r/Trading • • 19m ago

Advice You Are Wasting Your Time With MMXM, ICT and other YouTube Strategies

2 Upvotes

This is a no nonsense article I constructed to help you spot and resist fundamentally unprovable, jargon-heavy retail trading methodologies (like ICT, MMXM, and market cycles) that rely on hindsight and survivorship bias (overlooking negative outcomes) instead of genuine market mechanics.

Introduction - A Cross-Examination With Reality (ICT/SMC)
The idea of "price delivery" is based on a single entity providing quotes/making the market or actually influencing the price and "price delivery array" chart patterns are pseudo-scientific anchors for interaction, the more you look into it with an open mind the more absurd the claims become.

An algorithmic ‘delivery mechanism’ would imply stable order execution timing patterns, but order arrivals and limit order queue priority at microsecond scales exhibit a high amount of variability because of how markets discover new value constantly changes. Any time and sales market feed proves this statement easily (order timestamps are distributed unevenly, T&S has natural variability).

You don't need an institutional trader license to verify this, DataBento makes falsifiability accessible even through spreadsheet compatible CSV files, there are no excuses anymore.

Section 1 - Cycles
Technical analysis based market cycles are nonsense, methodologies that treat price as a function of fixed or harmonic periodicity often take advantage of illusions, hindsight and post hoc reasoning. This extends to any cycle detection software, plugins, or indicators built on these premises. Anyone grounded in the first principles of market microstructure and statistics would dismiss these methodologies as pseudo-science right away.

The market has no legitimate reason to follow a sequential theory about price step by step; nothing saves you from this reality, even if you manage to define and backtest it; the reason for it working is circular. It relies entirely on the data instead of the underlying substance, lacking a mechanism of its own.

Section 1.1 (The common logical issue which often contaminates public strategies)
MMXM is unfalsifiable, since the theory cannot be defined clearly to be repeated it cannot be proven to be profitable or unprofitable, it relies highly on intuitive discretion which erodes the objectivity. A pattern can be statistically real without offering a tradable edge but if there is no mechanical provable mechanism behind it there is likely no objective reason for it to continue.

According to cycle theories, the movement of price is based on repeated patterns of a certain period, and the combination of many such waves on real data leads to the emergence of a predictable pattern (this is what each educator claims in different ways). Educators often make bold claims; some will attempt to tie cycles to biology, physics, maths, nature, market makers, institutions, but price discovery is not rigid enough for most cycles to profit without over-optimising in a way that markets will not repeat 1:1 (overfitting).

Given this, MMXM, Hurst Cycles, along with any other form of cyclical or wavelike technical analysis, have absolutely no place in a serious trading operation. Cycle theories assert periodicity and then search for it in the data, which is the inverse of the deductive process applied by professionals.

Section 1.2 - The Baseline or Serious Data Collection
For MMXM this would need to be mapped out and tested properly across large samples.

Consolidations need to be defined by objective range and duration criteria; directional moves need defined movement and swing criteria; a so-called "liquidity sweep" needs to be a precisely defined price event; the reversal needs specific, explicit confirmation criteria; the second half needs a predefined, predetermined price objective; and, most importantly, there need to be clear, fixed conditions for invalidation.

Without this + rigorous testing with settings picked before testing (for objectivity) + without tweaking parameters (hindsight and overfitting) it remains a hopeless pseudoscience.

Section 1.3 - The Main Statistical Trap Behind Discretionary Strategies.
From the standpoint of mathematics, there is an infinite number of combinations of periodic functions that can be fitted to look good on any OHLC time series, including random noise, provided that the periods, phases, etc. remain free parameters (customisable). It means that we are dealing with the same type of overfitting that is known from academic research as a source of false quantifiable patterns. Over 9 years I have reviewed hundreds of technical analysis tools, and I have not identified a single concrete, falsifiable cycle yet. Unfalsifiable cycle theories with free parameters are more often than not a fugazi; I believe it is highly unlikely that an effective, market-beating one exists.

