r/TopCharacterTropes • u/Bi0_B1lly • 1d ago
Lore [Mixed Trope] The non-canon/fandom nickname surpasses the offical name
Example 1: "Mr. X" - The Tyrant from Resident Evil 2 was officially designated as the T-00, a codename for this specific T-103 series Tyrant... The nickname, Mr. X, comes from a line Claire says in the S.D. Perry novelization of RE2 that was later used for marketing in the Toybiz line of action figures for Resident Evil 2. Since then, fans have been calling this guy (and really any other T-103/103 adjacent series of Tyrants) Mr. X.
Example 2: "Golden Freddy" - The original game files for this Five Nights at Freddy's character had them named Yellow Bear, but after Markiplier began calling the character Golden Freddy on his playthroughs of Five Nights at Freddy's, the Golden Freddy name has since been accepted as the official moniker.
Example 3: "Pinhead" - Officially called the Hell Priest by Clive Barker, the name Pinhead originally started as a joke by the cast and crew of the original Hellraiser film due to the character's overall appearance and has since been largely taken on by the fandom and even various official releases as the characters name, despite Clive's absolute despise for it.
Example 4: "Tori-Bot" - A stand-in meta character meant to represent Akira Toriyama in various series he's created, most notably with Dragonball, the original nickname for this character was Robotoriyama, but many in the Dragonball fandom further shortened the nickname into simply Tori-Bot.
Example 5: "Pyramid Head" - The official name Silent Hill's creature designer Masahiro Ito had envisioned for this creature was Red Pyramid Thing, and James Sunderland even refers to it as such im-game, but due a single throwaway line of text referring to it more simply as Pyramid Head, that name overtook Red Pyramid Thing, seemingly due largely for the simplicity of it. While Ito doesn't seem to dislike the name, he's been rather vocal against the use of Red Pyramid Thing outside of the storyline of Silent Hill 2, but given it's iconic status in the fandom, it's made many more appearances outside of SH2.
For me, it's a mixed trope due to how often these nicknames can cause confusion and petty arguments within a fandom - some may take the nicknames as canon, while others may weaponize that fact as a means of claiming others are false fans for not knowing the true names for a character, and in some instances, even the creators are not fans of the name either but are forced to carry on the name due to fan recognition... It can both be a community event as much as it can be a tool to cause discourse.