r/Trading • u/According-Ad-2638 • 12h ago
Question Why copying someone else's trading strategy doesn't always work
Someone recently asked me how I model the decision to do nothing in a trading system. Do I use market state estimation, volatility filters, regime matching, or something else?
I think there's an important distinction here. Market state estimation tries to answer what state the market is in. What I'm interested in is what the system should or shouldn't do based on what the market is actually showing us.
For a new entry, the logic can be as simple as:
if entry_conditions_met and risk_allowed:
trade()
else:
wait()
The code is simple. The hard part is defining those conditions.
They come from research, background knowledge, experience, and an understanding of risk. There's no universal set of rules that works for everyone. Each trader has to find their own sweet spot.
We see people teaching trading strategies everywhere. But why does something that works well for one trader often fail to work as well for someone else?
I think part of the answer is that a strategy needs to fit the person using it, their objectives, constraints, and tolerance for risk. Even if you can reproduce the trades, that doesn't necessarily mean the strategy is right for you.
Of course, the strategy still needs a real edge. Personal fit alone won't make it profitable.
And this becomes even more important when managing other people's money.
In a way, a quant researcher is like a tailor making a custom suit. The challenge isn't just making a good suit. It's understanding the person who's going to wear it.
And that's much harder than it sounds.
Curious how others here think about this. How much of your no-trade logic comes from market conditions, and how much comes from risk constraints?