If a turning point in a cycle concept is not observed, the typical procedure for price cycle users will either involve adjusting the phases, changing the length of the cycle, or employing a "cycle extension" concept (post-hoc analysis), instead of a rejection of the theory. This can be quite dangerous; by chance, a trader can get a lucky streak and believe it was the power of the cycle. The unfalsifiability creates an invisible trap that can be indefinite, especially for more recent market pseudo-scientific “techniques”.

If each person executes a different configuration or executes the same exact one differently e.g., on different timeframes or markets, each trader produces a distinct set of results and anomalous performance (outliers) become testimony for so-called educators.

Section 1.4 - Heavy Reliance on Hindsight and Grand Names (the dress up)
It's always clear after the fact, SMC relies on hindsight and sunk cost from its esoterism, this is why people remain bound to it for years.

SMC: It's not three consecutive bars followed by a retracement or a breakout and retest; it is a "Institutional Order Flow Entry Drill". Ridiculous.

MMXM materially has nothing to do with market makers and "IOFED" has nothing to do with institutions.

A few out of millions of tries displaying anecdotal success from intuitive discretionary ICT trading does not legitimise it (survivorship bias), a lot of people have made a lot of money buying moving average crossovers or darvas box breakouts by chance which are materially just as baseless.

Do not let educators fool you:
Any phrase/term is worth simplifying, in real finance and other serious fields terms are designed to be legitimately descriptive, the dress-up is that "Institutional Order Flow Entry Drill" does not actually describe what it is or the mechanism and "market maker buy model" is not a market maker buy model, the jargon is like grand icing to mask a cake's mediocrity.

Look past the dress-up

There is no agreed upon way to deploy anything within these frameworks, when favourable data is published people will rush to validate it, when poor data is released people will rush to dismiss it. It's a classic pseudoscientific no true scotsman trap. There is no "right" way which is central to the problem and believing a strategy will be effective just because of data (regardless if it's a backtest or forward test) is circular reasoning in principle.

ICT/SMC has no verifiable underlying foundation beneath it for why it should actually work which is why it is mocked by quants and other serious traders.

Section 2 - Create your own strategies.
If you want to know precisely why it is a waste of your time to do otherwise, open a chatbot and ask the following

Why do public trading methodologies and strategies tend not to work? Rely on reliable sources, crowding realities and microstructure logic ELIA5.

Copy and paste it straight, no edits and see what you learn in two minutes.

The secret is in understanding why an edge could exist in the first place and you exercise your freedom by creating your own based on those lessons (available for free on the public domain, not on YT channels unfortunately).

Stop wasting your time trying to find gurus who have magic setups.
Intuitive discretion produces different outcomes for every person who attempts to apply it, the statistical consequences of this are misunderstood by their viewers.

Why repeating patterns are not enough.
If one does not see and know what is happening, their judgment is based on bias instead of reality and with enough rolls of the dice, the average number will come closer and closer to 3, although they believe they have a system which could bring the average closer to 6.

That is the issue.

If you do not understand the trigger for involvement, you are joining in at random areas with intent instead of consciously rolling dice. The market’s costs would bring the number below 3.00.

Transaction costs give relying on luck a hefty asymmetric tax.

Everyone believes a repeating pattern paying them today without knowing the cause is okay, but the catch is when the pattern stops repeating tomorrow. Without knowing what drives it, you cannot tell if the strategy is broken or just experiencing normal variability until transaction costs have already taken a large portion of your gains over time. At this point, many traders have already given most, if not everything, back.

Section 2.1 - Serious Traders Versus The Unserious:

  1. A serious trading operation actively tries to disprove its own theories through the act of testing, an unserious trading operation explains away failures with reframing.
  2. A serious trading operation is built on repeatable, objective metrics based on real principles while an unserious trading operation is built on cherry picked examples and success stories which deviate from the actual baseline (outliers).
  3. A serious trading operation updates their strategies and methods when new discoveries contradict present beliefs, an unserious operation ironically remains static despite contradictory evidence. Negative results will be dismissed as "tested incorrectly" while a genuinely precise, consistent way to test it is not provided.

