ago

New York in Escape From New York. The whole island is now a prison.

10

u/Recov3ry 3h ago

kowloon walled city irl

16

u/talking_joke 3h ago

Gotham City (DC Comics)

4

u/thegreatestdandino 1h ago

Shockingly there's a city worse than gotham in DC: Blüdhaven.

8

u/Screamin_Demon_Draws 3h ago

Meiyerditch from RuneScape, where people live in squalor in a cramped crumbling hellscape and are forced to give up blood to vampyres that fly over them like vultures.

7

u/thebaldguy76 3h ago

So Hub City is halfway between Gotham and Metropolis, so it is the "run-off" city for both. Its mayor was a drunken mess who was really just a puppet for a televangelist; the people of Hub wish their city officials were corrupt, at least with corrupt things get done. My point is that Denny O'niel's 80s Question is bleak, man.

4

u/SeasonofMist 2h ago

that's awful

7

u/MulberryField30 3h ago

Basin City, aka “‘Sin City” (Sin City)

7

u/ProfessionalFloor981 2h ago

Ankh-Morpork, for the most part. There are corrupt leaders elsewhere, but-actually, no, Ankh-Morpork is designed to destroy corrupt leaders. There are criminal guilds committing organized crime, but they exist as explicit institutions at the behest of the cunning Patrician, Lord Havelock Vetinari. An uncertified criminal would be hunted down by the City Watch, led by Captain Samuel Vimes, one of Discworld's most unshakeable agents of justice.

Outside of this legalized tyranny, there's Unseen University, run by barely sane wizard-politicians who would destroy Discworld outirght if not for the interventions of the IT guy, Ponder Stibbons. The city streets are caked in filth, disease and poverty run rampant, and there are gangs of ethnic minorities forcing immigrants into alliance. The city has a river, the river Ankh, but it's so polluted that no one in their right mind (and quite a few of the wrong-minded) would choose to drink any of it.

Rise for the National Anthem of Capitalism Ankh-Morpork, "We Can Rule You Wholesale!"

3

u/Individual99991 1h ago edited 1h ago

I dunno, so long as I wasn't in The Shades, or present during one of the periodic disasters (city burning down because someone found out about the concept of insurance, wizard magical war, dragon attack etc), I think I'd find Ankh-Morpork quite cosy. Perhaps I'm thinking of the later Discworld books where it's a bit more orderly though.

This -

gangs of ethnic minorities forcing immigrants into alliance

makes the books sound a bit racist though. It's worth pointing out to passersby that the minorities in question are trolls and dwarfs, and it's not "forcing immigrants into alliance" to much as clashing cultural groups feeding off long-held suspicions of one another, and some people feeling pressured into joining that against their better nature.

1

u/ProfessionalFloor981 37m ago

Okay, that's better than what I said.

6

u/Turbulent-Escape-876 1h ago

Sothoryos from A song of ice and fire.

A jungle continent mostly unexplored, filled with deadly diseases and parasites.

Deadly wildlife living in the jungles such as

Wyverns: Basically dragons that cannot breathe fire.
Giant Crocodiles
Velociraptors
All kinds of venomous snakes.
Piranhas
Giant white vampire bats
Giant apes that can kill an elephant in a single blow, aka King Kong.

4

u/thegreatestdandino 1h ago

Mount Greylock- Greylock

Nonsense is happening in the middle of real mount greylock in Massachusetts most of it being Tulpas

10

u/StandNameIsWeAreNo1 3h ago

IRL in Hungary we have Miskolc.

12

u/Drayner89 3h ago

What about Miskolc makes it particularly bad?

-3

u/StandNameIsWeAreNo1 3h ago

I can't say it without sounding racist. Yes, roma people are also people. But they internalized the systematic discrimination against them, and a majority of them are walking stereotypes.

Miskolc has the densest roma population in Hungary.

3

u/Brickywood 2h ago

Never ask a man his salary, a woman her age, and a European what is their opinion about the Romani

2

u/StandNameIsWeAreNo1 2h ago

Suprisingly, this is not an opinion. I am as supportive of them as I can be. Borsod county is just like that. I have been there. It's a mess.

1

u/Toothless-In-Wapping 2h ago

Hey! You were correct

2

u/PeanutBuny27 3h ago

Gottlos (Chikn Nuggit)

2

u/keelekingfisher 1h ago

The quarantine zone in Atomfall

An area of northern England that's completely sealed off from the world after the secret research going on at the Windscale nuclear plant went horribly wrong. The settlements are under martial law, the countryside is dominated by bandits, cultists, and mutants, and the interference from the plant means that most vehicles and ways of communicating with the outside world simply don't work.

3

u/AnyAgency9835 3h ago

Carcer Ci--Fuck you already mentioned that

2

u/ApprehensiveParty609 2h ago

How come no one has mentioned Gaza in 2026?

2

u/Individual99991 1h ago

Gaza at any point since 1948, really.

1

u/Toothless-In-Wapping 2h ago

Cause this isn’t our first time?

1

u/MulberryField30 3h ago

Roanapur, Thailand (Black Lagoon)

1

u/mitvh2311 1h ago

NYC in the MCU

1

u/JakeNubbin 11m ago

Brockton Bay from Worm! I know the whole story doesn't take place there, but in the span of like six months, that once city experienced the equivalent of a hundred evacuation-worthy disasters.

1

u/HammerofLevi 5m ago

Sadly Manhunt's Carcer City is not the same in HD Universe.

9

u/Alternative_Turn8863 3h ago edited 3h ago

Forgot to mention this in my post but san Angeles in hacking mall. San Angeles is a shitty crime ridden city that is so bad that rape and murder was the common crime. the mayor quickly accepted 4 military experimental mech suits to give to 4 loyal and trusted cops to go out and kill dangerous criminals as a test drive. The civilians loved them and cheered them on as the cops brutally murdered hundreds of criminals and your only hope as a criminal was to instantly surrender as they do give a choice at first before they decided to brutally kill you if you refuse. There's also supernatural Satan bullshit that was barely mentioned at all at first and shoved in at the end to make the situation far worse and more miserable.

23

u/MostInteraction3184 4h ago

Roanapur from Black Lagoon. The rest of the world is fairly normal, but then you have this one city that is completely lawless. It's a criminal haven filled with mercenaries and smuggling where murder is the norm, and the only real rule is to not piss off the wrong gangs. Especially the one run by that chain smoking Russian.

8

u/Perfct_Stranger 3h ago

Madripoor in Marvel/MCU is similar.

3

u/Evil_Midnight_Lurker 2h ago

They're probably the same place. Revy and Patch are drinking buddies.

12

u/Level_Werewolf_7172 3h ago

Rapture using children to mass produce a genetic altering drug leading to a struggle between oligarchs and a civil war with the majority of the population being addicted to genetic manipulating drugs and rendered insane