Those operating like serious traders build real skills, unserious traders waste years of their lives.

Section 2.2 - Understanding and My Secondary Claim
Understanding why things happen in markets is the foundation for the creation and monitoring of real market edges. 
Without such grounding, profitability is a game of luck rather than skill.
Quitting is the superior option.

If enough people try a moving average crossover system, SMC (or anything else with weak underlying foundations), a few outliers will succeed by chance alone. The problem is that many educators fake understanding to sell a story, distracting people from the truth.

My claim is not that public strategies cannot provide an edge, the legitimate concern is an edge's value decaying through crowding (multiple traders executing the same strategy resulting in modest-high volumes at predictable areas), which happens when a strategy e.g., open range breakouts becomes public. This can either reduce the strategy's efficiency dramatically or cause strategies to lose money after transaction costs.

Real education makes you question your assumptions.


r/Trading • • 45m ago

Discussion No CRSP access: is Sharadar OK for academic-style research?

1 Upvotes

I'm doing a research project on residual momentum in point-in-time S&P 500 stocks but I don't have WRDS/CRSP access. Is Sharadar good enough for this, and what pitfalls should I watch for (dividend adjustment, delisting returns, S&P 500 membership history)? Any better affordable alternative?
Thanks!


r/Trading • • 1h ago

Discussion The recovery math that changed how I size my trades

1 Upvotes

Something I wish someone had shown me in my first month: losses and gains are not symmetrical.

Loss on the account -> gain needed just to get back to where you were

- 10% -> 11%

- 20% -> 25%

- 33% -> 50%

- 50% -> 100%

- 75% -> 300%

Same thing in a short sequence: start with 1,000, lose 20% (800), then gain 20% (960). You're still down, even though the percentages "match".

What I changed after seeing this:

  1. Fixed risk per trade, decided before entry. For me that's 1% of the account. Five losses in a row then cost about 5%, which needs roughly 5.3% to recover. Five losses at 10% each would leave about 59% of the account and need around 69% to get back.
  2. The stop goes in before the trade, and it doesn't get moved further away.
  3. After 3 losses in a day I stop. Most of my worst days came from trying to win it back.

None of this makes a strategy profitable on its own, but it keeps you around long enough to find out whether yours is.

How do you all handle risk per trade? Fixed %, fixed amount, or something else?


r/Trading • • 9h ago

Discussion Advice for someone starting

9 Upvotes

I’m interested into getting into trading or just making money the fastest way with some risk what advice would u give


r/Trading • • 9h ago

Technical analysis A 10-loss streak is less rare than most traders think

3 Upvotes

Take a strategy with a 40% win rate. The odds that any 10 trades you pick in advance all lose are 0.6^10, about 1 in 165. So when you hit 10 in a row, it feels like proof the edge is gone. But that 1 in 165 only holds for 10 trades chosen in advance. Over 300 trades, a streak can start on any of them. Shuffle 120 wins and 180 losses thousands of times, and about half of the shuffles have a streak of 10+ losses somewhere. The streak that should actually worry you is the one fewer than 1 in 20 shuffles reach. For this example, that's 15 losses in a row, not 10. Your own line depends on your win rate and how many trades you take, so it's worth working out before you're in the middle of the streak.


r/Trading • • 9h ago

Strategy is haveing a trading strategy extremely important if you want to become consistently profitable

1 Upvotes

is it necessary to have a strategy if a trader wantes to become profitable


r/Trading • • 10h ago

Discussion Looking for a Reliable Time-Based Strategy for NASDAQ (London & New York Sessions) | Prop Firm Trading

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I'm currently looking for a reliable time-based trading strategy, preferably one that works well during the London and New York sessions, specifically for trading NASDAQ (US100/NQ).

I've experimented with ORB (Opening Range Breakout), but my results have been around breakeven. One of the biggest issues I've encountered is frequent false breakouts, which makes it difficult to maintain consistency.

I'm now looking to explore time-based strategies because I don't want to spend the entire day sitting in front of charts waiting for setups. I'd prefer a strategy with specific trading windows, clear entry conditions, and well-defined rules.

My main goal is to find a strategy that:

  • Works consistently during the London and/or New York sessions.
  • Is suitable for NASDAQ.
  • Can be applied in a prop firm environment.
  • Has clear, rule-based entry and exit conditions.
  • Doesn't require watching the charts throughout the entire day.
  • Has demonstrated long-term viability rather than just performing well in a short backtesting period.

I'd also appreciate recommendations based on actual trading experience, particularly from traders who have forward-tested or backtested their strategies over a significant period.

A few questions:

  1. What time-based strategies have worked best for you when trading NASDAQ?
  2. Do you prefer trading the London session, New York AM, or New York PM?
  3. Are there any specific models or concepts you'd recommend looking into?
  4. How have these strategies performed over the long term, especially in terms of win rate, risk-to-reward ratio, and drawdown?

I'm not necessarily looking for a strategy with an extremely high win rate. I'm more interested in something with a genuine statistical edge, consistency, and manageable drawdown.

I'm still trying to figure out which approach to commit to, so any insights, personal experiences, or recommendations would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks in advance!


r/Trading • • 11h ago

# DAILY MARKET BRIEF | Trading Strategies, Tools, and Resources

1 Upvotes

Daily market updates and resources for active traders managing risk and execution.

r/Trading Community Hub

Visit the Website

Independent research, trading psychological guides, and honest broker breakdowns for retail traders.

Join the Discord

Live chat on intraday setups, earnings plays, and technical analysis with fellow traders.

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Weekly market briefing analyzing order flow, macro data, and trade journals.

Have a Question? Post It.

The r/Trading newsletter pulls top community questions and answers them in depth every week.

If you're stuck on a position, trying to read a chart pattern, or struggling with risk management, drop a comment below or start a thread. The most valuable questions get featured in our weekend briefing with full technical breakdown and volume analysis.

This is the loop: you post, we research, the community gets the answer.

Build Your Portfolio

Bank Accounts

Reviewed national accounts for everyday banking and high-yield savings.

Local Banks

Community and regional options outside the big four.

Investing Platforms

Brokerages, retirement accounts, and where to actually hold your portfolio.

Financial Apps

Tools for budgeting, tracking, and managing money day-to-day.

Pre-Market Futures & Global Sentiments

US Stock Futures (CNBC)

Global Market Movers (Bloomberg)

Economic Calendar (ForexFactory)

Frame the session with futures, movers, and index sentiment.

Earnings & Macro Calendars

Earnings Calendar (Yahoo Finance)

Earnings Whispers (Twitter/X)

Tools to Explore

Finviz Stock Screener

Portfolio Visualizer

OptionStrat

Filter the noise, backtest your data, and read the tape. Build process, not bets.


r/Trading • • 12h ago

Question **How do you guys trade intraday momentum using top gainers and losers?**

3 Upvotes

I'm trying to understand how people actually trade momentum intraday, especially when focusing on top gainers and losers.

A few things I'm curious about:

\- At what time do you start scanning? Right at market open or after the first 15–30 minutes?

\- Since the top gainers/losers list keeps changing, do you keep scanning throughout the day or shortlist a few stocks in the morning and stick with them?

\- How do you select stocks worth trading? Percentage change alone, volume, price action, or something else?

\- Do you trade newly appearing stocks or avoid them once the move is already extended?

\- What is your entry setup? Breakouts, pullbacks, candle patterns, or something else?

\- How do you decide your stop-loss and exit? Fixed targets, trailing SL, price action, or a fixed risk-reward ratio?

\- How many entries do you typically take in a day? One or two setups, or multiple trades whenever momentum appears?

\- How do you manage risk and money? How much do you risk per trade, do you have a daily loss limit, and how do you decide position size?

\- Do you trade both gainers and losers, or mainly focus on one side?

Would love to hear your actual routine, from scanning and stock selection to entry, exit, stop-loss and money management. Trying to build a simple, repeatable process without constantly chasing whatever is moving.


r/Trading • • 12h ago

Question Why copying someone else's trading strategy doesn't always work

0 Upvotes

Someone recently asked me how I model the decision to do nothing in a trading system. Do I use market state estimation, volatility filters, regime matching, or something else?

I think there's an important distinction here. Market state estimation tries to answer what state the market is in. What I'm interested in is what the system should or shouldn't do based on what the market is actually showing us.

For a new entry, the logic can be as simple as:

if entry_conditions_met and risk_allowed:

trade()

else:

wait()

The code is simple. The hard part is defining those conditions.

They come from research, background knowledge, experience, and an understanding of risk. There's no universal set of rules that works for everyone. Each trader has to find their own sweet spot.

We see people teaching trading strategies everywhere. But why does something that works well for one trader often fail to work as well for someone else?

I think part of the answer is that a strategy needs to fit the person using it, their objectives, constraints, and tolerance for risk. Even if you can reproduce the trades, that doesn't necessarily mean the strategy is right for you.

Of course, the strategy still needs a real edge. Personal fit alone won't make it profitable.

And this becomes even more important when managing other people's money.

In a way, a quant researcher is like a tailor making a custom suit. The challenge isn't just making a good suit. It's understanding the person who's going to wear it.

And that's much harder than it sounds.

Curious how others here think about this. How much of your no-trade logic comes from market conditions, and how much comes from risk constraints?


r/Trading • • 14h ago

Resources Here's what my AI journal taught me... how much my worst behavior patterns like overtrading and FOMO cost me.

1 Upvotes

I have been trading all my life but recently I kept seeing the same thing in my own trades and everyone else's. I was losing money overall but not because of my setups. The losses ate all my profits and came from extra trades: the 4th and 5th trade of the day, the chase after a move already ran, the revenge trade after a loss.

So I built TaipTrade. It auto imports trades so I see ALL my trades not just the ones I log. It non-biasedly flags behavior patterns for me and tracks PL in chart form. It shows:

  • Best/worst trade and how many trades you made
  • Your behavior patterns: FOMO, chasing, revenge trades right next to the trades so I don't have to
  • What each habit cost you in dollars
  • What you can do to stop it--Rule and strategy building

I saw my worst days were almost always my busiest days. And the AI agent gave me rules to fix it, strategies to focus on and more. My losses were staggering--I would be profitable by a factor of 3x removing my worst habits.

It also has gamma/GEX levels for SPX, SPY and QQQ, and a market brief, and that's how I plan my day now.

I want to launch a beta this week for 10 traders so I can see what works and what's broken. Happy to answer anything in the comments. If you are interested give it a shot. I believe AI trading is how everyone will trade in the future.


r/Trading • • 15h ago

General news I built an open-source trading journal with a 3D whale to visualize my trades 🐋

Post image
1 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I've been building Whale, an open-source desktop trading journal.

I wanted something different from traditional trading journals that are just spreadsheets and tables.

With Whale, you can:

  • 📊 Track your trades and trading performance
  • 🐋 Visualize your trading journal as an interactive 3D whale
  • 🧠 Connect trades, setups, mistakes, and emotions
  • 📝 Write detailed trading notes using Markdown
  • 🤖 Use optional AI (Claude or Ollama) to explore your journal
  • 🔒 Keep your trading data locally on your computer

The idea is to help traders understand their decisions, recognize patterns, and learn from their mistakes.

It's still a work in progress, and I'd love to get some feedback.

Would you use something like this? What features are missing from your current trading journal?

GitHub: https://github.com/Kirby54/whale


r/Trading • • 15h ago

Question Need help understanding something

3 Upvotes

Big noob here, can someone please explain to me what happened with anthropic ?

Did every 83 share holders wait for a 30% bonus and then sell while everybody held?


r/Trading • • 15h ago

Futures Trading strategy

1 Upvotes

I’ve been learning how to trade for about a month now. I’ve finished tjrs and the pb bootcamp. I’m at the point where I want to start developing a strategy so I can backtest it and start working toward getting an eval. I enjoy using ict concepts and I’d say I’m pretty decent at spotting and applying them at this point I just need a concrete strategy. I’ve looked into ote/ stdv and think I would like it. And I also looked into the mech model so I’m at a standstill between what to use. I just wanted to ask what u guys use and if u have any tips or suggestions as a whole?


r/Trading • • 15h ago

Resources Free Trading Journal

2 Upvotes

I built a trading journal because logging my trades by hand was eating an hour of my day. I built Fintelligize and use it every day.

I started investing in 2024 and trade mostly options and swing trades. I wanted to know what was working and what kept costing me, so I logged every trade by hand. It took me about an hour a day, and I still couldn't see the bigger picture.

Why I built it:

The journals I looked at either charged a monthly fee or kept the useful features behind a higher tier. So I built my own, and it's the one I use for my own trades now.

What it does:

- Import: upload a CSV from your broker

- Numbers: win rate, profit factor, break-even win rate, expectancy, drawdown, and streaks

- Calendar and daily journal: see your good and bad days, and write down what you were thinking

- AI insights: once you have 10 or more closed trades

- It's free

I built this around my own workflow, so I'd like feedback from other traders. Do the numbers match your broker after you import? Is there something from your current journal or spreadsheet that you miss?

https://fintelligize.com

Thanks for checking it out!


r/Trading • • 17h ago

Stocks 24m looking for a stock market trader whom which i can learn snd study, i am learning stock market since last 6 years

3 Upvotes

r/Trading • • 17h ago

Algo - trading Should I start a prop firm right away, or test forward first?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/Trading • • 18h ago

Advice Want to begin Macro trading

2 Upvotes

Need advice like should i begin with my country only and how to get begin like resources from where i can learn like how to forecast macro variable and from there picking the sector and stock

I also heard the there is particular asset class that work in a particular time so how to identify it


r/Trading • • 19h ago

Question Trading platform

1 Upvotes

I'm just learning how to trade and from what I have seen everyone on youtube uses Tradingview. I tried it but the dekstop app is not letting me use it for free and the website is lagging so much that it's unusable. Are there any free alternative platforms similar to Tradingview? I am a beginner so I do not plan to spend any money on tradingview at this point


r/Trading • • 19h ago

Discussion momentum in bear markets

2 Upvotes

I read that momentum tends to drastically underperform during the recovery faces of bear markets compared to the really beaten down stock with good fundamentals. So I will be buyin stock with bad momentum but strong fundamentals, is this a good idea?


r/Trading • • 21h ago

Question OptionFlow

1 Upvotes

Who's the best on YouTube for options flow + GEX? Looking for practical content, not just theory.


r/Trading • • 21h ago

Question Footprint

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I want to learn how to read footprint charts properly (delta, imbalances, absorption, stacked imbalances, etc.). Who would you recommend on YouTube? I'm looking for someone who teaches with live examples on futures (ES/NQ) rather than pure theory.


r/Trading • • 22h ago

Discussion Elev8 deposit/withdrawal payment methods, which one to go for?

1 Upvotes

I know bank transfers are popular across traders, but bruhh, they take so long most of the time. Like couple of business days. I'm not that patient to wait it out normally, I will stress until money hit my bank account. So, I'd like to go for sth quick in processing... maybe credit cards? Or e wallets?


r/Trading • • 22h ago

Discussion The Trading Bible

3 Upvotes

What are your guys thought about the book named The Candlestick Trading Bible, i have recently started reading the book do you guys have any books you could recomend related to the stratergy in book or tell me about this stratergy